Birthright citizenship isn't even universal. For example, birthright citizenship does not apply to diplomats. And the language of the 14th amendment, as to whether it applies to illegal aliens, has never been tested at the Supreme Court level. The key phrase being "and subject to the juridiction thereof". It's certainly at least questionable that children of citizens of other countries born here are subject to our jurisdiction.
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.
Earlier drafts of the amendment read differently; for instance, "of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty". That the language didn't survive is telling. More telling is the debate about native American tribal sovereignty, in which context the jurisdictional limit makes sense: in effect, you're a citizen if you're born in the US and not subject to the laws of a native American tribe (SCOTUS acknowledged this, in a birthright citizenship case: Elk v Wilkins).
Wong Kim Ark is clearer about this: "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is a minimalistic way of expressing "everyone born here" except:
* Members of Indian tribes
* Children born of alien enemies in a hostile occupation
* Children of diplomatic representatives of a foreign state
In all three cases you have classes of people who are not just aliens, but aliens formally exempted while in the country from some or all of US law. Hence: subject to jurisdiction.
So I think we can put to rest the idea that this has gone untested by the Supreme Court.
Regardless, the (relatively recent) notion that you can negate ~150 years of birthright citizenship by parsing "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is about as credible as the idea that we can ban guns because of the 2nd Amendment's "in a well-regulated militia" qualifier.
It's certainly not unique. It's the norm in the Americas, including for example Canada: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli
> It's certainly at least questionable that children of citizens of other countries born here are subject to our jurisdiction.
Some people question whether you have to pay income tax too.
Jus soli in the United States is long since settled legal doctrine. Changing it would require a constitutional amendment.
That's a matter of opinion. "Settled legal doctrine" changes all the time. Every administration advances their own agendas by changing the context and arguments or straight up defying a prior decisions. Stating a "my best guess is it needs an amendament" is the only thing that can be said. This is not the same as saying "can't happen without an amendment".
Can you think of one with as strong a constitutional basis as birthright citizenship that "changes all the time"? The US government under multiple administrations struggled mightily for decades to revoke the citizenship of a single naturalized Nazi. No administration has the slightest chance of depriving millions of current citizens of citizenship by having strong feelings about it.
"If a baby with foreign parents is born on a plane flying above the United States, the baby is automatically granted American citizenship. However, if the baby is born while flying over the ocean, its nationality depends on the country from which the plane is registered."
I'm really not interested in the rest of your argument.
No, there are cities that refuse to expend local resources enforcing federal immigration law, leaving that enforcement to the feds.
This is not refusing to obey federal immigration law; in fact, the freedom of states (and therefore subordinate entities like cities, if not prohibited by state law) to refuse to enforce federal law is inherent in the Constitutional separation of state and federal spheres of sovereignty. This freedom was the basis of laws adopted by numerous states prohibiting state enforcement of the federal Fugitive Slave Laws in the wake of the Supreme Court decision in Prigg v. Pennsylvania (1842).
For example, most laws are enforced unevenly and incompletely. Insider trading, for example, is widely practiced and rarely punished (EDIT: AFAIK, but I've seen plenty of serious evidence of it). Speeding, labor laws (making people work off-the-books, ignoring overtime, etc.), sexual assault rarely results in conviction, burglary, illegal activities by government itself (politicians, law enforcement, etc.).
To be incensed that immigration laws are not enforced completely seems disingenuous. That doesn't mean there are no issues to address regarding immigration, but I don't believe the issue is the rule of law. (In fact, to be incensed about anything is a good sign that there's not a lot of reason behind it - anger is cover for lack of reason and is a propaganda tool.)
It's particularly sad that people want to enforce the law on the weak and poor, the 'war on drugs' is another example, and not the people who can defend themselves and who are doing far more damage.
I'll bet $1000 that everyone concerned about illegal migration would absolutely support going after crooked bankers.
Nobody will do it for them, certainly not Trump, and not Hillary - the Clintons are very deeply in the pockets of the banks.
Surely Sanders would - he's a good antagonist, but he's not quite the guy America would elect.
And 'the war on drugs' is very real, your statement is very unsympathetic to those who have lost lives and friends. Opiate overdoes - often from prescription drugs are a really huge problem, same with Meth. Even if drug use were treated as a medical issue and not a criminal one - the 'war on drugs' would still continue against dealers, and as the health community fights addiction.
This isn't evidence.
> 'the war on drugs' is very real
I'm not sure what that means. Certainly it's a real policy and there are real problems with drugs that should be addressed. The policy hasn't seemed effective, and has caused great harm to very large numbers of people - as is often the case, the poor and defenseless.
Join a finance firm and tell that to your compliance department, they'll get a kick out of it.
https://www.sec.gov/about/offices/owb/owb-tips.shtml
So, yes, I'd say that people with direct knowledge of actual insider trading have a strong incentive to report it. Quite different from petty crime in a town (or immigration), where nobody is really incentivized to do much about it until it gets really bad.
We're talking theoretically: Your point is one factor. Another is the profit from insider trading may far exceed the reward. Also, people who report it must become 'rats'; they risk sending their coworkers (and possibly friends) to jail, never working again on Wall Street, being completely ostracized socially and in the industry, and having the reputation of a traitor.
But again, that's theoretical. I don't believe I know how it works in practice without some good inside sources.
As far as being a rat 1). you can face prosecution for being aware of insider trading without reporting it and 2). anyone who's convicted legally cannot work for any SEC regulated institution ever again.
I'm sure some people do insider trading and get away with it, but some people also rob banks and get away with it. I just don't see any evidence pointing to the prosecution of it being lax.
That's just one example, and probably not a representative one, being a high-profile case. Sometimes they are made examples of.
> Risk v. reward skews heavily towards risk. ... I just don't see any evidence pointing to the prosecution of it being lax.
I don't see much evidence either way except for the SEC's billions in fines which someone cited above, which necessarily mean that it's happening in large volumes.
If you want hard data, in 2016 the SEC handed out $4B in fines: https://www.sec.gov/news/pressrelease/2016-212.html
> If you want hard data, in 2016 the SEC handed out $4B in fines
Possibly a sign that it's still widespread; and the SEC can't catch everyone, so more must be going on.
Let's see: You can't work for any large employer, as e-verify will likely catch you or else you will have to resort to organized crime to borrow someone's identity, at a price. You will not be able to travel, let alone internationally, but not even out of the city, without putting yourself at risk. Even staying put and the city being a sanctuary city doesn't prevent you from looking over your shoulder your entire life, because an ICE agent might still decide to deport you with or without cooperation from the local police. If you are ever detained under suspicious of a crime, however minor (speeding, jaywalking), you could be deported, even in a sanctuary city. A speeding ticket is an inconvenience for most people I know, but for an undocumented worker it can mean losing a life that they have built over 20+ years. It is literally signing up for being a second class person in a place where your entire life can be upended without notice and where your ability to plan your life or move around is severely limited.
People like me put up with the legal visa process, but I would never put up with what the undocumented population goes through. I have plenty of options that would be more attractive to me than doing that, both in my country of origin and elsewhere around the world. The reason they put up with that? In many cases they are running away from actual life-threatening violence and destitution caused by a drug of wars fought with American weapons over access to the American drug-consumers market (because, yeah, that whole narrative of "they have a lot of problems and they are bringing them here!" fails to account that a lot of those problems exist only due to proximity and relations with the U.S., even when they are not a matter of official U.S. policy).
Unless you want to have a career, make money, or succeed instead of merely survive. Then, doing it legally is pretty obviously the way to go.