News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by quanticle on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:40AM (#13762528)
I have to disagree. I think cars have pretty great UX. Do you remember learning to drive? At any point, was there any doubt as to what turning the steering wheel right or left would do? At any point, was there any doubt as to what the pedals did? Or the gear shifter? Or turn signals? The easiest, most intuitive software wishes it could be as immediately understandable as the control system for an automobile.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Arizhel on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:11PM (#13765683)
Much of that stuff has been standardized over a century. They weren't always that way on all cars.

For example, you cite the steering wheel as intuitive and obvious. It's actually not: in many early cars, there was no steering wheel. They had a "tiller" instead (a lever that you pushed from side to side to steer). There was a huge debate at the time over whether tillers or steering wheels were better. Obviously, the steering wheel won out, but if you could transport some people from 1895 to today, they'll complain that tillers should have been used instead.

The gear shifter is another example. If you drive a stick, you probably take it for granted that the gearshift is a lever in the middle between the seats. It wasn't that long ago that some cars and trucks had "3 on the column": the gearshift (manual transmission) was on the steering column. And automatic transmission gearshifts on the column persisted much longer than that; I think it took until the 90s for them to finally die out.

Turn signals aren't that obvious either; you're just used to them. My mom got a ticket in 1965 because her boss gave her his car keys to drive his car somewhere nearby. She had never driven a car before, only ridden as a passenger, but of course didn't tell him this because it would look really bad. She managed driving it ok (steering, gas), probably because she had watched others do it, but she screwed up with the turn signals and signaled the wrong direction for a turn while a cop was looking.

Most "intuitive" things aren't intuitive at all; people are just used to them because they're more or less standardized, and people have gotten used to them or have watched other people use them and learned that way. Take some primitive person from the Amazon rainforest who's never even seen a car and stick him in one (on a closed track) and see how well he figures out how to operate it. If he can't figure it out very quickly with zero instruction, then it's not "intuitive".

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by jdhzzz on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:50PM (#13766219)
I just drove a 2006ish BMW and was confused at the turn signal as it didn't "click in" when pushed up or down but immediately returned to center. It operated correctly though, turning off when the turn was completed.

Also the windshield wiper control was "opposite" of what I am accustomed to: down was pulse and up was constant. I got mad the first two times I wanted pulse but then realized it was better as my right hand is typically above the stalk on the steering wheel and it is much easier to simply swipe down than have to swipe down then up.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:19PM (#13770145)
My car was built in Europe so the turn signals are to the left of the wheel and the wiper controls on the right.

I'm used to it now but I can't tell you how many times I put the wipers on instead of indicating when I first got the car.

The car is a right-hand drive car (I'm in Australia) and a manual, so I actually think it's a bit stupid because both the gearstick and the indicator are on the left side of the steering wheel.

So it's not really possible to indicate while changing gears.

Perhaps that is part of the reason that people with European cars are so infamous for not indicating!

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Arizhel on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:46PM (#13770675)
Unlikely. All the European cars I've seen also have the signals on the left stalk. However, this is the US, where the steering wheel is also on the left.

It sounds like your car cheaped out and kept the same control layout for both LHD and RHD versions. Having never driven in a LHD country, I have no idea what other car companies do about this.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by brokenmachine on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:28PM (#13800707)
I suspect you're right about them cheaping out on my car, but I have also driven a LHD Audi that had the same setup. So it might be common to cheap out in that way.

Can any other LHD people with european cars comment? Are your indicators on the left side of the steering wheel also?

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Avernar on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:53PM (#13766251)
Can you imagine a head on collision with a tiller instead of a wheel? Especially before seat belts became mandatory.

And forget about an air bag in there. Might as well put a bullet in there instead and finish off he driver before he impaled himself.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Arizhel on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @01:57PM (#13766979)
I never said it really was superior, just that some people (living around 1900) thought so. Also, we're talking about how "intuitive" a user interface is here, not about the safety implications. It took many decades for cars to finally get airbags, collapsible steering columns, etc. It was quite routine for people to be impaled on steering columns until the late 20th century.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Avernar on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @03:00PM (#13767682)
I wasn't arguing about superiority. It was just a though of what things would be like if it had gone the other way.

Speaking of intuitive, a tiller on a car is only intuitive if you've used it on a boat. Pushing the lever in the opposite direction of where you want to go is counter-intuitive.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by technofiend on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:57PM (#13766314)
My wife's favorite aunt lost her first husband to exactly that: he was impaled by a tiller. Gruesome.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by douche on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:40AM (#13762767)
No, but I was learning on an 1985 Ford F150 with a 5-speed manual transmission. There were so few controls available that my lawn mower was more complex.

My 2010 F150 now has a baffling array of buttons and switches and extra levers hanging off the steering column. It's a crapshoot getting in a strange car and figuring out how the headlights and windshield wipers work in particular.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by VLM on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:52AM (#13763274)
Cruise control and audio and sometimes hazard lights too.

There's a classic Star Trek movie scene where helmsman Sulu is trying to fly a helicopter, I believe in the movie with the whales, and the helicopter stick controls do the car thing of randomly turning on windshield wipers and things.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by jabl on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:50PM (#13766228)
When I was a kid, I couldn't for the life of me figure out how my parents knew which way to operate the turn signals. It was to me unintuitive as the lever was operated up/down whereas the turn lights were right/left, and as on the car we had back then (a Saab 96, IIRC) the instrument panel had only a single blinking light for when either turn signal was enabled, instead of separate left and right turn signal lights.

But yeah, IIRC there has been research suggesting that cognitive load on aircraft pilots in old-fashioned aircraft (lots of separate switches and gauges) is lower than in modern aircraft with touchscreens.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by iainmerrick on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:12AM (#13764877)
Steering wheel and pedals, sure. Gearstick, mostly, although the positioning of reverse is different in different cars, and often there's a little trick to engaging it (push the stick down, or pull up a ring just under the handle). The shifter on automatics is often weird (but at least you never have to use it while driving).

Headlights, wipers, cruise control, trip indicator, window controls, A/C, radio -- all different on different cars.

Even the turn signals can vary. If I'm signalling left and want to turn it off, I expect to be able to cancel the signal by clicking the lever upwards, but I've driven cars where that causes it to signal right instead.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by wiredfool on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:33AM (#13763168)
Ah yes. Shifters.

Have you ever driven a three on the tree? Or where is reverse on my Renault Grand Scenic, with a 6sp manual and no markings on the shifter?

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by acomjean on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:00AM (#13763317)
Shifters with the various "reverse lockout features".

I remember being flagged down in a mall parking lot, and being asked why they couldn't shift into reverse (this shifter required being physically pushed down to move).

I had a GTI with the shifter lockout was broken (reverse all the way left and up, where 1st is..)

Whats three on the tree?

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by steverb on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:46AM (#13763571)
Three on the tree is a three speed manual with the shifter mounted on the steering column.

Saw it a fair bit on older sedans. I think the intent was to not have the shifter in the floor so you could get that big front bench seat.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by amyjess on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:04AM (#13764170)
I grew up in cars with column shifters and front bench seats, but they were all automatic (my mom had a 1985 Oldsmobile Ninety-Eight Regency (lemon!) and a 1993 Pontiac Bonneville SE). I can't imagine the awkwardness of operating a manual in that position.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Arizhel on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:14PM (#13765727)
Well it was quite common in 1960s pickup trucks.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by jessaustin on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:27AM (#13763467)
That would be a 3-speed manual with the shift lever on the steering column. I never understood how all those complicated linkages from the column down to the transmission ever seemed like a good idea to an engineer...
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by peckrob on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:26AM (#13765061)
When I worked for the Park Service, we had this positively ancient Chevy van we inherited from the Air Force. Thing was older than me, I think. No one knew exactly how many miles it actually had on it because the odometer only had five spaces.

Anyways, it had a 3-speed column shifter, and the top linkage off the column would often pop out first thing in the morning. You could tell when it happened because it would just shift with no effort, but you wouldn't move. Then, you'd have to pop the hood and fiddle with it until you got the link reconnected.

I'm glad 3-speed column shifters are gone.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by fr0sty on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:42AM (#13764544)
I had an '82 Chevy pickup with that shifter arrangement and it actually wasn't that bad even though the bushings had long fallen out all the joints so there was a good inch of slop in the travel of each of the arms.

Still shifted fine. Unless you didn't get it all the way engaged and the gears would bounce instead of mesh and jam the transmission into 2nd and 3rd at the same time requiring you go get out, open the hood and give the control linkage a good yank before continuing.

Still miss that truck...

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by jessaustin on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:16AM (#13764927)
Haha I have enough problems with the shift linkages on an old tractor of mine, on which the shift levers are located 4" above the transmission. I'd hate to have to deal with what you're describing here...
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by jschwartzi on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:44AM (#13764560)
It's pretty good in an automatic since there are only 3 or 4 positions people use, and it isn't moved while the car is moving.
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by ptaipale on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:14AM (#13763401)
Renault has a bit of history with slightly exotic controls. Take for example the Renault 4 shifter: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Renault4inside.JPG

When I got a ride from a friend long time ago, I was puzzled by how that operates. And, of course, there were two different W patterns manufactured at different times: one where R is top-left, and one where R is bottom-right (pictured above).

However, with modern Renault shifters you can't put it into reverse when you didn't intend to, because there's that ring that you lift before it goes to R.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by arethuza on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:10AM (#13764224)
Many years ago we had a Renault 4 hire care in Morocco and my wife was driving and she wasn't happy using that control so she got me, the passenger, to change gear.

She'd hit the clutch, shout the gear she wanted ("Second"), I'd change gear, she'd put the clutch in and on we'd go....

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:22PM (#13770157)
I hope you didn't have to do any hill starts...
Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by ptaipale on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:45AM (#13771755)
Changing gears is not a problem for hill starts, you start in 1st gear anyway.

Using handbrake to assist hill start could be a problem, but not in Renault 4, where it might actually be more feasible for a passenger to operate the lever: https://pim.famnit.upr.si/blog/uploads/Interfaces/hand-brake...

However, in modern Renaults some models (Scenic) have an electric handbrake near the driver door, where the passenger possibly cannot reach it. The electric handbrake is a hill start assist as such, though. And it's one of those electric subsystems that can break, is necessary for the annual MOT check, and is very expensive to fix... (900 € for the part, plus cost of work).

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by wiredfool on Thursday March 02, 2017 @08:38AM (#13773881)
And all of the special electrical thingies in my Renault are keyed to the VIN, so you can't get a used/refurb part, they've got to be new. And the Renault dealer is the only one that can program the VIN into the part.

I think my electric hand brake was 660€, but I've got a mechanic who's good at finding parts. But he still had to take it to the Renault dealer for programming.

And it relies on a 161€ clutch position sensor (which is different than the interlock for startup sensor)

Mechanically, Renaults seem pretty good. Electrically, I'm not so sure.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by brokenmachine on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:25PM (#13800692)
> Changing gears is not a problem for hill starts, you start in 1st gear anyway.

True, but in my car with a pretty slow first gear, on a steep hill you need to be pretty fast with the change from first to second.

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by arethuza on Thursday March 02, 2017 @03:37AM (#13772611)
I actually don't remember too many problems - we drove from Marrakesh over the Atlas mountains and stayed at Ouarzazate for a while before driving back.

The problem we did have was caused by a lack of clarity as to whose responsibility it was to keep an eye on the fuel gauge... :-)

Re:Why Some Cars Have Gas Tank Fillers on the Left or the Right by Stoo on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:38AM (#13764492)
And the interface is fundamentally the same, no matter who made the car.