News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by mabbo on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @09:35PM (#13826426)
The exciting part is if they successfully land it again.

Consider: eight first stage rockets have been landed already. One is a show piece (the first one) and at least one is too beat up to ever be reused. But that leaves a fleet of six-ish rockets. How many Falcon 9s would SpaceX need to run an active fleet that is constantly refurbished and reused, never replaced? They'd start to look less like Boeing and more like Delta.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by rst on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:21PM (#13826654)
Not exactly like Delta; Falcon 9 second stages are still one-flight throwaways, and plans for reusing them have been shelved. (That might change if they build a second stage powered by the Raptor engine currently being prototyped for their Mars project -- or a scaled-down version of it -- but that remains a poorly-sourced rumor at this point. If they're working actively on any such thing, they've kept it fairly tightly under wraps.)
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by greglindahl on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:30PM (#13826701)
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raptor_prototype_upper-stage_e...

While there's no money in this contract to develop the upper stage itself, only money for the engine, it's still a source.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by 824ueirwfjd on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @11:39PM (#13827028)
> eight first stage rockets have been landed already.

Wow this is truly amazing! I didn't realize they've landed it 8 times already... I still remember watching the youtube live stream of the first successful landing and how exciting and moving it was to watch. We're truly entering a new phase of space exploration and I can't wait to see what comes of the next decade and beyond!

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by mabbo on Thursday March 09, 2017 @07:44AM (#13828866)
After the 4th or 5th one landed, and it suddenly became clear that this was the new normal, Musk had this wonderful tweet: https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/72845980827000012...
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by Ntrails on Thursday March 09, 2017 @03:50AM (#13828021)
My favourite part of this is how my perceptions have changed.

    - This cannot be possible
    - Awww, they got pretty close that's incredible
    - Great Scott, they've done it!
    - Heh, they're getting good at this
    - There's no way they'll fuck this up
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by qeternity on Thursday March 09, 2017 @08:15AM (#13829004)
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

And then once the trick is revealed, it stops being magic and just becomes "boring" math/engineering/etc.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by ragebol on Thursday March 09, 2017 @08:15AM (#13829009)
Then:

- Yawn, another landing. It just lands, nothing exciting to see.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by LoSboccacc on Thursday March 09, 2017 @08:24AM (#13829044)
luckily between here and there the'll be a lot of entertaining fireworks to be had.

the only shameful aspect of it is how the press will portray failures as terrible events for SpaceX, while they're still pushing the envelope and boundaries of what we think it's possible with failures being normal for quite some time yet.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by alpos on Thursday March 09, 2017 @09:07AM (#13829311)
I think SpaceX has done a good job countering this perspective so far. Their press releases and web casts consistently reinforce that the landing is merely a secondary objective and an experiment which they will learn a great deal from whether it blows up or not.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by sametmax on Thursday March 09, 2017 @07:44AM (#13828862)
Pretty much my thinking too.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by gozur88 on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @09:58PM (#13826547)
They're a ways from being Delta. One of the things that came out recently regarding crewed launches is Merlin turbines have been developing cracks under test. They're probably only good for a handful of flights.

Musk claims that's all going to be fixed in the next version. We'll see.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by ygra on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:08AM (#13827370)
That didn't come out recently, that was known from the very start, as Gwynne Shotwell noted in the press conference prior to CRS-10. They have flown with cracks in the turbopumps since Falcon 9 flew for the first time and it was no big deal (customers have known and were okay with it for cargo flights). It's just that for human flights they want every most bit of safety margin they can get, so they'll fix it for Block 5.

To my knowledge there has only been one engine failure (which resulted in the secondary payload being lost), and it is not known whether that was due to the turbopump.

One other thing to consider is that most pre-Block 5 rockets won't fly that often even if/when SES-10 is successful and even lands again. Most customers get factory-new rockets and they already learned a lot on how to make the first stage easier and better to reuse. So once Block 5 comes around the older landed boosters are probably not needed much. They converted one of them into a side booster for Falcon Heavy already, as far as I know, so that may be one point for salvaging them.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by RangerScience on Thursday March 09, 2017 @04:33AM (#13828201)
What does Block 5 mean?
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by ygra on Thursday March 09, 2017 @04:52AM (#13828251)
It's effectively a version number. SpaceX have been quite inconsistent in how they've named their rocket versions, with Falcon 9 v1.0, 1.1, 1.2, Full Thrust, another upgrade that didn't get a name (informally called Fuller Thrust), and Block 5. Perhaps Elon is just messing with us. Effectively Block 5 is supposed to be the last iteration of the Falcon 9, with a slight performance increase and a lot of improvements to reusability, mostly from what was learned from the landed cores.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by sethrin on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:09AM (#13829735)
I suspect at this point that Elon's entire goal in naming things these days is to troll people. The naming of his autonomous barges after sentient spacecraft from Iain Banks novels is quite clever, and his announcement of 'The Boring Company' should really put to rest any questions of whether he's messing with us with naming things. I find it quite funny, personally.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by snovv_crash on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:20AM (#13830274)
Also notice the pronunciation Space-sex, and Tesla models s,3,X (he wanted a model E, but settled for 3 after Ford complained). He is clearly trolling.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by kitsunesoba on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:49AM (#13827290)
Even if a booster can only be reused 2-5 times, it's still a dramatic improvement over throwing it away after a single flight and will still have a measurable impact on launch prices. There's also savings to be had by putting all expendable flights on boosters that only have one or two launches left in them.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by XorNot on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:12AM (#13827398)
Seriously. Going from 1 to 2 uses is a massive improvement.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday March 09, 2017 @04:29AM (#13828176)
And being able to decommission, dismantle, inspect, recycle, and safely dispose, rather than throwing them in the ocean.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by TorKlingberg on Thursday March 09, 2017 @04:45AM (#13828233)
I think if they can only get two flights out of a launcher, it will not make economic sense to reuse them. But I think SpaceX will do much better than that.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by Zardoz84 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @06:12AM (#13828518)
cost = cost of single / 2 - cost of prepare the landed first stage

The "cost of prepare the landed first stage" is the big question here.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by simonh on Thursday March 09, 2017 @07:35AM (#13828821)
Plus the cost of the second stage.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by Klathmon on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:39AM (#13829974)
And the additional cost of developing a rocket that can land
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by gozur88 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:17PM (#13831479)
I agree, of course. But the comparison was to commercial air travel.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by stevep98 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:31PM (#13831654)
Recovering the engines allows for inspection and modifying the design to compensate for any problems.

Competitors just dump their flight-tested hardware in the ocean, when it is truly a goldmine of test data.

SpaceX is able to do all this testing with a free ride on paying launches. There's no risk to the primary mission, and they get to develop their capability.

There will be failures with reflown hardware for sure. I'm interested to know how well a failed engine can be isolated in flight so not to affect the others.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by greglindahl on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:37PM (#13832551)
F9 has single-engine-out capability, and it's actually been used. That requires that the failure be contained.

BTW engines are often tested on the ground, so the main extra thing SpaceX learns from landing stages is data from the non-engine components.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by alirazaq on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:11PM (#13826611)
Identifying those points of stress is the first step to building a better launch system.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by gozur88 on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:59PM (#13826853)
Oh, I agree. I just think it's going to be awhile.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by ChuckMcM on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:49AM (#13830489)
Agreed that each re-use lowers their overall operation cost for reaching orbit (and either increases profit or cuts customer cost to orbit depending on what ULA does).

I also find that it is considered 'normal' that if your developing a new orbital booster you should insure that it is re-usable if you want to be competitive. That will put an interesting pressure on Russian launch vehicles if they wish to continue to get international business.

But a critical issue which isn't resolve is 'cycle time.' For this to really be effective you can't spend as much time and money 'refurbishing' a booster as you did building it in the first place. (then re-use just saves materials and maybe time but not cost). Bezos demonstrated some pretty impressive cycle times with the New Shepard, and if they can get those type of cycle times on New Glen (a couple of weeks) they will be more competitive than Falcon 9. Fun times.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by sand500 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:58AM (#13830576)
I think time matters much less than cost because you could just pipeline a bunch of boosters being refurbished. You only have to have a booster ready at the rate it takes to get one of the three pads ready.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by greglindahl on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:51PM (#13832764)
It is nice that Blue Origin is intended to be reusable, but Long March 5/6/7 and Ariane 6 and Vulcan and Angora and GSLV mkIII are all not reusable.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by Coincoin on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @09:44PM (#13826472)
Not all flight plans can lead to a recoverable rocket. GTO and polar orbits can't land back. This means there will be unrecoverable rockets from time to time.

But your question still applies to recoverable flight plans. How many do they need to cover all those?

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by mikeash on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @09:52PM (#13826511)
GTO and polar orbits can still land, they just use the barge ("Autonomous Spaceport Drone Ship") instead of returning to the launch site.

There are launches which don't have enough margin to land at all. The upcoming EchoStar 23 launch is one of these. This is a GTO launch of a really heavy satellite, so getting it up there requires using the fuel the rocket would need to land.

However, this is rare, and it's likely that this will only happen a few more times at most

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by ceejayoz on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:06PM (#13826582)
> However, this is rare, and it's likely that this will only happen a few more times at most

Especially once Falcon Heavy comes online.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by mikeash on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:11PM (#13826610)
Only six more months! As it has been for the last four years....
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by alpos on Thursday March 09, 2017 @09:23AM (#13829418)
I think the key point there is that SpaceX can offer many new options for launch that seriously expand the kinds of contracts they can accept.

If your payload and destination allow for reuse then the cost of your launch is (cost of the whole rocket) / (number of reuses) + (landing & refurbishing costs)

If you require the full fuel of a Falcon 9 it might make sense to accept higher risk and launch on a rocket that is at it's last launch.

If you also don't want that risk, then maybe a mid-life Falcon Heavy can be cheap enough for you.

If Falcon Heavy is still too expensive even with re-use then maybe a one shot Falcon 9 is right for you.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by JshWright on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @09:55PM (#13826533)
Very few of their future flights will be expendable (in fact, the Echostar-23 launch coming up next will likely be one of the last).

The Block 5 upgrade will bring the performance of Falcon 9 (in a recoverable configuration) up to the point where flights like Echostar will be able to make downrange barge landings. Heavier payloads (which are _very_ rare nowadays) will fly on Falcon Heavy.

Polar orbits are almost always low-earth orbits, and therefore are much easier to recover. I would be very surprised if they ever flew an expendable launch out of Vandy in the future.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by rkangel on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:08AM (#13828312)
> Heavier payloads (which are _very_ rare nowadays)

Yes, but how much of that is because there isn't anything to launch them? When Falcon Heavy is up and running, a commercially feasible option will exist for the first time. Maybe that'll change, and we'll start seeing things in space that weren't commercially feasible before.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by JshWright on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:45AM (#13830031)
It's only commercially feasible if SpaceX is willing to sell that service. They are pretty firmly committed to the philosophy of reuse.

They have to fly expendable now, because customers can just fly on Ariane/Atlas/etc if SpaceX said no. Once Falcon Heavy is flying, there won't be any competitors with the same payload capacity (until New Glenn, which is also planning first stage reuse, but is still very much a paper rocket at this point).

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by WesleyLivesay on Thursday March 09, 2017 @07:52AM (#13828902)
There will always be payload that pushes the rocket to its limits, make a rocket with larger lift capacity and payloads will increase.

However, they can build that into the cost of the lift. If the rocket isn't recoverable because of what they want to put in it, just charge them for the rocket.

Either way it is better than what we have now.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by JshWright on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:47AM (#13830041)
Maybe... Elon is pretty firmly committed to reuse though. SpaceX is occasionally flying expendable now because they have to compete with Ariane and Atlas. Once Falcon Heavy flies, there won't be any such pressure.
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by LoSboccacc on Thursday March 09, 2017 @08:28AM (#13829059)
yeah if computer ram size growth taught me anything is that once there's capacity, there'll be consumption.

/me looks sternly at DooM

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by avian on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:11AM (#13827637)
From which flight was the one that is too beat up to be reused? What happened?
Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by ygra on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:30AM (#13828377)
JCSAT-14. It was the first successful landing after a GTO launch and it came down quite hard. GTO launches have the first stage come back quite a bit faster and with less fuel margin than LEO launches. See for example the SES-9 launch where landing failed due to too little fuel being left.

While SpaceX opted to test this core to the breaking point, they also noted that it could have been reused despite the damage. But having a core that represents more or less the worst damage possible while still being able to refly it is valuable in itself and for comparing other landed cores against.

They have since fired the engines for numerous full-duration burns at their test site and presumably nothing exploded yet. This doesn't tell much about aerodynamic stresses imposed, but at least the engines and tanks are seemingly good to go with minimal refurbishment for a few reflights at least.

Re:SpaceX Will Launch Its First Reused Rocket Later This Month by mrexroad on Thursday March 09, 2017 @04:15AM (#13828139)
It landed too hard iirc.