Well, product placement in movies is well known. Nearly everyone should know that companies pay millions of dollars to e.g. have James Bond drive their car.
What is way more evil is that what is called "influencer marketing", which you are addressing in your last part. It's especially evil because the target group for "influencers" is usually little kids.
But, once again, regulation comes to the rescue - at least in Germany, it's outright illegal. To quote §5a, sect. 6 UWG (law against unfair business practice):
(6) Unlauter handelt auch, wer den kommerziellen Zweck
einer geschäftlichen Handlung nicht kenntlich macht,
sofern sich dieser nicht unmittelbar aus den Umständen
ergibt, und das Nichtkenntlichmachen geeignet ist, den
Verbraucher zu einer geschäftlichen Entscheidung zu
veranlassen, die er andernfalls nicht getroffen hätte.
Translated (roughly, IANAL): He acts unfair, who hides the commercial purpose of a
business transaction as long as this is not obvious
from the circumstances, and the hiding is able to
trick the consumer into a business transaction he
would not have done otherwise.
The illegal act hereby is, e.g. as a youtube influencer, hiding that you were paid by an advertiser/vendor to promote a certain item in a "review", because an unsuspecting consumer may not know that your "review" is bought.This is the reason why "sponsored content" is clearly marked as such in German newspapers. Youtubers, on the other hand, have mostly ignored the law (and I'm happy for the day once someone uses the law to shut down the more obnoxious of the bunch like BibisBeautyPalace).
Especially when you consider targeting kids, is the result of this law actually effective in making it clear to them that something is an advertisement?
Regarding the "new form of media" aka clickbait youtube junk, weird blogs etc., however, it has not held up, for a couple of reasons:
- these participants often don't have imprints so it makes filing a lawsuit pretty difficult
- filing a lawsuit according to UWG is allowed only for competing companies (and they have to be competing with the advertiser, in the same areas of business!) and consumer protection agencies. No one likes an internet shitstorm for "going with the lawhammer after 16 year old youtube kids".
- there are just too many small-scale offenders, it's not worth the effort to go after them
Ads are already heavily present in those areas already. Many media outlets have "sponsored content" already. Movies have been doing both blatant and subtle placements for a long time too.
Console games have had embedded ads and vicious product placement, and some games are entirely based around brands (see most sport and racing games for the last 20 years)
The youtubers I respect (best content), have the format:
1. main content.
2. "Here comes an ad for X"
3. mildly entertaining ad for X
Uh, nowhere? People already ban ads wherever they reasonably can, in part due to the fact that excesses like popup ads, layer ads etc. have been encouraged and adopted instead of dropped and people just are fed up with being treated like a walking dollar machine.
The only reasonable ad slots will be where people literally cannot block them - which means in the meatspace. Classic old advertising columns are on the way of being replaced by shiny flashy LED screens, same for public transport information systems (e.g. Munich, https://www.mvg.de/services/fahrgastservice/fahrgastfernsehe...).
It will get really interesting once outdoor advertising can track people... but thank God, even in surveillance-friendly UK this stuff doesn't hold for long (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-08-12/snooping-...).