But a viable alternative to labour protection is a strong welfare system. That's the classic Denmark vs Germany comparison. Taxes are high in Denmark, but it's easy to hire and fire somebody. Which hurts business more?
A society needs a sane amount of labor protection. Too much and there won't be jobs (and the economy will suffer), too little and the people will have no power over their lives (and the economy will suffer).
Worse still, that optimum point will change all the time as an economy matures. And I don't think anybody has any good procedure for measuring it.
I don't know how this translates into differences in welfare spending (so it is possibly that Denmark spends more on welfare but that Germany just spends far more on other things - I haven't looked), or why the differences are so large, but of the OECD countries, Germany comes in only after Belgium (who always throne high above the rest on these lists) and Austria when it comes to the size of the tax wedge relative to total labour costs. Denmark meanwhile comes in near the OECD average, which was 35.9% in 2015.
[1] http://www.keepeek.com/Digital-Asset-Management/oecd/taxatio...
[2] http://www.keepeek.com/Digital-Asset-Management/oecd/taxatio...
What, you become the richest, most powerful country in the world? (I think America has the weakest labour laws in the developed world).
No you do that during world war by being the only country left with with virtually no damage to factories/infrastructure due to geography.
You then use that to establish a global hegemony.
And even then it only enriches the top of your society.
Source? I'm looking at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_income and none of the sources show a difference as high as that.
Also if you look at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_pe... the US has much lower median wealth than most European economies.
I thought the distinction was fairly clear, but perhaps I should have emphasised it more?
If Germans are making less but are worth more... There's interesting things going on that probably need to be taken into consideration in such a conversation.
If a poor person in the US has a $3000 car they might be poorer on paper than a middle class Singaporean who takes the bus but the latter would have to spend $100k to enjoy the same transportation lifestyle as the former.
Similar for things like detached houses and takeout food which are basic in the US but luxury items in most of the rest of the world.
What exactly does it mean to "enjoy the same transportation lifestyle" and why would it cost them $100k? Singapore is a tiny island with fairly comprehensive public transport, and relatively inexpensive taxis. What exactly is this middle class person missing out on?
> takeout food ... luxury items in most of the rest of the world.
What makes you think that? Takeaway food is readily available in every developed country I've been in, and usually even cheaper in developing ones.
What matters is someone's ability to reach places they want to go, not how far they are able to drive.
> eating takeout 2x a day
This is easily possible for a middle class person in Europe (although I think most would consider it inadvisable).
You mean when they got access to all that land to the west that was previously inhabited by Native Americans?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweatshop
And also this (which was, fundamentally, an economic institution):
Nor was slavery, for that matter. The main differences is that US slavery was domestic (and mostly contained to the south)[0]. Whereas European imperial powers (England, France, Belgium, etc.) outsourced their slavery, practicing forced relocation of people within their colonies and engaging those colonists in forced labor with the threat of violence[1]. That continued well into the 20th century.
[0] Though not as much as people like to think - the North was very happy to make money off of the slave trade, as long as they didn't permanently hold those slaves.
[1] One can try to engage in the abstract argument of, "well, is it philosophically better to enslave people within each others' native lands, rather than to bring them all to the seat of the empire and enslave them there", but that's a hair that's not worth splitting, and a far cry from the original statement.
More accurately, this happened because every other power was laid to waste by two successive world wars. You'd have been hard pressed to find a standing factory in Germany, Britain, or Russia in June of 1945.
https://www.quora.com/Economic-History-At-what-point-did-the...
Further, the US has had several boom and bust cycles people only really hear about 'the great depression' but there have been plenty of major slumps in the US economy for example around the Civil War. So, a nominal lead in good times is not that meaningful.
So it was only during WWII that the US went from near parity to a massive and sustained lead. And it did not take that long before we gave that up to either China or the EU depending on how you want to slice it.
Obviously US was looking great at that time, hence the immigration boom. (As Mark Twain went for in the name, the guilded age did have plenty of issues, but so did Europe. Class was strictly more palpable there, generally speaking.)
Then, as others with that firm foundation, we surfed tsunami of two world wars that swallowed everyone else. That seal Ed the deal (and the second got us out of the great depression).
Russia's military production had been moved away from the west of the country before Russia got there.
Britain wasn't bombed heavily. The Luftwaffe didn't have the capacity.
And the UK was much richer than the USA for a long time.
To be fair this happened during a period of high unionization and a top income tax rate approaching 80%, or more. I'm not saying those things caused the growth, but they didn't stop it obviously.
Also your comment is dismissive of things like income inequality, companies hoarding cash instead of investing it, healthcare access, quality of life, stagnant wages, etc and other things have the US hasn't solved but has been better addressed in more liberal nations. That high GDP is nice, but it doesn't stop poverty in the south side of Chicago nor does it create jobs in the rust belt. Maybe if we took these issues more seriously we wouldn't have elections where loud-mouth populists win due to electorate anger and instead have a system of government that reflects the needs of the people more than corporations.
The point being, there are options and - to some extent - the onus is on individuals to take charge of their situation and improve if, if they're dissatisfied.
Aaah, the old "put words into someone's mouth and then refute an argument that has nothing to do with what they actually said" trick. Cute.
And a huge part of that is how cheap and frictionless hiring and firing is (relative to other countries).
For example - I love languages! I wanted to become a polyglot in high school and speak several languages well enough to hold small talk. Practicing a language to fluency without residing in a country it is spoken is a lot of effort and requires a lot of self-motivation and time dedication. I rarely study anymore and am no longer confident in my ability to hold small talk in German or Portuguese. It's extremely satisfying to learn about various cultures, their history, and being able to speak with natives! You learn so many things about the world when you expand your ability to explore other cultures. No work to me is more satisfying.
But cultural and linguistic anthropologists, after putting themselves into debt from college, hardly make more than a McDonald's Manager. Not to mention work is sparse and difficult to find - nearly impossible outside of academia. I went with a job with more job opportunities and a higher base salary so that I could afford my more expensive hobbies like playing video games and actually visiting other countries to learn about their cultures. Something I wouldn't be able to afford to do if I had my "dream job" instead of a "well paying job".
But that leaves with me less energy and less motivation to study the foreign languages I would like to learn. I had to cut it down from twelve languages to three languages and I'm still not fluent in the two I'm studying. It's just too mentally exhausting to go from my day job to studying foreign languages during my free time day in and day out.
In Sweden it's not only hard to fire someone, but expensive as well.
That said, some of these are just a result of incompetence by the legislators and/or courts. It's been a few years, but I've seen organizations in my country trying that "self-employed" and the Labour Court straightened them pretty quickly when they tried to fire someone. If you have a boss, fixed place of work, working hours, etc, you won't fool anyone.
The six-month probationary period is mostly fixed by not allowing it to be constantly renewed. Replacing all your workflow twice a year (even if gradually) is a heavy tax.
Its certainly not hard to fire/layoff people in the UK