News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by ocschwar on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @03:53PM (#13126112)
I'm a huge fan of the hacker angle, but I really deplore their use of the Mad Genius trope.

In real life, when people are as tormented by schizophrenia and PTSD as Mr. Robot is, their talents are of no use and of no threat to anyone. We're surrounded by such people in every city, and the only threat they pose is to themselves.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by __jal on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:30PM (#13126388)
Eh.

I'm sure everyone here remembers the term 'suspension of disbelief' or related.

The reason a Hollywood virus or universal decryption key doesn't allow technical people to suspend disbelief is because both are immediately absurd in multiple ways, often to the point of being unintentionally funny.

It isn't hard for me, at least, to suspend disbelief that people with psychological challenges can do big things, because there are examples in which people with psychological challenges have accomplished big things.

Suspension of disbelief is tricky when approaching domain-specific knowledge. Really, the "hacker's complaint" is no different than lawyers complaining about, well, every courtroom drama ever.

I won't argue whether "Elliot's" PTSD is so severe that he couldn't function. It is fiction, and arguing about personal investment in fiction is a mug's game, outside of friendly bar talk.

I will simply note that you're vastly overgeneralizing the range effects of both PTSD and schizophrenia. PTSD, for instance, has in fact led to horrific violence, and, well, go google 'famous schizophrenics' if you'd like to see what people have accomplished.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by 0xcde4c3db on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @07:36PM (#13127525)
> Really, the "hacker's complaint" is no different than lawyers complaining about, well, every courtroom drama ever.

Except, oddly enough, My Cousin Vinny, which lawyers apparently love [1]. The fact that I can name one movie known for this probably proves your general point, though.

[1] http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/entertainment/movies/New-...

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by ocschwar on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:51PM (#13126994)
The issue with suspension of disbelief is that while smart people do it, weaker minds on the left hand of the bell curve just internalize the notion that the fiction they're watching is an accurate reflection of life.

So when the movies and television shows portray mad geniuses who threaten to destroy life as we know it, it covers up the sad reality, which is severe schizophrenics are only a challenge to our sense of decency, and little else.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by __jal on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:11PM (#13127083)
Citation needed.

I don't think it is anywhere nearly so simple as "dumb people believe fiction is real." There is a complicated interplay between lived experience, class, personality, education, desires and other priors driving how people process both fiction and nonfiction.

Or as a brief counterfactual, sure is nice how the murder rate has dropped now that we've banned violent video games, amirite?

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by int_19h on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:36PM (#13127760)
It's not because people are dumb. It's because they trust the blue screen - because, well, why wouldn't they? They don't know how it actually works.

And it is a real problem wrt applying such acquired "knowledge" to the real world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CSI_effect is a well-documented instance, and there are numerous reports by lawyers of juries making unreasonable assumptions (e.g. about the accuracy of DNA matches), or giving undue weight to "expert" evidence like bite mark analysis (which is fraudulent pseudoscience: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2016/09/07/...). All this stuff has effect on outcomes of real world criminal cases, sometimes literally with people's lives at stake.

As Cory points out in this piece, the same is true for information security. It all ultimately translates to a very skewed public picture of what the threats are and how they can be mitigated, and that, in turn, affects public policy and laws. That is a real problem.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by __jal on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @11:43PM (#13128453)
Honestly, I think we are saying something at least similar, but in the case of intersection with the legal system, I thin there's something else going on. Apologies, but I'm running with a tangent.

Bite mark analysis is a great example. It isn't just that CSI: Market Segmentation Unit convinces people science can do something it can't. The legal world (outside of some lonely voices to which nobody listened until pretty recently) was telling juries it was valid. Defense attorneys might have taken the odd run at expert testimony in a particular case if it looked promising, but their job is to win particular cases, not take principled stands in general. Meanwhile, the rest of the attorneys in the room (people with reputations for being serious, whom you might expect to have carefully considered the value of different types of evidence, given their careers) were taking bite mark analysis seriously. What, exactly, is a juror in that situation to do?

It is worth asking if the CSI effect is just a cultural feedback loop. Criminal law[1] has always wanted magic unassailable evidence. It just makes everything so much easier. Fiction sometimes still portrays fingerprint evidence as close to infallible, but who has spent generations treating it as such in the context it for which it matters most?

So at the risk of sounding cynical, I'll note that doubts about bite marks, fiber analysis, and now even fingerprints are legally acceptable now that a new magic guilt-certifier is available.

[1] I'm being somewhat flip with language. All of these topics are much more complicated than portrayed. Please take my broad generalities about legal topics in the spirit offered.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by int_19h on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:11AM (#13129073)
But aren't prosecutors and lawyers really a part of the general public when it comes to forensics? They have an "expert" telling them that they have magic, and they have Hollywood telling them that this kind of magic exists (and, as you point out, they have a good incentive to believe in magic - but it's not just the lawyers, it's the jurors as well - it makes their life much easier, too!).

But the same applies here! The general public wants to believe, for example, that if terrorists use encryption, some really smart guys from NSA or wherever can "hack" it somehow (but nobody else). Or at least that we could regulate encryption such that only the "hackable" varieties are available to terrorists. It makes them feel safer. And so you have 44% supporting legislation to mandate backdoors.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by __jal on Thursday December 08, 2016 @10:36AM (#13130897)
> But aren't prosecutors and lawyers really a part of the general public when it comes to forensics?

In this case, no, they aren't. A better comparison would be to a general contractor hiring an electrician. A prosecutor is likely to have no more formal education or hands-on experience with forensic science. But, as professional "consumers" of expert testimony, and a motivation (professional duty) to win, you can't evaluate their scientific ignorance the same way you'd evaluate a juror's. I don't think the reason bite mark analysis lasted so long is because Judge Goodsense watched cop shows, any more than you can say a GC can't be blamed for shoddy wiring because they weren't a member of the Electrician's Local.

To swap contexts, nontechnical people who work with programmers may not be able to give you the big-O cost of a loop, but they tend to know when a programmer is bullshitting about something.

This goes to my contention that the CSI effect isn't just 'I believe it 'cause I saw it on the toob'. Education, lived experience, class, personality and other priors play in to it. In the case of criminal evidence admissibility, I think there is at least motivated reasoning as there is true belief in methods. The motivation is in part the same as with how plea deals have evolved - the current criminal justice system would collapse if trials were needed for more than a tiny fraction of cases. Magic evidence is a performance hack.

I don't disagree that ambient falsehoods matter. I am saying that comparing motivated professionals in a field with random MOPs misses a lot of the picture, and that even your MOP is going to react to ambient falsehoods they can't evaluate differently, based on priors.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by int_19h on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:02PM (#13133749)
> This goes to my contention that the CSI effect isn't just 'I believe it 'cause I saw it on the toob'.

I don't think that is the case in general, either.

The problem is that "I saw it on the toob" has secondary effects, that attenuate as they propagate, but can still go a long way. Basically, you might not believe that DNA testing is 100% correct because you saw it on TV; but you you believe it to be 100% correct because "everybody knows it", and the reason why they do is because "everybody knows it", and so on, until you actually get to a much smaller minority who believe it because they personally saw it on TV.

(In general, it's amazing how many popular "common sense" things are blatantly false, but they keep getting repeated and propagated as part of ambient noise of society, because "everybody knows it".)

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by socmag on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:08PM (#13126233)
I don't think generalized comments regarding any mental illness are welcome to be honest. I don't need to point out the broad and varied spectrum of disorders a lot of us in Comp.Sci are prone to do I? Most of us are pretty damn functional (despite them).
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by socmag on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:16PM (#13126283)
Anyway personally I'm trying to hit up as many categories from within DSM V as I can. It's all good training for my ML side project :P
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by Rebelgecko on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:00PM (#13126170)
I agree that it's an overused trope, but don't think it's fair to say that schizophrenia keeps people from accomplishing impressive things (eg TempleOS)
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by saycheese on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:22PM (#13126333)
Review of TempleOS, its developer and their history with HN are covered: http://www.codersnotes.com/notes/a-constructive-look-at-temp...
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by ubercore on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:01PM (#13126183)
TempleOS may be impressive, but it's not especially effective
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by cmurf on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:14PM (#13126273)
It's an effective example of the possible benefit having a double major in psych and computer science. However, that is impressive psychopathology. I had no idea.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by throwanem on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:01PM (#13126184)
It's impressive, to be sure. Is it useful?
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by aoeu345 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:11PM (#13126252)
It is a tool to learn about how your computer really works by providing an extremely simple operating system. It's so simple you can draw circles on the screen with one line at the command prompt.

It is very dumb to argue it has no usefulness because it does not work with modern dev tools or environments

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by na85 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:38PM (#13126479)
Correction: it is a tool to learn how modern processors emulate x86.

Learning C or asm gives you no insight into what the microcode under the hood is doing.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by throwanem on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:42PM (#13126513)
And I'm quite certain there are better tools than TempleOS to learn how an x86 processor works.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by enraged_camel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:22PM (#13127140)
Really? Such as?
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by ambicapter on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:38PM (#13127223)
Probably a textbook.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by aoeu345 on Monday December 12, 2016 @06:27PM (#13163072)
Perhaps then one ought to use a textbook and TempleOS side-by-side to learn x86.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by yarou on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:22PM (#13126325)
It's coding for its own sake, much like how art isn't useful in the traditional sense.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by throwanem on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:36PM (#13126456)
Sure. But usefulness is the criterion under discussion here.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by usefulissubj33 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:47PM (#13126971)
Usefulness is subjective.

Some people learn well through certain methods than others. Some people stick with the first thing that they find and make it work for their needs. Never discovering the "better tools".

Richard Feynman, often regarded as one of the best teachers of physics to have ever lived, when asked how to teach, said he didn't know. He just tried to bring as many views to the table as possible. Some people learn from simple high-level descriptions, others need more details to build up to high-level understanding.

Pretty sure you're just being contrarian to be contrarian. Because it seems you're suggesting your way and the things you find the most value in are the only way. Which is a nonsense counter-argument to the question "Why does this thing exist."

Your criterion feels more like "I don't get why it exists. Thus it's useless."

Self-aggrandizing nonsense.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by throwanem on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:04PM (#13127055)
It's not my criterion; this discussion originated in a comment (not mine) claiming roughly that the products of mental illness are of no use to anyone. And I know full well why TempleOS exists: God told Terry Davis to build it. While that clearly means a lot to Mr. Davis, I am not sure how much validity you mean it to have to anyone else.

As it happens, I tend to agree that utility is where you find it. But that's not at all the same as saying that TempleOS is a good teaching tool. Perhaps it is. But thus far I see nothing save repeated assertion to support that claim, and it would be nice to see a bit more by way of substantiation.

For example, someone claimed that, because you can draw circles at the command line with TempleOS, it is simple. But I can do that too, with a terminal and a gnuplot build that include sixel graphics support. (I did it the other day for grins.) Does that mean my setup is simple? Obviously not. Why does it mean that TempleOS is? What does the existence of the capability say about TempleOS's suitability for teaching? Does it say anything? If it does, no one has seen fit to explain how. The same goes for the fact that TempleOS is written in C and assembly. Lots of things are written in C and assembly. Are they all good teaching tools?

(Also: A throwaway, for this? Why?)

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by sedachv on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:19PM (#13126313)
People like Terry Davis and Yayoi Kusama are outliers. Can you name any other schizophrenics that have accomplished impressive things? The only reason they are able to keep working is a lot of support from others over the years to help them overcome the negative effects of their mental illness - Davis' family made sure he received hospital treatment and now he lives on Social Security Disability; Kusama has been living full-time in a mental hospital for the last several decades.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by vanderZwan on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:34PM (#13126433)
> People like Terry Davis and Yayoi Kusama are outliers.

And is it so strange for a lead character in a movie or TV series to represent an outlier?

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by RUG3Y on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:27PM (#13126849)
In the show, Elliot is actually not all that functional. He's debilitated - he can't remember where he's been or what he's done, he's socially awkward and destroys his relationships, and he gets in a lot of bad situations as a result. He's also a drug addict. Maybe the picture of his life isn't all that unbelievable.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by majormajor on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:30PM (#13126398)
Writing compelling dramatic fiction about people who aren't outliers is hard, and that's something far more widespread than just Mr. Robot and the "exceptional genius" hacker idea.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by talmand on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:35PM (#13126450)
Can we not consider that Mr. Robot is an outlier in the show's world?
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by recursive on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:50PM (#13126572)
Stories about typical people doing typical things are not very compelling.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by arijo on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:34PM (#13126436)
What exactly are you trying to achieve with your argument? Do you think the kind of stigma you're contributing to persist will encourage any productive person with a serious mental illness to be open about their work?
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by palunon on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:14PM (#13127097)
>Can you name any other schizophrenics that have accomplished impressive things?

John Forbes Nash Jr. ?

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by sedachv on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:27PM (#13127166)
Take a look at Nash's publications: http://www.ams.org/notices/199810/milnor.pdf

After his first hospitalization in 1959 Nash only wrote two more papers in the 60s. Nash's schizophrenia definitely put a stop to his work.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by tripzilch on Friday December 09, 2016 @06:06AM (#13138029)
see here a (very touching, imho) story about a less lucky not-quite-outlier: http://www.iquilezles.org/blog/?p=2659
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by hrehhf on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:14PM (#13126756)
While you make a fair point, he does not have schizophrenia. He has dissociative identity disorder (also known as multiple personalities).
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by espeed on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:04PM (#13126691)
INTPs are most prone to mental disorders, esp schizophrenia, e.g. see http://psychologyjunkie.com/2015/11/02/mbti-and-mental-illne...
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by RUG3Y on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:30PM (#13126868)
Thanks for posting the link. I recently discovered what an INTP is and that I am one. I don't believe that I have a mental disorder but I definitely struggle with severe depression and mood swings, I'm trying to figure myself out.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by Odin78 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:47PM (#13126974)
You might want to be careful with that. The Myers Briggs test is most likely pseudoscience and you shouldn't base any important-ish life decisions on it.

Mediocre source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5pggDCnt5M

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by RUG3Y on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:49PM (#13126983)
I am skeptical. I don't take it as fact. I did find it interesting that the INTP profiles I read described me with painful accuracy, which is why I've begun exploring this stuff a little more. Still, it's good advice to take everything with a grain of salt.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by wolfgke on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @07:02PM (#13127375)
> I am skeptical. I don't take it as fact. I did find it interesting that the INTP profiles I read described me with painful accuracy,

I don't claim you are wrong, but be very careful about the Barnum/Forer effect when reading such descriptions:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect

BTW: I'm personally rather immune to this effect, since I'm not a person who fits "the profile of a typical citizen".

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by espeed on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:11PM (#13127090)
See Dario Nardi - "Neuroscience of Personality" | Talks at Google: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGfhQTbcqmA
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by tkxxx7 on Thursday December 08, 2016 @08:31AM (#13130132)
Check out some of Jung's work. Myers was a little misdirected, but she was not wrong.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by sharkweek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:08PM (#13127071)
Ignoring the MB quiz results for a second -

Depression is a (very common) mental disorder. I highly recommend talking to your doctor/a therapist about this if you're self-identifying as such.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by rak00n on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @09:14PM (#13127910)
Often depression is a side effect of harsh life conditions. Like moving to a new country where you have no social support or don't speak the language. I doubt a therapist can fix those problems.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by arthur_pryor on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:40PM (#13171344)
a therapist might not be able to "fix" those problems outright in a neat and tidy way, but i'd bet a good therapist could greatly ameliorate those problems, and help enhance quality of life in general.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by avg_dev on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:16PM (#13126294)
John Nash anyone?
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by boomboomsubban on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:30PM (#13126395)
He accomplished very little while suffering from schizophrenia, most of his work occurred years before he became ill.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by astrodust on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @09:52PM (#13128058)
You mean suffering more in his later years. He always suffered from it.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by Broken_Hippo on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:15AM (#13129649)
Nope, I truly think it is suffering later in life: Before it took hold, he had some symptoms - but he wasn't suffering.

I watched such a disorder do its stuff to my ex-husband. He always showed signs of it, but neither of us knew. It was more like a slew of personality quirks. Stress would get to him and he developed quite a temper. It got fairly bad before the diagnosis. I thought he had a drug problem (partially true, but you know).

And then one night he was convinced his spit melted concrete. And so on. Finally a diagnosis: A few years later he couldn't work. Sometimes, even while medicated, he had a flimsy grasp on reality, but most of the voices stopped, which helped tremendously.

The suffering after it takes hold can be a beast of suffering, which was so much differnt than before it really 'took hold'. The hardest period was the time between it becoming serious and the diagnosis.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by astrodust on Thursday December 08, 2016 @10:42AM (#13130940)
What I mean is it's an affliction that develops in severity over the years, but if you look back it was never not there, it was just in a much milder form.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by boomboomsubban on Thursday December 08, 2016 @01:32PM (#13132755)
But it wasn't there, signs existed that it might develop but if things had gone differently he may have never been been afflicted. Nash himself says a combination of stress to do great things and the necessity of thinking in unorthodox ways to do those things is what triggered the illness.

As far as I know, it's not something your born with, it's something your born more likely to develop.

Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by boomboomsubban on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @10:43PM (#13128260)
No, he may have had a disposition towards schizophrenia earlier in his life, but he developed it around 1959.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by riazrizvi on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:45PM (#13126959)
As a literary device, it is effective though. "He was so obsessed with X it drove him mad", is more pithy than "he was obsessed with X".
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by bitwize on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @03:58PM (#13126156)
Yeah, but a series about the TempleOS guy wouldn't make for such compelling television
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by yarou on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:18PM (#13126306)
Have you actually seen any of Terry's streams? They're actually quite instructive about topics like OS design. Barring the occasional rants against "CIA ni*".
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by zaphar on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:15PM (#13126279)
Sadly if current reality shows are any indication it probably would make for compelling television. But I wouldn't wish that on the TempleOS author in any fashion.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by RUG3Y on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:31PM (#13126881)
If the truth were embellished I bet Terry would make a good basis for an interesting fictional character.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by AlexCoventry on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:43PM (#13126518)
I wouldn't call Mr Robot compelling television. If it killed the Hollywood Hacker, he or she probably died of boredom.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by larsiusprime on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:13PM (#13126270)
I kind of want a TV producer to see this comment and go "challenge accepted."
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by cmurf on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:15PM (#13126278)
[God/OS/user's imagination] has the voice of the MCP in Tron.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by youdontknowtho on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:23PM (#13126343)
This is a fantastic point.