Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by ryandrake on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:26AM
(#13328433)
Wow, when I went to hit the back button in my browser, a jarring "HEY, BEFORE YOU GO" pop-up appeared on the page, prompting me to do whatever. Haven't seen that trick before! Nice to see annoyance-delivery is still an area of active innovation.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by SamBam on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:51AM
(#13328707)
Oh man, I see that all the time. Mouse leaves the window and I get a fullscreen ad begging me to sign up.
Half the time, I'm still reading the damn article, I was just playing with the mouse. Now I have to find your hidden Close button to keep reading. Go to hell, marketers.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by ryandrake on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:59AM
(#13328826)
Yea I see the "subscribe to our newsletter popup before I even get a chance to read anything" pattern all the time. This is the first time I've seen it actually wait and trigger on my taking an action to close the site. I mean, I guess that's kind of better than doing it just as I've read 3 words into a 3000 word article...
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by kossae on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:19PM
(#13329739)
FWIW, the Esc key normally gets rid of these. Regardless, it is such an annoying marketing trick. Who knows... it must still provide a positive ROI if so many sites are still using it, unfortunately.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by rangersanger on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:35PM
(#13329932)
cmd+w tends to work well. As for ROI, as a former ecomm product manager I can tell you that our marketing department's reasoning for requesting the feature was not based on ROI, rather, herd mentality. And, once a feature is there, it's extremely difficult to remove.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by owenversteeg on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:30PM
(#13329876)
At first, I thought "damn, I want one right now."
But then I realized something - most of the time, when I use a laptop, I'm fairly space-sensitive. You can't use one of these on a train, tram, bus, plane, or in any situation where there are people next to you.
And even when there is enough room, you pretty much instantly give up any semblance of privacy. Even though 99.9% of the time what I have on my monitor isn't something that I'd mind a random person seeing, sometimes it is. My current laptop's an Ideapad Yoga, 13" screen, and if I close a window and a sensitive document, or picture, or what have you is on the screen it's not a big deal. My body easily hides the screen from anyone behind me, and since the laptop is so small it's usually kinda tricky to see stuff on the screen from the sides anyway. Besides, I'm one of several people in the (train car|bus|plane|area) that have a laptop open, so usually nobody's watching my screen anyway. If someone's got one of these things? I'm going to take a look at it, probably look at what they've got open and what they've got on the screens. So are the other 40 people around me.
When they say "mobile desktop", that's exactly what it is, to me. If you use the 3 screens anywhere you wouldn't use a desktop PC, things become awkward. The problem is that the vast majority of places where I use my laptop aren't places I'd use a desktop PC.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by ChuckMcM on Thursday January 05, 2017 @02:06PM
(#13330302)
I think there is a comedy routine in there somewhere. Imagine the passenger in the middle seat of a crowded flight and suddenly their laptop keeps growing and growing :-).
IBM did a similar idea with a dual screen thinkpad, it was not very successful. My impression was that it just didn't make a lot of sense. Imagine a couple of USB-C connected displays on either side when you wanted them, no need to lug them around when you didn't. That would seem to be a bit more sensible to me.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by joveian on Thursday January 05, 2017 @06:57PM
(#13332658)
Also, on every laptop-like device I've used, there are four things that ever break (well not counting cosmetic damage and five if you count hard drives; I've been lucky with memory). Two of these are display hinges and the display cable. Three integrated displays sounds like asking for trouble. Seperate displays like you suggest might at least make it easier to replace the parts that break. Also you could then use them on a different laptop more easily too.
(The other two things that break for me are the power connection inside the laptop and the power cord where it bends just outside the laptop. I don't think I'm that rough on them...)
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by owenversteeg on Thursday January 05, 2017 @02:47PM
(#13330670)
Heh, funny you mentioned the IBM laptop. I actually have been thinking of getting one of those (W700ds) and gutting them to be more modern. I like it cause it's IBM (so pretty strong), the second screen is small-ish and not that intrusive, it's easy to take in or out, and it wouldn't take up that much space on a train/plane/wherever.
But yeah, I'm with you that I'd like a mini display that's detachable instead. I think one exists, but horribly overpriced, ugly, and horrible resolution.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by zem on Thursday January 05, 2017 @03:30PM
(#13331067)
can see it being useful for people who do a lot of business travel. you use it in single screen mode in public places, and expand to three-screen back in your hotel room or on your desk at the client's site.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by bkane521 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @02:04PM
(#13330273)
I wonder if there will be an option to keep the two extra screens collapsed. Certainly there's still the weight factor, but this would allow it to be more compact and would probably extend battery life considerably (though I imagine it will still be laughably bad).
I think it would be awesome to have access to three screens when you're on the road, but this thing definitely won't be replacing any ultrabooks anytime soon.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by Roritharr on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:21AM
(#13328383)
They really should walk over to LGs booth and take a look at their small, flexible OLED screens. These babies would make great panels for foldout screens as they are crazy slim.
Even the TV-Size ones are only 2.57mm thick.
(I badly want slideout screens, although at a 13 inch formfactor. My Dream would be something like the Surfacebook, with the option to slide out screens on both sides)
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by Slackwise on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:35AM
(#13328521)
Let's not forget build quality. They're the only¹ brand of mouse I've ever had die on me — multiple models, within 6 months of use.
A Boomslang or whatever it was called back in the day, then two Diamondbacks within a year, in like 2007.
I've had friends say their Naga and Lachesis or whatever die within a year too, usually the buttons or entirely.
I've now used a Logitech G1 since 2007 or so, with extremely heavy gaming abuse, and no problems at all. I am considering buying several more off eBay just so I can use it forever in the case this one breaks.
¹: Okay, I had the wheel go out on my $20 "Logitech Wheel Mouse" from 1999 after 10+ years of heavy use, and a $10 Dell generic mouse at the office after 5 years of heavy use. Just the wheel though. Might have just been dust, really, and fixable for both. The Logitech was used to death in gaming for at least 5+ years.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by slantyyz on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:46AM
(#13328648)
My Razer DeathAdder (which I bought because it was the top pick on the Wirecutter) lasted about a year before it started giving me phantom clicks. I bought the DeathAdder after a similarly priced Logitech bricked itself after about six months.
These days, I just buy cheap wired mice, because I don't really trust the expensive ones.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by baldfat on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:52PM
(#13330125)
I loved my ASUS ROG Gladius It comes with different pressure switches and is easy to change the switches (Bad switches is what killed all my other mouses before) and a detachable cord. I've had it 2 years and it is a tank. I hate switching mice.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by maxsilver on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:57AM
(#13328790)
In addition to build quality issues, Razer's products are often inherently broken by design even if you get a "working" one.
Their Core dock, the Stealth ultrabook, and the Orochi mouse, are all currently sold and not one of these products is fully functional with itself/its counterparts, even if you get a "good" unit.
Their designs are often neat / interesting / innovative. But until they learn how to create and ship working functional products, it's all just pretty artwork.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by mschuster91 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @03:13PM
(#13330917)
> I'm curious how long the battery lasts. That thing must have a beefy discrete GPU given Razer's pedigree.
I guess that the dGPU is only used when all three screens are extended or an application that requires a dGPU is running. Similarly to MBPs which by default use the Intel GPU and only on demand switch to the dGPU.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by slantyyz on Thursday January 05, 2017 @03:54PM
(#13331290)
I think the latest onboard Intel graphics (the ones used on gaming laptops at least) can drive a trio 4k screens [1] - I assume that would allow the battery last longer when not gaming. FWIW (anecdotal), I have a 4K non-touch Windows laptop with nVidia dGPU switching, and I can barely get 3h on battery (am a heavy Chrome user).
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by mschuster91 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @04:14PM
(#13331463)
That might be due to a lack of Chrome optimization on Windows - on OS X Chrome activates the dGPU for me only when something employs WebGL or plays any form of media.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by vinayan3 on Thursday January 05, 2017 @12:25PM
(#13329146)
Reminds me of the Dell XPS laptops which were like bricks, incredibly heavy. Not to mention the battery life was awful and the power brick was huge. Two of my college roommates had them and I remember they had huge backpacks and lugged them around campus.
I guess the people who would want these laptops don't care too much about portability or battery life?
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by mjolk on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:23PM
(#13329793)
I imagine this Razer "laptop" will have a price-tag of at least $5,000 and will have a battery life of less than a movie. This is a dogshow hardware to give to a few enthusiasts, industry people, and trade floors to build up the brand; it's more of a "we're enthusiasts too" brand pitch than it is a product.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by errantspark on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:37PM
(#13329957)
Maybe not at that price point, but I would consider buying one. I normally use 3 screens and I like to travel.
The segment of the population that requires a real GPU to get work done buys desktop replacement laptops and probably always will. Not everyone is a "digital nomad" or whatever. Sometimes you've just got to show a client a few tens of millions of polygons of art/CAD and you want to apply the finishing touches on the plane ride over cause you're way behind.
Though admittedly it's more likely to be a Dell Precision or a BOXX than this monstrosity I think there's more room in this market segment than you might think.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by mjolk on Thursday January 05, 2017 @02:18PM
(#13330410)
I wouldn't bet on a lower price point or any sort of portability with a GTX 1080 (the lightest 1080-equipped single-screen laptop I could find is over 7lbs).
> I think there's more room in this market segment than you might think.
I have an external display that I bring along to try to bridge the gap in loss of productivity of working in annoying places, but it (asus mb168+) has garbage drivers (can't adjust brightness on OS X or windows 10; crashes OS X), which is why I'd even consider a native multi-screen device. I think there's more room in the "external displays that aren't terrible" market than the big/heavy performance desktop-replacement market.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by supermatt on Friday January 06, 2017 @10:36AM
(#13337057)
I never seem to have been able to purchase a razer laptop. I recall there was one with a built in touchscreen at one point, possibly a keyboard with a built in touchscreen too, but have never seen it for sale. Do they ever come to fruitition? :(
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by BlackjackCF on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:01PM
(#13329568)
Props on them doing something new, I guess.
But also yeah, looks like a hinge can easily snap off... and knowing Razer's wildly fluctuating quality in its products, this thing is "Hingegate" in the making. Calling it right now.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by baldfat on Thursday January 05, 2017 @01:41PM
(#13329991)
Opposite meaning today?
I went to check and 9 years ago laptops were bigger then notebooks.
Back in 2008 - What is a Laptop Computer?
(n.) A laptop is a small, portable computer -- small enough that it can sit on your lap. Nowadays, laptop computers are more frequently called notebook computers, though technically laptops are somewhat larger in size than notebooks, in both thickness and weight.
- http://www.webopedia.com/DidYouKnow/Hardware_Software/laptop...
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by kbenson on Thursday January 05, 2017 @02:43PM
(#13330641)
Interesting. I was never aware of any actual distinction between them, I always assumed they were alternative names for the same thing. A niche technical marketing failure, at least in my case.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by LeifCarrotson on Thursday January 05, 2017 @12:11PM
(#13328962)
I wonder if something like that was the reason they keep calling it "the world’s first AUTOMATED triple display laptop" (emphasis added). Is/was there another triple display laptop for which you had to manually extend the screens?
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by 51Cards on Thursday January 05, 2017 @02:40PM
(#13330608)
really not feeling that keyboard layout. I really hate an off-center keyboard on laptops (like ones with a number-pad). I actively seek out machines that have the keyboard centered. Otherwise really interesting concept.
Re:Project Valerie – The world's first triple display laptop
by walterbell on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:18AM
(#13328339)
Please support vPro (VT-d, TXT and TPM) and lots of RAM for security virtualization use cases, e.g. Qubes secure compositing desktop with colored borders around VM windows, or Windows 10 Enterprise virtualization-based security.
Half the time, I'm still reading the damn article, I was just playing with the mouse. Now I have to find your hidden Close button to keep reading. Go to hell, marketers.
At least it only does it once, unless you clear the browser cache.
What has also been as old as the web is the first voted comment on any HN story being some totally irrelevant gripe.
But then I realized something - most of the time, when I use a laptop, I'm fairly space-sensitive. You can't use one of these on a train, tram, bus, plane, or in any situation where there are people next to you.
And even when there is enough room, you pretty much instantly give up any semblance of privacy. Even though 99.9% of the time what I have on my monitor isn't something that I'd mind a random person seeing, sometimes it is. My current laptop's an Ideapad Yoga, 13" screen, and if I close a window and a sensitive document, or picture, or what have you is on the screen it's not a big deal. My body easily hides the screen from anyone behind me, and since the laptop is so small it's usually kinda tricky to see stuff on the screen from the sides anyway. Besides, I'm one of several people in the (train car|bus|plane|area) that have a laptop open, so usually nobody's watching my screen anyway. If someone's got one of these things? I'm going to take a look at it, probably look at what they've got open and what they've got on the screens. So are the other 40 people around me.
When they say "mobile desktop", that's exactly what it is, to me. If you use the 3 screens anywhere you wouldn't use a desktop PC, things become awkward. The problem is that the vast majority of places where I use my laptop aren't places I'd use a desktop PC.
IBM did a similar idea with a dual screen thinkpad, it was not very successful. My impression was that it just didn't make a lot of sense. Imagine a couple of USB-C connected displays on either side when you wanted them, no need to lug them around when you didn't. That would seem to be a bit more sensible to me.
(The other two things that break for me are the power connection inside the laptop and the power cord where it bends just outside the laptop. I don't think I'm that rough on them...)
But yeah, I'm with you that I'd like a mini display that's detachable instead. I think one exists, but horribly overpriced, ugly, and horrible resolution.
Oh you can. You just use the display that gets slided at the front position.
> And even when there is enough room, you pretty much instantly give up any semblance of privacy.
I have a 3M display view protector foil. Works quite well, except if the spectator is directly behind you.
I think it would be awesome to have access to three screens when you're on the road, but this thing definitely won't be replacing any ultrabooks anytime soon.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MhGkxkzmPbQ
Even the TV-Size ones are only 2.57mm thick.
(I badly want slideout screens, although at a 13 inch formfactor. My Dream would be something like the Surfacebook, with the option to slide out screens on both sides)
A Boomslang or whatever it was called back in the day, then two Diamondbacks within a year, in like 2007.
I've had friends say their Naga and Lachesis or whatever die within a year too, usually the buttons or entirely.
I've now used a Logitech G1 since 2007 or so, with extremely heavy gaming abuse, and no problems at all. I am considering buying several more off eBay just so I can use it forever in the case this one breaks.
¹: Okay, I had the wheel go out on my $20 "Logitech Wheel Mouse" from 1999 after 10+ years of heavy use, and a $10 Dell generic mouse at the office after 5 years of heavy use. Just the wheel though. Might have just been dust, really, and fixable for both. The Logitech was used to death in gaming for at least 5+ years.
These days, I just buy cheap wired mice, because I don't really trust the expensive ones.
Yea, that's why I like my G1. It's built to last abusive clicks and has only 800DPI, which is perfect for me.
Conversely, had a super nice Logitech MX crap out on me in a year or so.
No thanks.
Their Core dock, the Stealth ultrabook, and the Orochi mouse, are all currently sold and not one of these products is fully functional with itself/its counterparts, even if you get a "good" unit.
Their designs are often neat / interesting / innovative. But until they learn how to create and ship working functional products, it's all just pretty artwork.
I'm guessing 2 hours might be wishful thinking (which is actually OK for me, since I'm plugged in >90% of the time).
I guess that the dGPU is only used when all three screens are extended or an application that requires a dGPU is running. Similarly to MBPs which by default use the Intel GPU and only on demand switch to the dGPU.
[1] http://ark.intel.com/products/88967/Intel-Core-i7-6700HQ-Pro...
I guess the people who would want these laptops don't care too much about portability or battery life?
The segment of the population that requires a real GPU to get work done buys desktop replacement laptops and probably always will. Not everyone is a "digital nomad" or whatever. Sometimes you've just got to show a client a few tens of millions of polygons of art/CAD and you want to apply the finishing touches on the plane ride over cause you're way behind.
Though admittedly it's more likely to be a Dell Precision or a BOXX than this monstrosity I think there's more room in this market segment than you might think.
> I think there's more room in this market segment than you might think.
I have an external display that I bring along to try to bridge the gap in loss of productivity of working in annoying places, but it (asus mb168+) has garbage drivers (can't adjust brightness on OS X or windows 10; crashes OS X), which is why I'd even consider a native multi-screen device. I think there's more room in the "external displays that aren't terrible" market than the big/heavy performance desktop-replacement market.
https://twitter.com/egypturnash/status/817111039519010817
But also yeah, looks like a hinge can easily snap off... and knowing Razer's wildly fluctuating quality in its products, this thing is "Hingegate" in the making. Calling it right now.
I can't really imagine trying to use this on my lap.
I went to check and 9 years ago laptops were bigger then notebooks.
Back in 2008 - What is a Laptop Computer? (n.) A laptop is a small, portable computer -- small enough that it can sit on your lap. Nowadays, laptop computers are more frequently called notebook computers, though technically laptops are somewhat larger in size than notebooks, in both thickness and weight. - http://www.webopedia.com/DidYouKnow/Hardware_Software/laptop...
Now if they only did it in the 12" and 15" as well....
The 40" will have double the surface area. And can be had for under $500!
http://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/by-usage/pc-monitor/best
You could just as easily say this laptop has the equivalent of a dozen 1080p screens, but at that pixel density, it's misleading too.