This chart is enough to make you cry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cadillac_V8_engine#500
Anyway, eventually engineers learned how to make engines that are highly efficient and have very low emissions, basically by making the things as complicated as sin.
For a good 10 years or so, all of these goodies they added (like Mass Airflow Sensors, etc) would fail in mysterious ways, and be very expensive to replace.
Now most of that stuff is pretty solid too.
A lot of opinion about car tech is set by stuff that is 10-20 years old, which is both fair and not fair. It's fair, because it's hard to tell how things will wear when they are new. It's not fair, because engineers have already fixed a lot of things that went wrong in the previous generation.
Anyway, Cadillac now has a 3.0L Turbo [0] that makes as much hp as the 8.2 from above.
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM_High_Feature_engine#LGW
Disclaimer, I work for GM, but I'm on on any engine team.
after several rounds of detuning for smog controls, among other reasons.
I doubt any of those "other reasons" were because the engine couldn't survive 400hp.
in the same wiki link you can find this for 1971.
365 brake horsepower (272 kW), or 235 horsepower (175 kW) in the new SAE net ratings
The biggest engine ever in a production vehicle, until the second-gen Viper came around.
Modern cars as a rule go hundreds of thousands of miles without major problems while using a fraction of the gasoline per mile and producing a fraction of the pollution.
Yeah, sometimes they get it wrong and design something that doesn't last. But do you think that didn't happen before, too? Remember that the models we know and remember 50 years later are the winners. There's a strong survivorship bias at work here.
https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/pu...
I wonder if it's hard for younger HN readers to appreciate the progress here? Having a car last 200,000 miles used to be a stroke of insane luck, like living to 90 years old - for most car models in the last 10 years, 200,000 is basically the least you could expect to get out of a car.
They had a million mile tundra not long ago, I don't think you'll find a million mile engine from the 50s-70s
How many typical new cars would it take to get to that? How many typical old cars?
The transmissions are another beast. They just seem to die at 140k, plus, or minus how you drive.
Their wasen't constant valve adjustments, or carb adjustments , distributors were dead simple. 90% of the time it was a bad condenser, or the points contacts needed sanding, unless you happened to own a British Vehicle.
And yes Amercan vechicles made in the late 70's, and 80's were aweful.
Old was not necessarily better, but Shade Tree mechanics could work on them.
There's a reason wealthy men buy old classic cars. A few years ago the average guy could buy a vice classic. Today--it's changed. Their are guys stockpiling older collectable vechicle.
Every wonder why the new cars offer just 7 year, or 100,000 miles of the Powertrain warranty?
Conversely, this doesn't mean that cars were made poorly in the past, it's just that the technologies and methods used in their manufacture have improved over time.
25 years ago is 1992, this is already way into "modern car" territory and million-kilometer executive cars.
Nowadays that's the minimum we expect (even for bargain-basement Korean subcompacts,* exotic Porsche sports cars or bleeding-edge high-technology computer-controlled Teslas), but >25 years ago it was virtually unheard of outside the Japanese brands.
*The Hyundai Excel and Pony had such poor reputations for reliability that their brand image still remains somewhat tarnished in the US, while the Daewoo brand had to be retired in North America/Europe entirely (I believe some of their models are now sold as Chevys).
Specification: Engine design lifetime = 2000 running hours.
CAD and FEA are great, but the above spec ruins it. You get parts made of light alloys and plastic, made of the minimum amount of material possible. They happen to be mostly fine when everything is perfect but any unintended load or crack in the plastic due to aging results in a catastrophe.
It seems odd that you would accept a design lifetime that is 40% of a car made 13 years ago.
I'm also not clear why you would expect the majority to perform above spec? Wouldn't a significant number fail under spec? Isn't a care which may become a total loss in 60-80k miles basically tissue paper quality?
Personally, I think a pretty big swath of engines make it well past 100,000 miles now - there are usually other issues with cars at about the 10 to 15 year mark with most makes and models that have to do with rust.
Designing engines that last significantly longer on average (say 250,000 miles) would require either a beefier design, which will add weight and reduce efficiency, or exotic materials that will significantly increase the cost.
Automobiles are pretty amazing for what they are. I agree with many others that they have gotten ridiculously complex, but this is mostly because of the emissions requirements - and that said I do enjoy the fact that smog is not much of an issue (at least in the US) these days.
Most used cars I've looked at in dealerships (as opposed to the Craigslist/Uncle Henry's as-is-where-is private sales) were overwhelmingly former lease vehicles.
It replaced a car that had 190k miles from around 2000. Its worst problems were a bad A/C compressor (replaced at ~100k miles) and a slipping clutch (it was the original clutch). The plugs and wires were replaced once during its service.
Modern cars are amazingly reliable and amazingly safe compared to their predecessors.
In those days you were lucky to get 80k miles on an engine before it needed a rebuild, while it's not hard to find post-2000 cars with over 250k miles on the original, un-rebuilt engine.
Coincidentally, I was recently reading about early American cars and their heavily overbuilt construction is a huge contrast to this "value engineering" of modern engines; whereas those old engines could be tuned to make far more than stock power with little effect on reliability, it seems today the aim is to make the margin as narrow as possible --- just enough to get past the warranty period, with the associated effect that, due to how the statistics work, quite a few of them will fail before too. Samsung's "exploding" washing machines are a recent, non-automotive, example of this.
Today's cars may be more efficient and less polluting, but if they last a fraction of the time as the old ones and have to be replaced many times more often, are they really that much better environmentally overall?