They want it this way. My company at its core relies on traditional advertising. Our leads are finally at the point that we're roughly 1:1 between traditional and online.
We've built tools to determine the effectiveness of our traditional ad spend so that we can better target our spend, but we're getting a ton of resistance to us using them. This is from our own internal person who has been running the traditional side of our ad spend for 30 years. Every player in the traditional ads game benefits from keeping the people controlling the spending completely in the dark.
We also have this fun problem where nobody's actually been verifying that TV ads actually run when they're supposed to. We have physical offices in all of the locations we advertise for the most part, so we're talking about setting up slingboxes and programmatically verifying that our ads actually run.
If you want a fairly raw build-your-own solution you could speak to someone like TVEyes who'll give you an mpeg or mp3 feed from 100s of channels across the USA.
If you insert a fingerprint into your advert audio, you can then auto-detect plays across the entire country.
Have you considered hiring Kantar to check if the ads are running? They do this.
Moreover, we're kind of the big company in this space. We own many of the billboards we (and our competitors advertise on). We have multiple different platforms that we sell to our "competition". They're 10-20 years behind us in tech and the budget/desire to get there. It makes sense that we build this ourselves and keep it that way.
1) Coupons or discount codes in print and tv/radio ads (or using a unique URL, phone number, etc.)
2) Simply watching to see if leads traffic (however you define it: foot traffic, hits to website, calls, etc.) surges in the period post ad campaign (assuming you stagger your campaigns for better individual campaign tracking)
#1 isn't an option for us because we don't take upfront payment, or really any money directly, from our clients. Tons of companies try this and it's expensive and doesn't convert well for everyone. In certain kinds of sales pipelines this works, but many times it's just people searching for a coupon code online and you don't get accurate information about what converted.
Uh, nowhere? People already ban ads wherever they reasonably can, in part due to the fact that excesses like popup ads, layer ads etc. have been encouraged and adopted instead of dropped and people just are fed up with being treated like a walking dollar machine.
The only reasonable ad slots will be where people literally cannot block them - which means in the meatspace. Classic old advertising columns are on the way of being replaced by shiny flashy LED screens, same for public transport information systems (e.g. Munich, https://www.mvg.de/services/fahrgastservice/fahrgastfernsehe...).
It will get really interesting once outdoor advertising can track people... but thank God, even in surveillance-friendly UK this stuff doesn't hold for long (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-08-12/snooping-...).
Well, product placement in movies is well known. Nearly everyone should know that companies pay millions of dollars to e.g. have James Bond drive their car.
What is way more evil is that what is called "influencer marketing", which you are addressing in your last part. It's especially evil because the target group for "influencers" is usually little kids.
But, once again, regulation comes to the rescue - at least in Germany, it's outright illegal. To quote §5a, sect. 6 UWG (law against unfair business practice):
(6) Unlauter handelt auch, wer den kommerziellen Zweck
einer geschäftlichen Handlung nicht kenntlich macht,
sofern sich dieser nicht unmittelbar aus den Umständen
ergibt, und das Nichtkenntlichmachen geeignet ist, den
Verbraucher zu einer geschäftlichen Entscheidung zu
veranlassen, die er andernfalls nicht getroffen hätte.
Translated (roughly, IANAL): He acts unfair, who hides the commercial purpose of a
business transaction as long as this is not obvious
from the circumstances, and the hiding is able to
trick the consumer into a business transaction he
would not have done otherwise.
The illegal act hereby is, e.g. as a youtube influencer, hiding that you were paid by an advertiser/vendor to promote a certain item in a "review", because an unsuspecting consumer may not know that your "review" is bought.This is the reason why "sponsored content" is clearly marked as such in German newspapers. Youtubers, on the other hand, have mostly ignored the law (and I'm happy for the day once someone uses the law to shut down the more obnoxious of the bunch like BibisBeautyPalace).
Especially when you consider targeting kids, is the result of this law actually effective in making it clear to them that something is an advertisement?
Regarding the "new form of media" aka clickbait youtube junk, weird blogs etc., however, it has not held up, for a couple of reasons:
- these participants often don't have imprints so it makes filing a lawsuit pretty difficult
- filing a lawsuit according to UWG is allowed only for competing companies (and they have to be competing with the advertiser, in the same areas of business!) and consumer protection agencies. No one likes an internet shitstorm for "going with the lawhammer after 16 year old youtube kids".
- there are just too many small-scale offenders, it's not worth the effort to go after them
Ads are already heavily present in those areas already. Many media outlets have "sponsored content" already. Movies have been doing both blatant and subtle placements for a long time too.
Console games have had embedded ads and vicious product placement, and some games are entirely based around brands (see most sport and racing games for the last 20 years)
The youtubers I respect (best content), have the format:
1. main content.
2. "Here comes an ad for X"
3. mildly entertaining ad for X
Right now Facebook suggests I like some furniture store - it should know by now that I don't give a shit about furniture or shoes or womens clothing, just because I am friends with people who do (mostly, funny enough, women).
Really facebook knows just about everything about me, yet they have never come up with an ad for a product I wanted to buy.
Anecdotally disabling blockers drastically improves relevance... though I still block them because relevant ads are as bad as untargetted ones.
Facebook is probably one of the only sites where I've seen an ad and gone "wow, I was actually looking for one of those"
Then again, I have a policy of not "liking" any kind of brand, group, or anything, don't post links to outside sites, and I randomly mark ads as offensive.
The argument can be reversed though: Despite the fact that traditional advertising is more or less blind to outcome and shows untargeted ads, it has survived for a very long time. This would indicate that businesses would be willing to pay to show untargeted dumb ads online too (if no other option exists).
Some campaigns are designed to increase some tangible result: more leads, more sales, etc.
Other campaigns, such as your Olympics example, are more general brand awareness and brand reputation/prestige building.
Basically the issue is that the argument, "You don't want everything to be a subscription/walled garden do you?!" turns out to have, "Actually yes, given the other options, yes we do!" as an answer. Especially when it turns out that the price of a subscription is highly negotiable when everyone is negotiating, and piracy exists.
I still cannot envision a world 100% without advertising, but my guess would be that the future would be more covert advertising, in the form of product placements etc. On the other hand, I think as the world becomes less materialistic (because it just isn't cool to hoard stuff now), perhaps the impact of having James Bond drive an Aston is going to become reduced.
I will happily pay for Spotify, because it does what it says on the tin: all my music in one place, fuss-free and then it gets out of my way. On the other hand, Netflix is now boring because they don't have all that I want, and so both Netflix and the Movie/TV licensing companies lose my money.
I really like your last point. The price of a subscription should be highly negotiable. The world is a more convenient place now (for a certain percentage of the world's population, admittedly), and expectations have shifted accordingly. Figure out a way of making me not jump through hoops, or you will lose.
The data to do this already exists in many cases.
For example, Google, Facebook - both know when people visit a location, and could cross-reference this with store visits now. If advertising exists in a physical location, and is effective, there is the potential for either of these companies to determine whether the customer visited a location where that physical inventory exists.
Traditional advertising only sucks at quantifying results because "new media" has no incentive to share the loads of data they are now collecting.
So a larger scale programmatic campaign is either a much earlier part of the pipeline than a lot of the adtech companies would have you believe, or is fairly pointless.
People actually do want to see ads in certain contexts. In many cases, they actually buy magazines like Vogue where it's filled with hundreds of pages of ads, because of the ads. People also buy local newspapers because of the ads & coupons.
The context where people want ads are shopping contexts. If you design your media property around a shopping context, featuring buyers guides or exclusive shopping info, the public will be more appreciative of your ads.
Context is very important. That's why 'other recommended products' on sites like Amazon are important. They are a form of ad, but most people don't see it as one, and they don't mind it.
People hate ads that attempt to capture your attention that are completely out of context. If I'm reading about network switches and flash ad for makeup pops up it annoys me. If it tries to exploit my computer it makes me ban all ads.
Is Netflix totally ad free? I've gotten the impression they were paid for product placement a few times. (Ex: Frank Underwood plugging Sony)
Their licensed stuff does but they can't rightfully edit it out since they didn't create the content.
I'm not sure why they'd have used so many if it weren't a paid product placement. The phones were much more numerous in HoC than they are in the real world.
I think this is spot on. And some people are willing to pay. Another example of this is Youtubers and Patreon. Now, you can finally block ads without guilt and support those creators far more reliably. If the number of supporters dominates the ad revenue, it also encourages more quality and less quantity.
For me, this is also where Youtube Red failed. It isn't transparent enough and I couldn't care less about all the "value-add" they tried to staple onto it. I'd rather pay ~$20/month distributed among roughly 6 channels via Patreon. Although it would be really nice to have a way to automatically give a few cents go to videos I watched and enjoyed (by some opt-out metric, e.g. watched more than 30%, or didn't hit dislike, or wasn't autoplayed "next up").
Isn't it a little perverse that the willingness of people to pay to block annoying ads provides an incentive to make ads ever more prevalent and annoying?
For companies, getting people to watch video ads is a win. For content creators, it's a win cause they get paid. For Youtube, it's a win cause they have a revenue stream. For viewers, it's a win because they don't have to pay anything.
The problem is in many cases, if you did want to pay, either to get rid of ads or to support content creators in a greater way, there's not much choice. (Which is puzzling as for a walled garden like Youtube the solution is much, much simpler than for the web.)
How much would it cost to offest the advertising income loss?
Often I don't care about ads. What I care most about is performance and usability. I don't want to wait the five seconds it takes the ad network to serve up an ad. I do not want hundreds of tracking scripts served from some ancient pre pentium box to make this worse. I also do not want to close 20 pop-ups.
Give me a nice eye catching traditional ad that just sits in the corner and leaves me alone any day. The cancer that is used for ads currently can just drop and die.
I'd say, is less slimy than traditional advertising.
Eh, traditional newspaper-billboard-and-broadcast-TV advertising doesn't try to follow me around and build an identifiable profile of me personally* - or serve up viruses then claim they're unable to stop doing that.The only virtue of online ads is you can remove them with an ad blocker (and that's not a benefit I've heard ad companies promoting).
*Obviously, there's still some profiling, but it's orders of magnitude coarser than Google has.
If Netflix was free but with ads (with ad-less subscriptions optional) their viewership and subscriptions would skyrocket, and end up supporting traditional advertising on a modern medium. The only thing I see in the way of something like this is ISPs refusing to give Netflix the bandwidth needed for something this massive. For this to be a possibility either the FCC makes ISPs a utility, or net-neutrality is repealed.
It's like 90% cheaper.
The reason for this is obvious on the Netflix balance sheets. They spent 3-5 times what came in.
Of course, this is not what the content producers want. And that's where things have gone wrong in the past, and will go wrong again.
In fact, Netflix and HBO are virtually the only people who actually allow you to reliably avoid ads. Even Hulu finds ways to force them down your throat when you pay.
I think the appeal of Netflix is that they aren't beholden to advertisers.
1) People straight up don't want to see ads. Ad blockers, Netflix, etc. are a natural response to this. If your medium relies on traditional ads, there's an increasingly large chance that your audience won't ever see those ads in the first place.
2) Companies want to know that their advertising dollars are actually producing results, and traditional advertising completely sucks at this. If you've never run a traditional ad campaign, I suggest giving it a try and then decide how much value you think you got out of it. You can spend thousands to millions of dollars and have absolutely no idea if your money impacted sales even the smallest amount. Compare that to adtech, where you get real data on outcomes on a regular basis. Even if it's crap data, it's often better than "well we think the brand is stronger now".
3) Traditional mediums for advertising are dying out quickly, especially with younger demographics. Newspapers used to be the prime advertising medium, and now most of them are guilting, begging, or strong-arming people into viewing their ads online. Magazines readership has been declining year over year for at least a decade. Live broadcast TV viewing among younger viewers has been flat or declining as well. Where are you supposed to find captive audiences willing to sit through your golden-age traditional advertising spots?
I agree that the adtech industry is slimy and in desperate need of a shakeup, but idolizing traditional advertising while ignoring the difficulties of ads in today's world doesn't really help here.