News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mr. Robot Killed the Hollywood Hacker by throwanem on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:04PM (#13127055)
It's not my criterion; this discussion originated in a comment (not mine) claiming roughly that the products of mental illness are of no use to anyone. And I know full well why TempleOS exists: God told Terry Davis to build it. While that clearly means a lot to Mr. Davis, I am not sure how much validity you mean it to have to anyone else.

As it happens, I tend to agree that utility is where you find it. But that's not at all the same as saying that TempleOS is a good teaching tool. Perhaps it is. But thus far I see nothing save repeated assertion to support that claim, and it would be nice to see a bit more by way of substantiation.

For example, someone claimed that, because you can draw circles at the command line with TempleOS, it is simple. But I can do that too, with a terminal and a gnuplot build that include sixel graphics support. (I did it the other day for grins.) Does that mean my setup is simple? Obviously not. Why does it mean that TempleOS is? What does the existence of the capability say about TempleOS's suitability for teaching? Does it say anything? If it does, no one has seen fit to explain how. The same goes for the fact that TempleOS is written in C and assembly. Lots of things are written in C and assembly. Are they all good teaching tools?

(Also: A throwaway, for this? Why?)

There are no comments on this comment yet.