Edit: You also cannot just discard certificates and use HTTPS as an "I'm talking to the same server I was 5 seconds ago", because that does literally nothing to prevent MitM attacks. If you can't assert that you're talking securely to the domain owner, then there's nothing at all stopping someone in a privileged network position from intercepting and altering your traffic, because they could simply proxy it through their own server.
>does literally nothing to prevent MitM attacks
It does more than nothing. Especially if you make the reasonable assumptions that 1) the user is not being MitMed most of the time and 2) the user is likely to have connected to the (small) set of sensitive sites before they experience their first MitM.
Example: my home internet is unadulterated. I check my mail. My computer saves the certificate. I go to a coffee shop. I check my mail again. Somone tries to MitM me. My computer instantly spots a changed certificate.
Obviously we should still use and verify certificates. But I notice a nasty trend of making the perfect the enemy of the good in security. There's a perception that if it's not perfect, it's worse than useless and should be shunned (probably due to historical bad experiences with false senses of security).
Not exactly sure what that'd buy...
That's worth something. But as the article points out, it doesn't help if you started out with the wrong domain name. (How do you get the bookmark in the first place?)
EV has the security benefit over DV in that you can use HPKP to pin EV CA public keys, so no DV certificates will ever be trusted for your site.
This statement does not make sense. Could you explain what you are implying here?
Presumably, MitM'ing the CA's traffic to the domain owner is significantly harder than MitM'ing a random user, though certainly not impossible.
HTTPS without certs means you are talking securely to your attacker :-)
This attack also requires the user to ignore the suffix.
I think Chrome used to do this too, but it doesn't for me right now; I'm not sure why.
Disclaimer: work for CertSimple, who only does EV certificates (which match a cert to a legal entity). Though I use DV for my personal site.