It's bizarre that people worship it, but then again, simplicity has always beat having to think.
It's pretty good over populations, and is pretty good even on lots of individuals. Body fat percentage and lean mass might be better but they're much harder and more expensive to measure (particularly accurately).
BMI is still a pretty good proxy measurement. There's a very high correlation between BMI and body fat content. People like to complain that BMI is useless because a few weightlifters show up as "obese" but those are so rare as to be statistically insignificant.
A good explanation I saw is that if you care what your BMI is you probably aren't a weightlifter
Why do you think how our body evolved is related to longevity ?
I'd at least say I don't see a strong evolutionary pressure for extended lifespans.
Also, a reproductive pair with living post reproductive (but still not decrepit) parents can breed at a higher rate as they are can delegate some childcare to them.
Why not both ?
Relatively high calorie diet, over the long run, to support strength training and a high level of exercise ... but regular (weekly ? twice-weekly ?) fasting to partake in what appear to be the benefits of forcing your body to change gears and clean house (so to speak).
You can have a relatively high calorie diet measured over the course of a week or a month while still fasting regularly.
What doesn't make sense to me is that exercise is known to be healthy but it will always lead to an increase in calorie consumption especially cardiovascular. When you exercise you are expending more energy so that means you need to take in more energy or calories.
But will strength training not wear out the joints?
For example strengthening your thighs reduces stresses on your knees. At least according to my orthopaedic specialist.
It turns out, after reading up on it, unilateral leg strength is important for knee health. The right muscles being strong and coordinated takes stress off the tendons, ligaments, and cartilage that support the knee. Doing one leg squats teaches and trains your glutes to balance and stabilize your body on one leg.
[1] For an unrelated experiement.
For awhile now, the "obesity paradox" has been a thing, where segments of the population who are a little heavier than one would expect actually have the best all-cause mortality rates.
Recently there's been some pushback on this "paradox", but the one I want to call attention to is here:
http://annals.org/aim/article/2499472/relationship-among-bod...
The problem with the obesity paradox is that it's been based on the flawed BMI. In this study, they actually did DEXA scans of elderly women's body fat percentage, and those with the highest BMI and lowest body fat percentage had the best all-cause mortality rates.
This suggests plenty of calories plus strength training is in the running for a longevity lifestyle. This makes sense intuitively and if one is familiar with the panoply of beneficial physiological effects from exercise on the human body. And, it would not come as a shock to find that increased strength from greater muscle improves, e.g., balance and coordination to prevent accidents in the elderly, nor that increased muscle mass provides a protective tissue reserve for fighting disease without the concomitant downsides of adipose.