The entire adult population is conspiring to lie to children, and it's up to the child to challenge it based on their own logic and observations.
It's a way to teach children to not trust authority blindly and to develop their own critical thinking skills.
I never felt betrayed by my parents about it. I remember feeling proud that I figured it out, and when my mother told me that everyone did it as a way to honor the memory of the real Saint Nicolas, I understood that.
The truth is just a Google search away now. I wonder if the Santa myth will recede into history for my kid's generation.
I don't expect most HackerNews readers to agree with that argument (I am of two minds on it) but I would hope it recommends to them a bit of intellectual humility.
Don't think too hard about that one.
You might end up a nietzschean catholic, like me on Tuesdays.