News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by savanaly on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:33AM (#14339174)
One thing to consider (and I swear I'm not (a) claiming this is necessarily in reality the case or (b) implying that if it were we shouldn't have a "Ryan's Place") is that there is homelessness due to different causes, some of them more amenable to help than others. If someone's homeless because they were dependent on a partner who was abusive and so they left that environment and are basically a functioning member of society who nonetheless isn't on their feet, it's a whole nother story (though arguably not more tragic) than someone who's a drug addict and therefore isn't on their feet.

For one of these two, a roof over their head and hot meals a couple times a day for a period of months is going to be extremely beneficial including in the long run, since they'll reliably be able to support themself thanks to the homeless shelter's infrastructure. For the other hypothetical case, it's still the right and humane thing to do for them, but the "bang for your buck" is lower to put it in crass terms.

If it just works out that women outnumber men in the former group, and the gender discrimination does a huge amount of work in selecting for the most efficient candidates to keep in the shelter, I'm in favor of the discrimination.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by will4274 on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:43AM (#14339867)
That's a great point. The wikipedia article and my best Google fu seems to say that while drug addiction and lack of education is common to both genders, domestic violence and poverty from supporting children are more common causes of homelessness for women and homeless men are more likely to be mentally ill. I see that providing temporary shelter for DV victims is an easier problem than mental illness. Poverty otoh..
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by nsnick on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:10AM (#14339301)
Why do you assume that homeless women are homeless because of abuse and not drug addiction, while homeless men are homeless because of drugs or PTSD? These assumptions seem incredibly sexist, especially in light of the fact that the current opioid crisis is affecting women disproportionately.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2016/08/31/opiods-...

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by msinclair on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:30AM (#14339365)
That's not really how I interpreted their message. It's more likely that a woman is homeless due to an abusive relationship than it is a man being homeless due to an abusive relationship. That isn't saying women are less likely to be homeless due to drugs. Independent statements.
[dead]
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by discodave on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:07AM (#14339474)
Because it is.

Here is a quote from wikipedia, from a sentence with 3 citations at the end of it:

"there is a large body of cross-cultural evidence that women are subjected to domestic violence significantly more often than men."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence#Gender_diffe...

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by marvin on Monday May 15, 2017 @04:47AM (#14340099)
You can't summarize a 4-paragraph nuanced discussion with "Because it is." by cherry-picking one sentence from one study. Even the Wikipedia link, which is likely to be biased in the direction of older research simply due to the volume, points out that there is significant debate around this.

Recent studies conclude with a much more equal gender distribution among victims, as OP points out.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by discodave on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:30AM (#14339569)
For anybody wondering if there is a difference between domestic abuse and domestic violence, according to the legal system, in the US, there is no clear delineation.

"Although some states use the term domestic violence while others use domestic abuse, the terms describe similar conduct."

http://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-defe...

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by HappyTypist on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:22AM (#14339530)
Domestic abuse is not the same as domestic violence.
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by nindalf on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:23AM (#14339794)
If you're going to disagree with someone, it's your responsibility to substantiate that disagreement. If that's too much of an effort, best not to say anything at all.
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by msinclair on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:15AM (#14339760)
That isn't what I said. I stated that it is more likely that a woman would be homeless from domestic abuse, not that men aren't the target of domestic abuse.
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by nsnick on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:30PM (#14342868)
Why would domestic abuse cause women to become homeless more often than men? If a woman runs away from her abuser, there are countless shelters she can go to. If a man runs away from his abuser, there is really nowhere he can go.
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by thaumasiotes on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:42AM (#14339402)
They certainly aren't independent statements.

Share of homelessness due to an abusive relationship + share of homelessness due to drugs + share of homelessness for all other reasons = 1.

If one of those variables goes higher, one or both of the others must go lower. On the assumption that one of those reasons gets more common "all else equal"... both of the others will go lower.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by msinclair on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:27AM (#14339811)
The OP didn't say that women were homeless due to abuse and not drugs and that men were homeless due to drugs/PTSD.

In fact if you read what they wrote, they didn't specify sex at all. A man can be homeless due to an abusive relationship, they never said they couldn't. Hence independent statements. nsnick was the one assuming something.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by mjevans on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:50AM (#14339428)
You are correct in the zero sum outcome for the //ENTIRE// homeless population; however you are not correct in the sense of a hypothetical subject being homeless.

A singular case subject/family could be homeless for MULTIPLE reasons or None (other than other of course) outlined above.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by thaumasiotes on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:53AM (#14339431)
> You are correct in the zero sum outcome for the //ENTIRE// homeless population; however you are not correct in the sense of a hypothetical subject being homeless.

This is wrong. What's correct as a description of the entire female homeless population is equally correct as a probability assignment for one element of it.

Your second sentence is unrelated to your first, and also applies equally well to the entire population as to an individual sample from it. It is arguing that the sum I describe is in fact more than 1. That is defensible, but it won't make the statements independent; they aren't.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by cabalamat on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:41AM (#14340304)
> Share of homelessness due to an abusive relationship + share of homelessness due to drugs + share of homelessness for all other reasons = 1.

No, because someone can be homeless for multiple reasons.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by thaumasiotes on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:28PM (#14342855)
I already acknowledged this in a cousin comment. As long as they can also be homeless for a single reason, the statements are not independent. A population of women who are homeless due to domestic abuse, but not for any other reason, simultaneously drives the share of women-homeless-due-to-domestic-abuse up and the share of women-homeless-for-reasons-other-than-domestic-abuse down.
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by chad_oliver on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:29AM (#14339362)
He explicitly doesn't assume that:

> I swear I'm not (a) claiming this is necessarily in reality the case

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by colordrops on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:46AM (#14339410)
What's the point of the comment then?
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by danjayh on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:47AM (#14339412)
and yet he goes on to say exactly that.

Hey, I'm not claiming this is actually reality, but did you know that women aren't as good at their jobs as men, and that's why they get paid less?^^

Yeah, I didn't think that putting a little disclaimer at the top was really good enough.

^^ Making a point about doublespeak. I think this statement is total BS.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by eecc on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:52AM (#14339672)
You're working yourself up the wrong tree... take it easy, it's not that anyone that doesn't exactly follow your very same mental model is a monster. Please
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by danjayh on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:36AM (#14339384)
Sounds like a lot of of stereotyping with a cop-out "hey, this is the reason! (but I really don't know)" disclaimer. Got any hard data to back this up?
[dead]
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by geofft on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:26AM (#14341000)
Just to make sure I understand you right, are you claiming that men and white people are not dominant groups in American society?
Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by cabalamat on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:25AM (#14341336)
To be specific, I am claiming:

* The vast majority of men do not have positions of power or great wealth.

* The vast majority of white people do not have positions of power or great wealth.

* The vast majority of homeless people, regardless of their race or gender, do not have positions of power or great wealth.

* White people, as a group, do not systematically oppress non-white people, preventing them from attaining power and wealth.

* Men, as a group, do not systematically oppress non-male people, preventing them from attaining power and wealth.

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by gjm11 on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:38AM (#14342397)
Those claims seem to me very different from -- and compatible with the negation of -- your earlier statement that it's wrong to consider "men" and "white people" dominant groups in society.

Since pretty much any claim about how these things are in the real world is liable to be controversial, here's a toy example to illustrate. Imagine a world in which (1) hundreds of years ago it became, never mind why, very widely believed that men are better and cleverer and harder-working than women, (2) such beliefs are extremely resistant to change regardless of empirical evidence, and (3) as a result of the persistence of that belief, men are consistently given better jobs, paid more, regarded as more trustworthy, etc., etc., etc., than women. But, as in our world, great power and great wealth are rare, and most people whether male or female don't have them.

In that world, the vast majority of men don't have great power or great wealth, and any oppressing that's going on is being done by everyone collectively; but, in that world, men are by any reasonable definition a dominant group: they are greatly overrepresented (relative to their numbers in society as a whole) among the powerful, the rich, the high-status.

So, let's return to geofft's question. Everything in your list could be true without making it false that men and white people are dominant groups in American society. Do you, in addition to holding the positions in your list, further believe that they are not dominant groups?

What would be your estimate for the proportion of men in the following groups in the US: (1) people with an annual income of $250k or more, (2) holders of national-level political office, (3) people with "executive" in their job title, (4) owners of businesses, (5) judges, (6) generals, (7) (full) professors, (8) religious ministers? What about the proportion of white people?

I'll make my prediction: in all those groups, the fraction of both men and white people will be greater than their fraction in the population at large; in several of those groups, much greater. Do you disagree? If so, let's check. If not, why don't you think this makes men and white people "dominant groups"? (Note that "dominant" is not the same as "oppressive".)

Re:Amazon to Build a Permanent Mary's Place Family Shelter W... by geofft on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:03PM (#14343166)
> White people, as a group, do not systematically oppress non-white people, preventing them from attaining power and wealth.

If you want to challenge this belief, I strongly recommend reading The New Jim Crow by Michelle Alexander (which I'm currently partway through). I'll still respect your position if you read it and continue to believe the above, but it's got a lot of good information and good analysis that's worth being aware of.