http://www.polygon.com/2016/7/25/12270074/pokemon-go-nintend...
That's not to say that Nintendo did anything to mislead the public, they didn't, it was just a widespread misconception.
As a gamer, Nintendo is somewhat "brilliantly innovative" but they also appear to be somewhat disconnected from their market. Pokemon Go is actually a good example. The Nintendo fan base is positively starving for content and Nintendo seems to consistently underestimate demand.
Or as you suggest, perhaps they are more interested in being innovative rather than servicing their fan base.
So while I think they should be praised for being innovative I would also say two things:
* Pokemon Go is not at all their innovation
* They definitely have problems
The run up in Nintendo stock happened because investors have been after Nintendo for years to start making mobile game versions of their crown jewel IPs, believing (rightfully I would point out) that this would be an absolute gold mine. When Pokemon Go became an unprecedented blockbuster success, investors reasoned that it would convince Nintendo to change course and make more mobile games.
The fall in Nintendo stock happened after their earnings call. On the call, Nintendo said that despite the success of Pokemon Go they were not changing their plans to increase their investment in mobile games. That's why their stock fell (to "only" a 60% gain).
The form factor isn't ideal for their games the gameplay model (short bite sized bursts) isn't ideal, even the pricing isn't ideal (look at the outcry over paying for Mario Run, I've heard people dismiss Mario Run immediately over the fact it wasn't 99 cents).
(Real questions; I'm not advocating for Nintendo.)
Per Wikipedia:
* Ingress: It was downloaded 8 million times "as of" 2015, about a year after its release, and claimed 7 million players in 2015.
* Pokemon Go: 130 million downloads in its first month, 650 million within 8 months. PG was "the most active mobile game in the United States ever with 21 million active users" within a week of its launch; note that is in only one country.
From a software development perspective Nintendo might not have done anything, but who had the vision to invest in bringing this to such a huge market? That also is an investment in creativity and innovation. (That's not meant to be a rhetorical question; I don't know the answer.)
As shown, the developer and publisher is Niantic which is also the developer of Ingress.
Perhaps you are referring to this snippet:
> The concept for the game was conceived in 2014 by Satoru Iwata of Nintendo and Tsunekazu Ishihara of The Pokémon Company as an April Fools' Day collaboration with Google, called the Google Maps: Pokémon Challenge.[21] Ishihara was a fan of developer Niantic's previous transreality game, Ingress, and saw the game's concept as a perfect match for the Pokémon series.[22] Niantic used the crowdsourced[23] data from Ingress to populate the locations for PokéStops and gyms within Pokémon Go, and data from Google Maps to spawn specific Pokémon on certain terrain or environment.[24][25]
So for background, The Pokémon Company is more or less a licensing body for handling licensing of the Pokémon IP and franchise. They collaborated with Niantic to meld an Ingress inspired augmented reality game with the Pokémon IP.
Yes The Pokémon Company is a subsidiary of Nintendo so in a way Nintendo had a hand in the collaboration...but I would probably classify it as a 2nd or even 3rd order relationship. But that is a personal judgement call I suppose.
In my mind, the augmented reality game design was wholly pioneered and executed by Niantic (not once but twice). The idea for melding said design with Pokémon IP came from the franchise licensing entity of The Pokémon Company which is a joint subsidiary of Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures who were the three businesses holding copyright on Pokémon at the time of its founding [1].
But again, somewhat of a personal view point.
To me, I wouldn't necessarily attribute much related to Pokémon Go to Nintendo.
They didn't develop pokemon go.
> But they don't get enough attention and praise IMHO
It's because they pull constant bullshit.
Everything is a shortage. NES classic, amiibos, etc...
Their online systems are years behind.
They try to get people to pay again and again for the same ancient games. You can't transfer games bought on the virutal console between different consoles, why? Fuck you that's why.
They are at times more concerned with being "innovative" then just providing a good core experience. You praise the wii but it wound being filled with shovelware and the motion controls are still just meh.
They are extremely hostile towards their own community. They zealously "protect" their IP (as is their right) from people doing lets plays and reviews and such on youtube.
I love nintendo the game maker, but they are not the best company around.
And the whole purchase on every single damn system made me stop buying their digital content.
There's a maddening idiosyncrasy (I feel there's a better word I can use... eccentricity?) to both companies where they do enough things right that I feel a kind of loyalty that I rarely feel for a company, but then they do plenty of things so spectacularly wrong that I feel a bit stockholm-syndromed for 'loving' them.
They aren't exceptional in the idea that none of the big game developers are really experimenting. Games today are very similar to the games 15 years ago in mechanics, and let alone title.
Even with Nintendo in the mix pushing for collaboration and positive experience you still have to turn to the indie developers willing to take the risk on a new IP with innovative gameplay. When done right is better than any flagship title since they are all the same.
I think that what both Apple and Nintendo have in common is that they don't just try to put hardware components into a box and sell them to you for cheap (e.g. Dell).
They have a chance of higher profit margins by taking themselves out of that race via trying to find creative ways to add value instead of optimizing raw performance / sale price.
They aren't afraid to take chances but not all of their chances are so great. The Wii U was a bit of a disaster.
Isn't that the nature of taking chances? If there weren't failures, it wouldn't be called 'taking risks'.
(On the subject of the Wii U, in a lot of ways it seems like the Switch might be the second iteration for being hip and also making a tablet, where the Wii U was the first one.)
Not sure if it's still true that all other console makers are subsidizing theirs.
Resident Evil 4, Metroid Prime have the best controls of any FPS I've ever played on console. It was just so natural, I could get head shots in RE4 by just pointing my arm at the TV and pulling the trigger.
Then they released the Wii U ...
Its library was smaller than I would have liked, but it definitely had a number of really great games.
If anything, I figure that Nintendo's brand stable allows them to take on bigger hardware risks than others. Sony and Microsoft both have motion control technology, but Nintendo was the only one to ship it to customers by default. Third party publishers were absolutely not on board with that -- they more or less treat consoles as underpowered PCs-- leaving Nintendo more or less standing alone. I don't think Wii ever really had top tier 3rd party support, because they're focus is on publishing a consistent experience across a variety of device types (well, that and Sony / MS using their capital to buy up IP).
tl;dr: Nintendo engineers are just as creative as anyone else's, but their management team is comfortable encouraging and placing large bets on them.
- Wii was more than a decade ago, and is widely considered one of last things they did right.
- Pokemon Go has nothing to do with Nintendo outside of their stake in the IP. Additionally, it's not remembered fondly by most people above the age of 13.
- Wii U was a massive failure, and has been buried by Nintendo
- The Switch was bungled pretty heavily, it's been nothing but criticized as far as I can tell. I haven't heard a single good thing about it, except that it has Zelda.
As far as innovation goes, they haven't innovated in years. They've introduced gimmicks that get ignored or ridiculed, not remembered.
I think it'd be interesting to see a Pokemon Go designed by Nintendo / Game Freak themselves.
It was made by the same developers—and the pokestops and gyms when the game launches were all ingress sites.
Off the top of my head, I see the Wii, Pokemon Go, and now this.
In addition to being innovative, they seem focused on artistry, creativity, and positive experiences for their customers. Wii in many ways encouraged collaboration and activity, playing with others (i.e., rather than alone with pizza all night long); it focused on that over flashy graphics and shock-and-gore. Pokemon Go got people out on their feet, interacting, exploring and engaging with their towns, creatively rather than garishly introduced them to the possibilities of new tech (AR), and was fun but not violent.
Perhaps that's already Nintendo's reputation; I don't know. But they don't get enough attention and praise IMHO. They seem to me to be like the Pixar or Apple of games, or better.