Re:Borderwise: App and a lawyer for immigrants, for $1
by tptacek on Friday February 24, 2017 @05:39PM
(#13728594)
The Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment reads, plainly:
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.
Earlier drafts of the amendment read differently; for instance, "of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty". That the language didn't survive is telling. More telling is the debate about native American tribal sovereignty, in which context the jurisdictional limit makes sense: in effect, you're a citizen if you're born in the US and not subject to the laws of a native American tribe (SCOTUS acknowledged this, in a birthright citizenship case: Elk v Wilkins).
Wong Kim Ark is clearer about this: "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is a minimalistic way of expressing "everyone born here" except:
* Members of Indian tribes
* Children born of alien enemies in a hostile occupation
* Children of diplomatic representatives of a foreign state
In all three cases you have classes of people who are not just aliens, but aliens formally exempted while in the country from some or all of US law. Hence: subject to jurisdiction.
So I think we can put to rest the idea that this has gone untested by the Supreme Court.
Regardless, the (relatively recent) notion that you can negate ~150 years of birthright citizenship by parsing "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is about as credible as the idea that we can ban guns because of the 2nd Amendment's "in a well-regulated militia" qualifier.
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.
Earlier drafts of the amendment read differently; for instance, "of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty". That the language didn't survive is telling. More telling is the debate about native American tribal sovereignty, in which context the jurisdictional limit makes sense: in effect, you're a citizen if you're born in the US and not subject to the laws of a native American tribe (SCOTUS acknowledged this, in a birthright citizenship case: Elk v Wilkins).
Wong Kim Ark is clearer about this: "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is a minimalistic way of expressing "everyone born here" except:
* Members of Indian tribes
* Children born of alien enemies in a hostile occupation
* Children of diplomatic representatives of a foreign state
In all three cases you have classes of people who are not just aliens, but aliens formally exempted while in the country from some or all of US law. Hence: subject to jurisdiction.
So I think we can put to rest the idea that this has gone untested by the Supreme Court.
Regardless, the (relatively recent) notion that you can negate ~150 years of birthright citizenship by parsing "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is about as credible as the idea that we can ban guns because of the 2nd Amendment's "in a well-regulated militia" qualifier.