News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by wolf550e on Friday April 21, 2017 @08:42PM (#14170524)
Their number 1 problem is the name.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by farax91 on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:37PM (#14170684)
I rarely comment on HN....but I just came to say that I effing love the name. Don't ever change it. Screw the VC's and middle managers.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by hendzen on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:29AM (#14171121)
Yes, screw the people who allocate capital and make purchasing decisions. Who would ever need their favor to found a successful enterprise software company...
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by hdhzy on Saturday April 22, 2017 @08:14AM (#14172138)
If they base their decisions on things like that you've got a bigger problem there...
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by sanderjd on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:28AM (#14171114)
I really don't get this meme. Who cares? Lots of projects have weird names. It's a database, not a consumer packaged good brand. Surely those who are evaluating the engineering tradeoffs in database technology aren't basing their decision making on a name.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by user5994461 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:32AM (#14171888)
There is an inner bias and emotion reactions to names. It always weights in in the decision.

If you think you are not affected. Would you try a product named "octopussy"? Would you deploy it across your organization and gives presentation about it?

P.S. Octopussy is a real tool that solves a hard problem I forgot about.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by bbcbasic on Saturday April 22, 2017 @10:02AM (#14172538)
How about git? I.e. mild British insult.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by ridwanmsharif on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:03PM (#14170578)
well personally I thought fleshing out a distributed key-value store atop thousands of raft groups whilst maintaining strong consistency guarantees would be their number one problem but I think we might have different definitions here.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by Quai on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:45PM (#14170706)
Tell that to the MongoDB-gang..

"Mongo" is a norwegian/swedish(?) slang for a retarted person. It's derived from the word "mongoloid" which was an person with Downs or a similar syndrome. The latter word is not commonly used anymore.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by detaro on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:30AM (#14171122)
In German as well.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by dawkins on Saturday April 22, 2017 @03:21AM (#14171510)
And in Spanish
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by user5994461 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:34AM (#14171896)
Actually, mongoloid (and similar) is the word. "Mongo" alone is not that bad and it's a prefix to many words.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cocktailpeanuts on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:13PM (#14170603)
Don't know why downvoted.

They can keep thinking the name is not a problem, or they can decide to grow up and change the name.

Only naive engineers who know nothing about branding/marketing will think this is OK. It's fine if they're just doing their own thing, but it's a whole different story if they're operating a business

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by moonshinefe on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:25AM (#14171866)
I'm usually on the side of rationality and not judging a book by its cover, but I have to agree here. That name is extremely unfortunate.

First impressions actually matter in human interactions, and when you're named after one of the most disgusting pests known to man, that's definitely not helping your case.

Sorry, not everyone (especially management and others you have to explain it to who aren't rational super-men) get a good impression on a technology you're peddling... it's associated literally with cockroaches. Good luck selling that to them. What's next, "Cancer-DB"?

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by user5994461 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:36AM (#14171901)
Next is aidsDB.

Because "aid" means to give assistance and that database is here to help you ;)

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by anarazel on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:34PM (#14170671)
Because it's unrelated to the post - which is about the architecture - and because it's brought up every single time?
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by sanderjd on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:34AM (#14171135)
Yeah the constant obsession with the name is so weird that it really makes me wonder if there's some astroturfing campaign going on. I'm not usually a conspiracy theorist but I mean seriously, the name is not that weird and the tech seems very interesting. The first time I saw comments about it I thought, "huh, yeah I guess that is sort of a weird name now that you mention it". The second time u thought, "ok I've heard this before". The third time I thought, "hmm, this is pretty tedious". And this is the 7th or so time now and I just think, "wtf is going on here?".
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by Johnny555 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @01:31AM (#14171237)
Really? You think it's astroturfing that makes people dislike a name with "Cockroach" in it? Do you think there are many people think "cockroach" has positive connotations?

The name is one thing that anyone can have an opinion about, the average person can't really speak to the internals of the database, but anyone can look at the name and say "I don't like it and wouldn't want to say I have 'cockroachdb' in my stack".

The very fact that it comes up every time there's a story about the database should be a pretty strong sign that the name is overshadowing the product. If it was named after an animal that doesn't have nearly universal disdain like "Koala-db" or "dragonfly-db", or even "ant-db", then I doubt people would be bringing up the name every time it's mentioned

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by bshimmin on Saturday April 22, 2017 @02:22AM (#14171342)
git is also a really bad name, and I've had awkward conversations with hiring managers about it in the past ("You want someone with experience in... what?!"). ("git" is a mild oath in British English, for those who don't know. I think Linus did know.)

But the reason that people don't complain about the name every time git is brought up is because git comes up in conversation a lot. CockroachDB is also a really bad name - I do agree - but the reason almost every thread about it on here is partially derailed by chatter about its name is, I think, simply because it doesn't come up all that often.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cocktailpeanuts on Saturday April 22, 2017 @02:40AM (#14171387)
> git is also a really bad name,

That's stretching it a bit too far. Just because it's a "mild oath" in British english, doesn't mean it's bad name for rest of the world. I for one have never heard about it and don't think git is a bad name at all.

Cockroach, on the other hand, I don't know of anyone who would get a good image in their mind hearing it.

So you think if people keep saying cockroach a lot, suddenly cockroach will magically become some nice clean creature in people's mind? That's like saying if you keep saying "ShitDB", someday people will think it's a good name.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cuu508 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @03:55AM (#14171584)
> So you think if people keep saying cockroach a lot, suddenly cockroach will magically become some nice clean creature in people's mind?

Something like that. People will associate the name with the database, not the insect. This does happen, over time you almost forget the the original meaning.

Some examples: when somebody says Oracle or Delphi, I'm thinking databases and Pascal successor, not ancient Greek stuff. When somebody says Pascal, I'm thinking programming language not the French mathematician. Fedora is a Linux distribution (and also a type of hat), Twitter is a social network (and also a type of bird vocalization) and so on.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cocktailpeanuts on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:52AM (#14173073)
You really think those analogy is relevant to this case? All the examples you pointed out all have either neutral or positive connotations. What you should have presented was any example of (if any) a successful tech brand with a name that brings strong negative feelings.

Cockroach not only has negative connotation, but the negativity scale is pretty strong.

Bring me a single person who will say they get good emotion when they hear "cockcroach". Sometimes you need to be stubborn about your business decisions, but if you're being stubborn about naming your business after a word most of the population will get negative feelings the first time they hear, then you're doing it wrong. It's not even a subjective thing, with a bad name, people are less likely to talk about your brand than if you had a positive name.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cuu508 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @02:58PM (#14174099)
OK, how about: I would not like ants crawling my room the same way as I would not like cockroaches crawling my room. But I don't mind using Apache Ant.

Or, for a not-exactly-elegant name: Ubuntu 4.10 Warty Warthog. You are launching a brand-new Linux distribution, why not call it after a warty wild pig. Worked OK for them.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cocktailpeanuts on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:15PM (#14175136)
Ant and warthog do not universally evoke negative emotion. In many cultures ants are in fact associated with creatures that work hard, some people when they hear ants they think of the emergent behavior their colonies manifest. Warthog is more of a neutral term. Hearing that word gives me neither good or bad emotion, so it really depends on the context you use it.

"Cockroach" on the other hand, like i said, I know of absolutely NO one who would get positive emotion upon hearing that word. Just like "rape", or "nazi" don't evoke positive emotion for anyone.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by sanderjd on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:59AM (#14176596)
I'm honestly curious: what does it matter to you? You keep comparing it to very extreme things and generally seem to care a lot, but I just don't get what the big deal is. "Cockroach" is just not such an offensive word that it's worth getting so worked up about.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by bshimmin on Saturday April 22, 2017 @03:05AM (#14171461)
I'm saying that if CockroachDB came up in discussion frequently, people would lose interest in complaining about its name, because after a period of time, the number of people who'd been exposed to it and previous conversations about its name would have eclipsed the number of people thinking, "Gosh, what an awful name! I wonder if anyone else has had this revelation, I better post about it right now!"
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by cocktailpeanuts on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:59AM (#14173109)
You're missing my point, because you're talking about AFTER this reaches that status.

I'm saying these people are doing their own technology disservice by making the brand difficult to talk about and take seriously.

It's their choice, but there's a difference between "stupid names don't matter, look at Google!" and "stupid names don't matter, look at FuckDB! RapeDB! CockroachDB!" (I know i'm going extreme with this but just trying to get the point across, that "stupid" names and "offensive" names are completely different things)

If you still disagree with me, I don't really have much intention of trying to persuade you nor care much about this company succeeding. I'm just saying it's a bad business decision to make it hard for your customers to advocate for your product. If there was a company with the same technology and they had a normal name, they would probably get much better traction (assuming that their tech is unique and useful).

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by sanderjd on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:24PM (#14176301)
I think it's weird that anybody would have any strong feelings about the name of a database project at all.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by atomical on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:31AM (#14171124)
I have to think about cockroaches every time I see a post about this database. It is fair game.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by anarazel on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:45AM (#14171157)
Seriously? I reflexively think about specific, often negative, things when I read about a lot of topics. That doesn't mean those thoughts have to be shared. I think a good rough guideline is trying to only comment if that comment has a chance of advancing the discussion, answer somebody's questions, or asks for more information. Restating repeatedly made comments doesn't do that.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by sheeshkebab on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:12PM (#14170601)
man, they are committed to spreading infestation...

"Roaches on Open Water! CockroachDB on DigitalOcean" https://www.cockroachlabs.com/blog/roaches-on-open-water-coc...

Next up - Annual cockroachdb conference: roach motel.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by systems on Friday April 21, 2017 @08:52PM (#14170554)
they should have named it after a fruit ... like mangodb or something
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by bshimmin on Saturday April 22, 2017 @02:15AM (#14171320)
Somebody already thought of that one! https://github.com/dcramer/mangodb

proprietary auto sharting algorithm makes me laugh every time.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by Rapzid on Friday April 21, 2017 @08:55PM (#14170558)
Mango IS tasty. Much more tasty than cockroach IMHO. Still though, I doubt the name is much of an issue.
Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by user5994461 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:38AM (#14171909)
I just had a horrible vision of mango and cockroach together :(

You guys are ruining my lunch time.

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by systems on Saturday April 22, 2017 @09:40AM (#14172447)
it was a word play on mongodb and apple :)

but i guess no one got the joke , because you know apple is like a famous tech company and mongodb is a popular nosql db

so apple+mongodb = mangodb .. got it .. no .. :(

Re:The SQL layer in CockroachDB by pstuart on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:18AM (#14171095)
croachdb.com is available...