News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jakelarkin on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:52PM (#13971089)
This is sort of like how when the waterless urinal was first commercialized, the plumbers union blocked it from getting approved in the general building code. Eventually a compromised was reached that involves requiring a plumber to draw an water line (unutilized) to every water-less install.

Unions for skilled, high-pay jobs in highly regulated industries really extract a lot of questionable value from society.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by VLM on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:14PM (#13971297)
waterless ones are patented and without a water line you'd be locked in to higher priced products and/or have to spend a lot of extra money to run a new water line after the walls go up. Generally the situation with waterless ones is people endlessly social signal their green superiority about them, then the incredible stench makes them install real urinals. Even if only 5% or so install real urinals the net cost is still lower.

Its kind of like an electrician demanding a ground line be run to every outlet while someone who knows nothing about electricity demanding that ground wire almost never carries current therefore is a waste of money.

Perhaps a better analogy is its like adding another fiber optic strand, before or during the project the marginal cost is extremely cheap, after the project is complete its unimaginably expensive to add another strand after the dirt has gone back in the ditch.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by fiter on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:36PM (#13971521)
I think it's very important to be able to let people make these decisions. It's inefficient to add a water line if it's never going to be used. You might believe I'm going to use it, but I might know I'm not going to use it. Maybe you're right, but I am the one paying the bill to tear off finishings to run water lines in the walls.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by RangerScience on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:47PM (#13971628)
Kiiiinnnnda. People make bad decisions, and the only architecture that matters is the one that lets you change. It's like the dig-once fiber policy for roadways, and is all part of the "don't build to peak value" idea; it's also like a usual problem with user interface design: if you only ever built user tools to do what you imagined, users (or later owners / tenants) are limited to your imagination.

I go to a gym in an office building; there are showers. Do you think the floor was built with anyone thinking: "Oh, one day there might be showers here!"? I worked at a company with a (big) 3d printer - we had to rinse part afterwards, and kinda managed to wedge the rinser into the (extra extra large) handicapped stall in the men's bathroom. Don't just build to what YOU can imagine, give people rope to make more things.

Running unused water lines [while it's cheap to do so] sounds like a good plan.

On the other hand, future proofing, and enough rope to hang yourself.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by djrogers on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:41PM (#13972044)
> Kiiiinnnnda. People make bad decisions

You can't outlaw bad decisions - but it seems that some people will never get tired of trying...

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by marcosdumay on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:51PM (#13972133)
Construction codes are all about outlawing bad decisions.

Of course, those are "bad" decisions that save a few penny from the builders, and stay hidden until they surprise the building owner with a huge unpredictable cost. No water lines to urinals fits that descriptions nicely.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by brudgers on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:42PM (#13972486)
As they say:

  Built to code == the worst construction that is legal
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by btschaegg on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:02AM (#13974218)
> Of course, those are "bad" decisions that save a few penny from the builders, and stay hidden until they surprise the building owner with a huge unpredictable cost.

Another case in point: http://mobile.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN0UG0H720160102

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by CPLX on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:30PM (#13972410)
In an optimal world, those would be the only kinds of decisions we would outlaw.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:54PM (#13972153)
You can outlaw bad decisions. That's the whole point of laws.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by viraptor on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:19PM (#13972339)
I thought law is about forbidding harmful decisions, not bad ones? (At least in theory) Most of the stupid things you do to yourself, without affecting others are not regulated.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:54PM (#13972854)
Bad decisions are bad because they are harmful. And most stupid things you do to yourself do affect others, and they are regulated according to the significance of the damage, not merely predicated on its existence.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by viraptor on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:38PM (#13973315)
I specifically qualified with not affecting others, because otherwise that would be a different discussion. Yet...
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:56PM (#13973423)
Yet we still find some reason to regulate just about everything, because people are pretty creative about finding ways to pass the consequences of their bad decisions onto other people.

I don't know real estate developers to be any sort of exception, do you?

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:43PM (#13973869)
Just because "we" find reasons to do this doesn't make it right, or a good idea.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:32AM (#13974096)
No shit. What is it you think I'm trying to say here?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ythn on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:05AM (#13977156)
Try outlawing tobacco and see what happens (hint: Prohibition).
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:16PM (#13981777)
I'm not arguing that all bad decisions should be outlawed, so I don't exactly see the relevance.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by btschaegg on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:53AM (#13974181)
I can actually see this effect in my flat. I live in a fairly old building; it's been renovated and I really like it, but the location of the power plugs is the same as when it was constructed (except for one room in my flat). This means each socket is located at the entry of the respective room - the result being that I have extension cords all over the place. I especially find this interesting since this means the pattern of power consumption by "normal people" must have shifted drastically in the last 60-100 years.

On another note, the obvious parallels to software engineering tasks seem very interesting. This shows that ideas like YAGNI very much depend on a cost-benefit-calculation that's very dependend on variables like scale and the anticipated cost of changes.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by WWLink on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @02:08AM (#13983834)
That electrical system sounds like a fire hazard. I'd hate to see what some of the other apartments look like!
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by btschaegg on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:47AM (#13984428)
I don't see how you conclude a fire hazard by the positioning of power sockets. Could you elaborate on that?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by fiter on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:41PM (#13973030)
I think this is a business decision.

Some building developers will reap the reward if it was a good decision, others will suffer the consequence.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:43PM (#13973865)
Dig-once policy for roadways makes sense because the roadway is a public good, and digging multiple times would cause problems for the public, and would cost more for the public, so the _public_ is well within its rights to require this policy.

Requiring a water line in a building is not the same thing. It's a private building, and the people who own it are well within their rights to decide to risk later disruption and cost if they need water lines. Legislating away that right is insanity and just make-work that costs the building owner money up-front for something they've decided they don't need.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by gingerbread-man on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:26PM (#13971912)
The problem is that cities don't want buildings torn down every 10 years because it's cheaper for the buyer to just rebuild from the ground up than to fight what essentially amounts to a heap of technical debt. Well-constructed buildings can last centuries: future-proofing is a pretty big deal.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jonknee on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:06PM (#13972891)
Why would a city care? That's just more permitting money and local jobs.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by hinkley on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:04PM (#13973133)
You're replying to a story about a guy who wants to replace tower cranes because two of them fell over and killed people in the same year.

That's why the city cares. Every time one goes up or comes down there's a risk involved.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Anderkent on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:23PM (#13972963)
Are you familiar with the concept of opportunity cost? Effort spend redoing things all the time instead of improving and building new things is not making a city better.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by aljones on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:55AM (#13976124)
If a city had the narrow concerns of a business then that might make sense.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by namlem on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:08AM (#13977188)
Because construction sites are ugly and noisy.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by paulmd on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:11PM (#13972284)
We do this in lots of places. For example, it's against building code in most places to build a house without power grid feeds, running water, or septic/sewer access. Sometimes there are exceptions for "tiny houses" but other times not.

You yourself might want to go totally off the grid and/or rustic, but the reality is that you are likely not going to be the last person who ever lives in that house. Maybe you don't pay your taxes and the township ends up owning a lien on your house. They don't want to have to spend fifty grand installing electricity or running water before they can sell the house.

Depending on how big the technical deficit is here, it may not even be cost effective to retrofit after the fact (after all it still needs to meet code). And knocking down a house because the previous owner was a weirdo is terribly wasteful.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by fiter on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:21PM (#13972954)
I suppose I didn't make it explicit, but my point is that these regulations can be costly and/or stifling for a future benefit that may never come.

Costly in the original example would be that waterless urinals are installed for the life of the building.

Stifling in your example would be because much land will never be used because it's infeasible to bring power, water, and septic. Someone could have a home, but nothing will happen instead due to the regulation.

Just to meet your last point: - Is today's weirdo tomorrow's visionary? - Is a weirdo not allowed to create what he wants if he's not hurting anyone?

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by gregmac on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:56PM (#13973933)
> these regulations can be costly and/or stifling for a future benefit that may never come.

You could say the same thing about much of the building code.

A lot of code is there to ensure that the floor doesn't collapse if you fill the tub up with water, have a room full of people jumping up and down, or buy a piano. There's more on ensuring the roof doesn't collapse if there's lot of snow on it, and making sure the house is solid enough to safely sustain reasonably high winds or an earthquake.

If there are no earthquakes, wind or snow storms, you never buy a piano or have a party and only ever use the shower, is the effort put in satisfying these codes wasted?

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by fiter on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:50AM (#13974842)
I think it's important to consider the difference between "possible benefit" and "avoiding injury/death".

When it comes to safety--because we understandably put such a large value on human life--small risks are something we consider.

I believe all of your examples fall into the safety category. Even worse about your examples is that the situations are unsafe and misleading. I think our regulations surrounding the safety issues that you listed are reasonable.

(Additionally, building codes do consider expected usage and alters allowances. No one expects a piano in an attic and the floor load per square foot requirements reflect that.)

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by rtpg on Monday March 27, 2017 @10:02PM (#13973451)
There aren't that many building regulations in the middle of the countryside.

Building busted stuff in the middle of NYC hurts everyone, because there's limited space.

Visionaries can build where other people don't want to be, or convince the people around them that what they want to do is a good idea.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by fiter on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:01AM (#13974892)
You'd be surprised at the prevalence of regulations! ("You have one flush toilet. U.S. regulations require every legally habitable dwelling to have at least one flush toilet connected to an approved sewer or septic system." -- So a composting-toilet-only house seems to be illegal everywhere in the US.)

Someone could buy an incredibly valuable vacant lot and fence it and never use it. As far as I know, that's not illegal but would cause the same problem you've pointed out. I don't think the utility hookup regulations are based on such "waste of space" reasoning.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by LordKano on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:43PM (#13971585)
In principle, I agree with you but in practice, I so loathe the stink of waterless urinals that on the inside, I'm glad they did that.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jlg23 on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:48PM (#13971630)
In principle, I agree with you, but in practice: Don't use my urinal if you don't like it.

Liberalism goes both ways.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by andrewflnr on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:49PM (#13972119)
In practice, your urinal is often bundled with things I don't have much choice in, like a university or employer. I'm not going to transfer to a new school because i don't like the urinals.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by LordKano on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:02AM (#13976175)
In principle, I agree with that but in practice; when you've got to go, you've got to go.

I have been nauseated every time I entered a public lavatory where waterless urinals were installed.

I have certainly avoided those lavatories in the future but once I'm nauseated, the damage is done.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by brudgers on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:41PM (#13972482)
Before sanitary sewer regulations, people got cholera and such:

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/15/science/15chol.html

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by aaron695 on Monday March 27, 2017 @10:16PM (#13973514)
Do you think it should be code that toilets have to be installed? You could shit in a box?

Personally this is not tooooo far off that. Ensuring toilets always work.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by awalton on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:23PM (#13972709)
> waterless ones are patented and without a water line you'd be locked in to higher priced products and/or have to spend a lot of extra money to run a new water line after the walls go up.

Urinals have a very long life cycle, and by the time one needs to be replaced, it is likely any patent left would be in Design only, and thus other manufacturers can build and sell them, allowing the market to rebalance the cost.

In other words, "they're patented" is a bogus argument for needing a water line.

There are better arguments which you tried to hit on - what if you want to replace a urinal with a stall or some other fixture, e.g. - but this one alone isn't a good one. There are also plenty of counter arguments for why this kind of thing is a really bad idea in the case of a water line (e.g., a blind water line is going to be a much more ugly problem when renovations do happen if they aren't well enough noted in the designs or if the designs are unavailable, and what happens when a blind water line leaks, bursts or corrodes through inside a wall due to freezing/accidentally drilling or nailing through a pipe/etc.)

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by sfall on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:33PM (#13972994)
waterless urinals require a cartridge which has to be replaced
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by djrogers on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:42PM (#13972053)
What about the flip side of it - someone wants to put in a few waterless urinals someplace where they can't run water line, and the alternative is no urinals at all? You've literally outlawed a portion of the utility of the invention.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by brudgers on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:41PM (#13972792)
Water supply lines are easy, sanitary waste lines are harder and messier. A location that will support a few 2" sanitary waste lines connecting to a 4" will support a 1" supply line.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by x0x0 on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:45PM (#13972076)
That's disgusting and unsanitary: no water == no sink.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by natosaichek on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:29PM (#13972407)
Ever used an outhouse? or been to a concert or event venue with portable hand-wash units?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by alphabettsy on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:27PM (#13972727)
Since when are those things regulated by the same building codes as a permanent building?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by tempestn on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:28PM (#13972401)
Outhouses don't have sinks and are pretty common. A hand sanitizer dispenser would do the job.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by akvadrako on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:24AM (#13975667)
waterless hand sanitiser doesn't actually work
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jrochkind1 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:47AM (#13976086)
cite?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:56PM (#13972184)
A pipe that runs to a waterless urinal doesn't actually waste any water.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by trapperkeeper79 on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:25PM (#13973796)
The plumbing unions made some dumb arguments about toxic gas coming up from the sewer IIRC. Why does the regulation care about costs anyways?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by wfo on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:50PM (#13971642)
Well, that's exactly the point. Just as corporations extract questionable value from society on behalf of their owning structure, unions extract questionable value from society on behalf of the workers. They are a similar-in-kind counterweight to corporate power, so it stands to reason they do similar things.

As it turns out in capitalism "extracting questionable value from society and taking it for yourself" is really the currency of power so an organization that doesn't do that is completely toothless and may as well not exist.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by crusso on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:04PM (#13972243)
But where corporate power with labor is scoped to each specific corporation, union power often crosses to many corporations, often even crossing to different industries. Many industries have needlessly suffered and died at the hands of overpowered unions.

Capitalism rarely extracts questionable value from society, and when it does it's normally the result of government interference in an industry in order to advantage one business vs another - creating non-value-based power imbalances like monopolies.

To the contrary, Capitalism has been proven time and again to provide maximum value for society.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jlawer on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:15PM (#13972666)
>Capitalism rarely extracts questionable value from society, and when it does it's normally the result of government interference in an industry in order to advantage one business vs another - creating non-value-based power imbalances like monopolies.

May I suggest cigarette / smoking advertising?

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Frondo on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:18PM (#13972335)
Wow! Many industries have "suffered and died" at the hands of unions? That is an amazing claim.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Ericson2314 on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:09PM (#13973151)
SMH at the libertarians who beleive competition magically always maintains itself in a free market.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by wahern on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:34PM (#13971515)
The dilemma is that those jobs might not be skilled and high-pay without unions.

Part of the reason there's so much make-work in unions today is because as a percentage of the workforce unions have largely been relegated to public works projects and other niches reliant on political support. It's an existential crisis for unions and their middle-class laborers, and so they're going to flex every political muscle they can.

Even though unions dominate in a country like Germany, the number of union workers required for any particular task is significantly less than is typical in the U.S. And that's because there's more union work available for their members. When union work disappears in the U.S., the union members don't just disappear, too.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by brudgers on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:38PM (#13972462)
Has nothing to do with unions. Waterless urinals were not allowed by the NYC Plumbing Code until May 2009 [0]. They became allowed as part of a water conservation plan. NYC has its own building codes because construction practices and urban density and infrastructure (e.g. fire and emergency services) are unique relative to the model building codes.

In terms of building codes, real-estate development interests have significantly more clout than unions. Partially that's because real-estate development is general seen as a net good. Partially it's their money talks several magnitudes louder because it is several magnitudes larger.

The fact that waterless urinals are allowed might be seen as evidence of the disparity.

[0]: http://www.nyc.gov/html/records/pdf/govpub/50076-22-09_build...

See also: https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/buildings/local_laws/ll41of2012.... for the larger law as of 2012.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ahoy on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:52PM (#13971661)
Union acts in it's member's interests: "Terrible, we shouldn't allow this".

Corporation acts in it's own interests: "Well you can't blame them for that".

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by a_puppy on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:44PM (#13972502)
I tend to think that monopolies are bad, whether corporations or unions. Local 14 is trying to be a monopoly.

One of the best arguments I've heard for unions [0] is that a negotiation between workers and companies is usually very lopsided: a company can afford for an employee to quit, but a worker often cannot afford to get fired. A union is powerful enough to negotiate equally with companies. But in the case of Local 14, it seems like the power is actually lopsided in the other direction: Local 14 can afford to boycott one particular construction project, but the building developers can't afford to go without cranes.

[0] https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/22/repost-the-non-liberta... (see section 2.5)

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by hinkley on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:14PM (#13973176)
> For decades, the local has had control over the training of new crane operators—and therefore who can work on a job site.

That's a monopoly practice, right there.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by andrewflnr on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:52PM (#13972139)
The difference is when either the union or a corporation successfully hijacks law enforcement to promote its members' interests over those of the public.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by wahern on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:43PM (#13972804)
When a corporation does it we blame the government.

When a union does it we blame the union.

It's a double standard. Worse, theoretically rent seeking by unions should be more tolerated than by corporations. We should minimize all forms of rent seeking, but some forms are worse than others. The rent seeking profits of unions are distributed to many more workers than of corporations, notwithstanding the fanciful image we have of the corrupt union boss.

Except for those on the far left, people generally perceive corporations as amoral. But almost all Americans, right and left, not only judge unions by a different standard, they're typically cynical about unions. Even well paid union members are cynical! It's... incredible.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by JBReefer on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:45PM (#13972504)
This is whataboutism. Both are bad, and holding the opinion that rent seeking is bad is logically consistent with condemning both action classes.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by CamperBob2 on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:04PM (#13972886)
One of these organizations produces goods and services. The other is, more often than not, just another parasitic middleman.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ahoy on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:37AM (#14042875)
Yes, the union members produce the goods and services.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by imgabe on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:13PM (#13972299)
There are plenty of people saying the former when corporations act in their own interests.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by atom-morgan on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:15PM (#13971309)
And when people advocate for programmers unionizing, I don't see why we'd be any different. There'd be people employed doing X, a programmer would make something to automate X, and "our" union would be trying to save their job.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by gingerbread-man on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:35PM (#13972006)
Just throwing in another reason why programmer unions don't make a lot of sense: licensing.

It makes sense to license electricians, crane operators, doctors, lawyers, and many other professions who do safety-critical work.

Only a very small minority of programmers work on software that could actually hurt someone (at Boeing, Toyota, etc...).

There's no reason to create a legal barrier to entry for programming.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by stonemetal on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:16PM (#13972929)
There are Medical health records in Postgres, doctor's office software running on windows and linux, Barcode readers at the local pharmacy, safety critical code in a git repo. If you are going to draw a line around safety critical software the dependency graph is much larger than you might think.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by viraptor on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:33PM (#13972425)
I don't disagree about licenses not making sense for programmers, but there's more ways to hurt people than physically. Think of people who lose money to fraud, get their personal details published, or get stuck in some process that costs them time and money just because they ended up in an unexpected state of a large and complicated system.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jaza on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:51PM (#13973390)
There is no general licence for a "construction worker". There are specific licences for things like "tower crane operator", "intermediate rigger", "advanced scaffolding erector".

Similarly, there would never be a general licence for "programmer". But some day there probably will be (and indeed probably should be) specific licences for things like "have back-end access to personal medical data", "modify source code of nuclear reactor control software", and "install networking hardware via which credit card details are transmitted".

It's not about creating a barrier to entry for a whole profession. It's about licencing people to work in specific situations where there are specific risks, such as privacy risks, public safety risks, and risk of fraud.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by llukas on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:21PM (#13972694)
You forgot only about: - banking - online shopping - medical data handling - other sensitive data handling - medical devices (pacemakers etc) - IoT
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by SapphireSun on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:13PM (#13973172)
Why would licensing be a barrier to unionizing? Surely a smaller licensed community is easier to unionize, but the whole idea is getting a lot of (skilled or unskilled) people together to bargain collectively when bargaining individually would be ineffective.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by RangerScience on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:38PM (#13971536)
This is like when people talk about the AI. The AI will do this, the AI will do that...

The AI doesn't exist. People will make it. That is when you know what it will do.

If we make the union, we can make plenty of reasons and ways for it to be different. Whether or not those result in a difference, is not very predictable.

Our day jab is literally understanding, predicting, and building complex systems out of ideas. Why would we be unable to make a union with a reasonable - even likely - chance of not developing the same problems these (much) older unions have?

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by viraptor on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:28PM (#13972399)
1. Organisation is created with good ideas. 2. Politically motivated or terrible at management and long term view people get to the top of organisation. 3. That organisation now protects the status quo, even though it's in everybody's interest to move on.

Tell me you've never seen this story... I've worked with managers who would absolutely go for hiring more people to continuously do the same stupid task rather than improving the process. If they were protected, it would be a very sad place to work.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by jlg23 on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:50PM (#13971641)
> The AI doesn't exist. People will make it.

But it will require much less people to build the AI. And that's the only relevant point when stepping into the investors' shoes.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by abandonliberty on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:09PM (#13972635)
Call it a 'professional association', like doctors, lawyers, and engineers.

The real problem is wealth concentration. Unions and professional associations are one way for the working class to push back when the society they live in is failing to do so.

It's the wrong tool, not addressing the root cause, has implementation challenges, and will create problems in the future.

But the ship is sinking right now. Since the 1970s.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kafkaesq on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:43PM (#13971588)
Except that there's no direct evidence of union shenanigans, in this case.

Yes, conceivably the DOB could be in backroom cahoots with Local 14-14B, and nixing the crane on stated grounds of structural design concerns -- whilst in reality having other motives. And not only "conceivably"; stuff like this happens in NYC all the time.

But we'd still need to see some actual evidence of such collusion, please; not just speculation (or arguments on the basis of "unions bad!", more or less)

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Dylan16807 on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:14PM (#13972309)
Who said anything about backroom cahoots? They're openly protesting.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kafkaesq on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:31PM (#13972415)
They're openly protesting.

City agencies don't just cave in to protests at the drop of the hat. Especially not NYC agencies.

So again, what I request is simply: evidence, not speculation.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by notgood on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:48PM (#13972827)
That's the thing about "motives", that you can't never prove or disprove one unless confessed by the "motivator" right?. So the only way to gather "evidence" would be to test the system and see if its actually dangerous or if its all bs.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kafkaesq on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:28PM (#13973807)
That's the thing about "motives", that you can't never prove or disprove one unless confessed by the "motivator" right?

So... ya might as well just believe whichever side of the coin you like better, right?

Works for some people, I guess.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:52PM (#13973903)
(Not sure that's the case here, but) when it all boils down to a he-said, she-said argument, the only thing you have at your disposal in decision-making is your perception of the character of the two parties. So yes, whichever side you like better.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kafkaesq on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:33PM (#13980397)
Not sure that's the case here, but) when it all boils down to a he-said, she-said argument,

You might want to question the validity of that assumption. Most likely the truth (was) basically knowable in this case, with a modicum of effort.

Just that Crain's apparently didn't want to take even baby steps in the direction of that effort -- i.e. the standard proactive, iterative follow-up that, you know, real journalists do: like contacting the entrepreneurial crane operator before publication to get their response to the DOB's claims about the composition of their rigs; and asking the DOB for their response to his response, etc. Or like, you know, talking to an independent expert or two. That kind of thing.

Instead they just did the usual throw-it-at-the-wall, see-if-it-sticks thing -- and presented it as a "he said, she said" story. Which may not have been all that illuminating or informative -- but at least got people to click on it, and (judging by the response here in this forum), to allow their buttons to be pushed.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by hehheh on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:41PM (#13972794)
Ok. What laws do we need to pass and enforce to allow us to collect and share that evidence? Would any such legislation pass?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kafkaesq on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:32PM (#13973824)
Most likely there are already processes in place to get down to the truth on matters like these. Slow-moving processes - but processes, nonetheless. You know - formal appeals, FOIA requests, lawsuits, expert testimony - that sort of thing.

But this all makes for poor ad copy, of course. "Bold, Crafty Innovator Thwarted, 'Cause Unions!" -- that's what gets people to click on your article. And share it in venues such as this one.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:53PM (#13973909)
The problem is that all those things cost money, and the "bold, crafty innovator", after putting $1M of his own money into it, can't afford to pay for all that. The city, and the union, have very deep pockets, and have no incentive to do the right thing and pay for it.

Sometimes Goliath stomps David, and we all lose.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kafkaesq on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:04PM (#13980687)
I'm not saying he has no reason to find fault in either the DOB's initial decision about his new crane, or in Crain's coverage of the issue.

Just that it's kind of weird (in my view) that so many people seem to be happy to conclude that we somehow "know" that it was union arm-twisting which (at least temporarily) sealed his fate. Despite the complete lack of primary (or even secondary) evidence for such a connection.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by tyingq on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:09PM (#13971250)
We're often guilty of the same sort of thing in IT. I've seen IT leaders go on witch-hunts for areas of a business solving their own small issues with Ms Access, FileMaker, etc. Or developers complaining about simple crud apps and their support being outsourced overseas.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by derefr on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:24PM (#13971408)
The Access/Filemaker thing is frequently an "actual" problem at the enterprise level, because in large-enough companies, the concern isn't just "does it get the job done" but also:

• Is the data being backed up? Is that backup process actually correct (i.e. if the backing data-store is a file on a SAN, and we perform filesystem-level snapshots of that SAN, can all the data actually be restored from such a snapshot, or will it be partially corrupt?)

• For that matter, is there a documented process for restoring from such a backup, such that whoever's on the ops shift could do it if need be?

• Is the backing store transparent/auditable, esp. for compliance to our privacy policy—i.e., can we write an indexing agent to determine whether any Personally Identifiable Information is being stored, without needing to ask the software's ISV for their format spec?

• Can the backing store be locked down with ACLs such that getting access to the app's connection to its backing store as an unprivileged user, doesn't let them grab our entire database, or execute arbitrary storage changes (e.g. DROP TABLE)?

• Can audit-trail logic be installed in the backing store (rather than in the app layer by the ISV), so that we will know if some contractor takes a copy of the data home with them?

When your software speaks to a formal DBMS, all these questions have easy answers. When it manages its own little proprietary DB/file-format thing, they're up in the air.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Spooky23 on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:01PM (#13971746)
I've been in enterprise IT for a long time. These issues only exist because the governance/funding model is broken, and IT is incapable of delivering scaled down solutions at a reasonable price.

Then when the access app gets "important", IT uses it as a hostage for more funding, using the absurdly expensive cost model that they build.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ufmace on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:45PM (#13972073)
Well true, but I expect the crane operator guys will say that this crane sounds all super-cool until one of them collapses and kills a dozen people, and then we'd all ask why they aren't subject to the same requirements as the bigger cranes.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by tyingq on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:51PM (#13971653)
I do get what you mean, but I assume a crane operator union has similar worries about this small crane and the potential safety, work rule, etc, issues. :)
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by stcredzero on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:03PM (#13971203)
extract a lot of questionable value from society.

So they've become "extractive" in the parlance of economists and sociologists studying 3rd world economies?

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by JBReefer on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:07PM (#13971233)
Right, or you could say that they were successful rent-seekers.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ryandvm on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:24PM (#13972368)
This is the kind of stuff that makes me chuckle every time someone suggests a software developers union.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by bjourne on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:40PM (#13972789)
Because it would be completely horrible awful if programmers were making $500k/year (convert to your local currency as you see fit) like 'effing crane operators? :)
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:57PM (#13973936)
That might be good for programmers, but is it good for society?
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by bjourne on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:32AM (#13975231)
Yes, absolutely.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Spooky23 on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:54PM (#13971688)
That's a great example of the positive impact of unions on society.

Those waterless urinals are a bullshit green thing used to suck up grant money -- sort of like the "big smelly" trash cans that appeared with Obamas stimulus program. Most often, if not usually, they are removed from service because they get disgusting unless you train your janitorial staff and keep good track of when maintenance is performed.

The pipes are there so when you decide to flush the waterless urinal, you can do so without engaging in some massive project.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by LordKano on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:30PM (#13971472)
I'm not sure which I hate more. Union shenanigans or waterless urinals. They both stink.

There are a few places here that use those urinals and the smell hits me in the face every time I enter the lavatory.

In the case you describe, perhaps the unions are a net positive because their protectionist rule will make it easier to replace those waterless stink pits with actual urinals in the future.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by milesrout on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:27PM (#13971442)
That's an absurd generalisation. One thing like this happens every 20 years and people talk about it forever. But companies do shit like this constantly.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by turc1656 on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:53PM (#13971680)
How is this an absurd generalization? This type of crap happens all the time. And people should absolutely talk about this stuff constantly because this kind of stuff shows the true colors of the union(s) and what they really stand for. And people need to be constantly reminded of that.

All of these unions that center around apprenticeship programs or requiring special training that is near-impossible to get without being part of the union is all just protectionist garbage. Its sole purpose is to control the supply of available labor for certain types of work.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by frgtpsswrdlame on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:02PM (#13971749)
Of course! Unions are a way to balance the scales against corporations. Controlling the supply of labor is very important if you want the wages to be at all decent.

But the parent is right that anything questionable done by unions is labored over and repeated again and again and again and again while corporations (for the most part) don't face the same scrutiny.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by arjie on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:13PM (#13972300)
Of course, and I wonder how equitable this control will be. Will it let the guy with the skill do it or will it be the friend of the union president?

Able-bodied men and women don't have jobs in America and you want a 'decent' wage floor of 150k for the chosen ones. Trade unions, the supposed bulwark of the left. Worker's rights, etc.

I fully expect people to support all this, have the unions endorse the Democrats, and then have discussions at afternoon tea about how everyone else just considers themselves "temporarily embarrassed millionaires" and votes against their own interest.

They want the jobs, man. And rightfully so. And when you stand there with your $150k-wage-floor job and they have to subsist on the dole because you decided to 'control the supply of labour', you shouldn't be surprised when they don't like you.

Unions and union workers are acting exactly as they're expected to under the Stolper-Samuelson Theorem. And everyone else is acting exactly as they are expected to as well. So I'm not surprised they're acting that way, but the Mafia act as expected to, and I'm damned if I'll back either of these.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by linkregister on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:27PM (#13972387)
Who is expecting a $150k wage floor?

Edit: the union mentioned in the article. (I hadn't read it).

It appears you're generalizing this union to represent other unions. It's possible for one union to be exploitative while other ones to have merit. Just as some corporations behave responsibly while a few others blatantly disregard consumers and workers.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by arjie on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:33PM (#13972426)
> The International Union of Operating Engineers Local 14-14B lays out the wage floor for its operators at $73.91 per hour. That’s $150,000 a year before overtime, plus benefits equal to $32.50 an hour. When the operator is behind the controls of a tower crane, he gets a $2-an-hour bump. On weekends, when cranes are moved, pay doubles. With overtime, many union members earn half a million dollars a year.

The union in the article.

EDIT: I also wonder how they get so much overtime. Surely it couldn't be because of 'controlling the supply of labour'. Yeah, that's right. Give them their half a million dollars a year. It's only 'decent'.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ubernostrum on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:27PM (#13978007)
OK, so let's really do this, even though the other commenter got downvoted into oblivion just for daring to check the math.

The claim is they make 75.91/hr when in the crane, 73.91 when not. Let's say they spend 6 hours a day in the crane, 2 hours not in the crane; that's 603.28/day. Five days a week is 3,016.40. 52 weeks a year would be 156,852.80.

So we're at $156,852.80/year from 8-hour days of work. We need to somehow get to "half a million". By which I mean we need to come up with $343,147.20 in overtime. The quote doesn't say what the overtime rate is, but traditionally it's time and a half; At a behind-the-crane rate of $75.91, overtime would be $113.86/hour. The engineer would then need to work "only" 3,013 hours of overtime a year in order to hit that "half a million" target. Or 2,135 hours of overtime a year in order to hit the $400k another commenter suggests below.

There are 8,760 total hours in a (non-leap) year and we've already used 2,080 of them accounting for 8-hour weekday shifts. So our engineer has 6,680 hours in the year left in which to work either 3,013 or 2,135 hours of overtime so we can bash him for making too much money. If he works an 8-hour shift every Saturday and every Sunday at the overtime rate, that only gets us 832 hours of overtime. We still need to find between 1,303 and 2,181 additional hours of overtime. That's an additional 3.5 - 6 hours per day every day for the year.

So... "many union members earn half a million dollars a year". To get to that number, at the quoted wages, they would have to be working 14-hour shifts every day. Not "every week day with two week's vacation". 14 hours every day: 7 days a week, 365 days a year. To get to the $400,000 estimate the comment below thinks is reasonable, they'd only need to work 11.5 hours a day all 365 days of the year. And that's probably a low estimate: I got that number by assuming the engineer spends 6 hours of every working weekday 8-hour shift behind the crane at the higher rate, and 100% of overtime hours behind the crane at the higher rate. If he's spending any more than 2 hours per weekday not behind the crane he needs to work even more hours since he's paid a lower rate then.

I hope nobody actually believes that these guys are genuinely working 11-14 hours a day, 365 days a year, or that if they are it would be wrong to massively compensate them for it.

Of course, someone will point out that I didn't account for the $32.50/hour in "benefits". But how can I? What does that mean? How many jobs have you had where you said "oh, my rate is low but I also count an hourly benefit amount as part of my wages"? Do you genuinely, truly, honestly and actively make sure you include the cost of any employer matching on your health insurance or 401(k) as dollar value and lump it into your salary? I know I don't.

But let's run with it anyway. Let's suppose the engineer gets 100% of his health plan covered by these "benefits", and what's more let's go high on it and assume that his health plan costs $5,000/month. If we only have him work 8-hour shifts 7 days a week we still need to make up a lot of money out of overtime or non-health-plan benefits:

weekday wage = (75.91 * 6) + (73.91 * 2) = 603.28

weekend wage = (75.91 * 1.5) * 16 (hours in two 8-hour shifts) = 1,821.84

Full week = 5 * weekday + weekend = 4,838.24

Full year of 8-hour shifts 7 days a week = 52 * 4,838.24 = 251,588.48

Add in $60,000 worth of health insurance = $311,588.48

To hit the "half a million" we still need to find nearly another $200,000. Specifically, we still need to find him 1,655 hours of overtime at this point. That's 4.5 hours a day in a 365-day year, so we're at 12.5-hour shifts, 365 days a year, to hit $500,000 in compensation.

A 401(k) doesn't help since his max contribution to that is $18,000/year, which is peanuts compared to the gap we need to make up to get him to $500,000.

But at this point I think we can safely say that something is very fishy with what you've quoted. And to reference my other comment, the reason this engineer isn't hanging out with other millionaires is that he can't because he spends 12.5 hours a day, all 365 days of the year, at work in order to get to that "half a million" wage you're attributing to him.

(except of course you know that the crane operators aren't really doing that, but that would sink the whole story...)

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by arjie on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:58PM (#13978307)
Why you'd go to the effort of doing all these estimates and just make up nonsensical multipliers is beyond me. Off-shift work is a little over 1.5x (this is non-overtime work that's not between 8 and 5), overtime is 2x. Weekend is 2x. Every overtime hour gets you a D stamp that is not insignificant in value.

All that information is public. I'm a little suspicious of a $500k crane engineer myself, but you managed to get everything wrong. If you missed half the stuff, and the half that was available in the article and in a two-minute Google, god knows what you're leaving out. I literally had the top result in my first search showing the wage card and here you're busy making up nonsensical numbers.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ubernostrum on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:57PM (#13978921)
OK, so let's run the numbers for overtime as double time.

An 8-hour weekday shift with 2 hours not behind the crane is:

(75.91 * 6) + (73.91 * 2) = 603.28

A five-day week at that rate is 3,016.40.

52 weeks of that is $156,852.80. Add $60k insurance (and it's questionable to bundle that as "pay", but whatever), and we're at $218,652.80. Add $18k for max 401(k) contribution and it's $234,852.80.

From there we need to find $265,147.20 in overtime to get to $500k. If the overtime rate is double time, and if literally every overtime hour worked is behind the crane, our engineer needs 1,747 hours of overtime in a year in order to hit $500,000.

Working at 8-hour shift every weekend day can eat up 832 hours of that, leaving 915 hours we still need to find somewhere else. That's 17.6 hours of overtime per week. If they're only worked on weekdays, the crane operator needs to work an 11.5 hour shift every weekday and an 8 hour shift every Saturday and Sunday, year-round, to hit $500,000.

I'm more than "a little suspicious" of that.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by arjie on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @03:22PM (#13979774)
I don't think you're measuring this accurately. You keep leaving out too much. Fortunately, since $235k is far above the threshold to make my point, I'm not going to press it.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ubernostrum on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:28PM (#13980358)
It's only $235k if you estimate health insurance at $60k + a maxed-out 401(k) contribution and add both of them to the dollar amount of what the engineer makes in wages.

Without, if they work 52 40-hour weeks, it's $156k. Which is good money, but a far, far cry from the "many make half a million" claim.

And since a little bit of "let's actually run the numbers you just presented" reduced the initially claimed amount by nearly 70%, I think it's perfectly reasonable to say the initial claim was not rooted in reality, and probably the real amount is lower yet.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Bendingo on Monday March 27, 2017 @10:03PM (#13973458)
Assuming hourly rate of: 73.91 (wage floor) + 32.50 (benefits) + 2 (bump) = 108.41 And a 40 hour standard week: 108.41 x 40 = 4336 (weekly rate), 4336 x 52 = 225492 (yearly rate) Assuming double weekend rate, for 8 hours on both sat/sun: 108.41 x 2 = 218.82 (weekend hourly rate), 218,41 x 8 x 2 = 3469.1 (weekend rate, 3469 x 52 = 180394 (yearly rate)

Therefore working 8 hours a day, for every day of the week (including weekends), for one year would earn: 225492 + 180394 = 405886

This is very big money but it's not 'half a million dollars'.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:00AM (#13973957)
80% of half a million is close enough, perhaps.

But, if not, the sentence still works with "give them their $400k a year".

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by ubernostrum on Monday March 27, 2017 @09:21PM (#13973205)
So where are all the engineers who work for a handful of years and then retire as millionaires? Where are all the crane operators rubbing elbows with their fellows at Davos?

I'll give you a hint: someone may trying to mislead you and inflame prejudices which have been carefully drilled into you over many years of media exposure.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by turc1656 on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:19PM (#13971863)
I agree corporations get off far too easy. And that is the fault of the government in many cases for not prosecuting them or letting them off with fines far below the profits of illegal activity.

"Controlling the supply of labor is very important if you want the wages to be at all decent." - I interpret that sentence very differently. I see it as controlling the labor supply is a great way to prevent the flow of labor that may be just as good and willing to work for less from entering the job market for this activity. It's also a great way to force higher prices upon your customers because no matter which provider/firm they go to they are likely to all have members of the union working there forcing the same wages.

This behavior at its core it anti-competitive. If they were in fact corporations this activity would be a felony. But as employees it is not. Just a thought.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by Retra on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:01PM (#13972225)
If a company couldn't "collectively bargain", it wouldn't even exist. Companies are not collections of individuals bargaining for themselves.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by mjn on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:50PM (#13972128)
The basic idea of collective bargaining isn't really illegal when applied to a employers in general, because it's already the norm on that side of the table. A group of businesspeople with mutual economic interest can legally "collude" when they decide what wages to offer employees, how to structure working conditions, how to carry out negotiations, etc., if they agree to form a legal partnership (you don't even need the newer legal fiction of unitary corporate personhood, just a classic partnership structure). Then colluding in business matters is not only legal, but expected. Why can't employees of such a partnership likewise "collude" when bargaining over wages and working conditions, forming into a single joined legal entity that sits opposite the joined legal entity of businesspeople on the other side of the table? It seems much more asymmetrical to say that the group of businesspeople can legally form a partnership to coordinate their economic activities for mutual gain, but the employees must each bargain individually and cannot form a, let's call it "workers' partnership", or union of workers, to likewise coordinate their economic activities for mutual gain.

One thing I find interesting: Will we will see some version of the odd asymmetries between corporate and union law tested out in the courts as the gig economy grows? A company providing labor, for example, can legally ask for exclusivity agreements. Aramark, a big catering contractor, does that frequently. A union can't, though; an exclusivity deal for employees, saying that catering staff can only be hired from a certain union, is banned as a "closed shop" under the Taft-Hartley act. What about a partnership of gig-economy workers? If they're not employees, it seems like they should be able to push for deals more like Aramark ones, even though unions can't do that.

Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by kelnos on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:06AM (#13973981)
The problem isn't "collusion" over wages for the union members. The problem is that the union is a gatekeeper for training for or holding that type of job, period. In this particular case, the law requires (for licensing) that prospective crane operators be apprenticed to a licensed operator before they're eligible for their own license. When all the licensed operators are union members, only union members can get licenses. That allows the union to get around the "closed shop" bits of Taft-Hartley, and allows them to restrict the supply of crane operators to their gain.
Re:Why is this little construction crane illegal in New York... by milesrout on Thursday March 30, 2017 @04:52AM (#13993858)
Well that has absolutely nothing to do with unions. That is the Government mandating that people be trained by particular people. That's a Government-imposed rule.

I personally think that laws banning closed shops are completely absurd and undermine peoples' freedom to negotiate contracts that suit them (which labour should have free access to, because of the massive unfairness of employment as a concept, and its inherent inequity between employer and employee).

But they have, and pretending that it's not their own fault for then turning around and effectively mandating a closed shop is absurd.