News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:33AM (#13866595)
I think critiques of American bumbkins is an American tradition. Hawthorne to Twain to Mencken to etc. It is the American organism hashing itself. It is healthy and has helped to make this country what it is. However there is a dangerous trend today to severely ignore the lack of this in other nations whose own bumbkins self-immolate while those who could be Twains or Asimovs are immolated. But hey, say what you want about about everyone if it makes you feel good.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dang on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:02AM (#13867132)
The reflection on American intellectual history in this comment is welcome. Its trollish and uncivil aspects are not. Please edit those out if you're going to keep commenting here.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @04:20PM (#13871125)
Wait, what part was trollish? Last sentence?
[dead]
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dang on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:56AM (#13867101)
Religious flamewar is not welcome on Hacker News, and we regularly ban accounts that conduct it here. Political flamewar isn't welcome either, and you managed to combine the two in a toxic cocktail.

All: please keep this poison away from here. If this is the kind of argument you need to have, this is not the website you're looking for.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by pdimitar on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:38AM (#13868364)
I am in full agreement with you, but I still feel surprised by the amounts of replies that person got.

Seems like people love to argue pointless negativity even if the "argument" it makes has zero roots in reality. That's extremely sad. :(

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:24AM (#13874198)
I don't know what that person posted but if you're referring to my post above as pointless negativity I just don't know what to think.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by pdimitar on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @12:18PM (#13877176)
No, wasn't directed at you, but at a heavily downvoted (and subsequently flagged) comment which was a very obvious troll and flame bait.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dang on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:46AM (#13868463)
It's human nature, so we can't change these effects, just maybe interpret them as damage and route around them a bit.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by pdimitar on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:48AM (#13868489)
My observation as well.

It seems that the idea of "don't make stupid people famous" will never work. Shame.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @04:26PM (#13871163)
People aren't allowed to comment on religion at all? Unless it's a positive comment that entices no debate? A discussion of religion is relevant to the article. I'm getting an icky feeling that if my post was directed at any other religion than Islam there wouldn't be an issue.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dang on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:46PM (#13873659)
That's not the case at all, but it's definitely a thing that trolls like to say.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @02:22AM (#13874188)
I understand concern trolling. I understand trolling. What I don't understand is how my post is trolling. I meant what I posted. It was in earnest. It seems like someone can say that a divergent opinion or criticism of religion is trolling here. Not all criticism is flame-warring. When I think flame-warring I think no-content shitposting and slurs. But if people are having a reasoned argument, even if it's not entirely cordial, I don't think that constitutes a flame-war.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by sabertoothed on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:41AM (#13866639)
Islam is not the predominant problem in the US. Really not. Nearly half of US Americans don't believe in evolution. Christian fundamentalism causes much more harm at the moment than islamists.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by autokad on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:04AM (#13866765)
300 million people believing in creationism is far less harmful than 1 person dropping bombs at a marathon.

i believe in evolution, but you need to get over the idea there is some kind of innate golden age waiting to happen if only those annoying chiristains would believe in evolution.

unless you are a biologist, believing in creationism has no impact on your life or how you do your job. i dont care if my brain surgeon believes in creationism. you know what i care about? how well they do brain surgery.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by adrianN on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:15AM (#13866829)
I'd argue that creationism is more dangerous, because it instills a general distrust in science. This leads to leaders who can openly claim that global warming is a Chinese hoax. Global warming will most likely kill several orders of magnitude more people than all Islamic terrorists taken together.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by swah on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:40AM (#13866993)
One can trust science, but not scientists as if they're some special beings above corruption and what else.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by Udik on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:19AM (#13866859)
> 300 million people believing in creationism is far less harmful than 1 person dropping bombs at a marathon.

How many bombs have been dropped on other countries because of the choices of those millions of uneducated voters?

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by swah on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:42AM (#13867013)
Are you talking about the Obama administration? Probably not, since what progressive folks usually mean by ignorant voters is "people that vote different from me, you know, those rednecks over there".
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by unprepare on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:45AM (#13868455)
Is moving goalposts your only argumentative tactic?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by consz on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:28AM (#13866916)
>300 million people believing in creationism is far less harmful than 1 person dropping bombs at a marathon.

Could you elaborate? You state this like it's obvious, but it isn't (at least to me).

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by sabertoothed on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:18AM (#13866849)
Evolution was just an example to illustrate how far religious superstition reaches.

Disbelief in science in general has a massive impact - causing deaths.

Even disbelief in evolution causes deaths, e.g. if we don't do enough to deal with antibiotic resistance.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by stillsut on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @12:22PM (#13868868)
> Even disbelief in evolution causes deaths, e.g. if we don't do enough to deal with antibiotic resistance.

I wonder if this is true? What is correlation of Americans who "don't believe in evolution" who would reject the notion of antibiotic resistance in infectious diseases if you explained it to them? I wonder how many would reject the notions of husbandry, e.g. if you continually breed for a certain trait, like agreeableness, that the offspring will be on average more agreeable than the previous generation.

There is the religion of Christian Science, which rejects taking all medicine, but even there, that would only seem to be beneficial in antibiotic preservation practices.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by smhost on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:19AM (#13866854)
This is what is meant by a cult of ignorance. They want to insist that the only purpose of knowledge is to fulfill one's practical economic role.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by tobltobs on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:17AM (#13866839)
but then why this fixation on Islam and not on the heroin epidemic or mass shootings?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by supergreg on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:34AM (#13866953)
Easier to deal with a "them vs us" than an "us vs some of us"
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dgellow on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:51AM (#13866694)
That's not what said the parent comment. Both religions have their (different set of) problems. But see how it goes when you criticize Islam. Criticize any other religion and you're fine, criticize Islam and you get a fatwa against you and become a racist xenophobic islamophobe.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by kevingadd on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:53AM (#13866707)
This simply isn't accurate unless you live in an oppressive middle-east country with extremist Sharia law. Incidentally, some of those governments are in power because of coups and/or unrest triggered by western nations for our own purposes. Obviously there's no western equivalent to ISIS at present, but arguably that's because of the unique instability that exists in the middle east, partly as a result of western intervention. ISIS wouldn't exist unless we helped create it.

If you look hard enough you can certainly find christian evangelical leaders who will call for the destruction of people who attack their faith. It's simply not normal and doesn't represent the vast majority of believers.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dgellow on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:26AM (#13866904)
> This simply isn't accurate unless you live in an oppressive middle-east country with extremist Sharia law

You don't have to live in a country under Sharia laws to get a fatwa against you. I mean, check this short list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatwas#Fatwas_promotin...

For the rest of your post, I'm not sure to see how it's a response to my comment.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:47AM (#13866667)
Christian "fundamentalism" is quite benign in this country. Aside from the issue of abortion and perhaps stem cell research can you list some travesties caused by Christianity in America? The fastest growing religion is non religion.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by danhak on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:52AM (#13866700)
Sending gay youth to psychologically damaging "conversion therapy" camps. Actively campaigning against the rights of gay individuals to marry or raise children. Physically abusing, disowning or abandoning gay children. There's a reason LGBT youth are 4x as likely to be homeless as their straight peers.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dgellow on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:54AM (#13866709)
Wait. Actively participating in a democratic process to support you opinions is a bad thing?

edit: I will clarify. I was reacting to "Actively campaigning against the rights of gay individuals to marry or raise children". I'm for gay marriage. I'm also for allowing other people to campaign against my opinions.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by kevingadd on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:56AM (#13866720)
It's weird how people can't agree on whether torturing teens or banning people from using bathrooms is an 'opinion', especially since doing those things has literally no upside for anyone, and it's 'solving' problems that don't exist.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dgellow on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:14AM (#13866824)
Seems to be the definition of what an opinion is. A personal view on a given topic.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by mtberatwork on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:02AM (#13866758)
When the consequences of an opinion directly infringes on a person's civil rights, then yes.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by bmelton on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:19AM (#13866857)
The consequences of such opinions almost always directly infringe on a person's civil rights in today's America. Increasing access to health care by raising taxes infringes upon economic freedom. Implementing gun control infringes the 2nd amendment. Keeping us safe from terrorists infringes on our fourth amendment rights.

We have, for at least the past few decades, opted to largely ignore certain types of civil liberties, and just about every American is willing to infringe someone else's liberties to get something out of the democratic process that they care more about. I agree that gay marriage is good, and doesn't hurt anyone, and that so long as marriage is an institution, every American who wants to partake in it should be allowed to, whether gay, straight, trans or whatever -- but let's not pretend that the infringement of civil liberties at the ballot box is a trait unique or peculiar to those voting against gay marriage.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by mtberatwork on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:56AM (#13867099)
I think there are a few false dichotomies in your argument. Those who campaign against gay marriage are directly seeking to abolish the rights of gay couples that are afforded to straight couples. The consequences of this is the removal of legal protections and benefits, based solely on sexual orientation, which directly establishes gay individuals as second-class citizens. Yes, this is a bad thing. Contrasting this with your examples, taxation and gun control measures are certainly not infringing on your abilities to achieve economic freedom or gun ownership. Now certainly there are many infringements on civil rights being done in the name of keeping us safe from terrorists, to which I would also say this is a "bad thing", but then I'm certainly not pretending infringement "is a trait unique or peculiar to those voting against gay marriage."
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by bmelton on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:13AM (#13867201)
That very much depends on how charitably one interprets the law.

If banning an AR-15 doesn't infringe my right to gun ownership, then in the same way, a ban on gay marriage doesn't infringe my right to marriage. I can still marry anyone (of the opposite sex) that I choose.

Like I said, I'm not arguing on behalf of those who would ban gay marriage -- I think it's a very wrong-headed position to take, but that dosen't invalidate that it's quite a common position to take, and that the infringement of rights we don't like is a ritual practiced by left and right alike, and that the exploitation of the democratic process to effect those goals is not only common, but _routine_.

The point is that despite democracy, the constitution and its provisions against being able to impose unconstitutional whimsies on populaces we don't like are supposed to encourage a tolerant society. The tolerance to let another person live their life in a way that you don't approve of is a pre-requisite to America functioning correctly. I'm not a historian, so I can't say if we've forgotten it, or we never really knew it, but it's definitely a lesson we need to learn or re-learn as appropriate.

Tying back to OP, at least one manifestation of that ideal is perhaps not in routinely making fun of the whole rest of America to which you don't belong. Of course, it is your right to do so, but disparaging ideas with which you don't agree (as opposed to making substantive arguments through engaged civil discourse) is perhaps not the best strategy to prevent against the continuation of those routine infringements.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by iiii_iivii_iiii on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:03AM (#13866760)
https://www.liveleak.com/view?i=f6d_1435932798

I am Jack's stunning lack of perspective.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by danhak on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:18AM (#13866851)
What is your point? That nobody should be criticized for anything as long as ISIS is doing something worse? That's the standard for American society now?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by jsmith0295 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:52AM (#13866698)
Even if that were the case, that doesn't make it a good idea to align yourselves with Islamists as many on the left have.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by pjc50 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:08AM (#13866790)
You absolutely have to distinguish between Islam and Islamism, just like people need to distinguish between Zionism and simply being Jewish. Or for that matter between the various forms of Christianity and their levels of political involvement.

People have a right to religious beliefs. They do not - must not - have the right to turn that into a legal enforcement of those beliefs on people who do not share them.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by jsmith0295 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:12AM (#13866813)
Yeah, I should've been more clear, but that is what I was talking about.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by kevingadd on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:55AM (#13866711)
Why not?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by jsmith0295 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:01AM (#13866754)
It's a totalitarian ideology which is fundamentally opposed to liberal democracy. It shouldn't be tolerated for the same reasons Nazism shouldn't be tolerated.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by jcranmer on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:58AM (#13867112)
200 years ago, people said the exact same thing about Catholicism.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by madengr on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:56AM (#13866716)
I agree, but the parent thread was about "other nations". Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world. The fact that any religion is growing is worrisome, but Islam is probably the worst.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by fdsak on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @10:08AM (#13867570)
You can say same thing about anything you dislike or don't know e.g "_ is probably worst" and I would suggest some words e.g democracy , West, Christianity.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by dgellow on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:32AM (#13866938)
> but Islam is probably the worst

I would add "... at the moment".

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by CalRobert on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:49AM (#13866674)
Maybe because it makes more sense to criticize actions than belief systems, many of which have profoundly varying styles and degrees of observation. Plenty of folks on the left (and right) criticize oppression, superstition, and the like. Plenty of folks in all camps are guilty of same.

Like Christianity, or any other major religion, adherents of Islam vary massively in how they choose to practice (if at all).

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by jsmith0295 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:57AM (#13866725)
The two are not mutually exclusive. Belief systems influence actions. Obviously it makes sense to call out the Neo Nazis within the Trump movement, so why wouldnt it make sense to criticize ideas which are effectively fascist held by a much larger number of Muslims, even those who have immigrated to western democracies.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by CalRobert on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:37AM (#13867334)
Because they're Neo Nazis. Not Neo Christians. I criticize the fascist beliefs of many of my countrymen but it has nothing to do with their religion.

Please, hang out with some Muslims. They're just regular folks like anyone else. If more people in the US understood this it would help a lot. It might also show the problems with targeting "Radical Islamic Terrorism" when it could also be "Radical Crime Committed by People With Various Motivations and Worldviews Many of Whom Hail From a Region With a Troubled Past, the Causes of Which are Myriad and Require Some Study of Post WWI Imperial Policy Among Other Things"

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:45AM (#13866659)
They won't even use the phrase "radical Islamic terrorism" just because experts, including Trump's National Security Advisor, think it's damaging to American interests to do so.
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by CalRobert on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:05AM (#13866772)
Some organizations prefer to avoid even the word "terrorist" because it can be interpreted in wildly different ways, is massively emotionally loaded, and does little if anything to add understanding to the conversation. It's also a lot harder to try to understand your opponent's motivations (which is critical to reaching a solution) when you say "radical Islamist terrorist" instead of "person or group who did X because they want Y".

http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidance/terrorism-...

Just saying "horrible jerks who do really rotten things for a variety of motivations" might be more effective in helping people ascertain risk. After all, Volkswagen put a dangerous agent in the atmosphere that will kill thousands of people - are they "terrorists"? Exxon-Mobil knew their business was likely to result in the displacement and deaths of anywhere from thousands to millions of people, are they terrorists? Millions of voters have installed a leader in the US who advocates bombing innocent families, many of them guided by their religious beliefs. Are those voters "terrorists"?

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by gmac on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:13AM (#13867206)
Just saying "horrible jerks who do really rotten things for a variety of motivations" might be more effective in helping people ascertain risk.

YES.

(OT, this was one of the things I most appreciated about Star Trek: Into Darkness — Cumberbatch's character sets off a large and destructive bomb in a government building, with much loss of life, and is then pointedly referred to throughout simply as a criminal. A heinous criminal, certainly, who must be dealt with — but a simple criminal nonetheless).

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by Cyph0n on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:40AM (#13866635)
Was it Islam that got the current president into office?
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by kevingadd on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:51AM (#13866695)
A significant portion of terror attacks in the united states are committed by non-muslims, mostly white and christian. Why won't the Right in America criticize Radical Evangelical Terror?

(This is a rhetorical question. It's not fair to blame clearly unhinged extremists on a religion at-large when billions of devotees do no harm.)

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by jbmorgado on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:32AM (#13866939)
> "Why won't the Right in America criticize Radical Evangelical Terror"

Because that doesn't actually exist and it's just a faux and very poor argument.

If you are intellectually honest you would understand there is a big diference between someone from a certain group (may it be christian, muslim, etc) just committing a crime as an individual and someone from a certain group committing a crime invoking principles that derive from belonging to that group (like their religious supremacy for instance).

In that regard, yes, there are a lot more islamic attacks than there are christian attacks. We had one single attack in Europe that could (emphasis on could since the guy was by foremost an extreme right winger and not some christian fanatic) be connected to christian ideologies in the past decades (by Anders Behring Breivik, which did in fact kill a lot of innocent people)... but now go and check how many terrorist attacks you have connected to islamic ideologies.

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by rimliu on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:01AM (#13866753)
Sometimes silent support acts as enabler to those doing the harm. Alas, views of the majority of muslims are not encouraging (i.e. views on issues whether sharia should be the law of the country, should apostasy be punished by death, etc.)
Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by huxley on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:49AM (#13867058)
Ask very religious Americans if they think the laws of America should be more driven by Biblical principles, it isn't any different.

Besides, religious courts already exist in the US. For example, Halakha are religious courts run for Orthodox Jews, they exist in America and make many decisions on family law and civil disputes. But even among bigger groups, lots of disputes are dealt with within the religious community, Catholics have 200 diocesan tribunals, if you want to end your marriage and stay in communion, you pretty much have to ask for an annulment at a diocesan tribunal.

Lots more examples:

http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/08/applying-gods-law-religio...

Re:Isaac Asimov Laments the “Cult of Ignorance” in the Unite... by rimliu on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:02AM (#13867133)
Interesting, I did not know about other religious courts. What I had in mind however was the opinion that Sharia should replace the country's court system.