News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by konschubert on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:12AM (#13299763)
> "Would you trust purchasing a house from a seller, without meeting/talking to them, or a single person before and throughout the purchase?"

You mean I can get an unbiased look at a house in peace, compare the numbers, look at the plans, measure the humidity and do my due diligence without a sales person breathing down my neck?

Hell yea. I'd pay premium for that.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by geocar on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:04AM (#13300235)
> > > "Would you trust purchasing a house from a seller, without meeting/talking to them, or a single person before and throughout the purchase?"

> You mean I can get an unbiased look at a house in peace, compare the numbers, look at the plans, measure the humidity and do my due diligence without a sales person breathing down my neck?

No, I don't think anyone means that. They mean purchase the house.

You can't go into a company and get them to show you their sales pipeline and their staff's performance evaluations before you (potentially) invest. If you want to do these things, you need to make a series of smaller deals first.

Human beings can be fluid, can enter into non-disclosure agreements and make these kinds of bespoke deals, while a web-based transaction form with a buy-it-now button cannot.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:17AM (#13299779)
I found my apartment online. Set up the meeting. Negotiated the documents and corrected them where necessary. The broker I paid 10% of my first year's rent? Apparently he bought a ticket to Paris the morning of our closing.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by johnchristopher on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:44AM (#13299883)
If you negotiated the documents yourselves, why were any broker involved ?
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by rejschaap on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:11AM (#13300000)
For my first appartment I used a broker as well. At the end of the process I discovered their added value was less than 0. Disregarding their fee, I paid too much for the appartement and they encouraged the high price, because they just wanted to close and receive their fee. When I bought my next house I did not use a broker. That's just the way things go, you live and learn.

People are more and more selling without a broker as well, or at least they start to use cheaper brokers where you only buy the service you need.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:05AM (#13300244)
Most apartments in New York City have a broker involved somewhere. In this case, the building owner had a sell-side broker. A condition for renting the building was paying the building owner's fee, directly to the broker, and while simultaneously absolving the broker of any responsibility to me, the paying party, over the building owner, the technical client.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by madeofpalk on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:10AM (#13300267)
The whole NYC real estate brokers thing is completely fucked. The whole thing is a scam.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by johnchristopher on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:00PM (#13302930)
Ah, I see. What's in it for the building owner then ?
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by koolba on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:04PM (#13302407)
> If you negotiated the documents yourselves, why were any broker involved ?

It's a scamola with a similar racket being Ticketmaster's "convenience fees". Most apartments in NYC will require going through their broker who collects a fee (usually a percentage of the first years rent). A chunk of that fee ends up being a kickback to the owner of the apartment. Ticketmaster does the same thing with venues (tack on $15 fee, give the venue $7.50).

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by princeb on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:28AM (#13299811)
since a company is made up of people, and the performance of a company is closely tied to the ability of the management, and when you buy over the company you might be concerned about your affinity as an owner to the group of people that makes up management, then I think an investment banker fulfils the same role as an interviewer or a recruiter for a job candidate.

would you hire a person for your team just by looking at degree transcripts, LOC written, and the resume? maybe you would, but I'm not too inclined to do that.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by gedy on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:27AM (#13300072)
I did exactly this when buying my home through Redfin. I only met the selling agent in person because they unlocked the door so I could see inside. The rest was though email mostly.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by tatabska on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:38AM (#13300115)
This is the classical hn bias. Normal people would like to talk to humans. Hn users would rather get info, plans, etc from houses and eventually buy them and sign the contract using a REST API with a node.js client..
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by jaypaulynice on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:03AM (#13300230)
That's a rational buyer...what do you think the bank does? They run the numbers to see if the person qualifies, has great credit, etc...do you think they care how your day is going? Lol...
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by tatabska on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:16AM (#13300291)
Of course they don't... But they are not the client... It's the client who needs honeyed words, and that an AI can't do..
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by rimantas on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:57AM (#13300422)
Rational buyer is almost an oxymoron.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by neximo64 on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:58AM (#13300205)
Exactly lots of people want the experience of the salesman in picking a house, information on the neighbours and what its like to leave there & why the previous person is getting rid of it.

The HN bias is a bit like the salesman is the inefficient part disincentivized to help you and trying to rip you off.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by hueving on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:16AM (#13300290)
The salesman is incentivized to screw you. They work on commission so the faster they can move houses, the better. Real estate agents are screwing both the buyer (feed you bullshit to get you to buy) and the seller (convince to back off of higher prices because the 0-15% difference in price isn't worth the weeks more effort on their commission).
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by neximo64 on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:21AM (#13300308)
Like a restaurant though, if they were bad at their job they wouldn't attract new clients. Under a HN analogy if they screwed clients they'd have a 0 rating and lose future clients.

The assumption you have is they are simply a market matcher but they're offering more than that.

Their incentive is to get the highest possible sale price in the shortest amount of time and a good reputation. That high price has to also be clearable meaning it cannot be just up in the air and seemingly arbitrary (it can cost either time or reputation).

Without them there is much more information asymmetry. Using an online version you basically have access to the same information you would as with them but without the human element to judge through nor their experience on offer.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by jaypaulynice on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:55AM (#13300417)
This is not true. Some professions are based on screwing the current client and moving on to the next one. How many times do you get to buy a house? This is why most people use an agent to sell their house. They can lie without seeming they're lying (sorry was unaware of xyz...that's what the owner told me)

The incentive for the agent is actually highest cash in down payment because they don't want to deal with the bank to get their money plus they get to keep the down payment if the buyer pulls out.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by nxtrafalgar on Monday January 02, 2017 @08:19AM (#13300979)
Perhaps things are different internationally, but if word got out that agents from the estate agencies I work with were regularly screwing buyers, they'd sink quickly.

> plus they get to keep the down payment if the buyer pulls out.

What? Where does this happen?

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by user5994461 on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:51PM (#13304401)
> Like a restaurant though, if they were bad at their job they wouldn't attract new clients.

In many places, the law is forcing you to go through an accredited agent to make a deal.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by user5994461 on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:49PM (#13304377)
Talking to a human incurs 10% of fees when you're buying a house/flat.

I don't know anyone who wants to pay that fee.

Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by madeofpalk on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:56AM (#13300198)
Kind of defeats the analogy though.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by tonyedgecombe on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:59AM (#13300213)
Judging by the way estate agents (realtors in the US) are viewed in the UK I don't think anybody likes dealing with them. I suspect most people would rather learn JavaScript, Node and a REST API rather than have to deal with them.
Re:Why do traders in investment banks feel their jobs are im... by wayn3 on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:00AM (#13300220)
a real estate agent can never be as shitty as javascript. (few things have the potential to get there)