News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by rimliu on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:12AM (#14020728)
What baffles me that it is still considered OK to indoctrinate children with provably false beliefs.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by blowski on Monday April 03, 2017 @02:40AM (#14021003)
What's the alternative? A civil servant deciding what is allowed to be taught to children? Can you teach skepticism by saying "you're not allowed to learn this stuff over here"?

Seems to me that allowing science to win out in the 'market of ideas' is the healthiest solution.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by xupybd on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:27AM (#14021148)
I can't agree with you more. When the state steps in to control what people are allowed to teach their children we have entered into a very very scary time. Freedom of personal belief is fundamental to all freedom. If we allow the state to dictate the beliefs taught to children we take away that freedom.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by socialist_coder on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:03AM (#14021710)
Did you know that homeschooling your children is illegal in every country in the EU except for the UK (and it is very rare there)?

For Americans, this is shocking (it was to me). "I can't homeschool my own children?!? That isn't freedom!" But in practice, the vast majority of homeschoolers are evangelical christians or other religious extremists. For the good of society, I would gladly take that trade.

Think about this another way: in the US, homeschool parents can impart any view they want on their children. They "win by default" because there are no competing viewpoints. In the EU, parents are still free to try and impart their beliefs on their children. But in this case, they need a stronger argument than what the school is providing. They will not "win by default" like in the US. I can't see anything "unfree" about that.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by ooqr on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:09AM (#14021907)
We're planning homeschooling. We're religious (none of the above), but planning on exposing children to math and science at an early age, using Socratic dialogue to ferret out poor reasoning, teaching skepticism...

Sometimes homeschooling is just better because the public school system isn't very good.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by literallycancer on Monday April 03, 2017 @10:49AM (#14023117)
>Did you know that homeschooling your children is illegal in every country in the EU except for the UK (and it is very rare there)?

Pretty sure this is wrong. You can homeschool your children, as long as they pass an exam every year (or every 6 months maybe), to prove that their knowledge/skills are good enough (e.g. at least at the level of a public school attendee of the same age).

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by xupybd on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:00PM (#14027606)
Yeah but what you're saying is that the state has the right to impart it's beliefs on these kids. I know you don't like the evangelicals beliefs and prefer what the state is currently teaching. But what if the tables were flipped. What if you lived in a country with a religious rule and your kids were forced to learn that religion. The only free and fair system I can think of is to allow parents the right to teach their beliefs to their children. As not everyone in society is ever going to agree.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by dottedmag on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:35AM (#14021793)
When did Denmark, Slovenia, Italy, Ireland, Hungary and France leave the EU?
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by socialist_coder on Monday April 03, 2017 @08:51AM (#14022369)
Thanks for the correction. I thought it was illegal everywhere.

I think my point is still valid though, especially because in many of those countries, yearly inspections are mandatory (unlike the US).

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by literallycancer on Monday April 03, 2017 @10:51AM (#14023133)
>I think my point is still valid though, especially because in many of those countries, yearly inspections are mandatory (unlike the US).

The inspections ensure that your parents can't fuck up your life. I think it's a good middle ground between allowing everything and nothing.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by socialist_coder on Monday April 03, 2017 @11:18AM (#14023379)
I don't disagree. Yearly inspections seems like a great middle ground (for us).

But, think of it in terms of the original argument. Are you still "free" if you are forced to teach what the state wants? The OP would say no, I think.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by dottedmag on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:05PM (#14023916)
You are not forced to teach what the state wants. You are forced to make sure your children pass exams.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by Klockan on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:43PM (#14024378)
I fail to see the difference, exams are there to make sure that you taught your kid what the state wants.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by irishcoffee on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:28AM (#14032331)
One is a subset of the other.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by ue_ on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:49AM (#14022070)
I agree very much; the presence of school would in some cases offer an alternative viewpoint or explanation and although the power of parents over children is strong, children develop critical thinking skills too. I think if anything it encourages one to consider alternate positions rather than just accepting something on authority of the speaker.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by xupybd on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @12:48AM (#14029542)
I think you are giving schools too much credit here. At best I think you'll find they just learn to accepting something else on authority of a different speaker.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by adrianratnapala on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:49AM (#14021415)
I agree with your sentiments, but we are not really being fair to rimliu, who has not actually mentioned government, science or any of their competitors.

So while I agree that there is no alternative better than the market-place of ideas; that's still compatible with saying its morally wrong to indoctrinate your children with falsehoods.

Being sloppy about your beliefs -- i.e. just going with your gut and not questioning -- is OK when it's just yourself. But maybe you should only teach kids about the things you have considered more carefully.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by abalashov on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:09AM (#14021099)
Which is fine, if science has a fighting chance in such a marketplace.

But the inherent humility and uncertainty of rigourous science is often no match for snake oil and demagoguery, as we know.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by dagw on Monday April 03, 2017 @05:08AM (#14021495)
Disagree very much. Church attendance all over Europe is declining at a significant rate, and even among those still attending, the number of people who truly believe is dropping. And even among those few who still truly believe the general consensus is strongly in favour of science and the scientific method. Science not only has a fighting chance, it is dominating.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by ooqr on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:12AM (#14021922)
Religion can still hold on to the fact that the only position you can actually arrive at by reason alone is agnosticism. Hostility toward science by religion is irrational and self-defeating, as is the converse.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by abalashov on Monday April 03, 2017 @05:28AM (#14021562)
For a stark contrast, come visit the USA! :-)
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by Neliquat on Monday April 03, 2017 @11:04AM (#14023236)
Its down here too... just try to find a city where they havent turned many an old church into a b&b, goth disco, or yuppie homes (thanks to grandfathered zoning exemptions in residential areas). Sure southern baptists and penicostals are a bit nutty in comparison, but louder =/= more.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by literallycancer on Monday April 03, 2017 @10:46AM (#14023100)
>What's the alternative? A civil servant deciding what is allowed to be taught to children?

It's not an alternative, it's what happens now, and will always happen, unless there is some major disruption in education.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by rimliu on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:12AM (#14021108)
Not fair competition when indoctrination is given a headstart. There is a difference between being allowed to learn this stuff and being indoctrinated since the days you are not even able to read.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by khedoros1 on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:24AM (#14021141)
So, should children be given to the care of the state at the earliest possible age? Or you'd rather have mass prosecution and re-education to stamp out beliefs that you dislike?

In the long run, maladaptive beliefs will die out and useful ones will survive, head start or no.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by cyborgx7 on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:33AM (#14021366)
I don't understand. I'm not advocating for the state to stamp out beliefs I disagree with. But the believes that should win out and survive should be the correct ones, not the useful ones.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by khedoros1 on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:07PM (#14024695)
The person that I replied to seemed to be saying that certain beliefs should be disallowed, and that's what I was responding to.

As to what should win out: Truth is a fine ideal to work towards, but one should never expect that it's what will actually win. "Should" is like "deserves". They're nice to think about, but not always realistic.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by ooqr on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:29PM (#14028217)
You're digging up a philosophical morass, though. Please prove that you weren't indoctrinated. In general, it's not possible if you're assuming the possibility that people can be brainwashed to the degree of rejecting reason.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by dredmorbius on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:32AM (#14021159)
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by sametmax on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:24AM (#14021140)
It's not as easy as regulate as stealing or murder. It's more like with freedom of speech. If you start drawing a line, you end up harming the very thing you tried to defend.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by AnimalMuppet on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:19PM (#14024860)
This is kind of an ironic comment to a post about intellectual humility...
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by dkarapetyan on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:38AM (#14020795)
That baffles you? Because of Romania's anti-vaccination movement 17 children are now dead: http://globalnews.ca/news/3345439/deadly-measles-outbreak-sp.... At the end of the day humans are just apes.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by carsongross on Monday April 03, 2017 @05:18AM (#14021534)
Can you give us some examples of provably false beliefs being taught to children?
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by adrianN on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:03AM (#14021709)
Santa brings presents to well behaved children on Christmas.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by JauntTrooper on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:20PM (#14024867)
It used to bug me, but now I actually like the phenomenon of Santa Claus.

The entire adult population is conspiring to lie to children, and it's up to the child to challenge it based on their own logic and observations.

It's a way to teach children to not trust authority blindly and to develop their own critical thinking skills.

I never felt betrayed by my parents about it. I remember feeling proud that I figured it out, and when my mother told me that everyone did it as a way to honor the memory of the real Saint Nicolas, I understood that.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by carsongross on Monday April 03, 2017 @02:08PM (#14025404)
But Santa does exist: he is a spiritual being and his spirit works through all the parents who make Christmas happen. Quite literally, a magic fat man makes presents appear under the tree on Christmas, and it's a miracle.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by JauntTrooper on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:25PM (#14024941)
Now that I think about it, this was all pre-search engines.

The truth is just a Google search away now. I wonder if the Santa myth will recede into history for my kid's generation.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by grkvlt on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:08AM (#14022441)
I was brought up not to believe in Santa (and apparently got into trouble at school for upsetting other children by telling them he didn't exist) and find it amazing that other parents are happy to lie to their children like this - setting a precedent that adults are not to be trusted, thus undermining lots of potentially valuable true advice. On the other hand, my family also took me to church every week, so there's that...
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by carsongross on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:18PM (#14024079)
Surely, the phenomenological existence of Santa can be understood by HackerNews readers, no? Santa is a spirit and exists spiritually in as much as he has an effect on this world. And so we find he has, and, therefore, does.

I don't expect most HackerNews readers to agree with that argument (I am of two minds on it) but I would hope it recommends to them a bit of intellectual humility.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by grkvlt on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @01:32PM (#14035211)
Maybe, maybe, maybe ... in the loosest, most hand-wavingly vague, almost, kind of sense, yes, IF - you s/spirit/concept/ then yes, that could be said to be true. But one could use the same argument about God, surely? In that the concept has a measurable effect on the world through the actions of believers, therefore He exists.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by carsongross on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @11:54PM (#14039529)
> But one could use the same argument about God, surely

Don't think too hard about that one.

You might end up a nietzschean catholic, like me on Tuesdays.

Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by nf05papsjfVbc on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:49AM (#14021845)
Heaven and Hell are just adult versions of this.
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by metaphorm on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:12PM (#14026677)
I think OP was referring to young Earth creationism
Re:The Case for More Intellectual Humility by grkvlt on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:05AM (#14022427)
Santa Claus.