News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by amelius on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:27PM (#13936040)
People have been recording the things they watch since the invention of the VCR.

DRM will not have any impact on that. Someone will come along, and make a video-grabbing utility that bypasses the DRM. Also, many of the content is already available via bittorrent.

DRM is pointless. But perhaps you are right about "browser vendors refusing to cooperate" not being the best possible approach. However, do you know what is?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by derekp7 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:47PM (#13936558)
We somehow got away from DRM on audio. I was wondering how to do this for video too. What worked for audio, was that you had one vendor (Apple) that had a large enough market share. In order to sell DRMd media that worked on Ipods, the media companies had to sell through Apple. Or they could sell non-DRMd files that would still work on Ipods. They did the calculation, and figured they would make more money going non-DRM so they can pick other distributors such as Amazon.

For video, people don't download it and take it with them (typically), they either play from their computer or from a set top box or smart TV. So there is no market forces that would give the movie studios any incentive to do non-DRM.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by eugeniub on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:53PM (#13936853)
> We somehow got away from DRM on audio.

Did we? Look at Apple Music, Spotify, and other subscription music services. They all have DRM.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by drdrey on Thursday March 23, 2017 @12:28AM (#13937375)
But music you buy on iTunes is DRM-free. That's a significant step away from DRM.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by josteink on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:35AM (#13937783)
> But music you buy on iTunes is DRM-free. That's a significant step away from DRM.

And Amazon. And Google Play music. And band-camp. Etc etc.

In fact, I don't know a single place on the entire internet which still sells DRMed music. Such a thing simply ceased to exist.

Imagine if we could make the same happen for video. That would be real nice.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Twisell on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:01AM (#13938043)
Yes but in Netflix case and html5 we are precisely talking about streaming service.

Download should be DRM free for free for vidéo that's true but don't blame Netflix for using DRM on a streaming service as every music streaming service does that too.

Indeed I think studios could reduce pirating to baseline (people who can't afford anyway) in a split second should they understand that people are willing to pay for a fair priced streaming service like Netflix. They just need to open up their catalogs like music majors finally did as an average wallet can hardly sustain a dozen different subscriptions in order to have a decent movie catalog.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by sneak on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:58AM (#13938239)
Nobody normal buys music and shuffles files around anymore.

They all just switched to DRMed streaming services.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by josteink on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:23AM (#13938580)
I think the entire Plex userbase would disagree. There's also a reason Google Play Music lets you upload your own music: Not all music can be found in "regular" streaming catalogs.

Technicalities aside: Also I like to think that buying albums (even if I stream them later on) makes the artist more money. And I want to support the artists I appreciate as much as I can.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by sneak on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:37AM (#13938632)
I meant "normal" as in mass-market, not "normal for HN". I, probably like you, of course have a unix fileserver in my residence (as well as a metric ass-ton of vinyl, because it seems we are similar types of nerd).
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by thirdsun on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:32AM (#13937941)
How else would a subscription service work? If you bought your music instead of renting it you'd truly own it without DRM or any other strings attached.

As a very frequent music buyer, I'd say the situation is very comfortable and user-friendly and I'd wish to see the same for video content.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by xg15 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:59PM (#13936601)
> What worked for audio, was that you had one vendor (Apple) that had a large enough market share. In order to sell DRMd media that worked on Ipods, the media companies had to sell through Apple. Or they could sell non-DRMd files that would still work on Ipods.

Ironically, this scenario just got more unlikely, thanks to EME now being a standard and thus available for everyone... Hooray for web standards!

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:03PM (#13936617)
We somehow got away from DRM on audio.

We got away from it with audio in part because a typical audio product such as a music single or short audiobook can viably be produced and sold DRM-free at a price so low that it's hardly worth anyone looking for it elsewhere even if they could find it literally for free. Unfortunately, the same economics don't work in most other markets.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by MBCook on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:34PM (#13937009)
> We somehow got away from DRM on audio.

Guess which industry watched how that happened REALLY REALLY closely?

The music industry was falling apart by the time they gave up on DRM, the video industry is still very strong and had time to learn where all the mistakes were made that lead to DRM free content.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by ubernostrum on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:50AM (#13937826)
The end of DRM for purchased music downloads was primarily driven by the need to break what the record industry perceived as a monopoly.

They got in bed with Apple, and at first they were happy with that -- Apple showed that offering a legal way to download music would succeed, so long as it was A) convenient, B) had a suitably large catalog and C) was priced in a way customers saw as fair.

And the result was Apple became a major player in the market, to the point that the record labels started getting scared of what Apple could now force them to do. So they needed to give Apple a competitor. Except... Apple wasn't about to license its Apple-specific DRM scheme to that competitor, and wasn't going to install the competitor's DRM scheme on Apple devices. Which left them with no way to introduce a serious competitor other than to go DRM-free so purchased music would be playable on all the popular devices, including Apple's. Thus, Amazon got to start selling DRM-free music (and eventually Apple got to sell it too).

I suspect sooner or later the book industry will have to go DRM-free to break Amazon's ebook stranglehold, in much the same way.

But video... is different. There isn't a monopolish player in the online video market. There are multiple competing services, some doing purchase and some doing temporary rental and some doing streaming and some doing combinations of multiple options, and there's nobody emerging with power to dictate to movie/TV studios the way Apple emerged in music or Amazon did in ebooks. Which suggests DRM on video is going to be with us for a while no matter what.

And video is one area where I have some sympathy for attempts to control access: the video market is quite young compared to music or books, and has had the short-term rental as a key segment of its market for roughly as long as it's existed. And this makes some sense, as video content tends to have less long-term re-use value: listening to a song multiple times, and re-reading a book multiple times, both seem to be much more common than watching a movie multiple times. So providing a reduced-price option which limits the number of times or amount of time of watching makes business sense. I'm unsure how to reconcile that with hardcore anti-DRM positions, since some type of access control is necessary to enable a rental market.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by MBCook on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:52PM (#13943572)
> I suspect sooner or later the book industry will have to go DRM-free to break Amazon's ebook stranglehold, in much the same way.

I wonder about this, because the fact is that I really LIKE Amazon's system. It doesn't matter where music comes from, I listen to it over and over and usually listen to each song totally.

But with books, it takes more than 3 minutes to read. The fact that all my stuff (Kindle App, Kindle, website) know my place and sync all that stuff is very handy. It's the main reason I use Kindle over physical books.

If you load non-DRMed eBooks onto Kindle my understanding is you don't get that functionality for them and I'm guessing no one would have the power to force Amazon to implement that feature. The end result is that Amazon's DRMed books may be more appealing to me than DRM free options from other places.

As for breaking their monopoly.... Apple tried and the government smacked them down for it.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by jMyles on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:57PM (#13937107)
> For video, people don't download it and take it with them (typically)

...which is crazy, especially for HD video. Why use the bandwidth every time you want to watch something when storage is so much cheaper?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by cstrahan on Thursday March 23, 2017 @12:55AM (#13937475)
That's assuming people are going watch things multiple times. Most people, including myself, are one and done.

I've always rented the movies I've watched because I know I won't watch them again, so the savings is win on the whole.

I guess there's something to be said for TV shows, as people often watch those over. I generally don't watch TV series, the exception being a couple Netflix series that friends have begged me to watch, so I don't have too much of an opinion there.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by jon-wood on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:28AM (#13938350)
I think this could be rephrased as people don't consciously download things to keep forever. Whatever device you're watching on will cache anything you've viewed for a while so it doesn't need downloading again, and I at least make quite heavy use of the ability to save things for offline viewing on train journeys.

What I don't do anymore is to download video or music and then just keep it around on a hard disk just in case I want to watch it again. At least in my case storage is actually far more expensive than bandwidth, both in monetary value and time spent maintaining things.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Sharlin on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:41AM (#13938651)
Bandwidth is practically free at least where I'm living in. Storage is something I need to think about and go buy separately.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by kriro on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:39AM (#13937970)
I'd say this is false. I'd love to watch more videos when I commute. My Pay TV provider even offers a download option for their streaming sub service(DRMed and self destructing after X days I think, never tried it) which would indicate that there's certainly market demand for it.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by hsivonen on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:24AM (#13938591)
Download as in "cache this title within this app for viewing in an environment where Internet connectivity doesn't work well yet" is very different from download as in "here's an .mp4/.webm file for you to hold onto for ever--have fun taking backups and figuring out which third party player can handle the subtitles.

Fun story: Not very long ago, I bought a copy of a documentary using the latter model.

Another person with whom I was going to watch the documentary had visited their site and seen what movie services it was on. I trusted that info at first without checking the documentary's own site. I got very annoyed about the movie services having the title geoblocked in my country (even when a movie service had presence here and in a neighboring country and the rights for both countries are typically sold as a bundle and the neighboring country had it available!).

Then I looked at the site of the documentary myself. And indeed, for the price of the Blu-Ray version, I could buy a full-HD .mp4 without DRM to download.

So I paid and downloaded the .mp4 plus .mp4s for all the Blu-Ray extras. And I downloaded a .srt file for the subtitles.

The Linux box I had connected to my TV couldn't do full HD well in software but could via VAAPI. However, the player that supported VAAPI was supposed to support .srt but didn't actually support at least this .srt file.

In the end, we watched it by pluggin in a more performant Windows laptop doing the whole thing in software.

Conclusion: This is what we always said we wanted. However, when it was there, I didn't expect it to be there and assumed I had to find the title on one of the big-name services instead of navigating to the documentary's own site. The UX of getting stuff to work was less smooth than with the locked-down streaming services.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Arnt on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:07AM (#13938263)
Some people want to download, they're a smallish minority. You can think about some reasons if you want, but but do the reasons really matter?
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by nsomaru on Thursday March 23, 2017 @12:51AM (#13937464)
Guessing that it's probably more rare to watch something again than it is to watch something new.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by toomanybeersies on Thursday March 23, 2017 @09:15PM (#13945777)
People usually watch video once, but listen to songs multiple times.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by canibal on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:04AM (#13939012)
>For video, people don't download it and take it with them

If this is so, why would Netflix have JUST added the download feature last quarter? Obviously there's some demand for storage-based playback.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by cletus on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:45AM (#13938198)
You can thank Steve Jobs for that.

When digital music downloads started record companies demanded DRM. They agreed to a model with iTunes of $0.99 per song. They chafed against this model and wanted pricing tiers. Jobs was willing to give them this but the price was to go DRM free.

Jobs could get away with this for two reasons. First, he was Steve Jobs. Second, the record industry had unwittingly created a virtual music download monopoly in iTunes.

I personally use Spotify because streaming is incredibly convenient and there isn't much you can buy but can't stream. I use Netflix and Ahbo Now for the same reason.

I'd never "buy" DRMed content so music would be fine. Video not so much. I personally don't have as much of an issue with DRM on streaming content.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dchest on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:27AM (#13938344)
Contrary opinion from a former Apple employee:

"The music industry didn't go DRM free because they hated DRM; they went DRM free because they were fearful of the leverage Apple was gaining with their iTunes + FairPlay + iPod combination. Apple’s DRM created this lock, and it became so successful that the music industry went with the lesser of two evils (songs locked to Apple’s iPod monopoly vs. the distribution of DRM-free music) and chose to distribute DRM-free music...

http://fortune.com/2014/12/14/re-thinking-steve-jobs-thought...

You say "Jobs was willing to give them this but the price was to go DRM free", but why would he do that if DRM was good for Apple, it's what locked this market to iPods? Doesn't make sense to me. The music industry had to go DRM free (with Amazon, for example) because that was the only alternative way to sell music that would play on iPods.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by lloeki on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:27AM (#13938604)
> You say "Jobs was willing to give them this but the price was to go DRM free", but why would he do that if DRM was good for Apple, it's what locked this market to iPods?

Here goes a ~10yo tidbit from SJ [0]. Whether you take it at face value, see it as a PR trick, or anything in between is up to you.

> Apple was able to negotiate landmark usage rights at the time, which include allowing users to play their DRM protected music on up to 5 computers and on an unlimited number of iPods. Obtaining such rights from the music companies was unprecedented at the time, and even today is unmatched by most other digital music services. However, a key provision of our agreements with the music companies is that if our DRM system is compromised and their music becomes playable on unauthorized devices, we have only a small number of weeks to fix the problem or they can withdraw their entire music catalog from our iTunes store.

> [...] only 22 out of 1000 songs, or under 3% of the music on the average iPod, is purchased from the iTunes store and protected with a DRM. The remaining 97% of the music is unprotected and playable on any player that can play the open formats. It’s hard to believe that just 3% of the music on the average iPod is enough to lock users into buying only iPods in the future. And since 97% of the music on the average iPod was not purchased from the iTunes store, iPod users are clearly not locked into the iTunes store to acquire their music.

> The third alternative is to abolish DRMs entirely. Imagine a world where every online store sells DRM-free music encoded in open licensable formats. In such a world, any player can play music purchased from any store, and any store can sell music which is playable on all players. This is clearly the best alternative for consumers, and Apple would embrace it in a heartbeat.

> Why would the big four music companies agree to let Apple and others distribute their music without using DRM systems to protect it? The simplest answer is because DRMs haven’t worked, and may never work, to halt music piracy. Though the big four music companies require that all their music sold online be protected with DRMs, these same music companies continue to sell billions of CDs a year which contain completely unprotected music.

[0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20080107121341/http://www.apple....

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by amelius on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:29AM (#13938609)
> ... the record industry had unwittingly created a virtual music download monopoly in iTunes.

I really wonder how they could have been so stupid.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:51PM (#13936847)
Aren't music publishers a lot less consolidated than there movie/TV counterparts?
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by yeukhon on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:12PM (#13936925)
Kinda of, but most labels find the big three for both production and distribution. There is independent distribution company within each of the big three to attract independent labels. Most labels come to the big three simply because they have the infrastructure in place for global distriubtion from marketing to production to music distriubtion to all the major DSP (digital service providers) such as Apple and Spotify, as well as ringtone. One interesting thing about music deal is that while the big three have the infrastructure and capability, for example WMG can sign a deal with Sony in terrority Y (a country or multiple countries) for the release of X there and they split the royality, and vice versa.

I said kinda of because not all sign with big three and further more there are so many independent artists out there releasing to YouTube or Apple iTune or Soundcloud on their own).

(Disclaimer: work in a music company)

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by dasil003 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:53PM (#13936576)
A lot of geeks are under the misapprehension that the studios don't know this. But actually they are not idiots, they are fully aware of the sisyphean nature and ultimate futility of DRM.

The point of enforcing DRM is not to prevent piracy, but rather to flex their market clout and demonstrate control. As long as they put up moderate barriers to ripping, and as long as they have legal sanction to suppress productized piracy, the steady stream of new must-have content allows them to throw their weight around. Licensing streaming without DRM is a slippery slope that decreases the perceived value of their content. Small distributors will do it because they need to make whatever money they can, big distributors will never do it because it damages their brand.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by matt_kantor on Friday March 24, 2017 @04:54PM (#13952141)
Spot on. Ian Hickson explained this very well a few years ago[0].

[0]: https://plus.google.com/+IanHickson/posts/iPmatxBYuj2

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by grinich on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:37PM (#13936125)
This is like saying door locks are pointless because you can break a window and climb through.

Protecting media copyright isn't a black or white thing like crypto. It's about compromises to drive behavior and consumer spending with convenience.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by amelius on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:09PM (#13936348)
What exactly do you think this DRM will stop?

1. People who have access to the content can usually see it over and over again (when they have a subscription to a service like Netflix). DRM will do nothing here.

2. People who don't have access to the content can't even see the DRM'ed version of the file, so DRM will do nothing here either.

3. People who want to pirate (illegally distribute) the content have advanced tools and knowledge to circumvent DRM, so DRM is of no use here again.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by recursive on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:25PM (#13936438)
Whether you have access to content isn't an immutable fact of your genetics. People can freely move between groups 1 and 2. That's the whole point.

For instance, I didn't have access to netflix content, and then I signed up for a netflix account and paid them money, and now I do have access.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by unicornporn on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:53AM (#13938011)
> Whether you have access to content isn't an immutable fact of your genetics. People can freely move between groups 1 and 2. That's the whole point.

So you're saying people could move to another jurisdiction to be able to watch their favorite show on Netflix? Yeah, that truly sounds like freedom to me. Or am I misinterpretating you?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by recursive on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:33PM (#13944553)
You're misinterpretating me. Some people already live in jurisdictions to which Netflix permits distribution of their favorite show. Those people can decide to pay for access or not.

It's also true that some people don't live in such places. But that doesn't matter. You said that DRM serves no purpose. For some it may not. But for some people it does.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by pferde on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:08AM (#13938267)
Yes, you are misrepresentating(sic!) him. The "move between groups 1 and 2" was meant as decision to start paying for a service, or to stop paying for a service, not a physical move. In other words, voting with your wallet.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:51PM (#13936571)
1. People who have access to the content can usually see it over and over again (when they have a subscription to a service like Netflix). DRM will do nothing here.

Sure it will. It will stop people writing a script to download as much as they can get away with in a single month and then cancelling since they have enough content to keep them going for several more months without paying for them.

3. People who want to pirate (illegally distribute) the content have advanced tools and knowledge to circumvent DRM, so DRM is of no use here again.

That is a big assumption, and in many cases not a correct one. The major online DRM systems today are fairly robust, and if anyone has a crack for some of them, they're keeping their cards very close to their chests. The leaks of major movies that you find on torrent sites and the like are usually from other sources.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by amelius on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:20PM (#13936713)
> Sure it will. It will stop people writing a script to download as much as they can

But the people who go through the trouble of that are exactly the people who wouldn't mind downloading pirated copies in the first place.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:30PM (#13936755)
If you're supplying digital content as a business, then usually that isn't your real problem. They weren't going to give you any more money anyway, and with the legal framework being as it is in most places today, it's frustrating to see your content ripped off but not actually worth doing much about it. Meanwhile, your real problem is probably people who will casually copy and share your content, because even if the multiplication is relatively small, those are potentially still reaching people who would otherwise pay for a legitimate copy.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by schrodinger on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:04PM (#13936621)
There's always the analog loophole. If you can watch it on your screen, you can record it.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:19PM (#13936702)
Of course, but typically quality suffers significantly, so what you get isn't as good as the original and that in itself is a deterrent for a lot of people.

Also, some modern watermarking techniques can survive conversions like this, so if anyone is making a habit of recording content from a service using watermarking and redistributing it on a scale that justifies taking serious action, it'll be pretty easy to prove who it was when the lawsuit comes up.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by amelius on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:51PM (#13937085)
> it'll be pretty easy to prove who it was when the lawsuit comes up

Perhaps. But this person can always claim that it was done by an external hacker. In fact, it can be done by an "external" hacker, and it will be if these guys are smart.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @11:43PM (#13937257)
I'm sure that's an appealing argument if you don't like DRM, but the reality is that someone who ripped content marked to their personal account, which server logs show did access the content in question from their usual IP address etc., is going to have a tough time convincing any court on the balance of probabilities that some unidentified bogeyman actually did it.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:58PM (#13936872)
> Also, some modern watermarking techniques can survive conversions like this, so if anyone is making a habit of recording content from a service using watermarking and redistributing it on a scale that justifies taking serious action, it'll be pretty easy to prove who it was when the lawsuit comes up.

How many compromised netflix accounts do you think are floating around? At some point the bits have to actually go to a display device as well, which can always be tapped.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @11:45PM (#13937261)
If a compromised account was used, presumably the server logs will show an unusual access pattern on that account, in particular involving the content that has leaked being accessed from an unusual location. And then presumably the person whose account was used will have to make a convincing case that they shouldn't be held responsible for access using their credentials anyway.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Thursday March 23, 2017 @01:24AM (#13937568)
Ok, what if a machine is compromised (there are millions of zombie boxes out there)? Someone can gain access, do their stuff and then upload the result. Are they going to start suing grandmas with weak wifi passwords? That worked so well for the RIAA last time.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Thursday March 23, 2017 @01:45AM (#13937626)
Then it'll be up to the person whose account was accessed to provide some evidence that something like this happened and that it wasn't their fault. That's how these things work. You go to court, you make your case and the other side makes theirs, and the court draws its conclusions and acts accordingly.

However, you don't just get to conveniently avoid taking any responsibility when there are videos being distributed that are specifically linked to an account you signed up for that clearly said you couldn't redistribute the content you got through it, just because there's some vaguely possible alternative that might have once happened somewhere maybe.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by boomboomsubban on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:57AM (#13937845)
A compromised account is a vague possibility? I'm not amazing at these things, but I could probably access a WiFi network unconnected to me, mask my IP to a different location, and acquire a random Netflix account in a couple of hours. These things are likely, and wrongful lawsuits greatly damage the company while successful ones provide a minimal benefit.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:11AM (#13937891)
I'm not amazing at these things, but I could probably access a WiFi network unconnected to me, mask my IP to a different location, and acquire a random Netflix account in a couple of hours.

Really? How would you do that, exactly?

If you're looking online and find camcorder copies of videos that were served to a specific customer at a specific time, as confirmed by the watermarking, and your server logs show that that stream was sent to the customer's usual IP address at the time in question, what are the odds that they were the victim of a carefully crafted hack of the kind you're implying, and not just someone who set up a camcorder to record from their own account?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:38AM (#13937963)
> Really? How would you do that, exactly?

Wireless isn't very secure, you're mileage may vary on the encryption mechanism but here is a guide to hacking WPA networks (with WEP it takes seconds):

http://www.hackingtutorials.org/wifi-hacking-tutorials/how-t...

From there you can try a range of known exploits and gain admin access to a PC, after that it's game over, they can run what they want, when the want. There is no careful crafting necessary, the process can be largely automated.

We aren't talking camcorder copies, but exact digital replicas from the netflix stream.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Thursday March 23, 2017 @12:50PM (#13941503)
WPA2 is reasonably secure and has been the standard for home and business WiFi for years.

In any case, merely compromising WiFi won't get you someone's Netflix account. The Netflix data itself, including the credentials, are all encrypted.

As for taking over someone's PC, that's far beyond the average pirate, and you're talking about serious criminal offences on top of mere copyright infringement at that point.

And even then, we're not necessarily talking about being able to make exact copies of the stream. The whole point of hardware-backed DRM schemes is that just because you can run software on the PC, that doesn't mean you can access the unencrypted data stream.

So again, how exactly were you planning to do this? What you're talking about is far beyond the average script kiddie or casual pirate.

Remember, we were talking about convincing a court that it was more likely that someone did all of this and that was how a watermarked copy of protected content got out than that the person whose account was used to download that content then somehow shared it. A slight possibility that professional pirates who are also expert crackers chose that particular customer to pick on and left no evidence having done so isn't likely to be very convincing.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by boomboomsubban on Friday March 24, 2017 @01:14AM (#13946789)
I can't figure out why you've added this ridiculous "need to use their computer" part, that would be necessary for a successful lawsuit but suing random Netflix users will look terrible even if the court clears them in the end. But OK...

WPA2 is reasonably secure, but most home instances aren't set up well. They often have WPS enabled or a guessable password. Plus weaker set ups are still easy to find. Once you're on, redirect Netflix to a site to grab their info, record the stream from a computer outside their house. This is needlessly complex for what is needed, find a compromised Netflix(+email?), record.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Friday March 24, 2017 @09:07AM (#13948630)
Netflix serves over HTTPS and uses HSTS. Under most circumstances, you aren't going to be able to MITM them and "grab their info" even if you've compromised their WiFi.

You keep coming up with these claims about how easy this is, yet you also keep missing basic technical points about the system actually works. As I've said before, if there is actual evidence that someone's account was compromised then they can produce that as part of their defence in court. However, if content that is watermarked to a specific account turns up all over the Internet, that is evidence suggesting that the person in question has infringed copyright, and that does need a real defence if the rightsholder chooses to take legal action accordingly.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by boomboomsubban on Friday March 24, 2017 @12:16PM (#13949933)
Yes, and people are so great at making sure they access https addresses and never ignore a "this may not be secure" warning.

And you're still ignoring the major parts. What someone actually needs to do is much easier than all this, and Netflix has already lost if they end up in court with an innocent person.

If you want me to prove accounts have been compromised, look at all the account breaches over the past few years, think of how many reuse passwords.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:15AM (#13937904)
> That's how these things work. You go to court, you make your case and the other side makes theirs, and the court draws its conclusions and acts accordingly.

Currently the burden of evidence is far too low. Something being done with my account, or even my machine is not evidence that I've done anything wrong.

> However, you don't just get to conveniently avoid taking any responsibility when there are videos being distributed that are specifically linked to an account you signed up for that clearly said you couldn't redistribute the content you got through it

How are we supposed to take responsibility for the actions of others? Should we be liable for crimes committed due to the insecurity of home networks? If so the computer industry has much bigger problems than DRM.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by Silhouette on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:33PM (#13942684)
Something being done with my account, or even my machine is not evidence that I've done anything wrong.

Yes, it is. It may not be absolute proof, but it most certainly is strong evidence.

How are we supposed to take responsibility for the actions of others?

Hopefully, you don't have to. But you also don't get to just invent some hypothetical bogeyman and use that as an excuse to ignore real evidence.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by infinite8s on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:15PM (#13936689)
If you discount the cost of your time to zero. Otherwise it's not even worth a minimum wage job.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:55PM (#13936865)
It only needs to be done by one person, not every viewer.

And yes, the value of much of my time is effectively zero. The same is true for most people.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by MBCook on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:36PM (#13937017)
That's why we have laws to apply negative externalities like very large jail sentences if you're caught distributing a file that you created by taping a movie off-screen.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by flukus on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:53PM (#13937092)
Local solutions to global problems that don't even work locally. Those large jail sentences also place a lot of externalities on the rest of society.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by MBCook on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:49PM (#13943531)
I agree. My comment was not meant as an endorsement, simply a statement I think that's how they've 'solved' that issue.
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by taneq on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:56PM (#13937101)
You missed:

2b. People who don't have access to the content, but want to watch it for free.

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by jimktrains2 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:10PM (#13936355)
> It's about compromises to drive behavior and consumer spending with convenience.

You mean grabbing a DRM-free (i.e. pirated) copy so that I can watch it at my leasure and on devices of my choosing, even if I have access to it via other legit means?

Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by notjoemama on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:25PM (#13943907)
Any free or low cost run-of-the-mill capture software renders DRM useless. If it's made out of bits, you can't ensure ownership after redistribution. In an environment like this people pay because it is quality content and access is easy. The publishers business model needs to get with the times, not strong arm browser vendors into adhering to their archaic requirements. I'm personally sick of hearing about this DRM war. There are so many more things to be concerned with. ◔̯◔
Re:Update on HTML5 Video for Netflix by accountface on Thursday March 23, 2017 @12:00AM (#13937296)
Do you lock the front door to your house when you leave?