News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer Science Education by 0xFFC on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:28AM (#13549238)
I don't want to be negative here, But I think anyone who can convince Berkeley guys to re-activate this[1] channel would make humanity much much more service.

I am saying this because this channel changed my life, literally. I do live in third world country, I went to local college, where you will learn nothing after 4 year (not even writing a simple hello world, TBH). But after watching and learning from this channel and MIT opencourseware, right now I am working on internal of linux kernel (just think about not being able to write hello world after 4 year, and compare it with hacking linux kernel to get a feeling about how far I came) as hobby project, and I came this far only by watching various (from OS class to compiler, algorithm, etc) class and solving their assignments and writing their projects. I came this far by my own (only, without any help other than free material in resource I mentioned). I am 100% sure I will go further and further, because this is my thing, I may not be that smart, but I am resilient.

So I am perfect/live example of how free educational material can change people lives, and I do live in very small city (indeed very small, which most people are not familiar with computer until 3,4 years ago).

I did have 40kb connection, sometimes I spent a whole day waiting for downloading a lecture, to watch it, considering I had to use VPN, you can understand how hard it was to download a whole class from youtube. Right now I have better connection.

[1] : https://www.youtube.com/user/UCBerkeley/videos

Re:Computer Science Education by wfunction on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:49AM (#13549335)
The issue was that people with disabilities across the country (i.e. non-Berkeley-students) were suing* Berkeley for not making their videos accessible. That's why you can't have nice things unfortunately. See here: http://news.berkeley.edu/2016/09/13/a-statement-on-online-co...

Lectures up to 2015 are still there though? Do you consider their materials obsolete or something?

*Edit: Specifically, the Attorney General was threatening to file a lawsuit pursuant to the ADA, and damages were ordered to be paid (I don't know if they actually were). Follow the link above to find the Department of Justice letter; the interesting bits are on the last two pages.

Re:Computer Science Education by libeclipse on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:13AM (#13549438)
What? So a lawsuit to allow more people access to knowledge resulted in no one having access to more of it.

Damn, that's just.. I'm struggling to refrain from saying a word that'd get me in trouble.

Re:Computer Science Education by tdkl on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:34AM (#13549773)
Yes, we live in a time where minorities tyrannize the rest.
Re:Computer Science Education by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:17AM (#13549994)
Or at least lawyers purporting to represent minorities, who collect 30% of the payout while the minorities get a $20 gift card (or some similar token).
Re:Computer Science Education by Yizahi on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:05AM (#13550519)
No. Minorities are still in worse situation than majority globally. And all so called "minority tyranny" is just a random malfunctioning of institutes usually directly involved in screwing minorities. E.g. some black woman successfully sued some white white male for racial/gender reasons and it was bad for common sense? That's because it was possible in the first place to do that, only previously it was done the other way.

PS: I'm not a minority.

Re:Computer Science Education by Chris2048 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:59AM (#13552053)
> Minorities are still in worse situation than majority globally

The "group average" of a persons designated (prescribed?) demographic is irrelevant on the level of comparing individuals and their interactions.

> only previously it was done the other way.

Given it was different individuals, this is only true if you define groupings specifically to, say, match a racist white and a non-racist white, from different generations, simply because they are both white; Hence mistreatment of some innocent, random modern white can be interpreted as 'comeuppance'..

Re:Computer Science Education by Chris2048 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:49AM (#13551966)
I'd pause to blame them, ultimately the law allows this stuff to happen.
Re:Computer Science Education by lr4444lr on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:19AM (#13550003)
The doctrine of Disparate Impact is way out of control.
Re:Computer Science Education by denzil_correa on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:16AM (#13549990)
> So a lawsuit to allow more people access to knowledge resulted in no one having access to more of it.

There is a merit in the lawsuit here. This is how discrimination starts. Over a reasonable period of time, the horse has left the barn and then will scramble over quick fix solutions to stem the rot.

Re:Computer Science Education by eru on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:27AM (#13549488)
You'd get symmetric situation if someone sues a biased employer who only hires gingers, and the guy decide to shut shop instead---don't you?
Re:Computer Science Education by Chris2048 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:50AM (#13549602)
Arbitrarily discriminating against gingers isn't the same as not doing extra work to make the videos more accessible.

Further more, the right to run a business, and participate in a particular economy, is regulated in many ways - these videos were given away for free to everyone, possibly at cost.

I don't think a free educational resource should have to meet this burden.

Re:Computer Science Education by eru on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:17AM (#13550271)
I'm not sure whether it makes a difference, but in my example the biased employer was arbitrarily discriminating in favour of gingers.
Re:Computer Science Education by Chris2048 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:30AM (#13551773)
Yes, I was suggesting your example was different to the situation in the article, or not relevant in the same way.
Re:Computer Science Education by cousin_it on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:45AM (#13549580)
It would be symmetric if hiring gingers was cheaper, like making non-accessible videos.
Re:Computer Science Education by Mayzie on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:24AM (#13549475)
> The issue was that people with disabilities across the country (i.e. non-Berkeley-students) were suing Berkeley for not making their videos disabled-friendly.

What the f#$k? Suing because their videos are not "disabled-friendly"? What does that even mean? God, the lawsuit trigger-happiness of some people...

Re:Computer Science Education by wfunction on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:34AM (#13549519)
> Suing because their videos are not "disabled-friendly"? What does that even mean?

Sorry, bad wording on my part (had other things on my mind and wasn't Englishing properly). Meant to say the content was not accessible; see edit.

Re:Computer Science Education by emiliobumachar on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:18AM (#13550280)
Specifically, it means subtitled. So that deaf people can acess them.
Re:Computer Science Education by matt4077 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:50AM (#13549845)
> "disabled-friendly"? What does that even mean?

I'd say lawsuits such these would be far fewer if people were at least aware of the existence of disabled people, and spend a modicum of attention on how to enable their participation in society.

"video" being latin for "to see" may provide a clue as to the type of disability that could have trouble accessing this content.

I'm not familiar enough with the subtleties of this case to know if subtitles, which IMHO could have been created rather cheaply or through volunteers, would have been enough to make them accessible, or there would have been problems with, for example, visual content such as diagrams and photos. In any way, I suspect the project was on weak footing within Berkeley anyway, and whatever support it may have had within the administration couldn't overcome the legal risks.

It's rare to find an example where the outcome, in strictly utilitarian terms, is as clearly negative as it is in this case. However, the ADA and similar legislation will always be a net negative if you're evaluating it in those terms.

To use the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act which has recently been in the news: guaranteeing disabled students equal access to public education is a losing proposition in terms of total utility. There will always be cases where a school needs to spend, say, $30,000 to make the new library accessible to people in wheelchairs, or may even decide not to build that library in the first place, because it doesn't have those $30,000. Without a doubt, spending the $30,000 on more books for that library would create more "total learning", even if means the few students in wheelchairs never even see a real book in their lifetime. There will even be cases where all this happens at school that don't even have any students in wheelchairs.

The reasoning, therefore, has to be different than purely utilitarian. Laws for disability access are a collective decision to break with purely economic rationality in an effort that emphasises a limited core of rights to be guaranteed for everyone much stronger than the broad welfare of society as a whole. That's not an unusual tradeoff. It's the same that's at play when we don't torture drug dealers to get them to give up their suppliers.

Note that there lots of reasonable exceptions on the books. Nobody is saying that your paragliding school needs to make accommodations for people in a persistent vegetative state. In this case, I'd argue that remote learning is an opportunity almost tailor-made for people with disabilities, and that whoever made this ill-fated decision at Berkeley – knowing how it will become a talking point against disability access – made a grave mistake.

Re:Computer Science Education by wolfgke on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:50AM (#13550851)
> I'd say lawsuits such these would be far fewer if people were at least aware of the existence of disabled people, and spend a modicum of attention on how to enable their participation in society.

I'd say people would be much more tolerant towards people with disabilities if there weren't such crazy laws and lawsuits.

Re:Computer Science Education by eru on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:22AM (#13550021)
By the way, you don't have to put utilitarianism against disability access.

You just need your utilitarianism to either maximize the the minimum welfare (ie help the least well-off member of society first); or use something like the sum of logarithms of welfares (similar idea).

Re:Computer Science Education by Chris2048 on Friday February 03, 2017 @02:35PM (#13562550)
> Laws for disability access are a collective decision to break with purely economic rationality

but which collective?

> It's the same that's at play when we don't torture drug dealers to get them to give up their suppliers.

I disagree a similar situation is at play.

Re:Computer Science Education by Chris2048 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:03PM (#13552092)
> whoever made this ill-fated decision at Berkeley

The legal instruments that caused this are to blame, not Berkeley. It's not Berkeley's job to manage public opinion wrt disability access when it regards the action of third parties.

Re:Computer Science Education by softawre on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:07AM (#13550535)
> "video" being latin for "to see"

Really? I thought it was a subtitles thing.

Re:Computer Science Education by 0xFFC on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:57AM (#13549375)
Yeah, I watched most of them already, But it is always better to have more and updated classes.
Re:Computer Science Education by hackermailman on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:15AM (#13550590)
There's also this list of MOOCs https://www.reddit.com/r/learnprogramming/comments/4rimxf/he...

What I do is find a university and look at their course public page where often in the calendar/schedule you can find lecture notes, slides and sometimes the lectures. If you find the lectures immediately grab them with some browser plugin to archive because they tend to disappear.

TU/e in NL has a lot of open english taught courses I've found, like this one with lecture videos http://www.hyperelliptic.org/tanja/teaching/crypto16/

Re:Computer Science Education by 0xFFC on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:48AM (#13551319)
Wow, you are fucking awesome. I dont know how to thank you.

I do the same. I downloaded your link and will look at TU more carefully from now on.

P.S. It is always this way, every time I find a new lectures, I get way too excited.

Re:Computer Science Education by hackermailman on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:40PM (#13552525)
Carnagie Mellon has some open too http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~213/schedule.html (Lectures) https://scs.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.a...

That book you can get the global 3rd version from Abe Books for $20something since you aren't in Can/USA

There's other courses in there, like this awesome math/compsci course https://scs.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.a... (click on the RSS(Subscribe) logo in the upper right, can download them). They also have some fully open courses like this db course with lectures on youtube http://15721.courses.cs.cmu.edu/spring2016/

Re:Computer Science Education by atmosx on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:40AM (#13549550)
I would like you to make an AMA or a blog post about your story with details. It is pretty inspiring.
Re:Computer Science Education by Yizahi on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:15AM (#13550587)
<slightly offtopic> I remember a story about Google doing some optimization on YouTube page to make it load faster. They done it, tested and then deployed changes to main site. After that they had seen that average page load time increased despite that page definitely loaded faster with fix. In the end they realized that lots of people from 3rd world could now load YouTube not in say 20-30 seconds but in 5-10 seconds (don't remember exact values) and so it changed from unreasonably long to acceptable. And so massive influx of slow clients dropped average time of page load.

That was a few years ago, so we can see that there are still maybe millions of people with very slow Internet connection out there.

Re:Computer Science Education by fernandotakai on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:53AM (#13549613)
tons of 3rd world developers are like that. i never went to college so i learned everything i know from watching videos on my 1mb connection and learning documentation.

after 10 years and a couple of startups, i wanna say that went particularly well :)

Re:Computer Science Education by 0xFFC on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:30AM (#13549759)
I will, let me to finish next phase of my plan before writing any blog post or AMA.(next phase : starting to work for big company or starting a successful startup)
Re:Computer Science Education by emiliobumachar on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:20AM (#13550292)
Take your time, but keep in mind that getting your story out there could help your next phase.