News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by tptacek on Friday February 24, 2017 @04:42PM (#13728188)
Children born in this country are American citizens, entitled to all the rights and privileges generations of American citizens, a great many of them immigrants themselves, fought and died for. If you object to that, take up your case with the US Constitution, not the major cities of America.
Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by jquery on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:36PM (#13728578)
USA's birthright citizenship is somewhat unique amongst countries. There's nothing wrong with questioning whether continuing the policy is good for America with the considerable amount of illegal immigration we have (estimates are that 7.5% of American citizens are born to illegal aliens).

Birthright citizenship isn't even universal. For example, birthright citizenship does not apply to diplomats. And the language of the 14th amendment, as to whether it applies to illegal aliens, has never been tested at the Supreme Court level. The key phrase being "and subject to the juridiction thereof". It's certainly at least questionable that children of citizens of other countries born here are subject to our jurisdiction.

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by tptacek on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:39PM (#13728594)
The Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment reads, plainly:

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Earlier drafts of the amendment read differently; for instance, "of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty". That the language didn't survive is telling. More telling is the debate about native American tribal sovereignty, in which context the jurisdictional limit makes sense: in effect, you're a citizen if you're born in the US and not subject to the laws of a native American tribe (SCOTUS acknowledged this, in a birthright citizenship case: Elk v Wilkins).

Wong Kim Ark is clearer about this: "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is a minimalistic way of expressing "everyone born here" except:

* Members of Indian tribes

* Children born of alien enemies in a hostile occupation

* Children of diplomatic representatives of a foreign state

In all three cases you have classes of people who are not just aliens, but aliens formally exempted while in the country from some or all of US law. Hence: subject to jurisdiction.

So I think we can put to rest the idea that this has gone untested by the Supreme Court.

Regardless, the (relatively recent) notion that you can negate ~150 years of birthright citizenship by parsing "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is about as credible as the idea that we can ban guns because of the 2nd Amendment's "in a well-regulated militia" qualifier.

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by pcwalton on Friday February 24, 2017 @06:06PM (#13728773)
> USA's birthright citizenship is somewhat unique amongst countries.

It's certainly not unique. It's the norm in the Americas, including for example Canada: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli

> It's certainly at least questionable that children of citizens of other countries born here are subject to our jurisdiction.

Some people question whether you have to pay income tax too.

Jus soli in the United States is long since settled legal doctrine. Changing it would require a constitutional amendment.

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by jack9 on Friday February 24, 2017 @06:36PM (#13728963)
> Changing it would require a constitutional amendment.

That's a matter of opinion. "Settled legal doctrine" changes all the time. Every administration advances their own agendas by changing the context and arguments or straight up defying a prior decisions. Stating a "my best guess is it needs an amendament" is the only thing that can be said. This is not the same as saying "can't happen without an amendment".

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by pvg on Friday February 24, 2017 @07:47PM (#13729317)
"Settled legal doctrine" changes all the time.

Can you think of one with as strong a constitutional basis as birthright citizenship that "changes all the time"? The US government under multiple administrations struggled mightily for decades to revoke the citizenship of a single naturalized Nazi. No administration has the slightest chance of depriving millions of current citizens of citizenship by having strong feelings about it.

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by ng12 on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:47PM (#13728655)
What does "born in this country" mean? If a baby is born during a layover at JFK is it an American?
Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by ardit33 on Friday February 24, 2017 @06:25PM (#13728883)
Yep, even if the plane has not landed yet.

"If a baby with foreign parents is born on a plane flying above the United States, the baby is automatically granted American citizenship. However, if the baby is born while flying over the ocean, its nationality depends on the country from which the plane is registered."

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by tptacek on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:54PM (#13728706)
Yes.
Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by xienze on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:13PM (#13728426)
That has nothing to do with the fact that if you are an illegal immigrant yourself there are cities in this country that refuse to obey immigration law. Again, the point is "why bother" if there are politicians and cities willing to bend over backwards for you.
Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by tptacek on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:28PM (#13728521)
I don't know what you're on about now, but a big chunk of your last comment talked about the advantages that accrue to children born in the United States. Regardless of the circumstances of those children, they are American citizens, full stop. They "get to use our schools" because they're citizens. They "get in-state tuition" because they are citizens. That is how citizenship works in the US: we don't have two classes of it.

I'm really not interested in the rest of your argument.

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by dragonwriter on Friday February 24, 2017 @06:13PM (#13728827)
> That has nothing to do with the fact that if you are an illegal immigrant yourself there are cities in this country that refuse to obey immigration law.

No, there are cities that refuse to expend local resources enforcing federal immigration law, leaving that enforcement to the feds.

This is not refusing to obey federal immigration law; in fact, the freedom of states (and therefore subordinate entities like cities, if not prohibited by state law) to refuse to enforce federal law is inherent in the Constitutional separation of state and federal spheres of sovereignty. This freedom was the basis of laws adopted by numerous states prohibiting state enforcement of the federal Fugitive Slave Laws in the wake of the Supreme Court decision in Prigg v. Pennsylvania (1842).

Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1 by charlesdm on Friday February 24, 2017 @07:33PM (#13729258)
They also receive the right to pay US taxes and file US tax forms, regardless of where they reside and what their parents' actual nationality is.