News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by LeonM on Monday May 08, 2017 @02:45PM (#14294372)
YouTube creators are highly undervalued.

Many of them are highly influential amongst their viewers and have more views than your average mid-tier TV show. Youtube also offers much better insight in the audience than TV channels ever can achieve.

And yet, the content creators need to rely on Patreon and selling merchandise to pay for their expenses.

I'm not saying all of them are struggling, in some niches (for example cosmetics) YouTube creators are known to make a pretty hefty buck in sponsorship deals, but the majority is highly undervalued.

Alejandro Salomon recently talked about this in his podcast [1], since this phenomenon is especially true in the automotive sector.

[1] https://youtu.be/fcIgvYzSFm4?t=1936

edit: typo

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by michaelbuckbee on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:36PM (#14294841)
If you want to see a really crisp example of this it's with food shows.

Look at this disparity:

"In 2015, more than 400,000 people on average are watching Food Network at some point during the day." [1]

Then check out Nerdy Nummies (a YT channel I found out b/c my 6yo loves it). [2] which is regularly breaking 1M views per episode, has 8+Million subscribers and lifetime has generated 1,949,110,170 views for YouTube [3]

And all of those numbers in a demographic that doesn't even realize the Food Network exists, with a pittance of the resources, no outside marketing and compensated a fraction as well.

1 - http://brandongaille.com/40-captivating-food-network-demogra...

2 - https://www.youtube.com/user/RosannaPansino

3 - https://www.youtube.com/user/RosannaPansino/about

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by johnnydoe9 on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:48PM (#14294928)
Even the more niche creators are getting pretty good attention, I've been watching Binging With Babish [1] and he recreates dishes seen on movies and tv shows. They taste bad mostly so he fixes them. Has been getting good amount of views consistently.

1 - https://www.youtube.com/user/bgfilms/videos

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by michaelbuckbee on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:08PM (#14295120)
A great example. He has a Patreon [1] that's making him $6k / month as he's getting pretty near 1M views per video.

1 - https://www.patreon.com/bingingwithbabish

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by puranjay on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @02:15AM (#14298068)
My wife and I have stopped watching food/travel shows. Instead, we just put on some of our favorite food channels on YouTube - like FoodRanger (Trevor James) or Migrationology (Mark Wiens).

I don't even get what TV channels are doing anymore. Trevor James' video on street food in Mumbai has around 8.5M views. He is also awkwardly affable and a great, gracious host.

Why aren't TV execs giving people like him TV deals is beyond me.

Here, you have a guy who has nearly 700,000 subscribers, is fun to watch and averages over a million views for each video...and you hire some no-name moron to host your TV travel shows instead?

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by unprepare on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:52AM (#14301045)
Maybe these people do get offers but prefer to work on their own schedules and without cumbersome contracts.

If you were making really good money making youtube videos, why would you want to sign on with food network (who probably demands things like good behavior clauses and stuff in their contracts), have to shoot a real tv show on the networks schedule, doing reshoots and promotional events, etc at the beck and call of some executive?

I absolutely agree that these youtubers are underpaid for the value that they create/the audiences they have accumulated; im just not as surprised that we arent seeing them convert into tv and movie personalities

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by hayd on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @04:22PM (#14303485)
> If you were making really good money making youtube videos, why would you want to sign on with food network

because they'd pay you even better money!

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by josephb on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @09:21PM (#14305241)
> because they'd pay you even better money!

That's assuming money matters :-)

Often people who are running their own world and in control of their own destiny are happy to stay that way regardless of better money.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by unicornporn on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @04:02AM (#14298428)
Thanks a lot. Trevor James was fantastic! Do you have more recommendations?
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by puranjay on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @05:33AM (#14298687)
Try the StrictlyDumpling channel for Japanese and Chinese food
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by matthewrudy on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @08:33AM (#14299426)
I'm a big fan of Hellthy Junk Food.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by Pulcinella on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:15PM (#14295181)
How "valuable" is a viewer of YouTube channel like that versus a viewer of the food network. For example, I've heard that many viewers of various toy unboxing videos are young children. I can't imagine most advertisers want to pay money only to have their ad viewed by somebody with basically no disposable income.

Edit: My comment was not about advertising to children directly. I was using that as an example. I'm not sure if a view on YouTube has the same value as a view in more traditional media (e.g. Television).

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by bigtunacan on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:30PM (#14295311)
I'm guessing by this comment that you don't have children? Kids are great customers. They are impulsive and buy into whatever flashy thing is on the TV or the current toy their friend has they must have too. The money flows from the pocket of mom, dad, grandparents, and other adult family members directly into junk for the kids. The kids are then bored of hot new toy X after a week and the cycle repeats.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by colefichter on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:20PM (#14295232)
You don't think advertisers want to market to children? I hope this was sarcasm and I'm just missing the joke.

Have you walked down the cereal aisle in a grocery store?

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by Pulcinella on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:36PM (#14295359)
Have you seen YouTube advertisements? Half the time the ad has nothing to do with the video. I've seen ads for cement mix in front of video game videos.

If I want to advertise my stand mixer, I don't want to have to pay when my ad is seen by a 5 year old just because a video about gummy bears was tagged "culinary."

I understand advertisers want to "get 'em while they're young" and want children to pester their parents to buy things, but 2 million views from children is not the same thing as 2 million views from the 18-35 bracket.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by taysic on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:03PM (#14295585)
I think Youtube advertisements are very targeted toward you, and not necessarily relevant to the video. Google uses the information it has on you and plays the products that have paid the most for your demographic from what I understand.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by emiliobumachar on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:01PM (#14295556)
My 3-year-old illiterate child keeps saying "skip" and pounding the skip button until it becomes available, every time he sees an YouTube add.

Hypothesis: maybe they're all like that?

(I do limit and monitor his YouTube use)

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by developer2 on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @02:54AM (#14298202)
Considering just how susceptible children are to advertising brainwashing, you might shed the guilt of skirting video ads on YouTube by installing an ad blocker (ex: uBlock Origin). Morality of blocking ads aside, I wouldn't want my children watching the number of pre-roll ads that YouTube pushes out. As a side effect, your child won't spend an hour a week clicking a skip button, or sitting though the ads that aren't even skippable.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:59PM (#14295544)
The toy unboxing channels exist entirely because they are so effective for attracting advertisers. Those weird 'Spiderman vs. pregnant Elsa' style videos are so popular for the same reason. Kids are perhaps the most valuable demographic for Youtube.

All in all I get the impression that Youtube had difficulty commanding the kind of money that TV advertisements generate, even before the recent ad crisis.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by kbar13 on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:21PM (#14295238)
yes but I would argue that product endorsements and advertising to young impressionable minds is extremely valuable.

The example I'd like to highlight is the success Apple gained through placing Macs everywhere in education. Students almost certainly cannot afford these machines but everyone has one and that's better marketing than anything else.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by PeterisP on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:47PM (#14295436)
Is there any practical/economic reason why mainstream TV channels aren't broadcasting episodes from such creators?

I mean, there's a bunch of hassle and negotiations to organize licencing, but that's kind of what these organizations know how to do.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by ramy_d on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:03PM (#14295577)
The content is so different in terms of format and length.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by prostoalex on Monday May 08, 2017 @11:32PM (#14297548)
Well, 400,000 viewers on average over 24 hours translates into 9.6 mil unique viewers a day (I estimated a standard Food Network show to run at 60 minutes, hence the 24 hour multiplier). Miltiplied by 365 days that translates into 3.5 bil annual views. Not lifetime, just annual.

And that's just the US Food Network before international syndication rights (as well as rebroadcasting rights through venues like YouTube or cable channel's on-demand), so a relatively clean and monetizable demographics.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by Naritai on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:22AM (#14297914)
It doesn't say 400,000 viewers per hour. Rather, it could be interpreted to say that an average day has a maximum peak viewership of 400,000.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by michaelbuckbee on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @09:36AM (#14299835)
The _on average_ was across days -> that on a typical day maybe 400,000 unique viewers have watched something on Food Network.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by MrFoof on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:43PM (#14295402)
Not surprised, considering the producer is HuskyStarcraft, and Rosanna isn't exactly "slacking off" herself. Basically what should be considered the benchmark for high production value on both ends.

If you were to make a food show worth mentioning, your standard for a presenter and production should be no lower. Take that with a different format, food, and possibly a theme and I'd say "general success" for one or two people to make a normal, middle class living is attainable.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by komali2 on Monday May 08, 2017 @02:59PM (#14294494)
>undervalued

I think this is arguable based on the meaning of "value." For example, what I would say are the "highest value" channels, i.e. educational, review, informational etc are not getting as much payout as "Spiderman and Elsa Sit On Eachother's Heads" or "man blows out his microphone screaming at minecraft" videos. I mean, capitalism, yea, I get it, people like Spiderman and Elsa more than learning about stuff.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by kbenson on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:06PM (#14294558)
I think it's fairly obvious that in a discussion about advertising, and how they are feeling the pinch of advertisers leaving youtube, in this discussion value is based on advertisers, since they are the ones paying.

This interpretation seems to be supported by the supporting statements included. Their value to you might be entirely different.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by gotchange on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:13PM (#14294645)
These questionable material in your opinion could have more entertainment value than other those educational and scientific material on YT and entertainment is more lucrative for advertisers than other genres.

This is a value judgement and therefore it's subjective and function of personal preferences.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by SilasX on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:02PM (#14295061)
Agreed. When I think of "goods that are underproduced relative to the social optimum due to how little of the value the producer is able to capture", youtube stars are nowhere near that list.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by Namrog84 on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:08PM (#14294579)
True but there are likely a few channels or videos that bring new users to the platform and then view other content and yet that creator only gets what that user viewed on their video. Not the fact that they likely brought a lot of views to the platform (rise in water lifts all hosts scenario)

I highly suspect if you look at what all the content creators and people receive via ads. Plus overhead of running YouTube. They are likely making tons more money in profit when main content creators are getting the short stick.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by puranjay on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @02:18AM (#14298078)
Well, I noticed that Dr. Jordan Peterson is getting like $32k in Patreon every month, so there's that.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by Taylor_OD on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:04PM (#14294542)
Yes. Highly Undervalued. I look forward to the weekly videos from my favorite Youtubers almost as much as my favorite big budget HBO/TV shows. I'm fairly young (24) but I'm not exactly the audience that most people picture when they think of people who are really into Youtube.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stupidhn on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:38PM (#14294864)
>Yes. Highly Undervalued. I look forward to the weekly videos from my favorite Youtubers almost as much as my favorite big budget HBO/TV shows.

How much of a monthly contribution are you making to the content creator?

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by jerf on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:51PM (#14294954)
I'm not Taylor_OD, but Patreon's currently running me about $70/month, with a non-trivial fraction of that being Youtube shows.

Having occasionally been pitching Patreon to the point that I almost feel like I'm shilling it, I do at least put my money where my mouth is.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by cowpewter on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:25PM (#14295267)
I back my favorite youtubers on Patreon at somewhere between $1-5 each. My monthly Patreon charge is north of $50 right now. I pay more per month for supporting Youtube content than I do for Hulu & Netflix combined.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by wcfields on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:45PM (#14294906)
Me viewing it along with the advertisements
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stupidhn on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:51PM (#14294946)
This is nothing against you, I do it too:

I find it hard to reconcile people arguing that they love content, and how it's "undervalued" on one hand, then stating that they pay <$1 for the product.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by electroly on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @10:52AM (#14300496)
There's nothing to reconcile. "Spot the hypocrite" is just a form of ad-hominem attack and has no place here. Arguments stand on their own merits. If it's true that YouTube creators are undervalued, then it's still true even if the person who said it doesn't pay at all.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by ChuckMcM on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:28PM (#14294773)
Yup, and this is the fundamental challenge Youtube has yet to overcome. Why is it worth $40,000 for a company to run a commercial on a TV show with half a million viewers but only $1,000 to spend on rolling their add before a Youtube video with half a million views?

There is the temporal bit, a TV show ad hits all viewers at the same time and on a particular date so you can put time specific information in it. And there is a diffusion bit, you can spend $40,000 for your ad across all videos that are rolling with > 1M subscribers so your ad money hits a bunch of different people rather than one person.

If Google could convince advertisers to pay more for advertising, they could compensate their content creators more. But they can't so they don't.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by rtkwe on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:43PM (#14294894)
There's also ad effectiveness to toss more variables into the mix. There's also the huge difference in the amount of possible content and time slots for a youtube vs a TV ad. There's a very limited amount of commercial time available in primetime popular shows vs the huge number of videos uploaded each day to youtube.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by afarrell on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @02:24AM (#14298099)
I jist wish I could tell youtube "I've seen this ad more than 200 times. I am well aware that if I ever want to lose a bunch of money and feel shitty about myself, I can download Trading212. Please sell me different things."

Then again, I can't convince gmail that I'm not interested in local singles, despite the fact that 70% of my emails are sent to another gmail user that I share bunches of calendar events with.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by doubleplusgood on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @03:45AM (#14298377)
If you're logged in, you can blacklist specific topics on Google's Ad Settings page[0] quite easily (you can also turn off tailored ads completely).

https://www.google.com/settings/ads/

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by daemin on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @05:08AM (#14298617)
So the ad has worked, in that it has raised awareness and you know of the product.

For the record I do find those annoying, but I often let them roll so the content creator gets that cash.

What I do find annoying are the really long ads, ones that are several minutes long and are played before a short several minute video.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by afarrell on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:58PM (#14302389)
Sure, but the opportunity cost of making me aware of a product repeatedly seems pretty high. I wish I could make the ads more targeted.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stcredzero on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:29PM (#14294777)
YouTube creators are highly undervalued.

How far away are we from direct micropayments to creators, as envisioned by Scott McCloud?

http://www.scottmccloud.com/3-home/essays/2003-09-micros/mic...

Right now, YouTube has to deal with advertisers on behalf of its creators, which means the perverse incentives of advertisers leak through and affect YouTube's relationship with its creators. YouTube could seek to outsource the advertiser relationship to the "Networks" that aggregate YouTube creators. There could be a model where you have independent creators that thrive off of micropayments, while larger channels could be aggregated by networks which deal with the advertisers.

Right now, Patreon is great, but the friction is still a bit too high.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by derefr on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:36PM (#14294844)
Micropayments are hard in general, because you have to solve a problem "for everybody" without creating a single monopoly ad-network-alike corporation to handle the money in the process.

But they can be solved in the specific case. Spotify is basically micropayments: you pay a subscription, the site tracks plays, and then the site reimburses content creators proportionally to their plays.

I feel like you could create a "Youtube killer" that used the Spotify system pretty easily.

But, of course, you would need people to actually pay a subscription. Youtube Red doesn't seem to be doing very well. (That might just be because people expect Youtube content to be free, though. It might be different if all the content is behind the subscription paywall from the start.)

Either way, you'll lose Youtube's viral aspect, that comes down to millions of ten-year-olds with tons of time and no money spreading your content.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stcredzero on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:45PM (#14295422)
(That might just be because people expect Youtube content to be free, though. It might be different if all the content is behind the subscription paywall from the start.)

Either way, you'll lose Youtube's viral aspect, that comes down to millions of ten-year-olds with tons of time and no money spreading your content.

You can have advertiser-driven content for ten-year-olds and paywalled content for people who have money.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by derefr on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:03PM (#14295581)
...which is what Youtube Red is. But everyone starts by consuming the advertiser-driven content, and this content anchors them on what the platform "should" cost.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stcredzero on Monday May 08, 2017 @06:35PM (#14296266)
...which is what Youtube Red is

Not exactly. YouTube Red distributes funds in a manner similar to Spotify.

But everyone starts by consuming the advertiser-driven content, and this content anchors them on what the platform "should" cost.

How is it that growing up with a guardian doesn't "anchor" everyone on what everything "should" cost?

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by fzzzy on Monday May 08, 2017 @07:33PM (#14296548)
YouTube Red does have Red-exclusive content, too.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by dredmorbius on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:01PM (#14295566)
We are a long, long, long, long way from a micropayments ecosystem. It's fundamentally at odds with information goods, particularly in mass media.

https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4r683b/repudia...

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stcredzero on Monday May 08, 2017 @07:12PM (#14296460)
Cognitive Load -- TL;DR: this continues to compound the cognitive overload of payment for content.

Under Brin's system, now I've got to:

    Decide if I want to read something.
    Decide if I want to pay for reading something.
    Decide if I've got buyer's remorse for having paid for something, and if so,
    Wrestle with the vendor's reimbursement system in the event of any dispute.1
1) Happens no matter what.

2) Can be automatic, so no decision applies. If the cost is low enough, it could just amount to some slightly varying small amount that gets auto-paid every month. It would be just like FastTrak toll payment -- something I don't really think about.

3) and 4) I don't think like this with regard to Patreon. If I decide a creator doesn't deserve my money anymore, I just stop paying them. I really couldn't give a rat's ass about the $1 I sent them last month.

So fundamentally at odds with information goods, particularly in mass media -- Wat!? Where is the evidence? Is Netflix massively out-earning Amazon Prime Video? If this was the case, why did video rental ever happen, and how does RedBox still exist? How does Steam and the Apple App Store exist and make money, for that matter? Apps and video games are just media, after all.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by dredmorbius on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @12:52AM (#14297809)
Fair questions. I've addressed a number of these in existing articles concerning information and markets. A search of my subreddit turns up most of these:

https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=information+ma...

Specific to your questions:

1. The problem with per-article paid access is that the question of access is tied to the question of cost. I'm working at a scale of information where I'm looking at thousands of books and articles. The overhead is nontrivial.

A library model -- where you simply have stacks access and don't pay per item viewed -- works out quite well. A rental model, where you're aware that each item carries some access cost, however low: $10, $1, $0.10, $0.1 -- adds up. For much of the world, any per-item cost is high.

The Internet offers us several such "library" models --Sci-Hub, LibGen, and BookZZ each provided unencumbered access to massive troves of published material. Extralegally.

Yes, you might find some way of wedging a paid-access metering model onto this, but to what end? Consider that the average American spends something on the order of $200 on direct media purchases (books, magazines, music, video) in a year, and an indirect $600 or so in advertising. Which has all kinds of distortionary effects on what is available, or produced. There are ~300k writers and editors in the country, whose core need is to a) keep a roof over their head and food on the table and b) have the tools for writing available to them. Seems to me that cutting out the inefficiencies and distortions of advertising would be a net win.

Your 2) is false: at some point, I've got to consciously decide whether or not I'm paying for content. Otherwise you're making a sham of the concept of a discretionary payment system.

For 3 & 4: it depends on what the granularity of the system is, on both payments and units of consumption.

First, with Patreon, you aren't paying for access to individual items of content, for the most part. The models vary, but range from "I'm pitching in to support someon I believe in" to "I'm gaining time-based channel access".

There's a word for that last, it's call a subscription. And subscription-based media access ... is very much a thing.

There's an entire industry that grew up around this, at a previous time when per-item access to media was expensive, and the joint problems of "how do I sample the wares" (for audiences) and "how do we keep our authors fed , housed, and clothed" (for broadcasters) came up.

The answer was the literary or publisher's magazine.

This was a regularly-produced (weekly, monthly, quarterly) publication, with a stable of writers, a compilation of works included with each issue, often publishing longer works in serial form, etc., etc.

It served as an advertisement for long-form books, should subscribers choose to buy them. It mitigated the risks (and bundled purchasing decisions), at the level of multiple authors (anywhere from a handful to 100s), on an annual basis, and generally offered something in any given issue worth reading.

It wasn't until the 1860s or so that additional advertising (beyond the books and publications themselves) became a significant component, though that grew rapidly through the last half of the 19th century. Hamilton Holt's Commercialism and Journalism, 1909, covers this in a brief 115 page booklet (available at the Internet Archive). (Holt was a magazine publisher, reporting on the industry.)

I see the present situation of one in which the question of where and how the bundling size has changed, and is shaking out. The previous regime served the needs and limits of paper-based publication, as well as vinyl & CD-based audio, and VCR and DVD-based video. In a world of ubiquitous digital distribution, those limits and gateways no longer exist.

And information is a public good, as Google's Chief Economist argues.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stcredzero on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:18AM (#14297903)
1. The problem with per-article paid access is that the question of access is tied to the question of cost. I'm working at a scale of information where I'm looking at thousands

Prices should be in tenths of a penny.

Your 2) is false: at some point, I've got to consciously decide whether or not I'm paying for content. Otherwise you're making a sham of the concept of a discretionary payment system.

Much as bundling has made a sham of cable programming consumer choice? Micropayments done correctly would pay directly per view. You'd exercise consumer choice by visiting or not visiting. If you're dissatisfied with a content producer, you stop visiting. If micropayments are measured in tenths of a penny, it's not even worth getting the refund. Instead of having your eyeballs paid for indirectly through advertisers, both viewers and advertisers can be bidding for your eyeballs. Long tail advertisers will be better served, and long tail consumers will be treated better by advertisers.

For 3 & 4: it depends on what the granularity of the system...The answer was the literary or publisher's magazine.

Note that digital goods aren't as limited in granularity as they were in the days of paper, vinyl, & CD.

And information is a public good, as Google's Chief Economist argues.

There are problems with advertisements paying for public goods. That's subject to its own kind of "Tradgedy of the Commons."

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by dredmorbius on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @06:42AM (#14298914)
> Prices should be in tenths of a penny.

Sorry, per item? Or graded in tenths of a cent?

On what basis? What do you see a total spend being? What kind of income do authors, composers, filmakers receive? Independent of work length or effort? What works are you incentivising as a consequence?

And again, to what end, and providing what kind of information structure.

Think through the pricing system, because 1) this isn't trivial, 2) what you incentivise matters and 3) what matters, ultimately, is whether and how those who can write are paid relative to other options.

> Micropayments ... would pay per view.

Why is that a desireable objective?

Should, say, healthcare, education, or fire prevention be paid on a per-service basis, by those who receive those services directly? Why or why not? What are the consequences of such a payments system? How do those consequences change with different social (or urban) environments, or shape those environments.

Bonus: Look up Crassus. After you answer. Adjust accordingly, if you like.

> Digital goods aren't limited in granularity...

No, but attention is markedly finite. Purchase decisions are a high-attention action.

> Advertising ... "Tragedy of the Commons"

I'm generally familiar with advertising, and quite familiar with the Tragedy of the Commons. I don't see how these two go together.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by pc86 on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:57PM (#14295010)
If Google bought Patreon they could integrate it directly into YouTube, but Patreon isn't platform-specific. It's hard to get something that's platform independent like Patreon and have it also integrate well with all the different content platforms out there.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by SimbaOnSteroids on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:52PM (#14295493)
Shouldn't they have some form of API that allows you to integrate it onto a webpage?
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by FullMtlAlcoholc on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:49PM (#14295472)
This is where an easy to use cryptocurrency could be useful
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by mahyarm on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:19PM (#14295713)
Currently at $1.50 transaction fee defaults with BTC.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by droidist2 on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @06:23AM (#14298854)
Litecoin then?
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by noobermin on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:12PM (#14294627)
Youtube created a place where thousands of content creators were free to produce and generate a following while making a decent living. The issue of course is once Youtube fell, that ecosystem felt the pinch. Once again, we are seeing yet another issue with having a monopoly in a market.

People are spinning this as either incompetence of Youtube or the sheepish fears of advertizers, but I think the real story here is this serves as a good example when there isn't competition and there are a lack of alternate providers.

Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by stuffedBelly on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:34PM (#14295335)
I recently started seeing some great YouTube musicians (Davie504, Pellek, etc) have to make videos to promote their Patreon due to sharp decline of revenue and I feel bad for them. Music production, especially for indie musicians, is very expensive (equipments, DAW plugins, hiring people to mix and master, etc). It's a very sad situation and a massive discouragement for YouTubers to keep up their video quality, in a long run, bad for YouTube as a content distribution platform.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by jasonkostempski on Monday May 08, 2017 @03:58PM (#14295022)
I feel like YouTubers of this caliber should have a more direct relationship with YouTube and the advertisers. They should be able to agree to set specific points in videos for commercial breaks and have the commercial steam directly as part of the main content to avoid ad blocking.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by thaumasiotes on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:26PM (#14295279)
For this to work fully, you'd also have to get rid of the ability to seek the video.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by mistermann on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:57PM (#14295521)
It would help, but you don't have to....more and more people are treating YouTube like TV - I watch on my TV via Chromecast, laying down on the couch, if a commercial comes on, I'm not getting up to skip it, first because I'm too lazy, and second because a 30 second commercial now and then seems perfectly reasonable compared to the alternative.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by thaumasiotes on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @02:09AM (#14298051)
A wireless mouse will relieve you of the need to get up.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by jasonkostempski on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:25PM (#14311323)
It shouldn't work fully, the preference and power ads are given now is already way too much, which is why everyone is trying so hard to block them. Besides, there are things that can be done, such as, if the user seeks past a commercial point, they get a commercial and then the normal content resumes. I'm sure cable providers would love this evil power for their DVRs too but even normal people would flip out over that.
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by gkop on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @02:27AM (#14298108)
Even using DASH?
Re:YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch by pjc50 on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:36PM (#14295363)
Youtube creators are also highly oversupplied. :(