The run up in Nintendo stock happened because investors have been after Nintendo for years to start making mobile game versions of their crown jewel IPs, believing (rightfully I would point out) that this would be an absolute gold mine. When Pokemon Go became an unprecedented blockbuster success, investors reasoned that it would convince Nintendo to change course and make more mobile games.
The fall in Nintendo stock happened after their earnings call. On the call, Nintendo said that despite the success of Pokemon Go they were not changing their plans to increase their investment in mobile games. That's why their stock fell (to "only" a 60% gain).
The form factor isn't ideal for their games the gameplay model (short bite sized bursts) isn't ideal, even the pricing isn't ideal (look at the outcry over paying for Mario Run, I've heard people dismiss Mario Run immediately over the fact it wasn't 99 cents).
(Real questions; I'm not advocating for Nintendo.)
Per Wikipedia:
* Ingress: It was downloaded 8 million times "as of" 2015, about a year after its release, and claimed 7 million players in 2015.
* Pokemon Go: 130 million downloads in its first month, 650 million within 8 months. PG was "the most active mobile game in the United States ever with 21 million active users" within a week of its launch; note that is in only one country.
From a software development perspective Nintendo might not have done anything, but who had the vision to invest in bringing this to such a huge market? That also is an investment in creativity and innovation. (That's not meant to be a rhetorical question; I don't know the answer.)
As shown, the developer and publisher is Niantic which is also the developer of Ingress.
Perhaps you are referring to this snippet:
> The concept for the game was conceived in 2014 by Satoru Iwata of Nintendo and Tsunekazu Ishihara of The Pokémon Company as an April Fools' Day collaboration with Google, called the Google Maps: Pokémon Challenge.[21] Ishihara was a fan of developer Niantic's previous transreality game, Ingress, and saw the game's concept as a perfect match for the Pokémon series.[22] Niantic used the crowdsourced[23] data from Ingress to populate the locations for PokéStops and gyms within Pokémon Go, and data from Google Maps to spawn specific Pokémon on certain terrain or environment.[24][25]
So for background, The Pokémon Company is more or less a licensing body for handling licensing of the Pokémon IP and franchise. They collaborated with Niantic to meld an Ingress inspired augmented reality game with the Pokémon IP.
Yes The Pokémon Company is a subsidiary of Nintendo so in a way Nintendo had a hand in the collaboration...but I would probably classify it as a 2nd or even 3rd order relationship. But that is a personal judgement call I suppose.
In my mind, the augmented reality game design was wholly pioneered and executed by Niantic (not once but twice). The idea for melding said design with Pokémon IP came from the franchise licensing entity of The Pokémon Company which is a joint subsidiary of Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures who were the three businesses holding copyright on Pokémon at the time of its founding [1].
But again, somewhat of a personal view point.
To me, I wouldn't necessarily attribute much related to Pokémon Go to Nintendo.
http://www.polygon.com/2016/7/25/12270074/pokemon-go-nintend...
That's not to say that Nintendo did anything to mislead the public, they didn't, it was just a widespread misconception.
As a gamer, Nintendo is somewhat "brilliantly innovative" but they also appear to be somewhat disconnected from their market. Pokemon Go is actually a good example. The Nintendo fan base is positively starving for content and Nintendo seems to consistently underestimate demand.
Or as you suggest, perhaps they are more interested in being innovative rather than servicing their fan base.
So while I think they should be praised for being innovative I would also say two things:
* Pokemon Go is not at all their innovation
* They definitely have problems