However, I'd like to highlight that women's refuges and most men's homeless shelters are actually dealing with very different problems. The problems faced by the average homeless shelter that principally serves men includes addiction and mental illnesses like you describe. Women's refuges don't tend to have either of those problems to the same extent, but schooling and former partners require their own set of skills. Equally, because the problems are so different, it makes sense to keep them separate (you don't want to put a six year old next to a meth addict, for instance).
Could we do more for both of these groups? Heck yes. Ironically, some US cities have shown that the cheapest way of dealing with homeless men may be to... give them somewhere to live.
Note: I lived in a women's refuge for a while when I was a kid.
> Who does Mary’s Place currently serve?
> Homeless women and men with their children from the greater King County area. The women and families we serve range from young adults to seniors and represent diverse backgrounds in race, ethnicity, class, sexual orientation, education, and life experience. Many struggle with disabilities and mental health issues. Approximately 30-40% of our guests are immigrants or refugees, the majority of those from East Africa.
For one of these two, a roof over their head and hot meals a couple times a day for a period of months is going to be extremely beneficial including in the long run, since they'll reliably be able to support themself thanks to the homeless shelter's infrastructure. For the other hypothetical case, it's still the right and humane thing to do for them, but the "bang for your buck" is lower to put it in crass terms.
If it just works out that women outnumber men in the former group, and the gender discrimination does a huge amount of work in selecting for the most efficient candidates to keep in the shelter, I'm in favor of the discrimination.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2016/08/31/opiods-...
Here is a quote from wikipedia, from a sentence with 3 citations at the end of it:
"there is a large body of cross-cultural evidence that women are subjected to domestic violence significantly more often than men."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence#Gender_diffe...
Recent studies conclude with a much more equal gender distribution among victims, as OP points out.
"Although some states use the term domestic violence while others use domestic abuse, the terms describe similar conduct."
http://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-defe...
Share of homelessness due to an abusive relationship + share of homelessness due to drugs + share of homelessness for all other reasons = 1.
If one of those variables goes higher, one or both of the others must go lower. On the assumption that one of those reasons gets more common "all else equal"... both of the others will go lower.
In fact if you read what they wrote, they didn't specify sex at all. A man can be homeless due to an abusive relationship, they never said they couldn't. Hence independent statements. nsnick was the one assuming something.
A singular case subject/family could be homeless for MULTIPLE reasons or None (other than other of course) outlined above.
This is wrong. What's correct as a description of the entire female homeless population is equally correct as a probability assignment for one element of it.
Your second sentence is unrelated to your first, and also applies equally well to the entire population as to an individual sample from it. It is arguing that the sum I describe is in fact more than 1. That is defensible, but it won't make the statements independent; they aren't.
No, because someone can be homeless for multiple reasons.
> I swear I'm not (a) claiming this is necessarily in reality the case
Hey, I'm not claiming this is actually reality, but did you know that women aren't as good at their jobs as men, and that's why they get paid less?^^
Yeah, I didn't think that putting a little disclaimer at the top was really good enough.
^^ Making a point about doublespeak. I think this statement is total BS.
* The vast majority of men do not have positions of power or great wealth.
* The vast majority of white people do not have positions of power or great wealth.
* The vast majority of homeless people, regardless of their race or gender, do not have positions of power or great wealth.
* White people, as a group, do not systematically oppress non-white people, preventing them from attaining power and wealth.
* Men, as a group, do not systematically oppress non-male people, preventing them from attaining power and wealth.
Since pretty much any claim about how these things are in the real world is liable to be controversial, here's a toy example to illustrate. Imagine a world in which (1) hundreds of years ago it became, never mind why, very widely believed that men are better and cleverer and harder-working than women, (2) such beliefs are extremely resistant to change regardless of empirical evidence, and (3) as a result of the persistence of that belief, men are consistently given better jobs, paid more, regarded as more trustworthy, etc., etc., etc., than women. But, as in our world, great power and great wealth are rare, and most people whether male or female don't have them.
In that world, the vast majority of men don't have great power or great wealth, and any oppressing that's going on is being done by everyone collectively; but, in that world, men are by any reasonable definition a dominant group: they are greatly overrepresented (relative to their numbers in society as a whole) among the powerful, the rich, the high-status.
So, let's return to geofft's question. Everything in your list could be true without making it false that men and white people are dominant groups in American society. Do you, in addition to holding the positions in your list, further believe that they are not dominant groups?
What would be your estimate for the proportion of men in the following groups in the US: (1) people with an annual income of $250k or more, (2) holders of national-level political office, (3) people with "executive" in their job title, (4) owners of businesses, (5) judges, (6) generals, (7) (full) professors, (8) religious ministers? What about the proportion of white people?
I'll make my prediction: in all those groups, the fraction of both men and white people will be greater than their fraction in the population at large; in several of those groups, much greater. Do you disagree? If so, let's check. If not, why don't you think this makes men and white people "dominant groups"? (Note that "dominant" is not the same as "oppressive".)
If you want to challenge this belief, I strongly recommend reading The New Jim Crow by Michelle Alexander (which I'm currently partway through). I'll still respect your position if you read it and continue to believe the above, but it's got a lot of good information and good analysis that's worth being aware of.
Because there are many people who think that discrimination against women is bad, but discrimination against men is OK. These people should be fought against.
The first person I met who was abused by their lover was male... she was female. I've met homeless men that risk getting their children taken away because the appropriate shelter wouldn't accept them. These sorts of things cause a negative stereotype for such places. It doesn't matter that most of the victims tend to be female: I'd rather them be gender-neutral on this front. IT isn't just a female problem.
Where we spend our charitable contributions is indicative of our values (both as individuals and as a society). Some charities are criticized for being too "feel-good" or being inefficient with donor money for emotional heart strings. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/heartwarming-causes-... OTOH, this argument taken to it's logical conclusion says we should only ever donate to the Gates foundation and it's ilk. I find it interesting that Amazon is receiving such positive press for making a donation to an organization that is deliberately aimed at a subset of an issue. I've never seen an article about a corporate charitable donation of this small dollar value on hacker news before - not that the value is so small, but most charity news that breaks the media bubble is so high (e.g. billionaires pledging to donate half their wealth).
The make a wish foundation existence says something about our values. So does this donation sitting on the front page. Some people love the make a wish foundation and say it reflects positively on our empathy and compassion. Others murmur about warm fuzzies vs the greater good. I don't think this ethical question should be invalid or offensive in the context of politically charged issues.
Provisional new guideline: When hot under the collar, please cool down before posting.
I still stand by everything I wrote, it is a sexist act from a sexist organisation. Until their behavior changes I will forever believe that.
You are basically accusing the mending of sexism of being sexist. That only makes sense when you either don't understand or don't agree that sexism even exists, or maybe in some level is ok with it existing.
Is this an ideological position, or a belief about effectiveness? That is, do you believe that it's fundamentally wrong to take sex-biased actions to fix sexism, or just inefficient?
Suppose a city has ten homeless shelters for men and one for women, all built in the early 20th century. Is it legitimate to fund the construction of nine homeless shelters for women without funding more for men? Why/why not?
It's not because someone wants to help women or minorities, that they're trying to take (equal) opportunity away from you.
Yes, women do get worse outcomes than men, on average, for some measures. For example men earn more.
It is also true that women get better outcomes than men, on average, for other measures. For example women live longer.
(It is apposite that feminists/SJWs think the first issue is something that needs to be solved, but the second issue isn't).
However, the thing we are talking about is homelessness. Men are more likely to be homeless than women. Men have, in your words, a "genuine disadvantage" in this measure.
> We are not coming after you, don't be afraid.
You personally might not be, but SJWs in general want a world where white men heve less rights than people who do not have these characteristics. This needs to be fought against.
I do not believe you. (Not unless you define "SJW" to mean this, in which case instead I say: OK, but there are so few of those people and they have so little influence that I don't see why we should care very much.)
So far as I can tell, "SJWs in general" think that in the world as it presently is, white men have it better than other groups, and they are trying to make things better for those other groups, and as long as white men have it better they don't mind if the things they do to help the other groups make things worse for white men.
Now, there are plenty of ways in which that might be wrong. For instance: it might be wrong to think that white men have it better; or it might not be reasonable to try to improve other people's situation at the cost of white men's, even if the latter are better off on average. But this is not at all the same as saying that "SJWs in general" want a world where white men have less rights than non-(white men), and if you want to make that accusation then I think you should be presenting evidence for it.
It's not perfectly clear what your objection is, but if it's the sort of thing I guess then I think you're wrong, for two reasons.
Reason 1
Here are some more things "feminists/SJWs" mostly don't see as problems to be solved: Men are taller. Men are stronger. Men score better in mental-rotation speed tests.
These are all advantages men have over women (you might disagree about the first, but all else equal it generally seems to be an advantage to be taller). So why are "feminists/SJWs" not trying to change them? Because, at least so it seems, they are fairly direct consequences of biology and are not going to be changed by any plausible sort of social action; especially not if you want them changed by making things better for women rather than by making them worse for men.
I suggest that this is also a reason why "feminists/SJWs" are not making noise about men having shorter lifespans than women. It seems like a biological rather than a social thing -- it's not like men have shorter lifespans because women keep shooting them -- and so the sort of activism that defines "feminists/SJWs" isn't likely to make a difference to it.
(I bet there are some people who would describe themselves as, or at least assent when others describe them as, "feminist/SJW", and who are working on improving men's lifespans. Those people would be doctors, biologists, and medical researchers. But they aren't doing that work as "feminists/SJWs"; why should they be?)
Reason 2*
Let's suppose, arguendo, that reason 1 doesn't work out somehow; let's in fact pretend that women's longer lifespans are as plausibly the result of discrimination as men's higher pay. Would that mean that "feminists/SJWs" are being inconsistent or insincere if they focus on making things better for women, even though there are things that could be made better for men as well?
Of course not. People specialize, and there's nothing wrong with that. And part of what it means to call someone a "feminist/SJW" is that they have chosen to give their attention to problems faced by traditionally-marginalized groups in general, or women in particular. What's the problem with that?
There is plenty of signs from research that point it towards a social thing and not biological.
1# Society values men for their ability to earn money. Women are valued for their social network. Successful aging is correlated to having a strong social network since it reduces stress.
2# Dating success for men is correlated to successful risk taking in maximizing earning potential. For women it is correlated to maximize personal health.
3# Studies on the health care system has shown to tendency to underdiagnose health issues for men while the opposite for women. Suicide is still the primary cause of death for men until around age 60.
(If you're defining "feminism" so broadly as "anything that benefits women," you can't turn around and define it so narrowly as "a cause that wants white men to have less rights".)
I've read plenty of feminists argue that society needs to solve the problem of women earning less, but never read a feminist argue that society needs to solve the problem of men living shorter.
This is, on the face of it, odd, given that one of these issues is a matter of life and death and the other one is not.
Saying the wage gap isn't a matter of life and death is dishonest. It absolutely is. The worldwide life expectancy gap between the sexes is about 5 years; the life expectancy gap between the richest and poorest Americans is 15 years[1].
[1]http://news.mit.edu/2016/study-rich-poor-huge-mortality-gap-...
It doesn't matter what my skin color is since this is simply about gender and equality. I visited america recently and I've never been in a more diverse city in my life. You should know this by now. And it's obvious that I am a male since I disclosed it in my first post.
> It's not because someone wants to help women or minorities, that they're trying to take (equal) opportunity away from you.
Look at my home country Sweden, probably the most "feministic" country on earth, here there are several laws that only applies for women. 3/4 of university opportunities goes to women. Men lose 9/10 of all parental disputes when it goes to court. Recently there was suggestions to the government to pay for womens university education in IT. etc. etc. etc. etc.
Yeah, I do not believe you since the facts in my country is the exact opposite. Don't tell me you're for equality if you acts tell another story. I am very tired of that kind of shit. There is NO REASON for the organization to exclude single men. This is why I would never support the organisation or any other organisation that has the similar sexist and toxic goals.
There have been many discussions on trying to even the gender-gap for certain professions, for example getting more men to be teachers (or getting more women interested in IT). I do not know how successful they are or if they are worthwhile, but I don't see a clear gender bias.
But it is still a majority with 60% women at Swedens universities (Source: http://www.scb.se/sv_/hitta-statistik/statistik-efter-amne/u...)
But on YH (Polytechnic schools) and alike there is even a bigger majority on 69%: http://www.metro.se/artikel/s%C3%A5-stor-%C3%A4r-kvinnornas-...
Still with those facts, the swedish government employs an extreme feministic group to suggest stuff that can empower more women in academia: https://www.svt.se/opinion/article2925614.svt
Sure, all the numbers weren't really correct but the trend is still clear. Feminists only cares about women and really want to diminish men in every way possible.
Here's one in my area, the Free Clinic Beacon House. It is specifically for single homeless men. https://stpetersburgfreeclinic.org/beacon-house-2/
If you Google around, there's also homeless programs that specifically focus on veterans, homeless programs that specifically focus on women with children, and homeless shelters specifically focusing on dual parent families with children. Along with shelters for substance abuse, shelters for domestic violence victims, and general purpose shelters.
I can see the need for some separation in charities, to help charities focus more on various issues that may be more prevalent with one group vs. another.
The big reason why most of the homeless are male is because as rough an existence as that is, they can survive out there. Women simply do not last as long. They're pressured into sex work, they're dragged into abusive relationships, or they die.
Women are also more likely to be homeless with kids, a nightmare scenario. They have significantly more motivation to get off the street by any means necessary if they're in that situation. By comparison a homeless old male can just stumble along at rock bottom for decades.
Survivorship bias. Be careful how you observe things.
How does this make any sense? It's the sexist "women are weak" argument without any obsfucation. This is the exact reason why there's more shelters for women than men, broken sexist logic like this.
There's more "women-only" shelters than there are men-only ones, but it's patently false to state there's more women-only shelters than there are non-specific shelters.
show me who tried to state that
You're presenting that as comparing the situation for men and women, but it's not doing that.
You're comparing shelters that let in men (i.e. including both men-only and mixed shelters) vs shelters that only let in women.
You could just as equivalently switched the genders in the quote and it's be just as much true "Every shelter is for women by default. Men-only shelters are the exception and are far fewer in numbers"
EDIT: to all the people downvoting this, care to say what you think the problem is with what I've said?
Except that's not true. In most cities there's a handful of women-only shelters, even fewer for women with children, and yet there's a multitude of other options not gender-specific.
Here there's maybe six women-specific shelters, yet there's dozens of Salvation Army locations alone. On top of that there's other organizations that offer shelter services. They do their best to cater to everyone that abides by the rules, but there's an inherent risk in those places.
It's not that women are weak any more than men are drug addicts, but shelters don't represent society as a whole. They're heavily skewed towards certain portions of the population, and that portion tends to have problems with mental illness, substance abuse, and a multitude of other issues. It's not the environment you'd want to be in under any circumstances, especially not as a woman.
Logic doesn't work that way.
#(X or Y) > #(Y-only)
vs
#(Y or X) > #(X-only)
See how these can both be true? (See how meaningless the comparison in either one of those statements actually is? That was the point I was making).
It seems to me that people are so ideologically driven in their thinking that they could only see what I was saying as "taking one side, to the exclusion of the other".
That is, people treating my statement as like
#X > #Y
is equivalent to
#Y > #X
like you did in your millionaires/billionaires attempt at an analogy. Even though if you take the ideological blinkers off it is plainly obvious that I'm not saying anything at all like that.
My original comment would be really greyed out if not for also having received a lot of upvotes along with all the downvotes (the points count on it has swung up and down over time).
While their work appears extremely positive and (of course) every charity is not required to solve every problem, I can't help but wondering about the many many single homeless men or homeless men disconnected from the families. The best data source on homelessness, the Annual Homeless Assessment Report to Congress indicates that the majority of the homeless are single males. Up to about 10% of the homeless are veterans (a group that is vastly male) and many of them have mental illnesses like PTSD. Are these people accepted at Mary's place? Is there a "Ryan's place" shelter? Does / would Amazon sponsor it?