News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by my123 on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:50AM (#14131233)
Might be a bit overblown - other presidential regimes such as France include many of the powers that Erdogan is claiming. As long as guaranteeing an independent judiciary can be done - the powers can be controlled(Trump couldn't do what he wanted to by a long shot)
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by dmix on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:56AM (#14131280)
France's president can appoint cabinet members without parliamentary oversight and has a strong influence over the courts?

Once you lose independence of the judiciary system you basically lost the last remaining checks and balances. This is why I never bought into the threat of fascism from Trump. He would have to make similar changes which would never get off the ground. The US system has been shown to work exactly as intended on a number of occasions in the last two months.

The problem is the executive state has grown significantly over the last few decades in the US. But that was hardly unique to Trump.

If anything the main issue is the presidents ability to conduct 'military actions' without congress. That seems like a major risk.

But compared to Turkey the situation is far better in other western states. This is one situation where saying "USA DOES IT TOO!" can't be used to dismiss this out of hand (or EU countries in this case). And even if they did it wouldn't make it a good idea.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by cm2187 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:02AM (#14131352)
Funny you mention justice in France. There are very strong suspicions that the current president of France is using the justice system against his opponents, with a wave of investigations hitting his opponents immediately after his election and another one now, right before a major election.

A centralized presidential system does make it easier to have all sorts of abuse, from which no western democracy is immune.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by pikzen on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:53AM (#14131811)
Correction for any non french reader: a candidate, Francois Fillon, which is being investigated for seven different charges, including fictitious jobs, embezzling public funds, trafficking influence, fakes and usage of fakes and a list of frauds that wouldn't fit on A4 paper [1] has accused the president of using "dark cabinets" to get some dirt on him, quoting a book. The author of said book immediately came out against that, Fillon got slammed by both the president and the ministry of justice, who reminded him he himself voted against numerous measures aimed at making presidential affairs more transparent. And then Le Pen has been spouting off her victim rethoric for years.

[1]https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affaire_Fillon

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by cm2187 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:57AM (#14131856)
There were also all the investigations that hit Sarkozy and the conservative party when Hollande took power and he perceived Sarkozy as his main rival.

I have followed French politics for too long to believe in coincidences.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by pikzen on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:00PM (#14131884)
I have lived in France and followed politics for too long to not know this isn't unique to Hollande. Sarkozy absolutely abused his power and is suspected to have been the cause of the whole Dominique Strauss Kahn affair. Chirac has been accused of it. Mitterand has been accused of it.

So far, there are no proofs. You also have to realize that our political class is prone to backstabbing, much much more than any other country. Everyone has dirt on everyone in the same party. So far, the Fillon revelations rather seem like they're coming from LR, not the PS or Hollande.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by cm2187 on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:09PM (#14131975)
I am certainly not suggesting this is limited to Hollande.

In term of proof, it has kind of been confirmed by Hollande himself indirectly. In his interview book "Un president ne devrait pas dire ca", he mentioned that Fillon contacted him after he took office, encouraging him to dig more dirt on Sarkozy, otherwise they will be facing him at the next election. Hollande then praised his own virtue by pretending he did not proceed and Fillon denied ever asking that. However whether this discussion happened or not, and whether Hollande did it or not, what Hollande confirmed indirectly is that it was a perfectly reasonable request from an insider of French politics (a former prime minister) to get the president to use the justice system against his opponent.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by my123 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:06AM (#14131395)
Without considering the ability for the president in France to pass laws without a parliamentary vote - with the only way to veto being a motion of non-confidence which forces the government to resign.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by pvg on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:13AM (#14131458)
The US system has been shown to work exactly as intended on a number of occasions in the last two months. [..] the executive state has grown significantly over the last few decades in the US. But that was hardly unique to Trump.

'Exactly as intended' and the growth of executive influence and the federal government as a whole seem rather contradictory. And what's unique is Trump himself.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by AnimalMuppet on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:36PM (#14133286)
What dmix claimed is not unique to Trump is the growth of the executive power. dmix is correct in this statement.

The next claim you had an issue with:

> The US system has been shown to work exactly as intended on a number of occasions in the last two months.

That's why it's not contradictory. The courts have (finally) been reining in the president. (It would have been nice if it started a decade or two ago, but Trump is, as you say, something of a unique threat, and that may be concentrating minds in the judiciary.)

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by pvg on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:47PM (#14133358)
It seems contradictory to me because it essentially admits that seminal presidents and events have substantially changed the system but it's ok, because this one won't. I don't think there's any reason to panic but as logic this seems pretty questionable.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by my123 on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:59AM (#14131314)
Building a strong opposition can be done, after all, the referendum was won with such a small margin, and without major cities for it. Guaranteeing the judiciary independence is the biggest issue of course. :-)
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by dleslie on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:10AM (#14131432)
Meanwhile, in Canada:

> As such, the prime minister, supported by the Office of the Prime Minister (PMO), controls the appointments of many key figures in Canada's system of governance, including the governor general, the Cabinet, justices of the Supreme Court, senators, heads of crown corporations, ambassadors to foreign countries, the provincial lieutenant governors, and approximately 3,100 other positions.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_Minister_of_Canada

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by my123 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:18AM (#14131515)
The constitutional court in France is appointed by the president, the president of the parliament and the president of the senate. One third for each.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by 1_2__3 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:23AM (#14131552)
You're certainly a busy bee, posting this repeatedly in this thread. Almost like you have an agenda.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by maxerickson on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:49AM (#14131770)
Twice isn't that much.

The bigger issue is their failure to add some context to make the comparison actually interesting. Like they could say that Canadian Prime Ministers are rarely removed from office (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prime_ministers_defeat... ). Nevermind that it has been done a number of times in an orderly fashion.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by graphitezepp on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:33AM (#14131648)
I am bothered by this. Always been incredibly ignorant about Canadian politics for no reason, is there something about Canadian gov that makes this less frightening then it sounds or does Canada just hand potential for ultra centralized control to their PM?
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by dleslie on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:42AM (#14131721)
Harper showed us that the potential for abuse was there, though that's not to say that he was particularly abusive, and it's been part of the political discourse since.

I think many Canadians took for granted just how much process was informal tradition followed on honour and not binding rules.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by ttn on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:56AM (#14131286)
Turk here. There will be 13 high level judiciary members, 4 of whom will be appointed by president (Erdogan) and rest by majority of assembly (Erdogan's Party). So forget about independency. They are not even independent at the moment anyways.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by low_battery on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:05PM (#14132540)
I had a second look at the proposed changes, there are 2 important ones regarding judicial matters, the change for constitutional court is mainly removing 2 members selected from military judges. The change regarding high judicial court is more complex but i don't see an alarming difference between the new and existing, could you point to me?

http://anayasadegisikligi.barobirlik.org.tr/Anayasa_Degisikl...

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by pknerd on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:32AM (#14131644)
If you read a bit, Ataturk also managed things single handedly so should not be an alien concept for Turks
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by stellar678 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:03AM (#14131369)
Is there some structural factor that prevents the assembly from being taken by Erdogan's opposition?
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by tormeh on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:12AM (#14131449)
A split opposition and a 10% voting threshold. The opposition would essentially have to lay aside their differences and form an anti-Erdogan party. That's unlikely, because the Kemalists and the Kurds hate each other.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by m00dy on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:22AM (#14131540)
Who told you that Kemalists and the Kurds hate each other ? Can you give me any source for that ?
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by tormeh on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:10PM (#14133992)
The Kemalists want one indivisible Turkey with only Turks. The Kurds not only persist in calling themselves Kurds instead of Turks, but they also want to secede. These two points of view don't play nice with each other.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by ttn on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:08AM (#14131415)
In theory they can. In practice, impossible. Its the culture. We do not vote for representative, we vote for a party and its leader.
Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by enraged_camel on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:57AM (#14131291)
>>As long as guaranteeing an independent judiciary can be done

It can't be done, not in Turkey. Appointing judges is in the hands of the Supreme Board of Judges and Prosecutors. The president appoints half of the 12-member board and the parliament, most of whom are Erdogan supporters, appoints the other half.

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by pikzen on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:55AM (#14131842)
wew lad

France is not even close to what Edrogan is doing. Yes, our system gives a lot of power to the president, more than in many countries. However, the prime minister is picked amongst the majority in the national assembly, and there are many, many countermeasures to ensure the president doesn't go wild, even if some recent presidents have tried to erode that (namely, Sarkozy).

Re:RIP Turkey, 1921 – 2017 by JeremyBanks on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:00AM (#14131327)
Yes, as long as there's an independent empowered judiciary.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016–17_Turkish_purges

But contrast that ideal with the reality that the government had already purged thousands of judges to destroy their independence and disempower then.