News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by thisisnotmyname on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:09PM (#1316260)
This has gotten a lot of upvotes in a very short time, so it must be ringing true with a lot of readers. I'd encourage some healthy skepticism.

1) It is really tempting to try to understand ourselves based on the assumed lives of our evolutionary ancestors, but the fact is we know almost nothing about their lives, and conclusions we draw from what we can guess are unlikely to be accurate.

2) There is not one citation in this entire article. This is all opinion, no matter how true it sounds.

3) He offers medical advice based solely on his personal experience. Sleep apnea may not be the same to all people.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mhd on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:51PM (#1316345)
With all that "paleo diet" rage, raw-foodians etc, I think that pop evolutionary biology is the new pop psychology.

Nutritional science is friggin' hard. Extrapolating from biological reactions has to take a huge load of variables into account and empirical studies have to monitor a huge bunch of people over a long period of time -- and all of them are lying.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by jacobolus on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:09PM (#1316658)
Do you know of any good nutritional science resources/explanations? I wish I knew where to find a readable overview based on careful research.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by yanowitz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @10:02AM (#1318014)
Gary Taubes' Good Calories, Bad Calories is quite good (http://www.amazon.com/Good-Calories-Bad-Controversial-Scienc...).
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by eru on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:49PM (#1316729)
There was an article on HN about the subject a while ago (http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/28/magazine/28nutritionism.t....) that was quite interesting and modest.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by dmm on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:43AM (#1317951)
That article is as much BS as the rest. Take the first line:

> Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.

Why should I eat "mostly plants"? He hands out a bunch of advice and never bothers to lay out a basis for his opinions.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by count on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @10:16AM (#1318054)
He spent 4 books laying out the basis for his opinions, along with citations, medical research, and the like. That article is just a summary of a long body of work by Pollan.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mattmaroon on Monday May 03, 2010 @08:11PM (#1316543)
But it's on the internet. It must be true.

Also, it has pictures, some of which are attractive females. I'm sold!

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by callmeed on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:20PM (#1316436)
"There is one other thing. You must exercise at least an hour every day. Walking is best."

Last month, we exhibited at our largest trade show of the year–at the MGM in Vegas. I ate like a pig for a week. The Grand Buffet. Kobe ribeye at Craftsteak. Sushi. Beer. In N Out Burgers. You name it.

When I came home, I had lost 6 pounds.

We also walked a ton that week, stood in our booth for 8 hours a day, and hauled a lot of stuff during the setup/teardown.

I think people misunderstand what it means to "exercise" (at least in terms of losing weight). You don't have to go to a gym ... just get on your feet and move.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by ghshephard on Monday May 03, 2010 @10:42PM (#1316821)
Agreed. It's remarkable - My weight has varied between 160 pounds and 210 pounds, and almost has 100% correlation with a single factor - whether I was carpooling or walking into work. Diet, secondary exercise, type of food I'm eating - none of them seem to have anywhere near the causative impact as just simply walking 25-30 minutes into work (and back) each morning. Every morning. Every Day. For months on end.

I have friends who mock this, and talk about how much more important it is to get into their peak-heart-rate on their at-home treadmill. That they've actually used maybe a couple dozen times.

I don't have a choice - have to walk to work. And Back. 3 1/4 miles a day. Every day.

That's almost a marathon a week. :-)

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mannicken on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @03:09AM (#1317376)
Walking 3.25 mi in 25-30 minutes? That sounds a bit too fast :)

PS. Sorry I'm just in a bad mood and feel the need to be anal.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by blangblang on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @11:52AM (#1318368)
I read it to be 3.25 mi total each day and 25-30 minutes each direction making the 3.25 mi tile ~ 1 hour. That seems a reasonable pace to me.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by zyb09 on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:12PM (#1316268)
Yes and no. To be honest I think right now nobody has a god damn clue how the body regulates fat and how weight gain really works. People recommend fruits, while fructose is probably one of the worst things you can eat. I can only recommend the book "Good Calories, Bad Calories" from Gary Taubes. Basically it explains the philosophy behind low carbohydrates, no sugar and high protein & fat. Makes evolutionary sense, too. At least that's what I believe in.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by anamax on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:37PM (#1316312)
> To be honest I think right now nobody has a god damn clue how the body regulates fat and how weight gain really works.

And, it's unclear that it necessarily works the same way in all people.

My opinion is that decomposition is the only permanent weight loss. Before then, there's maintenance, both successful and not which varies by both individual and circumstance.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by aaronblohowiak on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:16PM (#1316669)
"People recommend fruits, while fructose is probably one of the worst things you can eat." -- fructose is bad for you. Much worse than glucose. However, the amount in fruit compared to anything with HFCS is not even in the same ballpark. Also, fruit is fibrous and mostly delicious. Avoid fruit juice that gets rid of the bulk, but feel free to eat fruit freely (unless you are pursuing ketosis, obvi.)

I think all of the studies show that most people don't keep weight off, and that the slower you lose the weight the more likely you are going to keep it off. Also, running is good for the brain as well as the body.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by Evgeny on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:30PM (#1316454)
the initial role of big brains was for sexual attractiveness. For a long time, hominid females were selecting for big brains. Big brains served the same purpose as big tails do for peacocks. I think perhaps that those females were determined to someday produce a man with the mental capacity to understand women.

While this abstract is slightly funny, I suddenly realized that I have no idea about why humans evolved big brains. Why most of the other species do not select for bigger brains, while human evolution seems to suggest that a bigger brain is a much better survival tool compared to sharp claws or protective colour? Certainly, other species would have offspring which have slightly larger/smarter brains. Why is that only a few species (humans, dolphins ...) evolved relatively large brains?

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by kingsley_20 on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:13PM (#1316664)
This is from a Nova science documentary (Becoming Human): some scientists believe that humans evolved larger brains in response to a rapidly changing ecosystem. They've found evidence of a ginormous lake appearing and disappearing many times repeatedly over a few thousand years, in the Rift Valley, near where early hominids started evolving larger brains. The theory is that the rapid adaptability afforded by a larger brain was what selected for it.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by ZenzerNet on Monday May 03, 2010 @08:10PM (#1316540)
Probably random mutation that happened to turn out beneficial for us. In evolutionary sense, a larger brain doesn't seem to be of utmost importance for reproduction.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by _pius on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @12:54AM (#1317112)
Probably random mutation that happened to turn out beneficial for us.

Yes, but isn't that just restating the theory of evolution and natural selection?

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mattmaroon on Monday May 03, 2010 @05:56PM (#1316229)
There's strong evidence that exercise is actually counterproductive when trying to lose weight.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by byrneseyeview on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:21PM (#1316282)
What kind of exercise? Anecdotally, the kind that causes weight loss is pretty intense (i.e. sprinting, not jogging; Tabata is the most extreme form). See:

http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~cook/movabletype/archives/2010...

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by RiderOfGiraffes on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:06PM (#1316254)
Can you provide some links for that?
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by spamizbad on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:31PM (#1316301)
Not a link, but certain individuals in the pop-diet field argue exercise increases appetite and may cause you to lose self-control binge on the wrong kinds of foods. Or, they'll perform a workout that burns 200 calories and then promptly down a sports drink that puts 200 calories right back into their system.

Others state that unless you're carefully balancing your calories vs. your workout level, you can push your metabolism into "starvation mode" - for example: lets say you require 2300 calories to maintain your weight, but you want to slim down so you decide to consume 2000 instead. If you throw exercise into the mix you're burning off an extra 300-500 calories (a net of 1500-1700 calories) which may put your body's metabolism into starvation mode. Because different people's bodies response to exercise differently, actually tracking your net caloric intake is challenging and not fully understood.

And of course there's the studies that show exercising alone with no diet plans seems to have a negligible impact on weight loss.

I hope I didn't misrepresent their arguments, but that's the gist of them.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by eru on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:53PM (#1316737)
Some weight lifting sources (e.g. http://stronglifts.com/) say that cardio-exercise is almost useless for losing weight. They hold that building muscles with, say, weightlifting will work much better, because you will have a higher base metabolic rate.

There should be studies about this in the literature.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by nfnaaron on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:59PM (#1316369)
There are two things going on: exercise, and eating. You have to get control of both, however you do that. If exercise makes you eat more, you have more work to do on the eating. If you do eat more because of exercise, at least make sure the food is good for you.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mattmaroon on Monday May 03, 2010 @08:11PM (#1316541)
Humans aren't robots. I'll skip the philosophical discussion about whether or not will power exists (as you'd clearly need it to) but the fact is that if exercise makes you lose 200 calories worth of weight, but then makes you consume 250 calories, it's not helping you lose weight.

It's helping you in a number of other different ways perhaps, I was certainly not saying someone should not exercise. It's just not an effective weight loss technique.

Also when you add up the calories burned, even vigorous exercise just isn't that much. It's FAR easier to cut calories out of your diet than to exercise them away even if you assumed exercise did not make you hungrier or affect you in any other way adverse to weight loss.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by count on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @10:20AM (#1318069)
Exercise doesn't just burn calories during the period of time in which you are performing the exercise though. '200 calories' after 30 minutes of running doesn't mean that the run burned 200 calories. It means you burned 200 calories in that 30 minutes - over time, the running also builds leg muscles and encourages other physiological changes in your body that boost your base metabolic rate, allowing you to burn more calories even while sleeping.

To build that muscle, you have to feed it, so consuming more to burn more isn't necessarily out in left field as far as nutritional science goes.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by gte910h on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:24PM (#1316287)
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by ars on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:37PM (#1316311)
Exercise causes the body want more food.

I know it happens to me - after I work really hard, I'm very very hungry after, and I end up eating too much.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by gaius on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @08:40AM (#1317822)
You can eat as much chicken and broccoli as you want!
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mattmaroon on Monday May 03, 2010 @08:07PM (#1316533)
Someone posted an NYT article that linked to a good study.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:42PM (#1316320)
bs. How many fat joggers do you see?

It's pretty simple - burn more fat, eat less crap.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by jodrellblank on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:07PM (#1316396)
How many no handed pianists do you see?

It's pretty simple - playing the piano causes limb regrowth.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:19PM (#1316434)
Are you saying that once you're fat, it's impossible to exercise? I don't buy that.

If you're thin is it impossible to eat?

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by jodrellblank on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:53PM (#1316504)
I'm suggesting that the explanation "you don't see fat joggers because fat people don't jog" is as or more likely than the explanation "you don't see fat joggers because anyone who takes up jogging becomes thin so quickly that nobody sees them during the time when they are fat and jogging".

If fat people took up jogging and became thin, you would see fat joggers.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @03:08AM (#1317371)
So the issue isn't that exercise doesn't work, it's that either fat people don't take up jogging, or that exercise does make you thin.

Which was my point.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by aaronblohowiak on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:17PM (#1316671)
i am an overweight jogger. of course, i have lost 20 lbs since i started jogging, so we'll see how long that lasts ;)
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by JayJays on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:45PM (#1316489)
I think what he is saying is that your views are very black and white, and it's just not that simple. Maybe my definition of fat is different than yours, after working at a tech company for 5 years, but when I think fat I think 300lbs+, not 200lbs with a beer gut that can be jogged off in a few weeks. Some of these people have trouble walking to their cars without some kind of assistance, what is your solution for them? But hey, way to generalize a whole lot of people. Fat is fat, right?
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:53PM (#1316503)
Obviously the solution is to not get into that state in the first place. But granted, easier said than done for some people.

I'm talking about fat - able to exercise if you try. Not talking about morbidly obese.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by MichaelSalib on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:03PM (#1316382)
Overweight people tend to have joint issues that make running really painful. With respect, I don't think it is nearly so simple.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mattmaroon on Monday May 03, 2010 @08:19PM (#1316560)
If you assume that's a causation rather than a correlation do the world a favor and don't go into science.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by steveklabnik on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:44PM (#1316716)
Alternatively, he could do himself a favor and _do_ go into science. Or however that sentence should have been formed.

Then he'd learn about the difference.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @03:05AM (#1317362)
My point is, if fat people jog, they don't stay fat for long.

Perhaps I should have been clearer. But I'm lazy.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by mattmaroon on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @08:57AM (#1317865)
Yeah, but evidence suggests that isn't true. Studies of people trying to lose weight show that those who exercise and those who don't lose the same amount if you control for eating.

People who cut out calories and exercise lose the same as people who cut out calories and don't. People who exercise without changing eating habits don't lose weight, just like those who do nothing at all.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @10:39AM (#1318125)
It's best obviously to do both though. You really don't want saggy skin falling off your body all over the place...
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by Tichy on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:53PM (#1316352)
Might be survivor bias - if you are fat, you can't run very well, so maybe few fatties keep running.
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by axod on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:59PM (#1316371)
That's like saying "If you don't know how to play the piano, few beginner pianists go on to be able to play well".

I think it's just about determination, and wether you actually care enough about achieving the goal.

Re:Permanent Weight Loss by Tichy on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:08PM (#1316400)
Prove it by becoming a master piano player then :-)
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by Evgeny on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:52PM (#1316346)
Also, carrot is obviously good for the eyes. After all, how many rabbits wearing glasses do you see?
Re:Permanent Weight Loss by pier0 on Monday May 03, 2010 @10:10PM (#1316774)
Consult an attorney before applying any of the tips