As for gliding back: the Falcon booster does not actually achieve orbit-- when the main engine cuts off, it is on a ballistic trajectory back to the ocean. While it may be possible to design some sort of gliding apparatus to "save" a booster on a sub-orbital trajectory, it is (again, as I understand it), much simpler to simply adjust that trajectory via a boostback burn that reverses or slows that trajectory, and to then perform a suicide burn[2] to recover the stage, either on a barge or (on lower orbit missions) back on a land-based pad.
I am not a rocket scientist, nor do I have experience in the space industry-- these thoughts are just based on what I've read following the SpaceX reusability program as closely as I can for the past few years.
I do play a lot of Kerbal Space Program, though.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_Space_Shuttle...
[2] http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/10307/what-is-a-sui...
They also have no other option. Even one engine at lowest throttle (70 %) is powerful enough to lift the almost empty booster again, so they cannot hover (which would make things a bit easier, at the expense of needing more fuel).
(If someone can confirm/deny this? I'm seeing approx 28T dry mass, thrust per engine of 66T and min thrust of 70%, but that dated guess work from http://space.stackexchange.com/q/4466/ )
The Space Shuttle's engines were extremely complex beasts that begat the most advanced alloys at the time – very much bleeding edge, with the tightest tolerances possible, to squeeze out performance that wasn't thought possible before, using highly aggressive propellants (hydrogen embrittlement was a huge problem). As a result, they only had a tenth of their planned life expectancy (average of 5-6 instead of 55 flights), and needed an 80% refurbishment between every flight to replace cracked turbine blades etc. pp.
Falcon 9's Merlin engines, meanwhile, are best described as "boring": They're firmly a 60s design made cheaper than dirt thanks to modern manufacturing technology, and highly reliable thanks to a simple design and safe fuels (kerosene). SpaceX already demonstrated on the ground that Merlins can perform multiple missions without needing refurbishment.
Or, in car analogies: The Space Shuttle is a Jaguar, Falcon 9 is a Ford. While you can, on the paper, drive a Jaguar twice without seeing a workshop, nobody managed it yet.
> I was under the impression that SpaceX was trying to make the first re-usable rocket stage, but I've recently found out that that isn't true. The space shuttle already holds that title.
Kinda, sorta, in theory: While the orbiters did refly a lot of times, the engines (the most expensive part of the Shuttle) barely did, only in the "Ship of Theseus" sense. Same for boosters (fishing steel tubes out of the ocean and hammering out the kinks was a pure work creation measure), and the huge external tanks were made anew each time.
> I'm also kindof curious why they decided to go with a vertical-landing-design, instead of putting some wings on it and having it glide home like the shuttle did. Is that a weight-concern?
Precision and weight: Wings are dead weight for a vertically launched rocket, and increase drag (especially supersonic) further than folded-up landing legs do. Hoverslam point landings need very little added mass on the rocket, and you expose a far smaller surface to re-entry heating etc.
The vertical landing design is actually really smart because it allows a relatively un-aerodynamic object to get back to the ground without adding heavy wings and fairings. Rockets don't actually like having fins when they go up since the dynamic pressures get to be extremely high. Rather, they opt for gimbaled engines to steer (this also helps when there's no atmosphere to steer with). The only downside to this approach is that some of the fuel has to be retained for the return trip, though this is a relatively small fraction. The other huge issue you have to deal with when gliding back is having some sort of landing gear in addition to the control surfaces. You can put wheels on it but that's a lot of weight and if you land it horizontally, without the pressure of the propellant keeping the body rigid, it will most likely crumple.
The SSME are special and specially efficent because they burn fuel-rich and have multible pre-burners. They were very highly optimized but that made them complex.
Full-staged combustion has a better max performance for a given fuel and promises to be simpler in design.
SpaceX rockets use a much simpler engines, that burn oxygen and kerosene. The main cost is in the first stage of the engine - think two rockets on top of each other, the first stage is the bottom rocket that first first. When the first rocket is done, it falls away. This first stage accounts for the majority of the cost of the launch. Think of it was being equivalent to the main tank and 2 boosters of the shuttle.
What SpaceX manages, which no-one has done before, is to retrieve that big + expensive first stage for reuse.
http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/solid-rocket-bo...
All that stress + salt water meant a fairly extensive refurb process.
Could one conceivably use different materials (that maybe didn't exist back then) resistant to aquatic stress and salt, to have made the old plan much more cost effective?
Following this line of thought I think you wind up with something close to what SpaceX does. Because the next largest save-able cost would be the boat crew to go recover it. So attach a propeller to the rocket to have it come back on its own. Then you want to save that cost and complexity so have it come to your boat with no crew and touch down gently.
Basically, the physical and aerodynamic stresses of decelerating vertically are fairly similar to those of accelerating vertically. Whereas designing something which can work as a rocket and a plane would be a lot more difficult, and probably more expensive to produce.
It's more difficult to control vertically, but if you can get it right you save a lot of complexity in the physical engineering.
For RTLS launches, it would do approximately as good as their current approach, the fuel for landing burn+legs will approximately weight as much as wings and wheels. But would definitely cost more to develop.
A winged stage also having a jet engine, allowing it to fly back as a powered airplane, not a glider, would solve both issues, and will whole lot more efficient than current SpaceX approach for RTLS, and about as good as ASDS, but a lot, a lot more expensive to develop. They would have to become an aircraft company in addition to being a rocket company.
SpaceX ITS video:
Shuttle boosters are solid-fuel, so they can't restart, can't land, and were ditched in the ocean and refurbed. In contrast the 1st stage of spacex rockets can land itself.
I was under the impression that SpaceX was trying to make the first re-usable rocket stage, but I've recently found out that that isn't true. The space shuttle already holds that title.
For certain values of re-usable. It was pretty much stripped and refurbed for each mission, at enormous cost. The costs of spacex are orders of magnitude smaller.
I'm also kindof curious why they decided to go with a vertical-landing-design,
This design works everywhere, not just earth.
It's sort of apples vs oranges to compare the Shuttle main engines vs the Falcon 9 engines, because the Shuttle main engines were on the the crewed upper stage of the Shuttle stack and the Falcon 9 booster is the boost stage of the Falcon 9 stack.
The direct comparison is comparing the Falcon 9 booster (first stage) with the solid rocket boosters of the Shuttle stack, and comparing the Shuttle with the Dragon. Dragon v1 has a heat shield (like Shuttle) and then parachutes (unlike Shuttle). Dragon 2 will have reusable engines to land propulsively, which means it will land on land like the Shuttle.
The Falcon 9 booster is much, much more sophisticated than the Shuttle boosters. The Shuttle boosters were solid fueled; once lit they could not be turned off or throttled. They just burned at maximum thrust until they ran out of fuel, which is why they needed parachutes to land in the ocean.
Unfortunately NASA learned that salt water is terrible for engines, even if they land gently, and the cost of refurbishing the boosters after each launch (and the amount of time it took) was much higher than anticipated. Falcon 9's Block 5 booster should (hopefully) reach a point where it can land, get refueled, and immediately take off again, like a 747.
> I was under the impression that SpaceX was trying to make the first re-usable rocket stage, but I've recently found out that that isn't true. The space shuttle already holds that title.
For the reasons I have above, you were right the first time. SpaceX is trying to make the first reusable booster that achieves orbit. Both Shuttle and Blue Origin's New Shepard are reusable, but neither of them can reach orbit by themselves.
> I'm also kindof curious why they decided to go with a vertical-landing-design, instead of putting some wings on it and having it glide home like the shuttle did.
Scaling laws. Vertical take-off, vertical landing (VTVL) rockets scale to any size. Wings don't. The Falcon 9, the Falcon Heavy, and future mega-rockets will all be able to use the same basic technology. Wings don't scale well at all.
You are correct about the disadvantages of wings, but wrong about why SpaceX isn't using them.
SpaceX has always had the goal of landing on Mars and returning home. All their rockets have been developed with this in mind. They tested their first rocket, and got it to work. They sold it to Nasa and the like (and even developed it with some of their requirements in mind), but the goal was always to learn how to make bigger rockets that can get to Mars, that Nasa is willing to pay for the smaller ones is a side benefit. Mars does not have enough atmosphere for wings to work, therefore SpaceX is not interested in Wings.
Even if reuse of the rocket was clearly more expensive that building a new one each time (it isn't) SpaceX would be working on reusable rockets now because when they get to mars they need to land the rocket and latter reuse it to return back to earth.
Vertical landing for the Falcon 9 made sense because it meant they only had to add a small amount of extra weight and new systems (landing legs, grid fins, etc.) in order to achieve powered precision landings. In contrast, adding wings, landing gear, other aerodynamic components, and potentially other engines (in order to achieve powered landings) adds a lot of extra complexity and weight. Additionally, the stage is already designed to handle vertical flight and forces, making it strong enough to handle strong aerodynamic forces while flying horizontally is no small change. And vertical landing enables barge landings out at sea as well as dramatically reducing the size of the landing facilities (a small pad versus a landing strip). All of which saves costs, complexity, and enables a higher percentage of the vehicle's performance to be used by the customer versus for recovery.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_space_shuttle_landing_...
Of course, the Earth rotates underneath the Shuttle while it's in orbit, so when the Shuttle comes back around in a polar orbit it's quite some distance to the west of the launch site, so it needs to be able to make significant maneuvers for this to work.
Vandenberg never ended up hosting Shuttle launches, of course. It was nearly ready, with mission planned and everything, when Challenger exploded. This caused a reevaluation of the whole idea, and it ended up being scrapped. But the design consequences remained part of the vehicle until the end.
And of course, there was John Glenn, monitored inside and
out, blood tested, urine sampled, entire organism analyzed
for signs of accelerated aging. Close observation of the
Senator suggested that there might not be any medical
obstacles to launching the entire legislative branch into
space, possibly the most encouraging scientific result of
the mission.As tempting as it is to picture a blood-spattered Canadarm flinging goat carcasses into the void,...
> The Soviet Shuttle, the Buran (snowstorm) was an aerodynamic clone of the American orbiter, but incorporated many original features that had been considered and rejected for the American program, such as all-liquid rocket boosters, jet engines, ejection seats and an unmanned flight capability. You know you're in trouble when the Russians are adding safety features to your design.
The Solid Rocket Boosters are strictly speaking doing exactly what the Falcon 9 booster is doing: being recoverable. However, the Falcon 9 boosters have much greater capability to be re-used without refurbishment, since they don't encounter salt water.
The SSMEs (Space Shuttle Main Engines - Aerojet Rocketdyne RS-25), required an almost complete rebuild after every launch. It was nominally reusable in that the parts could be reused, but it took a long time to refurbish and re-test the engines. Also, the first stage of the Space shuttle included the solid rocket boosters and the hydrogen fuel tank. The boosters were absolutely reusable (I seem to remember reading that of all the SRBs, all but four were reused - two from the first launch were never recovered, and two from the Challenger disaster that couldn't be recovered). But the Space Shuttle wasn't fully reusable like the Falcon first stage.
To me, the difference between the Space Shuttle and the Falcon 9 is kind of like the difference between a doctor of mechanical engineering and a mechanical engineer. The Space Shuttle was an amazing (and complex) piece of tech - the engines used liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen, which is incredibly efficient but notoriously difficult to work with (cooling hydrogen to a liquid sate and keeping it cooled is not trivial). It was a long (~10 years) process to develop the Space Shuttle from the existing tech we already had. The result was a highly tuned and complex engine that was incredibly efficient. It makes you feel a bit warm and fuzzy at how efficient and well engineered the engines are.
SpaceX went the other way - they said we'll use a slightly less efficient set up (RP-1 (refined kerosene) and liquid oxygen) as our fuel, but we'll make up for it by making each individual launch much much cheaper. So while they may not have the fuel efficiency of the Space Shuttle, for the cost of a single Space Shuttle launch (~$400M per launch according to wikipedia), SpaceX could launch 6 or 7 Falcon 9s (~$60M per launch). The SSMEs are very efficient engines. The Falcon 9 is a very efficient platform. It's kind of like a big picture vs micro optimization sort of thing. (There is no judgement here - the Space Shuttle was developed by a government with much different concerns and constraints than the private business developing the Falcon 9).
Having a fixed wing aircraft come down from space really doesn't make that much sense when we get down to it. It's a really great and interesting concept, but the realities of it make it not worth the trouble. Sure the Space Shuttle glided, but even a brick going 17,000 miles an hour will glide for a long while. This video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3JZtY7bcbM) gives a great overview into the complexities of a plane-shaped spacecraft hitting the atmosphere at 7 km/s. When a capsule (like the Apollo Command Module) hits the atmosphere, you only need to protect one side of it, and you just let the thing fall like a stone then slow it down with parachutes. The Space Shuttle Orbiter had to have different materials with different heat shielding properties all over its body because it would glide through the air at different angles. The bottom of the orbiter had an enormous surface area, and it needed to be thermally insulated. But heat shields are very heavy, and that amount of weight would make the launches impractical and landing impossible. So NASA had to develop new, light materials that were incredibly strong and also heat resistant.
The Falcon 9's first stage is not going nearly as fast as the Space Shuttle Orbiter when it hits the atmosphere, so it's not really appropriate to make a direct comparison about the complexities there. But this is to me another part of the brilliance of SpaceX looking at the big picture - it's much easier to reuse the first stage (which is typically the most expensive part of a launch vehicle) which doesn't reach orbital velocity and capture as big a chunk as the savings as possible rather than being totally 100% efficient.
I would not be surprised if NASA was 50 or 60 years ahead of its time with the Space Shuttle. It seems like private industry is catching up to where NASA was with the Saturn V in the 60s just now (we're still not close to a rocket as powerful as the Saturn V). We may see that in 20 or 30 years, the industry uses the materials and knowledge gained from the Space Shuttle to develop new and novel spacecraft.
Again, I'm just a programmer who loves rocketry and space - I apologize if there are any technically inaccurate bits in this post.
Early on they tried parachutes but ditched them, iirc.
At this point you have traded several tons of parachutes and many more points of failure which could cause loss of mission (parachutes are complex mechanisms) for a smaller weight of fuel and exactly the same points of failure as a rocket always has. Then SpaceX added grid fins, since purely propulsive landing was not going to be anywhere near accurate enough.
Classic example of working to your strengths, where the greatest strength of a rocket is acceleration along its primary axis :D
They could do something like the Russians do with Soyuz - small solid rocket boosters that fire right at landing. But yeah, that's a lot more things that have to go right.
Also even with the rocket motors Soyuz hits the ground pretty hard.
And yes, Soyuz hits pretty hard. But Soyuz was developed over fifty years ago. I'll bet we could do better today.
I'm not sure what advantage additional solid landing rockets would provide over just slightly bigger fuel tanks for the main engines.
I was originally thinking about solid rockets in context of a parachute system, but the more I think about the more I believe truly gentle landings aren't really a feature of the current design.
I'm not sure how much weight it would add, but it seems like having the ability to fine-tune the thrust at the very end would allow them to land much more gently and feel better about not introducing metal fatigue or other damage. Of course the addition of a smaller LF engine probably makes the most sense.
I was under the impression that SpaceX was trying to make the first re-usable rocket stage, but I've recently found out that that isn't true. The space shuttle already holds that title.
I'm also kindof curious why they decided to go with a vertical-landing-design, instead of putting some wings on it and having it glide home like the shuttle did. Is that a weight-concern? Aerodynamics, mabye, but couldn't the wings be articulated in the same way that the landing legs are right now?
(I will admit some ignorance in this field. I'm definitely a fan, but I'm definitely not a historian or a rocket scientist)