News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by onli on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @07:30PM (#13370698)
I don't get it. This is a IBM PC moment right here. Imagine you could standardize the smartphone. Really divide it into block, standardize the communication bus. Make it a PC. It would be huge, eat up the smartphone world, just like the PC ate up the homecomputers.

I even think this is how Google would have beaten the iPhone. Android as the OS for an ever-evolving phone, where if a user needs more ram he would just add more, if he needs a new processor he would just replace the current, if he needs a higher resolution display the old just would get replaced. Of course that is not easy, of course in the beginning a tailor-made smartphone would be slicker, faster. But then you support it some time and you get loyal users upgrading their device instead of even considering something else.

I know there are limits to upgradeability, just as a PC reaches the moment where all that remains from its old incarnation is the case. But still, enabling upgrades and thus removing consumers from the market would be a huge hit to all other smartphone vendors, probably spawning a more targeted parts industry.

And no: The current module system from LG or what Ara was presenting in the end is not it. Adding a new photo lense interests no one. You need to be able to switch out the core components to make an impact. The Fairphone 2 comes close, but I don't think you can drive real core upgrades without controlling the OS, and thus it ends up with a core module. We'll see. If they manage to add things like replacing the display with a better display, the core module with a more powerful one, that might already be good enough.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by femto on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:43PM (#13371066)
Did the upgradeable PC ever really work, or did the vast majority of PCs sold go to the dump with exactly the same configuration as sold? After a few years, it becomes a cascade of dependencies: Can't upgrade memory because the old motherboard won't support state of the art DIMMs, the bus used by current cards (ISA, PCI, AGP, PCIx) doesn't match the motherboard, power supply connector has different number of pins, and if you replace the motherboard to allow a newer component to be plugged in then all of the other old stuff needs to be replaced due to the new motherboard. The most success with longevity seems to be USB peripherals, with old/new stuff working together, and it's worth noting that USB is external to the PC. (I'd contend that that USB's success is largely due to the mechanical simplicity of USB, which is beginning to disappear.)

With increased integration, there's also an aspect of the cost of a module being almost independent of its contents, meaning that the cost of making a device is roughly proportional to the number modules it contains. Under those circumstances, it makes sense to minimise the number of modules, the lowest overall device cost being a single integrated unit.

In my mind, the key to long life is freedom to modify the software. It's amazing how far a well designed hardware platform can be pushed with software optimisation over time. I do embedded systems in my day job and our current product does things that weren't even thought of when it's hardware was designed, by virtue of the original design keeping the hardware simple whilst doing as much as possible in software, and current creative use the existing hardware resources.

I think a fixed hardware platform can work well, provided an original design goal is to do as much as possible in software and there is complete freedom to rework the software going forward.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by swsieber on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:51PM (#13371102)
The boon wasn't that consumers could customize their computers - it was that competitors could easy compete on individual parts because of the standardization.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by femto on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:21PM (#13371233)
A valid point! The economics of integration seems to be driving us towards single boxes which suit stifled competition?

Is there an opening here for a non-manufacturing "open" standards body to emerge? They could publish mechanical specifications for a "click together phone" and a specification for a simple electrical bus/interconnect (use USB for everything?)

One could envisage a series of standard exterior cases, based on a common unit of measure. Each case might contain openings for screen, camera, connectors, etc. according to the type of device. Inside the case would be spaces for internal modules, also based on the common unit of measure, not specific to any one type of module and with interfaces in standard positions. Exterior cases in the series might include:

* Smartphone

* Tablet

* Laptop

* Desktop

* Media player

Such a movement could arise from the Makerspace movement, as it would be a relatively low cost thing to do? One can imagine a website with specification documents and 3D printer files for the various module outlines. People would then be free to experiment on making new components within this ecosystem.

---

Edit: I'm pessimistic that the above would progress past a hobbyist level as the economics favours an integrated approach, unless it spurs a level of competition and innovation that undercuts the premiums being charged by the makers of walled gardens.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:50PM (#13371608)
It basically won't happen until we have a competitive processor that's fully open. Nobody has a strong incentive to start a standards body when they can control a market instead.

Even when Google was still working on Ara, they planned to release the "Endo", or base frame, itself, and then just let vendors sell modules with a similar OEM partnership to how they control Android OEMs today.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by nrp on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:29PM (#13371509)
There are equivalents in smartphones. MIPI standards like D-PHY and C-PHY and DSI and CSI on top of those ensure compatibility of cameras and displays in a way there is significant competition among suppliers there, and wide range of options for handset makers. JEDEC similarly does so for DRAM and Flash. Unlike the IBM PC era, the mechanical interfaces aren't standardized due to the desire for deeper physical integration for miniaturization, but the electrical interfaces and protocols still are.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by flukus on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:37PM (#13371299)
> Did the upgradeable PC ever really work, or did the vast majority of PCs sold go to the dump with exactly the same configuration as sold?

It worked in 90's and early 00's, particularly with RAM, hard drives and CD ROM drives. You could walk into a consumer electronic store and buy these drives stand alone, I don't think you can do that anymore. I was frequently upgrading friends and family computers for beer, anyone technical usually had a bunch of old RAM sticks and hard drives lying around for anyone that wanted them and a new computer frequently meant a new motherboard and case where you could add all the component of the old one.

This was a time where hardware upgrades were a huge deal. Going from 8MB to 16MB of RAM was a lot more valuable than going from 8GB to 16GB is today. And there were frequently software releases that warranted hardware upgrades. For my, buying visual studio necessitated I upgrade my 540MB hard drive to a 3GB one for instance.

> After a few years, it becomes a cascade of dependencies: Can't upgrade memory because the old motherboard won't support state of the art DIMMs, the bus used by current cards (ISA, PCI, AGP, PCIx) doesn't match the motherboard, power supply connector has different number of pins, and if you replace the motherboard to allow a newer component to be plugged in then all of the other old stuff needs to be replaced due to the new motherboard.

Yeah, it became like that in the early 00's from memory after a decade of relative stability. That's when the hardware world got too complicated for a simple software dev like me. Although with everything on SATA and PCIx these days I wonder if I could pick it up again.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:52PM (#13371621)
It's still true today if you buy non-"premium" laptops and boxy desktops still. DDR3 was the RAM of choice for a good long number of years, and SATA drive connectivity standards have reigned for even longer.

Stores like Fry's Electronics have major component offerings, and even at your Best Buy or Staples today there's generally a limited supply of standard replacement parts for conventional PCs.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by akozak on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:51PM (#13371099)
That the vast majority of people have a different relationship to technology than you is a critical insight for engineers transitioning into (consumer facing) product development.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by digi_owl on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:10AM (#13372106)
It did, until it no longer did.

With DOS and Win9x one could effectively replace everything underfoot of the OS and it would hardly blink. Yes it would fall back to 640x480 and 16 colors, and demand you install some new drivers, but beyond that you could do just about anything and it would still boot.

Come NT and you would just be greeted with a error screen and a demand that you did a recovery (that would effectively roll back all patches etc).

And these days you have to phone Microsoft if you try anything like it more than a couple times because you tripped their DRM checks.

Yes, one could wander into a solid case of "my grandfathers axe". But the various layers were independent enough that they would come up in some kind of state that you could work with.

Sadly i fear that Linux is heading into the NT realm with the changes to the graphics sub-system that has come in recent years.

Where before higher modes were the realm of X, and things like 3D acceleration was yet another semi-independent layer, these days the kernel may well give you an error if you do not have the right GPU driver compiled in.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by AstralStorm on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @08:35AM (#13373758)
It will not. It should boot using either VESA, VGA or EFI video driver. Low resolution, no acceleration, potentially single monitor, but it will start. Even OpenGL will work via software emulation.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by pjc50 on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @08:56AM (#13373867)
I have personally experienced it not working, by changing the motherboard+hard disk combo from IDE to SATA. No SATA drivers installed => system boots but Windows falls over as soon as it stops using the BIOS.

(I can't remember exactly which version of Windows this was!)

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by digi_owl on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:27AM (#13374036)
I think it was more a response to me jab towards changes to the Linux graphics stack.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by hackuser on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:01AM (#13372086)
> Did the upgradeable PC ever really work, or did the vast majority of PCs sold go to the dump with exactly the same configuration as sold?

IME, it never did. Except for techies, hardly anyone opened their computers. I remember seeing some system offered to corporate customers that lacked upgradability (except maybe memory). At first I objected - what a ripoff - but then I realized the truth.

My impression is that PCs got their start with hobbyists and were designed for them, with extra slots and bays, etc., and to this day the designs are still adjusting to the vast majority of end-users. I think the first office suites included relational database authoring tools for everyone - as if most office workers would just whip them up as needed, like word processing documents.

Apple has always seen it differently: You couldn't (can't?) open the cases without special tools.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by intoverflow2 on Thursday January 12, 2017 @09:32AM (#13382436)
>Apple has always seen it differently: You couldn't (can't?) open the cases without special tools.

FYI the Mac Pros before the trashcan had a latch and the side opened just fine for upgrades. Actually even the trashcan can be opened but I kinda get the impression it can only be opened for you to admire it not really for you to upgrade it...

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by grzm on Thursday January 12, 2017 @09:35AM (#13382458)
Not everything can be swapped, but memory and storage can be:

Upgrade memory: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205044

Upgrade storage: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202881

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by WalterBright on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:49PM (#13371354)
> Did the upgradeable PC ever really work,

It did in the early days (the first 10 years). These days, the mobo, CPU, ram, power supply, graphics card all seem to need to be a matched set.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by p1mrx on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:47AM (#13372247)
For the mobo, CPU, and RAM, I would agree, but power supplies and graphics cards have been forwards and backwards compatible for roughly a decade.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by WalterBright on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @05:43AM (#13373038)
Not in my experience. The disk drive power connectors have changed, the fan connections multiply, and the mobo/graphics cards sprout extra needed connections.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by p1mrx on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @03:55PM (#13377414)
The SATA power connector is ~14 years old, and graphics cards often come with adapters for the PCI-E power connectors. Some GPUs (like the GTX 1050 Ti) are entirely powered by the PCI-E slot.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by SerLava on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:44AM (#13372239)
Oh man, I was poor soon after leaving my parents' house, and stopped thinking about PC upgrades for about 7 years. When income finally happened, I decided to customize a gaming PC and I thought I was just stupid. I guess it's actually a lot harder now.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by throwaway91111 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:55PM (#13371375)
You've been active through the transition. Care to speculate why?
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by flukus on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:44PM (#13371812)
Basically the interfaces between the components became less stable, instead of a single PCI connector for every component and IDE for drives, several were around at once. These were stable for a long time because the CPU was always the bottleneck, then suddenly CPU's got to the point were disk/RAM and graphics card buses were the bottleneck. So probably nothing intentionally sinister, other than the lack of more future proof standardization when the change happened.

Now that CPU speed increases have leveled off things seem to have stabilized again.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by WalterBright on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @12:40AM (#13372023)
This. The interfaces kept changing at an accelerating rate. In the 80s people bent over backwards to not change the interface. That all went out the window.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by jpm_sd on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @07:52PM (#13370807)
Nope. Sorry. Physics. Compared to a lightweight device that fits in your pocket, an IBM PC is huge. Colossal. All the space you could possibly need for modular interconnects, sheet metal sub-chassis-es, proper fasteners, etc. etc.

A comparably-modular mobile phone cannot be anything but thick and heavy, unless you would prefer fragile and unusable.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by djsumdog on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:40PM (#13371048)
That's not what makes a PC. A PC has a bunch of standard hardware, a VGA/VESA interface, a console, a legacy BIOS or newer UEFI.

Android phones have NONE of this. Google could force this. Their "Open Handset Alliance" is not at all open. It's a closed lock in system to keep all their manufactures from ever making Amazon phones.

Google has a vested interested in selling more phones. They could easily require standardization. They could ban binary blobs. They could require all manufactures to make their kernel patches and drivers upstreamable and meet Linux kernel standards. But they don't.

You can take a 32-bit x86 Linux distro from today and run it on an old Pentium. You can take a really old 32-bit distro from years ago and run it on a modern machine (of course very little of the hardware will work, but it should boot in legacy mode...okay, okay it might not boot, but if it does boot you will get a console I/O).

It has nothing to do with the phone and has to do with the fact that ARM is not an architecture. It's a SoC sold to tons of manufactures who all connect whatever they want to onto whatever pins they want to. Yes yes, there are things like Device Tree configs, but name a phone that supports them (no seriously, I'm asking. Are there any? Like I would want to buy/experiment with them if they exist).

Every ARM device seems to have a totally different base image and this isn't maintainable. We need a standard device/IO configuration system so that you can install standard AOSP + drivers onto any phone just like we can with Windows:

http://penguindreams.org/blog/android-fragmentation/

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by sjg007 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:40PM (#13371051)
PCs were expensive which created the markets for upgrades and components. Phones are basically disposable.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by autocorr on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:33PM (#13371774)
It seems likely they only appear that way because the initial cost is amortized into the contract for most people in the US. An iPhone 7 is around $700! And flagship android phones are up there too. I guess people have a lot of disposable income or just see the sign-up price?
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by kemiller on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @12:43AM (#13372039)
Starting price for the IBM PC was over $4000 in current dollars, for a dramatically less-capable device. It's not that upgradability wouldn't be nice, it just isn't as important as portability, reliability, battery life, or initial price.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by intoverflow2 on Thursday January 12, 2017 @09:36AM (#13382472)
From what I've seem most people end up dropping and smashing them every 5 months, they're well aware of how much they cost because they'll happily slide their fingers across shards of glass to avoid paying again.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by Unai on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:37PM (#13371298)
One could say that's a good reason to push the modular phone.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by wapz on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:19PM (#13370963)
I would think a 'modular' phone would have to be one that you could open up and swap out the parts like a pc. You could customize it easily because nothing would be soldered to the board but with onboard ram for boards I don't see how it would be replaceable. The camera lens, speakers, etc should be easily replaceable though.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by rtkwe on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:39PM (#13371045)
There's still just not enough space in anything like a modern smart phone to fit all the interconnects to allow that to happen. A laptop sodimm slot is 3-5 mm thick by itself. Also in general you could replace cameras and speakers now they're often their own assemblies or boards.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by onli on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:16PM (#13370943)
I don't believe that for a minute. While it won't be easy – otherwise Ara would have succeeded already – I don't think we are anywhere near a problem that physics make really infeasible. Where is the physical argument? Where is the formula that says that blocks that size can't stick? You "just" need well defined small intercommunication system for small blocks with one good system that holds it together.

If that were impossible, Ara would have not come as far as it did, and the Fairphone 2 would not be as modular as it is.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by jfoutz on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:36PM (#13371031)
Think of it this way. You could have one big board with spots to put in upgrades, camera, memory graphics, whatever.

Soldering can get things pretty small, and pretty close together. Home soldering is possible, but requires some tools, and a steady hand. if you want people to solder, you'll probably need to make the connections a little bigger and further apart than what you would need for a nice smt with mask in a shop. Soldering is is also kind of hard to reverse.

Any mechanical fastener is easy to undo, but much more bulky than soldering. i'm thinking little plastic clips, but there are alternatives. in any case, they're going to be bigger.

That leaves maybe some kind of conductive epoxy and a solvent to remove it. that should be pretty comparable to soldering, but seems like it would have the same problems, you'd want bigger surface mount pads.

mechanical fasteners are the way to go, you don't need any (or many) expensive tools to get it right. but mechanical fasteners are big, and that's space that could go to more battery, bigger screen or whatever. further apart means slower bus speed, and probably other problems.

The other options require special tools. So phone plus $200 or whatever for the tools just isn't worth it. (and making the process super reliable for novices isn't easy)

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by smallnamespace on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @07:55PM (#13370827)
> Make it a PC. It would be huge, eat up the smartphone world, just like the PC ate up the homecomputers.

I don't quite understand this point.

PCs are inherently upgradeable, but it seems like consumers would rather treat them as disposable electronic devices, judging by the success of barely-upgradeable Macs and other laptops.

And I'm not sure I blame them either, it's not like it's easy for a consumer with no techy knowledge to know whether they should upgrade the RAM, or the SSD, or the GPU, and research which components are compatible, best bang for the buck, etc.

You're making out upgradeability to be the reason why PCs won and are super successful, but it seems more because there were a whole bunch of PC-compatible clones that could all run the same software. The hardware/peripheral compatibility between PC clones was never very particularly good until well into the 90s, well after the PC standard had already 'won', and the computers they replaced were also upgradeable.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by acchow on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:14PM (#13371695)
> PCs are inherently upgradeable, but it seems like consumers would rather treat them as disposable electronic devices, judging by the success of barely-upgradeable Macs and other laptops.

Disposability is a side-effect of non-upgradeability - consumers don't explicitly want either of those, they just want a good product. And a good product can't be upgradeable.

See Daring Fireball's article on this: http://daringfireball.net/2011/09/new_apple_advantage

The money shot is, "Apple offers far fewer configurations. Thus MacBooks are, to most minds, subjectively better-designed — but objectively, they’re more designed. Apple makes more of the choices than do PC makers."

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by bluedino on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:55PM (#13371123)
Exactly - and a bunch of companies built phones that can run Android, so Google has won, in a way
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by bagrow on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:03PM (#13370881)
How many smartphone users even know how much RAM they have? Smartphones are eating everything because they just work. Even more than PCs, which are also heavily commoditized these days. It seems like almost everyone thinks of upgrading computers and phones these days the way I would think of upgrading my microwave: by buying a new one.

Is this a very western-centric view? Maybe... But it seems like everyone wants things to just work and unless they are VERY price-conscious, they don't want to think about it much.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by 21 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:42PM (#13371062)
Heck, I'm a software developer and I don't really know how much RAM my phone has.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by flukus on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:15PM (#13371699)
I didn't until I discovered it wasn't enough to run pokemon go.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by lobster_johnson on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:06PM (#13371176)
PCs weren't successful because they were upgradeable or because you could build custom ones out of commodity parts -- all that happened because the PC was successful.

The PC was successful because everyone wanted a computer that was like a PC, and two things happened: With the clone market, enough manufacturers could make the same thing, thus making computers affordable. Secondly, MS-DOS (and later, Windows) became a de facto standard preventing manufacturers from fragmenting the market with vendor-specific platforms. You bought a PC and it could run any DOS application.

Now, the clone market happened because the PC had standard components, which allowed any vendor to compete. Why can't standard components drive a new revolution in phones? Because everyone already has cheap, disposable phones. As far as the consumer is concerned, the mobile phone's "PC moment" already happened, except without the modularity.

If there's anything to disrupt today, it's the network.

(Would a modular phone be nice? Sure, probably. Would it work, physically? Not if you want to keep the form factor of today's slim smartphones.)

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by janekm on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:12AM (#13372116)
This actually already happened, to the extent that it ever made a difference in the PC ecosystem. The manufacturers of cheap phones in China use standardised modules: motherboard PCB, display with standardised connector, battery, "open mold" (a standard mold designed by a design contractor for the chipset vendor, open to many manufacturers).

This allows them to quickly assemble low-cost phones with components from a large number of manufacturers, driving down costs.

So the financial benefit that came from the open PC ecosystem has already been realised on cheap Android phones, the equivalent of the crappy PCs assembled from lowest bidder components of yesterday (Dell, Packard Bell, etc).

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by losteric on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:23PM (#13370982)
I would argue that standardization in the PC markets is driven by overlap between enterprise server hardware, enterprise PC hardware, and (incidentally!) consumer PCs...

Think about laptops, they've been around for a lot longer and are much closer to desktop PCs. Why hasn't modularization transformed that market? What about tables?

Answer: Most consumers don't care. They won't upgrade their PC, their laptop, their phones, their tablets, they'll just check them out and get a new one every 5 years.

Phones and tablets don't have enterprise demand. Laptops have some enterprise demand, which corresponds to some degree of customization/standardization.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by bluedino on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:58PM (#13371142)
Modular design of PC's made the manufacturers all race to the bottom in price and nobody but Apple has made money from personal computer sales in 15 years.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by Laforet on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:21PM (#13371236)
This is a good point. I've always wondered why PC components have always been priced with total transparency and razor-sharp margins unlike most other kinds of tech.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by flukus on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:25PM (#13371740)
How much of that race to the bottom was driven by a handful of integrators like dell though? If they were on store shelves they might have other ways to increase profit margins. Spending $10 more on a better component is an easier decision than spending $100 on a packaged product that you don't know the internals of.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by nine_k on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:40PM (#13371564)
In a PC, you have plenty of room for interconnect. A system board can easily dedicate 25% of the area to PCI slots, and another 25% to CPU and RAM slots. A typical chassis has plenty of empty space, for air cooling if for nothing else.

A phone has nearly zero empty space. It has to be very compact, especially thin, it has to have a large battery, a large screen, and powerful chips. Also consider things like antennas, microphones, speakers, usb and headphone connectors that cannot be made smaller than physics and standards dictate.

A phone has no room for connectors between major components that would be remotely convenient for the user. Many connectors, is placed in accessible ways, would also work against mechanical strength. Good connectors that won't break after 2-3 reconfigurations, aren't cheap. Thus a phone with connectors will need to be significantly larger and heavier, and also costlier.

The PC argument does not work with mobile devices. At best, major components, like radio interfaces board, or a screen, or a battery can be made standardized and user-replaceable, likely requiring tools and skill. Batteries are easiest, but even these are far from standardized, and there are little incentive for manufacturers to work towards this. Users are content with glued-in batteries anyway.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by beambot on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:22PM (#13370977)
Full modularity never made sense. The system-level tradeoffs for battery, screen, and antennas are just too astronomical.

But one or two expansion slots... now that would've been revolutionary. You could add whatever mattered to you: medical devices, specialized cameras, etc. etc. etc. Instead we're left with shitty USB or audio jack dongles or detached Bluetooth devices. Suck.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by usrusr on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @10:08AM (#13374389)
Low effort modularity would be so easy... Back when smartphones were not phablets and batteries were swappable, custom back covers for fat extended batteries were available for almost any device. That's one precedent. The other are Wi-Fi SD cards that were sold before digital cameras started to integrate Wi-Fi on their own. There is another. Custom back covers for the minority who needs extra space and few connectors in the form factor of wired microSD (because micro USB is specified with far too strong mechanical reserves for this use case) would come at near zero extra bulk for those who don't use those possibilities and the minority who does have exotic needs would still be served.

Everything that would be used by more than 5% of users should still be integrated, everything else would be a waste of resources because high numbers have such a strong effect of making electronics cheap and light.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by serge2k on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:14PM (#13371212)
> Instead we're left with shitty USB

How is USB not a fantastic answer to the problem you described?

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by nradov on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @12:43AM (#13372036)
USB by itself is a terrible answer. The connector is small and weak so you can't hang a peripheral device from it without risk of breakage. The only way this would work is if phone manufacturers agreed to add mounting rails or magnets at a standardized position near the USB port in order to provide a secure and robust mounting point. But realistically I doubt that the major manufacturers would ever cooperate on that type of standardization.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by beambot on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:20PM (#13371719)
Dongles slapped on after the fact are a poor design. They ruin the ability to hold the device one handed, the ability to pocket the phone with the module attached, or add substantial bulk to cases that must be redesigned for every variant of phone.

USB is a decent electrical interconnect and API standard... But not a good cellphone mechanical modularity standard.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by voltagex_ on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:21PM (#13371725)
Possibly due to the placement of USB on most phones - at the bottom, where a drive would stick out awkwardly.

Also, MicroUSB on a lot of devices doesn't seem like the most robust port ever - I think it would eventually wear out with more than just the nightly plug/unplug for charging.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by ebbv on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:16PM (#13370946)
Do you realize what percent of all IBM compatibles ever had any upgrades done to them internally? Almost none. It seems like a defining feature if you're a nerd like me who did it with all your PCs but most people and most businesses bought them in a configuration and used them in that configuration until they were replaced.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by flukus on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:43PM (#13371325)
> Do you realize what percent of all IBM compatibles ever had any upgrades done to them internally?

Many, especially in the 90's when compelling software often necessitated hardware upgrades.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by tomc1985 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @11:40PM (#13371797)
I think part of it is that none of the OEMs really want to be just a computing platform. Margins are razor-thin due to competitive pressure from both the markets and from suppliers. They see Apple and Google and Microsoft dominating the field with their tightly-integrated ecosystems, commanding what is essentially a royalty on all "app" economic activity (to say nothing of hardware sales and everything else). And they want some. Bad.

Besides, public opinion on computing as a platform seems all but dead. This is a computers-as-appliance age, where everyone is punch-drunk on services and single-use apps. Power users seem to be disappearing; nobody wants to learn how to do anything and so much of what sells are just variations on a it-wipes-my-own-ass theme. Platforms don't work in that world; too few want to bother with them.

Nobody wants to simply build computers anymore, it seems. Too boring.

(edit: On the margins thing-- the big three enjoy greater margins because they offer greater services, insulating them from said pressure)

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by pjc50 on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @10:46AM (#13374711)
The standardization and cloneability of the IBM PC cost IBM a fortune. Nobody is going to make that mistake again.

Allowing interoperability on your system allows other vendors to drive down your margins. That's why we're in the mess we're in. It's part of the problem with IoT, too. It would be great to have a secure, interoperable set of home automation parts, but every manufacturer wants you locked into their cloud and buying new devices every few years to maintain the revenue stream.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by serge2k on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:10PM (#13371196)
> just like the PC ate up the homecomputers

Ever increasingly cheap and plentiful clones made computers finally cheap enough for anyone to own?

Phones are already way beyond that point.

> where if a user needs more ram he would just add more, if he needs a new processor he would just replace the current, if he needs a higher resolution display the old just would get replaced.

Why would I ever want to deal with that?

No one wants to deal with that. Just works is way better than endless tweaking.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by flukus on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:24PM (#13371247)
> Why would I ever want to deal with that?

Because it's cheaper and easier than throwing out a phone and getting a new one. Phones could less 10 years with ad hoc upgrades instead of 2. I'd love to have been able to take my galaxy nexus (best phone ever) and add more ram and a faster processor.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by alphakappa on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:36PM (#13371548)
It's possible that people get bored of their devices well before the devices stop functioning.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by digi_owl on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:02AM (#13372091)
The thing about the PC was that it was an accident of history.

Being made largely out of off the shelf parts, and coming from a company with a massive brand recognition in the business world, the PC was ripe for cloning.

The standardization only happened after the BIOS had been cloned, and the clones defended successfully in court.

As Project Ara moved forward, it became more and more clear that Google would have none of that clone business.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by toast0 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:11PM (#13370922)
The problem is connectors, there's no room in a phone to have connectors between the motherboard and smallish parts. Modular display and camera can make sense, but more as build time options.

How has google not already beaten the iPhone? They have vastly more users, and have very small margins (the end state for PCs)

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by sjg007 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @08:44PM (#13371069)
The iPhone has a better ux and battery life. The software is also likely higher quality.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by toast0 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:23PM (#13371244)
Modular hardware wouldn't improve ux or software quality. It would probably reduce battery life because there would be less space.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by sjg007 on Thursday January 12, 2017 @10:28PM (#13388191)
I said that the iPhone was better.. modular is worse I agree.
Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by mcphage on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @09:45PM (#13371338)
> I even think this is how Google would have beaten the iPhone.

By market share, Google won years ago. By profit, commoditizing the phone hardware even further would drive android manufacturer profit down even further.

Re:The dream of Ara: Inside the rise and fall of Google’s mo... by kchoudhu on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @10:22PM (#13371481)
Who made cash from the IBM PC moment, though? It certainly wasn't IBM.

Why would a privately owned company like Google seek to emulate this behavior?