News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer Science Education by m0nty on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:09AM (#13549674)
Looks great if you're Indian, Irish or female.

Edit: Or AU/NZ, missed that one.

Re:Computer Science Education by dotancohen on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:35AM (#13549781)
I don't see why this rather insightful post is downvoted. The site specifically targets these groups by name.

Why in the age of a _World_ Wide Web and "post-discrimination" are large companies such as Google deliberately targeting specific groups? What will be in the girls-only code program that might be inappropriate for boys?

Re:Computer Science Education by hdctambien on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:06AM (#13549935)
> Why ... are large companies such as Google deliberately targeting specific groups?

Large companies are judged by the diversity of their employees. They want to hire more women. In order to hire more women, there needs to be more qualified women applying for jobs. In order for there to be more qualified women applying for jobs, there needs to be more qualified women. In order for there to be more qualified women we need to be teaching more girls how to program.

> What will be in the girls-only code program that might be inappropriate for boys?

It's more about what won't be in those classes, specifically: inappropriate boys.

One school of thought about why there are less girls in computer science classes is that the environment/culture? of the currently self-selected students can sometimes (seem) abrasive and uninviting.

Maybe that is just a stereotype, but offering classes specifically for underrepresented demographics is at least a method to test that theory.

Re:Computer Science Education by titraprutr on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:19AM (#13550008)
> Large companies are judged by the diversity of their employees

And here is the problem - diversity has become a goal rather than a natural consequence of everyone having equal chances.

It's not the lack of diversity that those companies should focus on - much more important is an elimination of any kind of discrimination based on gender/race/religion etc.

Re:Computer Science Education by hdctambien on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:51AM (#13550144)
I see it as more of a temporary compensation for earlier gender based biases.

In a world where boys and girls are given the same opportunities at (even) younger ages, you wouldn't need something like this.

As it stands right now, it is intimidating for a girl to sign up for her first computer science class knowing that it will be full of boys that have been encouraged to do computer sciencey things from an earlier age. There is the perception that the girl will come in at a disadvantage.

Allowing a them to sign up for a class with the perception that they all have equal footing/previous knowledge could give them the confidence they need to join the classes with boys that are perceived to have more experience.

When the time comes that girls are signing up for computer science classes at the same rate as boys, then classes like this would no longer be necessary.

That being said, public schools cannot create X-only classes. There is no discrimination in which students can signup for my computer science classes and I have unfortunately low female enrollment.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:38AM (#13550760)
> I see it as more of a temporary compensation for earlier gender based biases.

So you tolerate that a complete sex shall be punished for former sins. Clearly not my sense of justice.

> In a world where boys and girls are given the same opportunities at (even) younger ages, you wouldn't need something like this.

Everybody can use the internet to learn coding. But at least to me it seems that mostly boys (with few exceptions) seem to love doing this - in particular from young age on.

Re:Computer Science Education by hdctambien on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:34AM (#13551173)
> So you tolerate that a complete sex shall be punished for former sins

This is not a zero-sum game. Creating a new opportunity for girls does not remove an existing opportunity for a boy.

> But at least to me it seems that mostly boys (with few exceptions) seem to love doing this - in particular from young age on

Maybe you should try talking to more girls and asking them what they are interested in.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:40AM (#13551245)
> > So you tolerate that a complete sex shall be punished for former sins

> This is not a zero-sum game. Creating a new opportunity for girls does not remove an existing opportunity for a boy.

Not when quotas are involved. In Germany, where I live, every few years serious attempts to introduce women quota for companies are attempted to pass as a law (which typically are only prevented in the last moment because of massive protests of business associations).

Re:Computer Science Education by metaobject on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:12AM (#13551569)
So are there any gender quotas currently in place?
Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:33AM (#13551798)
Some political parties already have quotas in their statutes for a long time (Die Grünen (Green Party) - 50%; SPD - 30% I think).

Since Januar 2016 gender quotas for the supervisory council of the 106 largest market-listed companies were introduced. For restaffing in the supervisory council there is a quota of 30% for both gender (or the position has to be left vacant).

Wikipedia link:

> https://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Frauenquote&oldid...

Here a Reuters article about the topic:

> http://web.archive.org/web/20160619090749/http://de.reuters....

Here an "official" article by the Federal Minestry for Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth ["Federal Minestry for everybody except men" ;-) ]:

> https://www.bmfsfj.de/bmfsfj/themen/gleichstellung/frauen-un...

Re:Computer Science Education by FT_intern on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:19PM (#13552256)
> This is not a zero-sum game. Creating a new opportunity for girls does not remove an existing opportunity for a boy.

Head count is orthogonal to gender make up of the company

Re:Computer Science Education by cdmcmahon on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:22PM (#13552304)
> So you tolerate that a complete sex shall be punished for former sins.

You are not inoculated from the past sins of gender discrimination. So simply because you did not discriminate does not mean you did not benefit from past discrimination. While this fact should not be used to hold you accountable, it should be used to pursue policies that offset that advantage.

A company offering a program for girls is not punishing boys. It's giving girls a boost that was given to boys of previous generations.

Simply giving equal opportunity after decades (longer, really) of inequality is not truly equal. As an analogy, imagine if a government gave extremely preferential treatment to one company over another for an extended period of time (lower taxes, looser regulation, etc.) and all of the sudden started treating the two companies the same. Would you expect them to have an equal chance of success? Surely the accumulated benefits of the one company would still provide a significant advantage that would have to be remedied before the companies have an equal chance of success.

Edit: I realize I assumed you are male, which your comment does not state. Mea culpa. Read this comment as directed at any male who opposes policies that promote gender equality in STEM education.

Re:Computer Science Education by reitanqild on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:27AM (#13550678)
of boys that have been encouraged to do computer sciencey things from an earlier age.

YMMW but IIRC my experience has been a bit different :-/

Edit: added IIRC

Re:Computer Science Education by FT_intern on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:17PM (#13552240)
>I see it as more of a temporary compensation for earlier gender based biases.

That hasn't been proven or quantified. If you're going to use sexism to fix perceived sexism, you should quantify and prove the original sexism first.

Re:Computer Science Education by sh_tinh_hair on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:13AM (#13550577)
Apologetics only gets you so far. In this case I don't care for the attempt. Let those who have an interest take advantage and the rest catch as catch can. This marketed approach is badly conceived.
Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:54AM (#13551374)
You cannot stop an object in motion without applying a force in the direction opposite the motion. And you cannot eliminate a large scale social trend by declaring it over.
Re:Computer Science Education by NetStrikeForce on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:09AM (#13550549)
> And here is the problem - diversity has become a goal rather than a natural consequence of everyone having equal chances.

And here is the problem - people think diversity is a goal per se, while it is actually a competitive advantage.

Re:Computer Science Education by RUG3Y on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:48AM (#13551314)
It's a wrong assumption that diversity of demographics is the same as diversity of thought. It's also wrong to assume that a lack of diversity in demographics automatically equates to a lack of diversity in thought.

A competitive advantage would be gained through diversity of thought. Making gender, skin color or any other superficial characteristic into a numbers game in order to look diverse is in no way a competitive advantage.

Re:Computer Science Education by NetStrikeForce on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:44PM (#13554990)
> It's a wrong assumption that diversity of demographics is the same as diversity of thought. It's also wrong to assume that a lack of diversity in demographics automatically equates to a lack of diversity in thought. > A competitive advantage would be gained through diversity of thought. Making gender, skin color or any other superficial characteristic into a numbers game in order to look diverse is in no way a competitive advantage.

Well, not really. I mean, not at all. I appreciate you took your time to tell me I'm wrong, but you might want to support it with something more solid. Diversity of thought is not just what happens when you get two people together. If those people have a very similar upbringing, chances are they think in a similar way. They might reach different conclusions and one of them might reach the right one, but they might be missing points of view that could increase their accuracy when making decisions.

Your upbringing shapes how you think, what you fear, what you wish. Of course even inside the same communities very similar people might have completely different trains of thought, but what you call "superficial characteristics" as gender or skin colour it is (unfortunately) not superficial in many places. Many men can't even imagine the things a woman has to endure at the workplace, or your skin colour when you're a minority.

Even things like being a native speaker of a foreign tongue shapes how you think. The culture of your hometown, province, region, country defines you, too.

If you've lived a different life because of your gender, ethnicity, passport, disability, country of birth or even family wealth chances are you can bring quite different points of view than people with different gender, ethnicity, passport, disability, country of birth or even family wealth.

There are studies that show correlation between higher diversity and better performance (Forbes, McKinsey).

P.S.: I suspect you're the one that downvoted me (just above 500 karma, only reply to my comment). I appreciate you followed up with a comment, but downvotes are not "I disagree" signals. Please learn to be a bit more tolerant with people that does not think like you, instead of trying to shut their voice down.

Re:Computer Science Education by pgbovine on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:08PM (#13554126)
N=1 personal anecdote: A few years ago I spent a day visiting Wellesley College's CS department (all-women's school) to give a talk and to meet with professors and students. And one of the main vibes I got was that students felt way more comfortable there just focusing on hacking, understanding, debugging, struggling, etc. with the hard parts of CS/programming without worrying about the tons of well-documented implicit biases, stereotype threats, and issues that are commonly-found in regular CS classrooms. It wasn't that they somehow wanted special treatment as "women studying CS" (they didn't) -- they just wanted to be able to focus on CS without all the other external crap that their peers in traditional CS programs need to deal with. See Unlocking the Clubhouse for a comprehensive study of this phenomenon.
Re:Computer Science Education by NoodleIncident on Thursday February 02, 2017 @02:45PM (#13553856)
> Large companies are judged by the diversity of their employees.

As the one judging the ones doing the judging, it's fun to imagine that the judgement is what motivates the corporation's actions. I don't think that's actually what happens though.

The motivation I've actually seen corporations act upon, is that diversity in employees has direct benefits to the company's bottom line. For example, googling "facebook diversity" gets me this paragraph:

>"Facebook’s mission is to give people the power to share and make the world more open and connected. In order to achieve that mission, we need an employee base that reflects a broad range of experiences, backgrounds, races, ethnicities, genders, sexual orientations, abilities and many other characteristics."

You can assume that they're all lying to virtue signal if you want, it's impossible to stop anyone from assuming such things. But if you're proposing an alternative to their stated motivations, you should probably explain why that motivation isn't actually true.

Re:Computer Science Education by pdyck on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:25AM (#13550026)
> can sometimes (seem) abrasive and uninviting

Well that's just discriminating against nerds

Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:25AM (#13550308)
> Well that's just discriminating against nerds

This is exactly the problem. You've assumed that 'nerds' -- people who are skilled and passionate about tech things -- are male. It's that kind of assumption which enforces a massive mental barrier for women to be able to consider themselves legitimately passionate and skilled about tech, and also for men to recognise them as such too.

Until the association of nerds with masculinity is broken up, boys and men will dominate tech at the expense of others. And until that that point, programs like Google's which foster different ('minoritean') associations with being passionate and skilled with tech will be needed.

Re:Computer Science Education by reader5000 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:26AM (#13551731)
"Stereotypes" come from patterns in empirical reality. They are not created and administered by some Evil White Male committee as you seem to think. Women are in no way discriminated against in tech, nor have they ever been. Passionate and skilled women in tech certainly exist, they are just relatively rare. Withholding resources from boys because of their gender actually is discrimination, and should not be encouraged.
Re:Computer Science Education by macintux on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:16PM (#13552223)
> Women are in no way discriminated against in tech, nor have they ever been.

I don't even.

Re:Computer Science Education by digler999 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:37PM (#13552478)
> Passionate and skilled women in tech certainly exist, they are just relatively rare.

exactly. I dont agree with you that women have "never been" discriminated against, but I do agree that vocational fields are not homogeneously populated (and that is not the result of discrimination).

* I dont see very many women police officers

* (this was mentioned on HN last week) not very many oil-rig workers are women

* I dont see many heterosexual men working as hair dressers or bridal shop/wedding planners/fashion designers/makeup artists ("this is clearly a glass door organized by the Gay Male Establishment to prevent heterosexual men from breaking into this field. Such abuse of privilege" /s).

* I don't see many women working as bouncers at night clubs

* I don't see many women working as commercial pilots.

But you know, for all the "I don't see"'s , when I do see one that defies the norm, I dont think much of it. They're people just like anyone else, free to pursue whatever they want. But it's not automatically discrimination when groups of people gravitate to certain fields.

Re:Computer Science Education by tehwalrus on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:40AM (#13550095)
Politeness and intelligence/knowledge are not mutually exclusive traits.
Re:Computer Science Education by titraprutr on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:16AM (#13549984)
> What will be in the girls-only code program that might be inappropriate for boys

Unfortunately, a lot of tech companies these days consider "positive discrimination" as a good thing.

Re:Computer Science Education by m0nty on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:13AM (#13549975)
I have no problems with these groups in themselves, I'm of Irish descent so it would be a bit stupid if I did. It does seem like a very limited selection, though: there are hundreds if not thousands of other groups which could be accommodated with their own courses. Where are they?
Re:Computer Science Education by jhanschoo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:26AM (#13550317)
From the piecemeal nature of these programs it seems to me most likely that they were resources from past initiatives by their local offices that this website just aggregated.
Re:Computer Science Education by bluebeard on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:21PM (#13554263)
Well, my guess is as follows: Irish: big corporate tax breaks in that area. India: outsourcing potential. Perhaps more liberal attitudes towards CS education? Women: we really need more women in tech, though on a corporate level where money is the motivator I can only guess what the incentives are.

The above are my assumptions and may be wrong.

As for your girls-only code program comment, I have taught kids to create things using visual scripting tools. There is a difference in what the girls want to make and what the boys want to make. This was my first hand experience and is a limited insight into a small world.

Re:Computer Science Education by GrantSolar on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:55AM (#13549872)
>Why in the age of a _World_ Wide Web and "post-discrimination" are large companies such as Google deliberately targeting specific groups?

Because the gender ratio in STEM fields skews heavily towards men.

>What will be in the girls-only code program that might be inappropriate for boys?

I can't imagine there would be anything that was 'inappropriate', though there may be some boys less excited about making a dress light up. Google is using existing gender roles to introduce girls to code and get them excited about STEM, something that may be far more difficult once they grow older.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:42AM (#13550794)
> Because the gender ratio in STEM fields skews heavily towards men.

Girls are free to study what they want. If they don't want to study STEM fields - their problem, which I don't feel having to care for.

Re:Computer Science Education by dwaltrip on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:02AM (#13551447)
Apparently it's your problem as well, because you appear to be personally upset by a program that only helps them.
Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:15AM (#13551601)
I am always upset over discriminatory programs. If one would replace "women only" by "white people only", you would probably be upset, too.
Re:Computer Science Education by dwaltrip on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:22AM (#13551674)
How do you feel about Spanish language programming courses? What about affordable housing?

How do you define discrimination? I think there isn't a clear line, and we have to use our evolving best judgment depending on the context.

How else can we attempt to more quickly resolve unfortunate and unfair dynamics the past has brought us?

Lastly, I think it's a mistake to assume all discrimination is zero sum. We will all reap benefits from previously disadvantaged groups receiving more opportunity.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:42AM (#13551895)
> How do you define discrimination?

Using any other criterion than ability for e.g. staffing jobs/university places/... In this sense every forced quota on gender/skin color/race/... is discrimination. Women only programs are, too (as "men only", "white only" or "black only").

EDIT:

> How do you feel about Spanish language programming courses?

Living in Germany I openly don't understand what you want to imply with this question.

Re:Computer Science Education by dwaltrip on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:41PM (#13552543)
I'm implying it's not as simple as you are making it out to be. Does Google fall under your definition? They must, or it wouldn't seem fair to be upset at them. What counts as a "program"?

If your complaint is mainly about quotas, I don't have as much to say about those. My intuition is that strict quotas are overly heavy handed and also treating the symptom not the cause. I would guess that programs that seek to help certain groups closer to the source (e.g. in the education and training phase) are more effective.

Re:Computer Science Education by dwaltrip on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:50PM (#13555707)
To clarify, I was referring to Google's C.S. education program that is targeted at women, not hiring processes
Re:Computer Science Education by byubadger on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:47PM (#13552624)
>I think there isn't a clear line

A clear line has been drawn in the form of protected classes. Primary language spoken and income are not protected classes. Gender is.

Re:Computer Science Education by GrantSolar on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:40PM (#13555610)
>Girls are free to study what they want.

Of course, but when the disparity is so large we should at least question why that is. Are girls biologically less inclined to find any appeal in STEM, or is it due to upbringing? This course appears to be following the latter, and either challenging any social bias that may dissuade girls, or balancing out any extra persuasion of boys

Re:Computer Science Education by digler999 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:28PM (#13552362)
> some boys less excited about making a dress light up

you're using gender stereotypes ("girls like dresses", and implied its corollary, "boys like machines") in an argument against gender exclusion.

Re:Computer Science Education by GrantSolar on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:33PM (#13555532)
Yes. Regardless of anyone's stance on them, these stereotypes exist right now and are being re-inforced by society.

It's not easy to break down cultural barriers, and doing so in one fell swoop is near impossible. Employing these stereotypes in order to bring an end to them is not necessarily a bad thing

Re:Computer Science Education by Yizahi on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:39AM (#13550093)
Pink code highlighting? :)
Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:03AM (#13549916)
Presumably Google is targeting India, Ireland, NZ and Australia because they have significant bases in those countries.

In regards to targeting young women, they're making an effort to redress the obvious gender imbalances and male dominance of the tech world. Why is that a problem?

Re:Computer Science Education by a_j_c on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:42PM (#13553183)
> "In regards to targeting young women, they're making an effort to redress the obvious gender imbalances and male dominance of the tech world."

It could be that they are just virtue signaling and trying to appease the easily offended bloggers and tech "journalists"

Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:42AM (#13550395)
Problem: There's a massive gender imbalance in CS and amongst the coding community. There are loads of men and hardly any women. Most of half the population would never consider working for us or our partners. Solution: Make a website which specifically encourages young girls to see themselves as coders.

Problem: We have invested loads of money into our Irish, Indian, Australian/NZ offices, but we could increase our pool of workers from those countries. Solution: Make a website which specifically encourages kids from those countries to start their journey into CS and tech.

What is the problem?

Re:Computer Science Education by reitanqild on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:25AM (#13550659)
No problem for you. And I have learned to live with it but as a young boy it was extremely frustrating to see girls getting advantages throughout the whole school system just for being girls.

Now I am fully aware that I have certain advantages ("privileges") as well but as I said: when you are young this can be extremely frustrating.

Re:Computer Science Education by notheguyouthink on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:35AM (#13550742)
I mean, it's frustrating at any age. It's not a popular opinion, but just because you know "some" things are easier for you than say, "girls", doesn't make it any less frustrating.

Sure, they're frustrated too i'm sure - i'm not denying that or putting anyone down, to be clear. It has always just seemed like the wrong approach to a problem, or possibly projection of a problem where a problem doesn't exist.

Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:59AM (#13551424)
It's frustrating because you don't have all of the advantages, or just the advantage that you really want?
Re:Computer Science Education by reitanqild on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:24AM (#13551698)
It is frustrating because as a kid/young adult you don't see the full picture : you only see you are being discriminated against.

It is frustrating because for many young men the disadvantages often seems to outweigh the advantages.

It is frustrating because as a kid/young adult some of the the countermeasures are so broad that they are hard to understand as anything but pushing one gender ahead at all cost: try to make sense of the fact that for years there was extra study points for women in higher education, including studies where female students were overrepresented like chemistry and nurse studies. (Yes, now it has been adjusted somewhat from what I see.)

Edit: and it is frustrating because it seems unfair. It seems almost like we have a built in "fairness" scale which is miscalibrated so by default it only detects unfairness against me: like when a kid go and have a really great time and come home and are angry their siblings got a candy while they were away :-/

Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:05PM (#13554085)
This is true; the advantages I have are not as well advertised. For example, no professor ever told me anything like, "Women don't study mathematics," as my girlfriend had.
Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:06AM (#13550963)
I can't speak for your particular experience at school, but in general I think it's a shame that people whose lives are, as you say, "privileged" by the systems in which we live feel like they are at a disadvantage because of concerted attempts to raise others to their level.
Re:Computer Science Education by reitanqild on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:07AM (#13551521)
You know, I was a lot younger then.

Furthermore I was answering a direct question: "What is the problem?"

Also I put the "privileged" word in quotes for a reason: while being male gives me a number of advantages it also gives me a number of disadvantages.

Furthermore there is all the rest: coming from a low socioeconomic background should account for a lot as well (buying a pc was a huge deal - I think I was 15 when my dad finally managed to get hold of one, going abroad for holiday was never an option, working unpaid at my dads business was pretty much expected and I started working as a farm hand with other farms when I was 15. )

As I said I don't care much but I think I can explain why for a lot of young men the idea of male "privilege" feels like a reality they don't experience as for them any male privilege seems to be overshadowed by a number of other factors.

Re:Computer Science Education by FT_intern on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:25PM (#13554298)
I can see that. It must be very juxtaposing to see upper middle class blacks/hispanics/females (the typical "oppressed minority" working at big tech companies) getting special benefits.
Re:Computer Science Education by reitanqild on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:41PM (#13557475)
Typically I don't care.

All I want from people I work with is that they are good so we can move projects forward and that they don't bully or otherwise negatively affect lives of people around them.

Re:Computer Science Education by a_j_c on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:45PM (#13553220)
+1

Class > Identity politics

Re:Computer Science Education by paulddraper on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:44AM (#13550807)
> What is the problem?

Discrimination.

It has been justified for centuries with all manner of reasoned arguments. Hopefully we will eventually learn discrimination is a Bad Idea.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:52AM (#13550873)
> Hopefully we will eventually learn discrimination is a Bad Idea.

... including discrimination against boys/men - which quota regulation and "women only" programs are (imagine the outcry if one would replace "women only" by "white people only").

Re:Computer Science Education by shuntress on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:16AM (#13551034)
You seem to be worried about over-correction where there is clearly none.

If we had a CS field dominated almost entirely by women then the "women only" programs would be undesirable.

This is a man in a boat protesting that a drowning woman is being helped out of the water but he is receiving no such equivalent assistance.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:34AM (#13551179)
> You seem to be worried about over-correction where there is clearly none.

I live in Germany - and there the situation is IMHO different.

Re:Computer Science Education by lorenzhs on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:04PM (#13552106)
What are you on about? I'm a PhD student at one of the top German universities for CompSci. There are around 10% women in our bachelor's and master's programmes. The department is actively trying to get more women interested in studying computer science, because it very much is a boys' club.

The problem isn't about access to courses. It's that existing programmes don't appeal to women, and it's dumb to ignore half of the population when you need more qualified people. That's why we need to make getting into computer science more attractive to women. Acknowledging that the current system just doesn't work for them is a necessary first step towards making it work for everyone.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:16PM (#13552221)
> What are you on about?

The laws for women quota: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13551798

Otherwise:

Nobody forces women to study a non-STEM subject - they decide it themselves. So doing promotional programs for women has the implicit implication "women are too stupid to get on their own what they should study (while men are smart enough to find this out on their own)" - something I would never ever claim.

Re:Computer Science Education by lorenzhs on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:37PM (#13552484)
No, nobody's claiming that. If that's your takeaway from outreach programmes, maybe you should talk to women about their experiences in computer science.

The reason for outreach programmes is that what's currently offered seems to appeal to men but not nearly as much to women, and that we should fix that. There's nothing patronising about admitting a problem and attempting to alleviate it. Some attempts might be misguided or based on incorrect assumptions, but that shouldn't discredit the entire endeavour.

(Since we're talking about computer science education, I'll disregard the entirely unrelated comment about quotas in businesses.)

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:57PM (#13552738)
> (Since we're talking about computer science education, I'll disregard the entirely unrelated comment about quotas in businesses.)

There are also (more implicit) women quota in the university laws (Landeshochschulgesetzen) of Germany's federate states e.g. for casting professors.

Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:03AM (#13551461)
The majority of high skilled tech jobs aren't held by men? There are no selective barriers to entry?
Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:13AM (#13551581)
People are free to study what they want. If there are more men who want to study a STEM subject, this will of course lead to a majority of men. Indeed, typical STEM subjects have no limitation on your A-level mark (Numerus Clausus) for being allowed to study it. So there is clearly no selective barrier to entry (Numerus Clausus) [but I'm not a native speaker of English - so it can be that "selective barriers to entry" has a subcontext in English that I'm not aware of].
Re:Computer Science Education by shuntress on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:46AM (#13551932)
Have you ever been somewhere where it was clear everyone noticed you didn't 'fit in'?
Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:58AM (#13552039)
> Have you ever been somewhere where it was clear everyone noticed you didn't 'fit in'?

There are multiple ways to answer the question:

1. I often don't fit in - and don't consider this as a problem.

2. I have yet to see a woman studying a STEM subject who is very skilled at it and made such complaint.

3. Saying one does not study, say, computer science because one does not fit in means that "fitting in" is more important to you than the things you learn in computer science. In other words: You don't consider CS as something really important to you. This is clearly not the inner urge for the subject that I expect from people studying it.

Re:Computer Science Education by hdctambien on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:32PM (#13554363)
> I have yet to see a woman studying a STEM subject who is very skilled at it and made such complaint.

Seriously, you should actually talk to some of these women about their experiences.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:31PM (#13554855)
> > I have yet to see a woman studying a STEM subject who is very skilled at it and made such complaint.

> Seriously, you should actually talk to some of these women about their experiences.

I have.

Re:Computer Science Education by a_j_c on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:53PM (#13553300)
> "Have you ever been somewhere where it was clear everyone noticed you didn't 'fit in'?"

Yes, being an actual liberal in SV and not just a Dem apologist...

Re:Computer Science Education by FT_intern on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:29PM (#13554335)
That's not possible in the tech field because the tech field is very diverse. With the high immigrant %, most people do not fit in because there is no majority/in-group. The demographic is fragmented with the immigrant groups clustering by native language and country of origin. You end up with maybe 30-40% Americans in an engineering team.
Re:Computer Science Education by shuntress on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:43AM (#13559700)
I didn't mean specifically in the tech field.

My peers in undergrad computer science were as you described, except I would estimate 60-70% Americans, 95% male 5% female.

I now work for a small-ish company with ~25 developers on a few different teams. All men.

I understand that this is anecdotal, though not uncommon.

Re:Computer Science Education by camus2 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:00AM (#13550926)
> Discrimination.

So it's a problem in CS but not in education or healthcare, where women are the majority?

Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:07AM (#13550977)
In what part of healthcare are men systemically impeded from involvement?
Re:Computer Science Education by RUG3Y on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:41AM (#13551250)
I don't think it can be demonstrated that women are systematically impeded from involvement in STEM fields and CS when there are many programs actively targeting women and girls. A skilled woman in CS appears to have a huge advantage in hiring, at least in any company I've been in.
Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:13AM (#13551578)
Problem: women face selective barriers to entry in this field.

Solution: introduce programs promoting the field to women and girls.

Problem: women have a huge advantage due to the programs.

...?

Re:Computer Science Education by camus2 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:08AM (#13550985)
> In what part of healthcare are men systemically impeded from involvement?

In what part of CS women are systematically impeded from involvement?

Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:40AM (#13551238)
Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:04AM (#13551477)
Have you a better one?

Doing nothing isn't a better idea.

Re:Computer Science Education by pliptvo on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:24AM (#13551103)
Discrimination isn't just an idea, it's a material reality. Women are systematically disadvantaged on every level of tech, from the assumption that 'nerds' are boys, which seems to go back to IT marketing from the 1980s[1], to their being prevented from holding senior offices in the biggest tech corporations. They are discriminated against by a male-dominated industry and culture. Only when the systemic, material conditions of patriarchy are no longer in force will it make sense to no longer 'discriminate'.

Also, care to name one thinker from history who doesn't advocate discrimination of some sort? Seriously. Who is your model?

[1] http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-...

Re:Computer Science Education by paulddraper on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:08PM (#13552152)
> Only when [X happens] will it make sense to no longer discriminate.

Problem is, no one can agree when X happens (or has happened).

"Only when we're safe will it make sense to no longer spy on all our citizens."

"Only when our enemies are defeated will it make sense to no longer have Emperor Caesar."

Re:Computer Science Education by reader5000 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:31AM (#13551783)
Your evidence of "material reality" is just you repeating your claim.
Re:Computer Science Education by Lawtonfogle on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:23AM (#13550647)
The problem? Because those actions are discrimination. Using discrimination to fight discrimination largely targets the under privileged members of the privileged groups.

It's basically a call for equity instead of equality, except it is limited equity which automatically assume some do not need equitable help. It is also limited in how it's applied.

Find the actual problems causing any modern day biases and fix those. Personally I work with some kids to help them love math. In my (admittingly anecdotal experience) there is a bias noticeable in middle school for all kids to not like math that evolves into a gender bias but to some extent hurts both genders' ability and desire to learn. Identifying and remedying the cause of this would do more to help both girls and boys than targeted aid in high-school or college.

Re:Computer Science Education by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:29AM (#13549751)
There's also a middle-school program.

For those who didn't look there is a very short list of programmes mentioned which discriminate on sex, age, ethnicity.

Re:Computer Science Education by dotancohen on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:36AM (#13549788)
A "short list" which is four of the five listed programmes. Id est, 80% of the programmes on the list discriminate.
Re:Computer Science Education by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:41AM (#13550393)
Bad wording, my intention was to say they all discriminate, assuming "middle-school" is intended to refer to an age range.

5 is a short list, no.

I assume it's the start of what may later become a directory of offerings.

There are masses of MOOCs that aren't discriminating though.

Re:Computer Science Education by hrodriguez on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:59AM (#13551423)
I too was very surprised by the limited options. I keep seeing American companies investing overseas instead of building a stronger base at home. It's frustrating.

Now, don't get me wrong. I understand these are international firms and it's good to see CS education targeting other communities and certain imbalances in the system but...

Their are large swaths of communities right here in the US that could use the support of American companies investing right here in their home-base. As a result, I see these efforts by US firms as a marketing gimmick to help them further their interests in entering new markets and appealing to certain political alliances.

Re:Computer Science Education by protomyth on Thursday February 02, 2017 @01:34PM (#13553123)
Apparently if your racial group is listed in the "Other" category of Google's diversity report they won't throw you a life line on education. You know, after they made sure Google Voice wouldn't service one of the tribal community colleges, they could at least do a little outreach.
Re:Computer Science Education by cardiffguy on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:32AM (#13550348)
I wonder if I'd qualify. I have dyslexia and dyspraxia but always feel like "learning difficulties" put you in the camp of "not disabled enough". I managed to get a first class degree in compsci and recieved the standard disability grant from the uni.
Re:Computer Science Education by mcguire on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:15AM (#13551607)
You got a disability grant? Would that be considered reverse discrimination?
Re:Computer Science Education by cardiffguy on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:36PM (#13552465)
In the UK it's fairly standard to get financial support in terms of technology to help with the disability