I don't even get what TV channels are doing anymore. Trevor James' video on street food in Mumbai has around 8.5M views. He is also awkwardly affable and a great, gracious host.
Why aren't TV execs giving people like him TV deals is beyond me.
Here, you have a guy who has nearly 700,000 subscribers, is fun to watch and averages over a million views for each video...and you hire some no-name moron to host your TV travel shows instead?
If you were making really good money making youtube videos, why would you want to sign on with food network (who probably demands things like good behavior clauses and stuff in their contracts), have to shoot a real tv show on the networks schedule, doing reshoots and promotional events, etc at the beck and call of some executive?
I absolutely agree that these youtubers are underpaid for the value that they create/the audiences they have accumulated; im just not as surprised that we arent seeing them convert into tv and movie personalities
because they'd pay you even better money!
That's assuming money matters :-)
Often people who are running their own world and in control of their own destiny are happy to stay that way regardless of better money.
Edit: My comment was not about advertising to children directly. I was using that as an example. I'm not sure if a view on YouTube has the same value as a view in more traditional media (e.g. Television).
Have you walked down the cereal aisle in a grocery store?
If I want to advertise my stand mixer, I don't want to have to pay when my ad is seen by a 5 year old just because a video about gummy bears was tagged "culinary."
I understand advertisers want to "get 'em while they're young" and want children to pester their parents to buy things, but 2 million views from children is not the same thing as 2 million views from the 18-35 bracket.
Hypothesis: maybe they're all like that?
(I do limit and monitor his YouTube use)
All in all I get the impression that Youtube had difficulty commanding the kind of money that TV advertisements generate, even before the recent ad crisis.
The example I'd like to highlight is the success Apple gained through placing Macs everywhere in education. Students almost certainly cannot afford these machines but everyone has one and that's better marketing than anything else.
I mean, there's a bunch of hassle and negotiations to organize licencing, but that's kind of what these organizations know how to do.
And that's just the US Food Network before international syndication rights (as well as rebroadcasting rights through venues like YouTube or cable channel's on-demand), so a relatively clean and monetizable demographics.
If you were to make a food show worth mentioning, your standard for a presenter and production should be no lower. Take that with a different format, food, and possibly a theme and I'd say "general success" for one or two people to make a normal, middle class living is attainable.
Look at this disparity:
"In 2015, more than 400,000 people on average are watching Food Network at some point during the day." [1]
Then check out Nerdy Nummies (a YT channel I found out b/c my 6yo loves it). [2] which is regularly breaking 1M views per episode, has 8+Million subscribers and lifetime has generated 1,949,110,170 views for YouTube [3]
And all of those numbers in a demographic that doesn't even realize the Food Network exists, with a pittance of the resources, no outside marketing and compensated a fraction as well.
1 - http://brandongaille.com/40-captivating-food-network-demogra...
2 - https://www.youtube.com/user/RosannaPansino
3 - https://www.youtube.com/user/RosannaPansino/about