Vanguard, however, is owned by it's investors if that's important to you.
Last I checked you can also trade some Vanguard ETFs on Robinhood as well. I just checked, you can buy VOO, among others, on Robinhood as well as iShares ETFs, which are also low cost index funds.
Basically, if you want low cost index funds you have a lot of options, including Robinhood
(1)https://www.fidelity.com/mutual-funds/investing-ideas/index-...
(2)https://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/nn/m/indexfunds.html
But I use Merrill Edge as a commission-free brokerage (30 trades per month with $50k assets, 100 trades per month with $100k assets). The upside (apart from not being limited to iShares at Fidelity and Schwab at Schwab) is in the credit card, which beats Fidelity.
Bank of America Travel Rewards rates:
* $50k+ Merrill Edge Balance: 2.25% travel rewards cash back
* $100k+ Merrill Edge Balance: 2.625% travel rewards cash back
Bank of America Cash Rewards:
* $100k+ Merrill Edge Balance: 3.5% groceries, 5.25% gas cash back.
Great deal. Oh, and they'll often pay you about 0.5% (up to $1000) of assets to transfer your equities in. Holding Vanguard/Schwab/iShares ETFs there is a dream for a personal finance geek. The credit card deal alone makes it all worthwhile.
My point was, while Vanguard is certainly a great option, there's plenty of other great options out there as well.
Yup, even Warren Buffet tells his rich friends to do so too:
http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2016ltr.pdf
Over the years, I’ve often been asked for investment advice, and in the process of answering I’ve learned a good deal about human behavior. My regular recommendation has been a low-cost S&P 500 index fund. To their credit, my friends who possess only modest means have usually followed my suggestion.
I believe, however, that none of the mega-rich individuals, institutions or pension funds has followed that same advice when I’ve given it to them. Instead, these investors politely thank me for my thoughts and depart to listen to the siren song of a high-fee manager or, in the case of many institutions, to seek out another breed of hyper-helper called a consultant.
That professional, however, faces a problem. Can you imagine an investment consultant telling clients, year after year, to keep adding to an index fund replicating the S&P 500? That would be career suicide. Large fees flow to these hyper-helpers, however, if they recommend small managerial shifts every year or so. That advice is often delivered in esoteric gibberish that explains why fashionable investment “styles” or current economic trends make the shift appropriate.
The wealthy are accustomed to feeling that it is their lot in life to get the best food, schooling, entertainment, housing, plastic surgery, sports ticket, you name it. Their money, they feel, should buy them something superior compared to what the masses receive.
Listen, I understand that this is widespread, so I'm not targeting you specifically. But could we try not to use generalizations like "millenial", especially when they refer to vaguely defined generational boundaries?
Your point is very strong, and stands on its own without making what I interpret as an implicitly ageist assumption about a large swath of the population. Millenials are adults. Young adults, sure, but they have agency. It is no more predatory or clearly unethical to lend to them versus lending to baby boomers or gen X.
I take issue with this because you have implicitly robbed them of their agency as a group by phrasing your criticism as "Enticing millenials...". There's no reason to single them out. They may have less money as a group, yes, but there's nothing about trading on margin that makes it inherently more dangerous for millenials over any other generation.
You didn't mean to intentionally portray them this way, but you singled out a particular group because, like I said, it's ubiquitous. We should really try to curb that, in my opinion.
Any negative assumptions being read into the phrase "enticing millennials" are created by the reader's own bias. I think because so many articles are published complaining about "those damn millennials" we automatically assume anyone using the word is doing so in a negative way. I wasn't (I am a millennial myself).
Robinhood's strategy would be predatory in the context of any target market. If they were going after boomers, I would have said "enticing boomers."
Are you sure about that? I'm the only person I know in my age group using Robinhood. But it's gotten popular with my parents and their friends for example. My mom tried to sign up for Gold before I stopped her.
I don't think they're enticing millennials, just anyone who doesn't understand finance or trading very well, which it seems is most people.
FYI, in the context of traditional brokerage houses (and in most places outside the valley) a 37-yr old is still a "young" customer.
'Given that active managers’ performance can vary based on market cycles, the newly available 15-year data tells a more stable narrative. Over the 15-year period ending Dec. 2016, 92.15% of large-cap, 95.4% of mid-cap, and 93.21% of small-cap managers trailed their respective benchmarks.' [1]
The question folks need to ask is this - Will my stock trading strategy + low (zero with Robinhood?) trading fees outperform 90%+ of the top fund managers who are using the most sophisticated investment tools available? If not, just buy index funds and spend as little as a few hours / year managing your investments :)
[1] http://us.spindices.com/documents/spiva/spiva-us-year-end-20...
"Top fund managers" are working with billions in AUM. If you have found meaningful alpha on a portfolio of $100k - $10M (or a section of capital within that range), you will have an easier time capitalizing on that strategy than a fund manager who needs to figure out how to scale a profitable strategy to billions in assets.
Difficulty in getting orders filled on one end and literally moving the price on the other are two big reasons it's far easier to find profitable strategies on relatively smaller portfolios. It's not just a comparison of the tools and skills used in institutional funds. The amount of money they are working with is an obstacle in of itself.
This is also why, incidentally, the most successful hedge funds in the world typically close their doors to outside capital and cap it at, say $10B or so.
Would you know if Robinhood supports pre-authorized purchase plans? For example the ability to buy x shares of VOO on the first day of each month automatically? I didn't see anything on the FAQ but maybe I missed it. Pre-authorized purchase plans + no commissions could be interesting.
I'll try to do a blog post when I get the chance.
There is an unofficial api[1] you could use to cron-buy, though it's unofficial-ness means I don't officially endorse :)
[0] https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/206445496-Tr... [1] https://github.com/sanko/Robinhood
I totally agree with your investment strategy, and you can do that on Robinhood, by the way.
Use the advisor (robo or human) services of any of the top online brokers and they will recommend you put your money in index funds.
Also, putting together a "long term" portfolio of indexes at Robinhood assumes that Robinhood will be around offering free trades for the next 40 years. Otherwise you're looking at hefty capital gains taxes to transfer when they pivot or go belly up.
There once was a company called Zecco...
you should be able to account transfer out without causing a taxable sale.
how well that will go in the event they pivot or fail and have to transfer your assets over to some backup service is of course unknown.
Good question - this is an on-going topic in the market actually. The correct answer, like a lot of financial economic theory goes, is that no one actually really knows.
---
Yes, you need somebody to listen to the news, crunch numbers, and then actively trade stocks in order to set an accurate price. But what matters here isn't the percentage, it's the absolute number of active traders, and their analysis "skill". Let's say you start with 50k professional bankers and 50k totally passive etf investors like you and me. Let's say that the passive investors buy/sell based on events that are totally uncorrelated with the market; they buy small orders of VTI every once in a while when they have a bit of extra cash, and they sell large blocks when they experience major life events like buying a house or having a kid. In other words, their effect on prices is random. Also let's assume that new passive investors are introduced into this system gradually, and that we're taking a "long term" view of everything. In this case, having another 100k, or 500k, new passive investors riding the wave of market growth doesn't change anything.
On the other hand, going back to our 50k/50k split, if you add another 100k poorly-performing analysts into the mix, e.g. uneducated consumers day-trading on emotion instead of news, they'll distort prices and create a bit of market inefficiency. Distorted prices are actually good for the above-average analysts, since they'll capture those extra pennies on their trades by more-accurately pricing stocks, but obviously bad for the below-average traders themselves--who will underperform the market--and the passive investors--who just buy/sell at market prices. You can kind of think of this situation as the etf investors paying an additional "management fee" to the good traders for their trading expertise.
So to summarize, the percentage of passive traders to total traders doesn't matter as long as the absolute number of active traders doesn't decrease, which won't happen because of the large incentives created whenever the system moves away from equilibrium.
---
Now, in practice you'll never have completely passive investors. People will panic if they lose 10% of their investments overnight. Also, merely making a decision to invest in a particular index, like the S&P 500, is making an active choice to invest in Apple and McDonalds but not Tesla or thousands of other companies. So in practice a horde of passive investors buying Vanguard ETFs won't be completely neutral to the maket, but nonetheless the effect will be minor and--according to some people--perhaps even positive: http://www.businessinsider.com/passive-investing-makes-marke...
Why Vanguard? Why not buy SPY through Robinhood? Same index fund, except no commission.
"Because of daily rebalancing and the compounding of each day’s return over time, the return of the Fund for periods longer than a single day will be the result of each day’s returns compounded over the period, which will very likely differ from 300% of the return of the Index over the same period. The Fund will lose money if the Index performance is flat over time, and as a result of daily rebalancing, the Index’s volatility and the effects of compounding, it is even possible that the Fund will lose money over time while the Index's performance increases."
"Sophisticated investors" aren't doing any better.
- VFINX is up 72% in 10 years. AMZN for example is up 1220% in the same 10 years.
- VFINX is up 72% in 5 years. XIV is up 530% in the same 5 years.
So I assume based on your strategy you put all of your money in AMZN 10 years ago, sold it right before each drop, re-bought right before each rise, and are now filthy rich. Oh you're not? I wonder why.
Also, XIV is an inverse volatility trading vehicle. It's not meant for long term investors and frequently goes through 90% drops. This kind of extreme volatility is corrosive for long term returns. The last 5 years have had abnormally low volatility due to extremely low interest rates, hence why that ETF has done so well over that time period. Of course it's effortless to cherry pick winners when looking backwards instead of forwards.
No, that's just a buy-and-hold... just the same as an index fund. I didn't cherry pick anything. Plenty of high profile stocks went up more than 72% in the last 10 years. They're not even hard to find.
The problem is how do you pick the ones that will beat the market beforehand, when everybody has access to the same information about the prospects for future growth & earnings?
It's been proven by hundreds of studies to be a statistical near-impossibility over long periods of time. Any outperformance over the short term can be mathematically reframed as random luck (which a retail investor like you and I will incorrectly attribute to being the result of our own abilities).
That's like looking up last night's lottery numbers and picking them for tonight's ticket because they won last time.
It's not hard to find stocks that have done well.
It's hard to find stocks that will do well, and do better than the market as a whole, and to never make a mistake and pick one that goes bankrupt.
99% of users on the platform will ulimately end up participating in a direct transfer of their own wealth to a more sophisticated trader or algo (i.e. The banks and hedge funds who aren't just doing this for "fun" and have the financial and political backing of the world's elite). Side note: even those hedge funds can't consistently beat the market.
If you are reading this, for your own finacial future I beg of you, please take your money to Vanguard instead and buy some index funds. Scratch your "trading" itch by trying to game your asset allocation instead. Future you will thank present you.
If you don't believe me, please look into any of the academic research that has been conducted around efficient markets.