See, before opioid prohibition, deaths from opioid use were quite rare. You ever heard a pothead drone on about "it's nearly impossible to overdose from smoking marijuana"? The same thing applies to smoking opium. It's nearly impossible to overdose on that. But prohibition (which optimises for potency/volume, in order to reduce the risks of ending up in a concrete box) has pushed us from opium smoking and oral laudanum to injectable heroin to fentanyl and now (in the late 2010s) we're at fucking carfentanil (which is so potent it's been used as a chemical weapon).
This is the "iron law of prohibition" at work: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_law_of_prohibition
The current USian "opioid crisis" is another manifestation of opioid prohibition pushing people from safer, cheaper, less disruptive and deadly drugs to more deadlier ones. Two decades ago some USian opioid users could go to pill mills and get prescriptions for pharmaceutical grade opioids but the DEA kicked down doctor's doors a bunch and that ended up pushing people to the illicit market. Maybe next time you see those scary increasing graphs of opioid deaths vs time, give that a thought? Sum up all those deaths (compared to the baseline, prior to the increased LEA focus on "pill mills) and ask yourself: are all those needless deaths worth it?
The DEA cracking skulls over opioids and investigating doctors is literally the only reason illicit fentanyl (and fent analogues) even is a thing. I am so very doubtful that skull-cracking and door-kicking will miraculously work after decades of it not working. The only way out of this hell is a total unconditional surrender in this "war on drugs".
I'm not an expert. Can you please link to studies to verify this?
We're talking about overdosing and I don't think marijuana falls into that category.
Can you imagine a THC analog that's 10^4 times more potent? Is overdose really impossible? I suspect that we'll find out, in a few years :(
Ironically, the obverse task -- trying to create a molecule that acts on similar neurobiological targets as an illegal drug but doesnt get people high or look like a molecule from an illegal drug -- is similarly fraught. A flagrant example is BIA 10-2474, an experimental drug meant to target the endocannabinoid system in a roundabout way -- not by directly activating receptors, but by inhibiting an enzyme that degrades endogenous chemicals that activate endocannabinoid receptors -- which would have similar effects as directly activating those receptors. A trial of it killed one person and irreversibly neurologically damaged a few others.
We criminalise drugs at deep costs to research and medecine (I haven't even gotten into the use of MDMA in psychotherapy or ketamine for depression), and regardless on what side of the law they work on, it is a very difficult task for chemists to try to imitate drugs that have been with humanity for millenia when they aren't allowed to make molecules that look like blacklisted ones.
Now, if it was legal people wouldn't have to resort getting that crap as a replacement.
I mentioned the (commonly known) lack of marijuana overdoses to analogise it with the (lesser known) utter rarity of overdoses with smoked opium: low potency mixed with a route of administration that acts as a dead man's switch (if you nod out, you'll likely drop the opium pipe) makes for safe drug use.
Religion? Well, addiction is perceived rather like possession by the Devil. Or at least, weakness. Lack of faith. Really, as Bill basically said, those dirty addicts deserve to die.
It's just that Purdue Pharma managed to addict lots of people by rewarding doctors to over-prescribe, and flooding distribution chains in the southeastern US. Maybe economic collapse is part of the problem. But there's a good chance that things will be manageable after the Purdue mess has been handled.
Edit: In a dead comment, revmoo mentioned kratom, a natural opiate analog. The DEA decided last year not to ban it, after massive public comment. Advocates claim that it helps addicts break their addictions.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/oct/14/kratom-dea-b...
The root of the problem is doctor prescribed opiates.[2] Prescription pain killers that were marketed as non-addictive turned out to be highly addictive. These are still widely prescribed. For example, oxycontin had revenues of over $2 Billion in 2013.[3]
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opioid_overdose
This is an extremely simplistic view that elides...most of what is going on, such as:
1) How poisoning/overdose deaths are reported by medical examiners -- something that varies a lot by region and over time
2) The increased introduction of fentanyl (and fent analogues) into the heroin supply
3) It doesn't factor crackdowns on pill mills and crackdowns (both from DEA and also self-directed) on opioids prescribing in general
Opioid use is not inherently dangerous. Indeed, long-term use of pharmaceutical-grade opioids is remarkably safe (especially compared to other painkillers or other drugs such as alcohol) -- opioids don't tend to cause organ damage.
There are several actual circumstances where opioid use gets dangerous to life and they are:
1) Dosage/concentration uncertainty
2) Contamination of a lower strength opioid (say, morphine or heroin) with a much higher strength one (fentanyl or fentanyl analogues)
3) Poly-drug use: combining opioids with benzos or alcohol to exploit synergistic effects
When it comes to pharmaceutical-grade opioids, the doses are known and measured and there's no risk of contamination with unknown amounts of fentanyl analogues. Indeed, the mechanisms of drug prohibition actually incentivize the use of extremely high potency/volume opioids such as fentanyl.
The third issue, poly-drug use, also is a consequence of prohibition -- the prices of opioids in the black market are artificially inflated (if you don't have the requisite permission slip for the drugs, you need to invest in all sorts of countermeasures to avoid being put in a cage and your product seized), so users need to economize, and this sadly happens by combining benzos with opioids, which can lead to fatal respiratory depression. This is also a symptom of prohibition and is not inherent to opioid use. Indeed, an overwhelming majority of so-called "opioid overdoses" involve other drugs (and most often it's either alcohol or a benzodiazepine).
The DEA (and other flavours of doorkickers) targeting doctors and deputising them as law-enforcement agents who have to decide between the evil undeserving addicts and the deserving patients in pain is what has created this affair.
Blame the prohibitionists, as this is a problem of their own making -- the crackdowns on "pill mills" and "overprescribing doctors" is what denies people a safe and legal source of pharmaceutical-grade opioids and forces them onto the black market of illegal, overpriced, and fentanyl-contaminated opioids (which leads, of course, to the deaths that are used to justify even more crackdowns).
I am not an expert but the overdose problem is not just about purity/concentration. Even ibuprofen has nasty effects over the long term.
"Overdose deaths involving prescription opioids have quadrupled since 1999,1,2 and so have sales of these prescription drugs.3 From 1999 to 2015, more than 183,000 people have died in the U.S. from overdoses related to prescription opioids.[1]
And it isn't like there aren't other models we can learn from. Portugal springs to mind.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/06/05/why-h...
There's a lot of interesting detail to be learned from studying their system, but the tl;dr is that after decriminalization, deaths in Portugal due to overdose plummeted.
Rehabilitate at least enough users that you can darn well ask them what's driving this. They know; it's their lives. Ask people, and then find ways to address the problems in their lives that they point out.
Stop treating this as alien! It's all around us, every day, every city, every year. We have no right to ignore this kind of mass suffering as if we can do nothing!
You may be conflating the medical consequences of addiction with the decision to start using.
Are you claiming that tens of millions of people got a pop-up box asking them, "Are you sure you want to abandon your children, alienate your family, and ruin your life? This operation is irreversible!"? Remember, one of the major ways in which the opioid epidemic has spread was medical doctors, of all people, prescribing heavy opioids for pain management.
How do you think these things happen?
How do you think the other cases should be judged, though? Say the case of someone who starts using heroin as an adult, without first being prescribed opioids.
Would you not treat that as a moral failure on his or her part?
There is usually very little to the "choice" that addicts once made. My girlfriend was injected with meth amphetamine when she was 11 (by an "angry" 14 year old). That experience solidly messed up her brain chemistry, and no one knew how to help her.
Her doctor used Depot Provera to chemically castrate her at around age 19-20. This likely made her suicidal, as is frequently the case [1].
Should my girlfriend be punished for her doctors inability to help her?
[1] http://www.sciencefriday.com/segments/looking-beyond-condoms... - caller at 8min30sec was similarly made "manic and suicidal" with Depot Provera.
She overdosed on me a year ago, likely because of the benzodiazepines that the mental hospital got her hooked on (she thought heroin would get her through benzo withdrawal, but really each amplifies the other's effect). I called 911, they did their job, and the police decided they didn't need to make the situation worse.
Here's the link to my comment from 13 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13846763
In case I wasn't clear about it, I think that the production, distribution and consumption of drugs should be legal. Not only is it none of anyone else's business, there's solid evidence that legalisation helps efforts to minimise harm.
But in the case of people who make an informed, consensual decision to take drugs (and again, to be clear, it sounds like neither was the case for your girlfriend) there is clearly a moral dimension to the decision.
Perhaps you're confusing with my claim that choosing to use drugs has a moral element, with some sort of moral censure on my part?
I'm with Scott Adams on this: you should be free to kill yourself at any rate of your own choosing, provided your cold dead body isn't blocking my driveway in the morning.
People should be perfectly free to act immorally, provided they're not violating the rights of others.
Here's an article by a psychiatrist about the way Suboxone is regulated now: https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/02/02/practically-a-book-rev...
Some questions come to mind:
- Is it the role of the government to keep people safe from themselves? If so, how?
- Would harsher drug laws make things better or worse?
- How big of a role does purported economic opportunity have to do with drug abuse? My theory used to be that structural unemployment was the root of this epidemic; those born into the quickly receding middle class---those who relied on low-knowledge/low-skill jobs for a modest living---are hit the hardest since they did not anticipate such a shortage of low-skill jobs.
- What does religion have to do with this?
- What does culture have to do with this?
- Are members of the military more or less affected by opiod drug abuse?
- Does providing safe places to take drugs alleviate the problem, or does it make it worse?