Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by bflesch on Thursday April 20, 2017 @05:30PM
(#14161114)
Would be great if you can just take a video and it would automatically capture the keyframes relevant for this type of transformation.
The end game would be that you put your phone in recording and on some stand, and you just have to slowly turn the pages of your photo album. One can dream.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by kayoone on Friday April 21, 2017 @02:17AM
(#14163465)
analyzing every frame of a video is very computationally expensive and the video resolution is often much worse than the photo resolution on such phones. But in principle the same techniques could be used so i don't see why it shouldn't be possible at some point.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by ziikutv on Friday April 21, 2017 @07:41AM
(#14164630)
I think there were some good counterpoints to what you said. But the most important one is.. USER.
People will record the video differently hence, adding more complexity to solving, comparatively, a simple problem.
One person might do the movements really fast, which leads to blur, which would mean they now need to add de-blurring. Other person might even miss an angle that was required. I think this is likely why panoramas are made in parts.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by CardenB on Friday April 21, 2017 @12:26AM
(#14163093)
Is this very different from how it works? From what I can remember from the last time I used it, you point it at the image, and it gives you a set of points to center your camera around, automatically capturing the photo at those points, so you never have to press any buttons.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by ehsankia on Thursday April 20, 2017 @09:45PM
(#14162495)
That would be extra processing analyzing frames trying to find the right ones. Again, the biggest problem with this is doing it on the phone at a reasonable speed.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by sitkack on Thursday April 20, 2017 @10:46PM
(#14162737)
Interleave a lower resolution higher frame rate video with the maximum frame rate of the largest size image (5-8 fps). Process the images in the background when the phone is wall power, and or push to cloud. It would be nice to do an incremental first pass to see if one has high enough quality source material.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by tempestn on Friday April 21, 2017 @01:24AM
(#14163281)
Yeah, just tried it. It was good enough that I would use it if I was at a friend's house or something and wanted to take a picture of a picture, but otherwise I'd use a scanner. Far better quality, both in terms of sharpness and colour balance.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by mavhc on Friday April 21, 2017 @04:03AM
(#14163824)
What I really want is a sheet feeding photo scanner that scans the front and back and won't destroy old photos, or even better, a company that will rent me one for a few months. Then I can scan the 1000s of photos my parents have, and send it back.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by tempestn on Friday April 21, 2017 @04:47AM
(#14163972)
That would be handy. You would think such a thing must exist. There are certainly companies that will digitize all your photos for you, including some cleanup in editing software, but I believe they charge ~ $0.75/photo. Anyway, they must have some decent hardware.
I just finished scanning a batch of my old high school photos, but I didn't take a lot, so it was only a few hundred. Managed to fit three at a time on the bed of my all-in-one printer/scanner, but it was tricky because there was a dead zone along the edges, so they had to be in the middle, but spaced out enough that the software could auto-crop them. Still not TOO bad, but I wouldn't really relish doing it for thousands.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by lfowles on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:19AM
(#14166324)
Doesn't seem like an insurmountable task for a week of netflix and a ScanSnap scanner[0]. Personally, I have the s1300i and scanned thousands of pages of notes.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by mavhc on Saturday April 22, 2017 @06:45PM
(#14175287)
I looked at the ix500, but couldn't find much in the way of people using it with photos, a) quality, and b) how well it handles photos rather than paper
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by vanderZwan on Friday April 21, 2017 @05:44AM
(#14164186)
How did you hold the phone? Based on the article you'd think it works better if you held the phone at a slightly different tilt every shot, to ensure non-overlapping glare
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by radarsat1 on Friday April 21, 2017 @09:30AM
(#14165373)
Really nice challenge for computer vision: given a video of a camera moving around above a photo, with a variety of (unknown) distances and angles, for each frame, find the photo, merge pixels to give super-resolution. Even with all the advances lately in vision research we are still not there yet.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by dbg31415 on Thursday April 20, 2017 @11:54PM
(#14162993)
So I really like it... but...
It makes really blurry photos. Every photo I take looks like someone turned the pixelate filter on.
Any suggestions... I'm doing this at night with lights on... will try it tomorrow during the day to see if more light is the answer.
EDIT: The photos I get back aren't only blurry, compared to photos I take with my phone camera, but they are about 2/3rds the size. iPhone 6S... I'd rather it take a bit longer on the compile and get me a better quality image.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by martin-adams on Thursday April 20, 2017 @05:34PM
(#14161136)
I used PhotoScan in December to digitise a lot of my parents photo albums. I was really impressed with the ease and results. Right now I would consider using anything else.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by agumonkey on Thursday April 20, 2017 @07:50PM
(#14161919)
I found MS Office Lens a tad better when I tried both a few monthes ago. Something in gPS bothered me but I can't remember what. That said this upgrade seems quite serious.
> After testing PhotoScan on a variety of pictures using four different phones, I'm sad to report that we're not getting our camera's worth from the app. The long dimension of scanned pictures is always scaled (up or down) to 2,000 pixels, compared to the 4,000-pixel capture resolution of the 6P (12.3 MP -> less than 3 MP).
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by pasbesoin on Thursday April 20, 2017 @06:15PM
(#14161403)
I noticed the limited resolution, as well.
If you are looking for real "archival" imaging, this app probably won't suffice.
On the other hand, it's nice to have on your phone to grab the occasional image e.g. from a picture on the wall behind glass or something similar. As another commenter mentions, maybe to grab an old photograph out of an album and put it on Facebook or the like.
Users should also note, its cropping is not always accurate -- larger contrasts produce better results. But, after it grabs its initial image, you can adjust the cropping -- including outward, to the limit of what was initially imaged.
P.S. I have a Nexus 5x. I'm guessing the app may work relatively well for me also because I'm using a phone that the Google developers are particularly likely to specifically support and have used/tested against.
Since this appears to be a small project -- maybe a 20%-er or the like? -- at a guess, results may vary significantly depending upon phone and camera module. At a guess -- I've no idea.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by Theodores on Thursday April 20, 2017 @08:07PM
(#14162001)
Having an average smartphone is where you went wrong - you need to persuade your employers that you really need a Google Pixel XL. Get one and then you can expect cool smartphone apps to actually work, albeit on the maxed out Google phone but not on your own normal phone.
In day to day use you may find the big phone with its 'best camera ever' and full suite of sensors to not be practical compared to your svelte normal phone. The added bulk, the fear of dropping the bulk or the likelihood of theft just puts you off carrying it around. But when these exciting science experiment apps come along then you are good to go, no need to make space for the app on your normal phone (where it probably won't work anyway) you can put it on the big phone. Even more fun, you can share the big phone around without fear of your personal messages popping up on its screen - a guest phone as it were.
The latest and greatest Beta version of Android is also default on the Pixel series, I didn't even have to install PhotoScan, mysteriously it was already installed on mine when I had the 'must try this' moment a few minutes ago.
Android phones are a bit like office PCs in the 90's when you could have some 386 running Wordperfect in the same room as some Pentium machine used for CAD, sure they all use some variation of the same operating system but that 'flight sim game' would only be worth attempting on the latest/greatest hardware and totally useless on anything less.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by nodesocket on Thursday April 20, 2017 @04:12PM
(#14160385)
I used PhotoScan (iOS) to scan about 20 photos, and it worked surprisingly well. The quality was great, no clipping or unexpected cropping. Really impressed.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by wtallis on Thursday April 20, 2017 @11:15PM
(#14162838)
Copystands that are large or have integrated lighting are quite expensive. I use a $45 smaller copy stand with a pair of $7 lights clamped to the shelf above my desk. If you have a real camera with a tripod mount, it's a very reasonable solution.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by alistairSH on Thursday April 20, 2017 @04:55PM
(#14160772)
I had the same thought. Disable the flash. Use a copystand. Or, just use a scanner (the last three personal printers I've owned double as scanner/copier).
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by BugsJustFindMe on Thursday April 20, 2017 @05:52PM
(#14161243)
There are dozens of apps already on the play store that will do geometry correction for images taken at an angle. No stand required. My partner uses one for working in archives.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by robbrown451 on Friday April 21, 2017 @01:57AM
(#14163388)
I get good results just taking pictures of pictures outside in bright sunlight, as long as the sun isn't directly overhead. They are evenly lit, plenty of light so not grainy, and no glare.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by anigbrowl on Thursday April 20, 2017 @09:55PM
(#14162532)
Very interesting. I had similar problems when photographing my paintings, and while the best photographs are taken with a good DSLR and a polarizer that can end up becoming a project in itself.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by s_gourichon on Friday April 21, 2017 @12:15PM
(#14166855)
Many comments the output pixel count, no one seems to have noticed (1) the white border (2) ad at bottom (3) JPEG artifacts (block and mosquito noise on edges, dull and noisy colors, color smear) excessive compression. No wonder: 158kbytes for a 1399x2184 picture is 0.05 byte per pixel which ... may be enough or not depending on your quality expectations.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by s_gourichon on Friday April 21, 2017 @12:29PM
(#14167004)
It might be that photos that are sent to Google get saved with decent compression (0.5 byte per pixel instead of 0.05) in DCIM/PhotoScan. Yet what if I want to keep ridiculous old haircuts private? There's no explicit "save locally" feature. :-/
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by pbw on Friday April 21, 2017 @10:44AM
(#14166010)
I tried this and my result was really low resolution and had a giant blob of glare on it. Had really high hopes from all the technology behind it, but it didn't work in my case.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by itaysk on Friday April 21, 2017 @08:27AM
(#14164884)
it looks like a new thing, but 2 weeks ago I stumbled upon this via a link in Google Photos app and tried it. Resulting picture did not look better then one taken without flash in a lighted room using camscan app.
Re:PhotoScan: Taking Glare-Free Pictures of Pictures
by sprafa on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:44AM
(#14166557)
brilliant bricklaying. Is this really the best thing CV researchers should be doing? There are so many unsolved problems and they're working on removing glare from old photos?
The end game would be that you put your phone in recording and on some stand, and you just have to slowly turn the pages of your photo album. One can dream.
People will record the video differently hence, adding more complexity to solving, comparatively, a simple problem.
One person might do the movements really fast, which leads to blur, which would mean they now need to add de-blurring. Other person might even miss an angle that was required. I think this is likely why panoramas are made in parts.
I just finished scanning a batch of my old high school photos, but I didn't take a lot, so it was only a few hundred. Managed to fit three at a time on the bed of my all-in-one printer/scanner, but it was tricky because there was a dead zone along the edges, so they had to be in the middle, but spaced out enough that the software could auto-crop them. Still not TOO bad, but I wouldn't really relish doing it for thousands.
[0]: http://www.fujitsu.com/us/products/computing/peripheral/scan...
I didn't see any mention of resolution in the blog post, and many comments here and elsewhere about low quality.
Is the resolution still capped?
It makes really blurry photos. Every photo I take looks like someone turned the pixelate filter on.
Any suggestions... I'm doing this at night with lights on... will try it tomorrow during the day to see if more light is the answer.
EDIT: The photos I get back aren't only blurry, compared to photos I take with my phone camera, but they are about 2/3rds the size. iPhone 6S... I'd rather it take a bit longer on the compile and get me a better quality image.
Example. http://i.imgur.com/63tgrwK.jpg
But that said, I've not explored what else is out there.
It sucks when science creates something cool but it doesn't work in the real world.
> After testing PhotoScan on a variety of pictures using four different phones, I'm sad to report that we're not getting our camera's worth from the app. The long dimension of scanned pictures is always scaled (up or down) to 2,000 pixels, compared to the 4,000-pixel capture resolution of the 6P (12.3 MP -> less than 3 MP).
If you are looking for real "archival" imaging, this app probably won't suffice.
On the other hand, it's nice to have on your phone to grab the occasional image e.g. from a picture on the wall behind glass or something similar. As another commenter mentions, maybe to grab an old photograph out of an album and put it on Facebook or the like.
Users should also note, its cropping is not always accurate -- larger contrasts produce better results. But, after it grabs its initial image, you can adjust the cropping -- including outward, to the limit of what was initially imaged.
P.S. I have a Nexus 5x. I'm guessing the app may work relatively well for me also because I'm using a phone that the Google developers are particularly likely to specifically support and have used/tested against.
Since this appears to be a small project -- maybe a 20%-er or the like? -- at a guess, results may vary significantly depending upon phone and camera module. At a guess -- I've no idea.
In day to day use you may find the big phone with its 'best camera ever' and full suite of sensors to not be practical compared to your svelte normal phone. The added bulk, the fear of dropping the bulk or the likelihood of theft just puts you off carrying it around. But when these exciting science experiment apps come along then you are good to go, no need to make space for the app on your normal phone (where it probably won't work anyway) you can put it on the big phone. Even more fun, you can share the big phone around without fear of your personal messages popping up on its screen - a guest phone as it were.
The latest and greatest Beta version of Android is also default on the Pixel series, I didn't even have to install PhotoScan, mysteriously it was already installed on mine when I had the 'must try this' moment a few minutes ago.
Android phones are a bit like office PCs in the 90's when you could have some 386 running Wordperfect in the same room as some Pentium machine used for CAD, sure they all use some variation of the same operating system but that 'flight sim game' would only be worth attempting on the latest/greatest hardware and totally useless on anything less.
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/buy/Copystands/ci/711/N/37151...
You'd think there'd be lots of cheap ones coming out of China, but I couldn't find any with a quick search.
It's a perfect way for a not-so-technologically-savvy parent to scan their old photos and put them up on Facebook.
https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-Q5bnNur88ME/WPfbie00jGI/AAAAAAAAB...
[1] nice initials btw
Who's the guy in the sample pic? One of the researchers?