For a more 'down-to-earth' answer, we can look into the past - how did the space race, landing on the moon, etc contribute to the development of science, technology, art... Did that have anything to do with our development as a species ?
If we manage to settle on Mars, that would mean a great deal of new technological and scientific discoveries - which we'll be able to apply here on Earth. Maybe the solutions for the problems we experience here on Earth lay on other planets ?
Other planets will follow and eventually other stars. There will probably be generations of people who live and grow on a space ship, watching space youtube and movies all their lives - set in a strange distant place called Earth.
Eventually, they will arrive on a planet far away and settle there - maybe they'll forget all about their space trip and technology - become farmers and raise space chicken - only to reinvent rockets once again thousands of years later.
Maybe this whole thing is inside our DNA ?
I think realistically most of the people who first colonise mars will be doing it for financial reasons, because better options are not available to them on Earth.
Sure the delay fluctuates between 5-25 minutes, so you won't be enjoying any realtime activities like voice calls or playing Quake. [1] Initially bandwidth will probably also be too low to casually download 4K cat videos. However there won't be any issue with setting up a local Mars community web proxy that downloads HN & friends in compressed batches. There are a lot of things to do on the internet where even a 25 minute delay is no biggie.
--
[1] Although it shouldn't take too long until there are enough local people on Mars for low latency activities among themselves.
Vacationing with a view of the Earth's limbe is conceptually not that different from vacationing on a cruise ship around the Caribbean. Sure, the losgistics are a bit tougher; the ship goes Mach 25 and a broken window will boil everyone's blood in a few minutes. But the point is to get out of the house and get some reading done somewhere else.
"The billionaire tech entrepreneur also laid out a vision for space commercialization that stretches out for hundreds of years, leading to an era when millions of people would be living and working in space."[1]
This is hundreds of years in the future, at which point Bezos believes the population of the earth will be in the tens or hundreds of billions. He thinks the surface of the earth will be "zoned strictly for 'residential and light industrial'", probably for a combination of pollution, land quality, and resource scarcity. In that scenario (which seems unlikely) millions of people would be like .001% of the population, which makes... some sense?
[1] http://www.geekwire.com/2016/jeff-bezos-lifts-curtain-blue-o...
where do you see this mentioned?
I think it's generally agreed earth population will never get to hundreds of billion, the demographic trend is to get to around ~10B and stop there (kids per family decrease as living conditions improve, and they are at ~2 in most of the world bar africa)
EDIT: AIU it, Bezos just thinks we will have laws set up to avoid destroying our environment, hence forbidding things like heavy industry on earth.
That was one thing in The Expanse (great TV show about basically this (and also a series of books that I haven't read yet)), that I found a bit odd. We're currently doing everything we can to replace truck drivers and miners on earth with robots. So why would truck driving and mining in space be done entirely by humans?
The problem with automation and AI is that a powerful enough AI will render any story pretty boring, because it can basically do anything. So when writing fiction, one has to put brakes on some implications of technology just to be able to make a story.
But assuming that fully-automated space-everything wasn't developed before Epstein drive[0], the geopolitical (systempolitical?) situation makes the whole scenario plausible - you have overcrowded Earth with most people living on Basic Income just because there aren't enough opportunities, Martians hell-bent on terraforming their world ASAP, and the Belters, who can't live downwell and whose ability to provide services to inner planets is the only way to survive out there. One could imagine a strong opposition to automated mining from the Belt, and powers on Earth and Mars not too eager to upset that.
--
Also, read the books. TV show is awesome, but the books are even better :). I binge-read them all last month.
--
[0] - pretty much the only fictional human technology in The Expanse; it's a hyper-efficient fusion drive
All of the culture novels feature "AI is that a powerful enough AI [sic]" yet I do not feel these stories are rendered boring. The AIs just become more characters.
The net long term difference of which is effectively zero. Adventure travel Everest climbers are not pioneers, and provide no new knowledge about Everest or the human condition - while burning up millions in cash in the process.
The frontier is still terrestrial.
Edit: Typos
Rocketry comes pretty close though.
IIRC Elon Musk has stated that the cost of fuel is almost negligible in current rockets.
The money might literal be burnt in the form of fuel, but it will be only the cost of the fuel. Modern and older rockets had to burn that and effectively burn all the other disposable costs, like the whole rocket and every piece of gear sent up. The situation is certainly being improved by these new innovators, and that is the point that was trying to be made and it is highly likely that you knew that.
When you have billions of dollars, there are many ways you can choose to spend your money. Some choose to use it on fleeting pleasures, but luckily humanity has others who have decided to use those resources in a systematic way that would help the greatest number of people possible, those like Bill Gates and Warren Buffet. We need those people. And we also need people who are willing to indulge the wildest fantasies of the human imagination in a completely reasonable way, like Musk and Bezos, who are thinking far ahead (and Bezos is the ultimate long term thinker), and realize that they now have the ability to bring about the innovation and lay out the first steps of commercial space exploration, which is necessary if the light of human consciousness is to see all the wonder the universe and the future has to offer.
Potentially, thousands of years from now there will be hundreds of billions of people populating multiple star systems. Their existence will be due to the efforts of people who are spending substantial amounts of money to make space travel feasible today, despite how unrealistic it seems to most of us.
You need to stop with the sour grapes, the tall poppy syndrome, and you need to start supporting the people who are actually doing shit. And you need to do it before the window of opportunity to use our technology to save ourselves closes. Keep in mind that me writing this comment to you is an enormous waste of my time, and I really thought it through, so please absorb the meaning in my words and stop having these pissing matches on the internet over things you completely misunderstand.
None of that is going to happen in our lifetime. But the lifetime of our great grandchildren? There's a good chance. After all, this isn't the first time. However we will have several centuries to adapt. The real issue is we're destroying the natural environment faster than it can possibly adapt or evolve, but we'd be doing that even without climate change.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Therm...
I really don't care if that causes some shade to fall on your fantasies of what this project might lead to. Not a bit. In fact, I couldn't care any less.
We are not discussing "Sci-Fi" here. This isn't a "Trekkie" convention, it's the real world effects of this we're talking about.
Earth is complex enough for any person to be visionary. Please do not let your own interests overshadow others.
I totally get the personal excitment. And with a few dozen millions dollars in my pocket I would totally invest into something fun even if uneconomical.
Probably people like Planetary Resources[0] and Deep Space Industries[1] that intend to get their raw materials from Space.
There isn't much joy in that.
You could sell your stuff to the local space colony of the billionaires a thousand kilometers away from the mining site.
Why, they'll be driving SpaceUbers, doing the laundry, delivering food, walking the dogs, etc of all the techies debugging the asteroid mining robots, of course.
You're not even close to the mark though.
Infrastructure, warehouses, and a rescue network mostly likely. Getting fuel reserves and supplies into particular places, making ranger stations, and maintaining all of that.
It's also not impossible that some mega rich people decide to fund private projects that only have a slim chance of making a profit. Most of them will fail, but they'll still need workers while it's ongoing, and that still means you're giving knowledge to humanity when those workers figure stuff out and train others.
>And "Living on Mars". No thanks, I'll pass on that too.
That's fine. It seems rough because it is (understatement of the year). But there's always going to be a subset of the population who just want to get out and explore and colonize. The risk is not for everyone, because yes, sometimes you go exploring and die for a stupid reason completely out of your control.
Besides, we really don't have any full-time Martian marketing agencies to influence everyone's perceptions of life on mars. So of course it seems terrible. :)
I'll leave explaining most of that point to a pretty good filk song:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ab_mH8R0KTM
http://lyrics.wikia.com/wiki/Julia_Ecklar:One_Way_To_Go
Maybe to quote one verse:
Breaking free of gravity, moving industry
Beyond the planet's surface into space
Lunar mines and factories, Lagrange Point colonies,
Total productivity and nothing goes to waste
Solar-sailing ships deployed to mine the asteroids
While Earth becomes a paradise, her ugly scars erased
If you want a more "vivid" and detailed view of how this may look like (good and bad sides), I'd recommend "The Expanse" book series (and TV show) - a hard sci-fi about humans who just begun expanding throughout the Solar System.There are lots of useful things to do in space, but we need to bootstrap a profitable economy in space to get there.
Moving things between space and earth will always be costly and people will still want to live on earth. If we can solve waste, productivity issues in space why should we not be able to also solve them on earth?
"Total productivity" and "Earth becoming a paradise" are dreams, of course. This is a song, not an economics report. But it outlines pretty well the things people might reasonably want to do in space, and why.
EDIT: And Blue Origin and SpaceX both use liquid fuel rockets exclusively which cause very little ozone depletion. There combustion byproducts are entirely made from oxygen, hydrogen, and carbon with no nitrogen or chlorine mixed in.
EDIT2: Also, apart from the danger of ozone depletion there really isn't any harm in "poking holes in the atmosphere". The atmosphere is a fluid, it flows back together just fine after the rocket passes.
My arguments would be what others already pointed out, that tourism is irrational industry and the crazier the ride, the more people will be interested.
I am really overjoyed that something is happening on space front.
The comparison is foolish.
NASA's estimates a trip to Mars would take 21 months [1]. I don't know where you work, but I doubt you have 21 months of vacation accrued. If you do, do you have the $250k per ticket? If you do, do you have mental / psychical health to be accepted? If you do, do you accept the flight risks? If you do, do you accept that time does not stop on Earth (loved ones aging, loved ones dying, etc)?
If you do, you're _incredibly rare_.
This isn't flying 6-hour flight to Mexico to sit on the beach.
One thing i do believe is the possibility to mining space (specially asteroids, like this -> "NASA to explore asteroid made of $10,000 quadrillion worth of metal", google it).
I imagine SpaceX and Blue Origins playing a huge part (if not all) in the future of this kind of exploration.
In my mind, there's trillions of things to do here that we don't get to do. Sure looking at mars sky would be something amazing, but I'm not in a hurry.
Made in Space is working on producing ZBLAN optical fiber in orbit, for sale back on Earth. [1] ZBLAN is an alternative to normal silicate fiber which has much higher theoretical performance limits, but worse performance in practice due to gravity induced crystalline impurities. Producing it in microgravity should allow it to reach its full potential.
They haven't launched the first batch yet, but their claim is that because optical fiber doesn't weigh much, and this higher quality fiber is so valuable, it's actually profitable at current launch costs to do this manufacturing in orbit.
The linked article ends with a quote from the CEO: "We believe in-space manufacturing of goods valuable to people on Earth will soon drive significant commercial activity in space, perhaps one day creating a space-based economic boom." Consider the lithography processes our chips are made with, or the single-crystal turbine blades that help modern jet engines and rocket turbopumps work as well as they do. There's an enormous variety of precision processes that could benefit from operating under an ambient acceleration between 0 and 1g.
Orbital manufacturing is probably the most believable short term goal for commercial space, but there are a plenty of extremely exciting opportunities out there:
- The Mars colony will be our stepping stone out into the asteroids and the rest of the solar system. The thin atmosphere and lower gravity makes lifting mass from the Martian surface about an order of magnitude less difficult than lifting from Earth's surface. The difference is so extreme, that if you assume commodities will someday cost about the same on both planets, structures in Earth orbit would actually be cheaper to build and launch from Mars and then tug over to Earth.
- The potential wealth from mining other bodies is unfathomably huge. A small minority of asteroids out there are actually chunks of proto-planet cores unleashed during the violence of the early solar system. A single rock like that has more accessible platinum, rhodium, and other heavy metals than all known accessible deposits on Earth's surface. This fact becomes a little less surprising when you learn that all of Earth's accessible deposits are nothing more than impact sites from rocks like this. The "original" heavy metals of Earth all settled deep inside the core while the planet was still molten, far too deep for us to ever reach. These heavy elements are unbelievably useful. The state of the art in a huge fraction of the "hard" problems in chemistry boils down to "We can do it with platinum group catalysts, but those cost too much for industrial use."
- Orbital superstructures. Made in Space's Archinaut project [2] is an early effort to free satellite designers from the size and weight constraints of delicate folding structures riding inside a single rocket fairing. It's still early, but once launch costs drop and/or we start doing heavy in-situ mining, we can reasonably start building kilometer scale stations. Enormous solar arrays to power all our new orbital industry, or 5,000 person orbital ring cities with a relaxing level of partial g and perfect climate control. I'd love to live in a place like that.
My favorite analogy for this is the settling of America. Settling the new world in sailing ships that took a month to cross the Atlantic was a terrible investment with hardly any foreseeable return. But then we made better boats, and new communication systems, and all sorts of other new technologies which created exponential returns from the colonies. The west still leads the world because of the unimaginable profits it made off the Americas. Settling space, and particularly Mars, is the biggest opportunity we've had since the 1500s.
[1] http://www.madeinspace.us/projects/fiber/ [2] http://www.madeinspace.us/projects/archinaut/
And working in space...for what reason? For certain industry maybe, but is it a really a worthy goal to chase after? I don't know.
I am from Brazil, that is a gigantic country with stupid amounts of land. Also I really wanted to live on a rural community and farm a bit, yet somehow it seems 100% of the land, even the most inaccessible places, have an owner, and prices of land a ludicrous (land in Brazil somehow cost more than same land in France plus real medieval castle in it...)
So, colonizing mars sound awesome.
Well, trip to Mars won't be cheap, and by the point it is inhabitable for average people, it would have land owner maybe government as well, at that point.
And "Living on Mars". No thanks, I'll pass on that too. I can certainly see the thrill of the ride described though and who wouldn't want to be weightless for 4-5 minutes? But the market for that carnival ride is about as big as the number of cars Ferrari sells each year so I don't get that.
One can call this a "steppingstone" tech for now if they choose but it's more likely to be a cliff unless there's something of real value here. Even if we go out on a limb and say all this is really a way for the wealthy to escape the planet they'll find there's no place close enough to go so even that doesn't make sense.
No, none of the above makes sense to me yet so there must be something more fueling this race than what's being said.
And hey, isn't there also a downside to poking holes in the upper atmosphere and/or ozone depletion? How long do we let someone profit off the effects of that?
I honestly don't know the answers to those questions but I do wonder about them.