News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by John23832 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:43AM (#13426588)
I don't get why people are so surprised that this is the Apple we're seeing under Tim. Tim was the COO... he knows operations. He's not a creative, he's not a tech guy. He knows operations, and he knows them well.

While the creative/user facing side has been lack luster (depending on if you ask the average consumer or a techie), the operational side is booming. Their product line has slimmed, they have clear and concise build processes, they've improved their services roll out and are still sitting on a mound of cash.

I think Tim has accomplished what he was put in place to do. People act like Steve Jobs, the guy who put Tim there, didn't know Tim at all. Jobs knew Tim very well. He knew what Tim was good at, and I'm sure they talked about what Tim should do in the future. This is the established course for Apple. Take it or leave it.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by rapsey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:54AM (#13426669)
> Their product line has slimed, they have clear and concise build processes, and are still sitting on a mound of cash.

The mac line is regressing in terms of hardware and software. While they used to have one of the best mobile dev environments, they now have the worst development environment. XCode is a bigger mess every release. Every macOS has more bugs then the last.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by tptacek on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:01AM (#13426723)
The Mac line is regressing according to people who bought the first iteration of a new Mac product, violating a cardinal rule in place since the Titanium Powerbook. To my eyes, this is more like adherence to a time-honored Apple tradition.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by deong on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:39AM (#13427064)
When the second generation won't exist for half a decade, I don't think the old rules are still in effect.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by msabalau on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:43AM (#13427101)
Fair enough, but for many people love for Apple has always been a combination of admiring the solid design of an individual product alongside the brand of "think different" innovation. If you feel that Apple hasn't really done anything astonishingly innovative since 2010 (the iPad, and the iPhone 4, i.e. Retina), you are losing the brand identity half of the value prop.

That Apple, as if they were making washing machines or minivans, cares about Consumer Reports recommendations is far more damaging to their mystique than getting not getting a CR recommendation.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by apercu on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:18PM (#13428727)
I think that's true for those that look at products as some sort of cultural artifact, but for many of us it was simply easier to replace the current laptop with the new model and know you'd have quality components.

The same could not be said for most popular non-apple laptops (HP, Dell, Compaq, etc...).

You might buy a Compaq and two years later buy the same model and have completely different (usually terrible) video card, screen, etc...

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by rapsey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:42AM (#13427091)
Software is getting less reliable as well.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by tptacek on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:31AM (#13427582)
You are not going to convince someone who ran 10.0 that we have reached some unprecedented low in Apple software quality.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by nickpsecurity on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:48AM (#13427771)
Sun did an rewrite and upgrade of Solaris into version 10 with quite a bit of reliability. All that work cost just under $300 million. Apple has over 100x that money. You'd think they could at least afford the SDL & static analysis Microsoft was using if not a total rewrite of Mac OS X into the greatest OS ever made.

They also have differentiators of usability, cool factor, UNIX support & privacy given Microsoft's turn with recent Windows. There's also a software ecosystem to further monetize & develop. Apple is screwing up big time in letting Mac OS languish.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by brianwawok on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:49PM (#13428445)
So what would the return on that money be?

The dev market for laptops is X. The random Joe Sixpack market for iToys is 100x or 1000x. If they are going to invest some giant figure in development, it will be for Joe Sixpack toys and not the best OS to ever live.

(That is if throwing money at the problem would actually make a better OS. I suspect Microsoft throws more money at OS than all the other OS companies combined. They still have some massive failures).

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by nickpsecurity on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:43PM (#13429034)
What would the return be on vertical integration that Apple does in general? About nothing vs good strategies for COTS acquisition and supply chain. So, why does Apple do these things? To reduce risk to brand or products caused by 3rd parties plus allow them to control key aspects of technology to benefit themselves.

Similarly for Mac OS. The main alternatives to watering down experience of their developers or power users are a scheming competitor with history of screwing its own ecosystem up arbitrarily and Linux distros that are lame compared to Mac/UNIX experience. I say that as an Ubuntu user.

If they want their own fabs and phones, it seems fitting to also ensure their desktop experience for developers or power users is similarly low risk or tuned to their needs. Redmond and Linux surely aren't.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by johansch on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:39PM (#13431067)
It's not in the nature of operationally minded people to think long-term. They think about the next quarter, or at most towards the end of the current accounting year.

To put it another way: all they do is tactics - not strategy.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by johansch on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:37AM (#13427660)
At that time they had a proper excuse though - it was brand new, they had financial issues, their old OS was antiquated so they had to rush, etc, etc. They then worked diligently for like a decade to reach a peak in terms of features, design and quality around the time of Steve's death in 2011.

Now they don't really have any excuses.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by statictype on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @08:04PM (#13432057)
He said its getting less reliable - not that we reached an all-time low.

There seems to be a very obvious regression in quality - but that doesn't mean its worse than how it was 15 years ago (or worse than anything else in the market right now)

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by yardie on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:02PM (#13427926)
I don't remember 10.0 as buggy. Slow, definitely.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by tptacek on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:05PM (#13427956)
Then, respectfully, you don't remember 10.0.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by johansch on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:22PM (#13428148)
I also mainly remember the slowness. I ran it on a 300 Mhz PowerBook iirc. (It wasn't my main machine/OS though.)
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by apercu on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:16PM (#13428700)
Memories. I had two partners that always had to have the latest and greatest. They both bought ti-books. I was on a pismo.

One of the laptops started peeling apart in 6 months.

The other was dropped by airport security and fell (almost)completely apart. Now, any laptop would have smashed, but given what happened to the other guys ti-book....

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by agmcleod on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:19AM (#13426876)
Yeah pretty much since android studio replaced eclipse, things got better on the android side. Though I still find android a pain from an ecosystem perspective.

Haven't done a lot of straight up native apps, but I use the tools for react native & cordova stuff.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by rapsey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:30AM (#13426982)
Android dev has improved by leaps and bounds. iOS dev has drastically regressed.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:34AM (#13427019)
I'd argue that Swift is one of the best things that happened to iOS development in the past few years.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by rapsey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:41AM (#13427084)
Compiler that regularly crashes. Dev environment that regularly crashes, behaves strangely and is full of bugs. Really long compile times.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by sssilver on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:45PM (#13429648)
I disagree with the Xcode sentiment. While it's horrible in its current state, it has consistently gotten better with every release, although honestly the progress is so slow that it feels like the only thing that can salvage it is perhaps architecture redesign and rewrite from scratch.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by dottrap on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:45AM (#13427117)
> he's not a tech guy

Well, he kind of is, but not in a way that appeals to most tech geek crowds.

He has a degree in Industrial Engineering which (defined by Wikipedia): "work to eliminate waste of time, money, materials, man-hours, machine time, energy and other resources that do not generate value".

Engineering to make things more efficient and reduce waste may not be "tech sexy", but to make it happen involves real technology and engineering.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by ProAm on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:20AM (#13427474)
It took an Industrial Engineer to get rid of the headphone jack.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by bluejekyll on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:12PM (#13428036)
Honestly, the headphone jack while ubiquitous, is an ancient interface.

My biggest issue with it's removal is that they didn't replace it with another analog interface. I believe that the DAC should live in the phone, leaving the headphone to merely to deal with a simple analog signal. I haven't jumped into the wireless bandwagon, bc the wire has never bothered me. On top of that I have a great battery and DAC in the phone already, I really don't want to be bothered with charging one more thing.

If they had adopted a new standard interface that would have been great. Hell I would even be ok with it being usbc if that meant that the jack was standard. It's this non-standard interface that has me considering not buying a new iPhone. I don't care about the loss of the analog jack as much as the non-standard wired option that's left.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by ProAm on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:18PM (#13428096)
> the headphone jack while ubiquitous, is an ancient interface

Ancient, but MASSIVELY used, and affordable. There are finally high quality affordable wired headphones out there that I can use between multiple devices. Removing it forces people to spend significantly more money on a ancillary accessory that is not guaranteed to work across multiple devices. It was a money grab.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by exabrial on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:34PM (#13428282)
If I'm taking an international flight, I have to carry headphones to use the in-flight entertainment. Whether or not Apple likes it or not, the headphone is here to stay for a very long time.

There is _also_ not enough wireless bandwidth available for an entire plane of people to simultaneously support 250 different stereo audio streams in such a small area. ...or a crowded office.

I have a really nice pair of IEMs I had molded to my ears from Alclair Audio. They're already expensive enough, there's not reason to add the inconvenience of batteries, latency, and bandwidth competition.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by remarkEon on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:58PM (#13476015)
Curious. I see more and more of the in-flight entertainment systems including USB chargers on them - for charging, not listening. My experience on flights where I use the analog jack is that it's usually a terrible experience, in terms of audio quality. IFF the USC-C standard becomes more ubiquitous, this might be rendered a moot point.

Of course, I do not know if the USB-C has been tested for the kind of brutal, constant usage that would be common on aircraft so I might be completely wrong.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by John23832 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:51AM (#13427179)
True, but it seems his focus is more process engineering than what you and I would consider "techie".
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by simonh on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:01AM (#13427285)
> While the creative/user facing side has been lack luster

I just don't see it. 5K and retina wide colour gamut displays, the aggressively lightweight MacBook design, new Mac Pros with an entirely new touch interface system, new keyboard mechanism and new hinge mechanism, continuity, a new graphics API subsystem (Metal), a brand new programming language. Then you have the Apple Watch. Which area exactly do you think they are lacking in?

What other computer manufacturer or OS vendor is out-innovating Apple? Microsoft Surface? Bought-in commodity touch tech and 5400 RPM hard drives.

If you compare the last 6 years with the period between the introduction of the iPod and the introduction of the iPhone, the last 6 years easily wins in terms of new innovative product releases and updates.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by addicted on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:21AM (#13427483)
This is my problem with Apple at the moment.

They are doing hard things. However, I suspect they are completely out of touch with the actual goals of their customers.

MBP is an engineering marvel. Fitting that technology, with that battery life, into those size and weight specs is incredible. However, are the sacrifices made to achieve that last 0.2 pounds of weight loss, or fraction of cms size reduction worth it? I don't think Apple is in agreement with their customer base here.

Swift. It's a really nice language, but was there any reason for Apple to invent a completely new language? The problem for Apple was Obj-C, but there are many other languages that could have worked as well. Even if they did need to invent a wholly new language, the marginal benefits just don't seem appealing.

The new keyboard mechanism has only led to a keyboard that at best is considered an improvement by as many people as those who consider it a downgrade.

Metal. Nice, but once again, did Apple really need to invent their own graphics subsystem which cannot be used on non-Apple platforms? How does that help anyone outside of lock in for Apple?

Apple Watch. Nice product, but WatchOS3 was basically what OS 1 should have been.

I think Apple has been doing a lot of things. I get the feeling the percentage of those things which are actually aligned with what customers want, or make life easier for customers, either due to NIH or due to wanting to create lock in, is extremely limited.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by iainmerrick on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:46AM (#13427744)
Swift. It's a really nice language, but was there any reason for Apple to invent a completely new language? The problem for Apple was Obj-C, but there are many other languages that could have worked as well.

I think the main requirement was interoperability with Obj-C. They really needed something reasonably similar (OO and reference counting). No existing mainstream language would have fit in neatly without extensive customization.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by sssilver on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:47PM (#13429658)
> Swift. It's a really nice language, but was there any reason for Apple to invent a completely new language? The problem for Apple was Obj-C, but there are many other languages that could have worked as well.

What language(s) do you have in mind?

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by John23832 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:08AM (#13427345)
>>(depending on if you ask the average consumer or a techie)

There are definitely people who feel left out by Apple. As evident by the numerous blog post and talks on the internet.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by simonh on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:45AM (#13427733)
If the internet were to be believed, the iPhone was a marketing-lead fad with no chance of success and every month since 2007 a new reason gets trotted out for their impending doom. Meanwhile actual sales, customer satisfaction ratings and margins climb ever higher.

All of which drives the haters ever more cranky, hence all the blog posts.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by John23832 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:11PM (#13428017)
None of what you said matters.

I said in my previous comment (and was implied in the OP) that people feel left out by Apple. The only proof I need for that is one person write a blog post saying that they feel left out by Apple, which we've definitely seen.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by Caprinicus on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:29PM (#13430013)
It matters because people writing angry blog posts because apple leaves someone out has happened at every iteration of every apple product ever.

Apple removing the firewire port was the end of the world.

http://appleinsider.com/articles/08/10/16/jobs_responds_to_o...

Apple removing the matte screen option was a the end of the world

http://www.macworld.com/article/1136061/matte_laptops.html

Using USB instead of ADB, SCSI and GeoPort and ditching floppy drives was the end of the world

http://www.technologizer.com/2008/10/17/firewire-isnt-alone-...

I don't think I even need to link posts about powerpc, flash player, or the 30 pin connector

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by John23832 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @04:02PM (#13430243)
But it doesn't. I was simply stating that some people feel left out. That is it. Regardless of whether people have BM'd on the internet before. Regardless of the implications of someone feeling left out.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by simonh on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @06:00PM (#13431293)
I get it, so me people feel left out. I agreed with you, hence my comment about cranky blog posts. I'm just saymg that's business as usual and it doesn't mater. They'll buy a Windows or Linux machine and get on with their lives.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by John23832 on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:53AM (#13444174)
Ok, I get that.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by jrs235 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:45AM (#13427739)
Operations tend to focus on and optimize for efficiency (doing things right). Steve Jobs at CEO was a visionary and was focused on effectiveness (doing the right thing(s)).

What has happened since Tim took over is, and should have been, expected.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by devoply on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:37AM (#13427045)
Operations will not keep Apple alive. I mean Jobs was a genius in knowing what people want, but he wasn't good at knowing how to replace himself. It's outside his abilities just like it's Cook's abilities to be creative or to know what people want. Operations people are good for operations, and nothing else. And usually hated by many people in the company for the policies they force on the company in order to improve the bottom line.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by spaceisballer on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:36AM (#13427647)
I think that people just want Tim Cook to be Steve Jobs. However Steve even wanted Tim to come in and do what Tim does.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by wavefunction on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:56AM (#13426686)
You'd think their OS releases would be decent but Mavericks and Yosemite sucked. Mavericks, ostensibly an update to include their ebooks platform caused my macbook pro to shut-down at random times and force me into quasi disk-repair to start the computer back up again.

It was by-far the worst experience with a computer I've ever had, and I started out on 286s many moons ago so I seen some chit...

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by ihuman on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:14AM (#13426839)
What does this comment have to do with the one you replied to? Instead of adding to the conversation about Cook using what he learned as COO under Jobs, you're complaining about software updates.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by misnome on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:37AM (#13427039)
And the windows 10 anniversary update literally caused my computer to freeze for up to 30 seconds every time I tried to interact with the task bar.

These things happen with all companies.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by agumonkey on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:16AM (#13426850)
I wonder if they discussed the phase Apple is entering right now though. I agree with you that Jobs probably understood 100% what Cook at the head would mean, and did it willingly; IMO to ensure a long and smooth ride of the previous era successes. Now did they have plans in mind for long term ..
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by CodeWriter23 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @03:29PM (#13430012)
I'm pretty sure Steve was counting on them keeping Forstall as part of the team. He kind of was Steve Jr. when it came to making people cry and pushing them to reach beyond what they think they are capable of. But Tim and Jonny (and maybe Craig) didn't like it.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by ProAm on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:28AM (#13427550)
> This is the established course for Apple. Take it or leave it.

Umm no, share holders and the board definitely has a voice and I think we are not too far away from Tim leaving as CEO. Normally they'd give a guy like this a year maybe 18 months to right the ship, the only reason why it would be longer at Apple is because their development and release cycle is absurdly long. If it takes 3+ years to upgrade each product line, he might get 3 more years at the helm before they politely oust him.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by dottrap on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:00PM (#13427903)
Tim Cook has performed well for share holders. He has led Apple to record shattering profits, huge cash surpluses, and even in years like this where they came in under target, they still dominated in profits relative to their peers.

For share holders, the pressure on Tim Cook is not for him to step down. The pressure on Tim Cook by many share holders is to focus only on iPhone and for him to abandon the Mac, Apple TV, and other things that are not considered material to the profits of the company.

We saw this before during the iPod domination years. Vocal share holders wanted Steve Jobs to ditch the Mac and focus only on iPod.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by ProAm on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:05PM (#13427953)
But I think the smart share holders are very weary of Apple moving into the Ballmer era. MS was in the same boat, hugely profitable but drifting into a technical no mans land where people lost interest in the platform and do not care to give them a second chance once viable other options are available. Apple is absolutely still a money printing machine, but they are skating on thin ice with product quality and innovation. With a new CEO Apple will still be a money printing machine, but maybe get some of its mojo back.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by icanhackit on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:53PM (#13431992)
> they are skating on thin ice with product quality and innovation

How did you come to this conclusion? I've been using Apple computers since the late 80s and iPhones since the day the 3G shipped in 2008 and consider Apple's current computers, phones and accessories to be robust, of the highest material and design quality, and packed with cool tech. I walk around with my 7 Plus feeling like I'm a goddamned cyborg. I look around the streets and see a significant number of people sporting an Apple Watch while I've seen next to no one wearing a competing smart watch apart from Fitbit...which is pushing the definition somewhat. Around Christmas I was surprised to see quite a few people with AirPods but have yet to see anyone with another brand of wireless in-ear headphones.

You know what Tim isn't very good at? Being a bullshitter/salesman the way Steve Jobs was. And to sell the company to people who can't objectively see that Apple is doing some very cool things.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by olkid on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @12:18PM (#13428099)
Agreed. I applaud cnbc for linking to Steve Blank's article "why Tim Cook is Steve Ballmer"
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by athenot on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:50AM (#13426637)
The unfortunate part of this is that while a crazy product-driven visionnary needs a solid Operations leader to deliver the product, an Operations head will not suffer having a crazy product wildcard among his ranks. So this is a one-way transition from creative chaos to predictable stability.
Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:07AM (#13426779)
Is there any evidence at all to back up this assertion? Why in the world would you assume that an operations head can't see the value of product driven visionaries, but the reverse is true?

I have worked several times for operational leaders who have valued and cultivated visionary product thinking.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by serge2k on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @01:54PM (#13429153)
Is being an ops guy an excuse for letting their software quality drop?

I think the hardware design issues are a result of the change in dynamics with Ive and Jobs, but quality issues aren't really excusable.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by PopsiclePete on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:29AM (#13427561)
>This is the established course for Apple. Take it or leave it.

Heh. No. That's not how publicly traded companies work. Tim Cook is not an Autocrat.

Re:Former Apple engineer: Tim Cook made Apple a 'boring oper... by 91bananas on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:53AM (#13427199)
> Their product line has slimed

Possible Freudian slip?