News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @01:23PM (#13124806)
Nice writeup, but calling Dosa, Appam and Iddiappam "Breads" is more than a stretch. None of these 3 have the major ingredients of what makes a bread. And it's missing the most important Indian bread - the Naan (despite the tagline saying "go beyond the Naan").

1) Dosa - Crepe made from fermented lentil & rice paste

2) Appam - Rice pancake

3) Iddiappam - Steamed rice noodles.

None of these are anywhere close to the traditional Bread as we know them.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by jasim on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @02:45PM (#13125556)
Only if you believe that there is a canonical definition of bread, which refers to the things made out of wheat flour, whose only acceptable meaning is what the western hemisphere thinks of as bread.

Dosa, Appam, and Idiappam are breads, even though even in South India, if you ask for "bread" from your local grocer, they'd give you sliced loaves. We use the word bread to refer to these other staple breakfast dishes in an anglicized context, because it maps better than any other word to the meaning we want to convey. Which is why restaurant menus categorizes them under "Indian Breads", and if you accept that language is mutable and responds to how people use it, this is as good an alternative meaning as it can get.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:08PM (#13126234)
> canonical definition of bread.

Love it! Spoken like a true engineer :)

The process of Baking is what makes a Bread a bread. If it's not baked in an oven, it's not Bread. I didn't make that up, that what has defined a Bread since the beginning of time :)

Dosa is fried on a stovetop pan. Appam is cooked on a stovetop pan. Iddiappam is steamed on stovetop using water. None of these are baked at any time in the process.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:47PM (#13126545)
The process of baking is almost definitely not what makes a bread a bread. We had breads long before we had ovens, and we have things that are indisputably breads today that aren't cooked inside ovens. Even today, we can readily cook breads that are typically cooked in an oven over a suitably large open fire or uncovered grill.

A bread is a solid stable foam created by heating a dough made primarily of milled plant matter and water. There are no breads that aren't foams, and there are no breads I'm aware of that made primarily of something that isn't plant matter or that hasn't been crushed or otherwise processed to create a homogenous dough with a water-based liquid.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by ars on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:10PM (#13127082)
> A bread is a solid stable foam .... There are no breads that aren't foams

So Matzo is what? It's unquestionably bread, yet is not a foam.

And your definition is too broad - what about a pancake?

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:31PM (#13127192)
Help me understand why you believe Matzo isn't a culinary foam. Foams aren't created solely by leavening --- or rather, all breads are intrinsically leavened somewhat by consisting of large amounts of water and being cooked, which converts bound-up water into steam that leaves bubbles behind as it evacuates the product.

Pancakes are quickbreads!

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by ars on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @07:35PM (#13127518)
> Help me understand why you believe Matzo isn't a culinary foam.

Because when I break off a piece and look at it it doesn't look like a foam. (Note I mean the handmade stuff, not the lightweight, cooked at a lower temperature, machine made version, which is admittedly kinda of foamy.)

But, if you consider that to be a foam, I have to ask: What cooked until mostly dry, flour/water product isn't a foam? i.e. saying "foam" doesn't actually add any additional info.

> Pancakes are quickbreads!

Well, in that case we can simplify the definition: Bread is flour plus liquid cooked until mostly dry. Flour is defined very broadly, as is liquid (for example shortening is a liquid by this definition).

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by moultano on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:14PM (#13126753)
>A bread is a solid stable foam created by heating a dough made primarily of milled plant matter and water.

The most common Indian bread, the roti, is not a foam. It's a very flat bread made of wheat flour and water with no internal structure.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:31PM (#13126876)
I'm pretty sure it is; it's just a foam of very small bubbles. It's the little pockets of air in bread (usually made by escaping steam, from the water in the dough) that make it tender and palatable.

The most obvious foam structure we think about with bread are the big bubbles inside a sourdough or tuscan loaf. But the foam that, say, Harold McGee is thinking about when he describes bread as foam is occurring at a smaller scale.

A communion wafer, for instance, is indisputably bread --- extremely thin, with no discernible internal structure --- but it's also basically a very thin slice of styrofoam.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by oasisbob on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:59PM (#13135516)
If you define a foam as "a substance that is formed by trapping pockets of gas in a liquid or solid", a roti is absolutely a foam. Or, a foam subunit.

(When you make roti, it usually expands like a balloon during the cooking process.)

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by pcrh on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:01PM (#13126661)
>A bread is a solid stable foam

Another engineer I'd bet :-)

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:33PM (#13126899)
It's not my idea; it's Harold McGee's.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:08PM (#13126718)
ROFL.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by hueving on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:11PM (#13127091)
So would you call a birthday cake a bread then?
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:34PM (#13127207)
Most cakes are quickbreads. We don't eat them the way we eat other breads (as a utilitarian cuisine staple), just like we no longer really eat biscuits as a staple bread --- but for a long time, biscuits were the staple bread for lots of people.

As you can see, my definition of bread is functional --- it's about how the bread is constructed and how it behaves as a final product. But there are other valid definitions of bread that capture things like the setting in which they're consumed --- maybe the default for things consumed in a pastry setting shouldn't be "bread", even when the product is a culinary foam made of a dough (but then you run into trouble with sweetened breads eaten as desserts!).

I'm fine with those definitions too, but would note that they rule out none of these indian breads. I'm pushing the functional definition because the parent commenter tried to rule out dosas based on a functional definition, and that functional definition was incorrect.

(There are obviously exceptions for "cakes" that are really set custards and things like that. But birthday cake isn't such an exception.)

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by jpatokal on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:44PM (#13127265)
It's common in the West to equate "bread" with things that are savoury, but a visit to your local Asian bakery will quickly demolish that notion.

So, yes, a birthday cake is a special type of highly decorated, sweet "bread". Or you can take a leaf from the Swedish/Finnish book and have a savoury cake:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sm%C3%B6rg%C3%A5st%C3%A5rta

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by vesinisa on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @07:26PM (#13127471)
That, and birthday cake, are as bread as pizza is bread (and yes, pizza is bread.)

If you find it hard to believe, it helps to know there are many varieties of pizza in Italy that do not include tomato sauce (pizza bianca). For example, quatro formaggi is often without sauce. But the plainer pizze bianche are actually similar to focaccia, which is a cousin of the world famous pizza, and indisputably bread.

So at what point along the focaccia - pizza continuum does the dish become un-bread? At the addition of tomato sauce? Then how come is quatro formaggi so often served in pizzerias? At the addition of cheese? Marinara, one of the most classical of all pizzas, is defined by its lack of milk-based ingredients (which do not preserve at sea, hence the name.)

Clearly, pizza, too, is bread.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:38PM (#13127765)
Well, pizza crust is bread. Pizza is only bread in the same sense that a sandwich "is" bread.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by flukus on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:48PM (#13127288)
I've always wondered where scones fit in. They taste like bread but typically come with cream and jam like cake.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by solipsism on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:54PM (#13127007)
That is not how words work. First of all, bread has existed for much longer than the word "bread". And any translation into another (perhaps earlier) language is bound to be imperfect. Things called "bread" don't line up perfectly with things called "pan" in Spanish.

Stop looking for precision in words. If you want to talk about "things that are baked in an oven" then say that.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by jasim on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @10:01PM (#13128104)
> The process of Baking is what makes a Bread a bread.

Says who? The dictionary? It can change. You forget that language is a social construct, and like it or not, India is a country of a billion people with a different cultural context and we're going to make words up, or overload new meanings to existing words. And there is nothing you can do about it. That's how language works. You could claim ownership over it and try to dictate and browbeat alternate usages, but come to India, and try telling them that Appam is not a Bread, they'll tell you "of course not, Appam is an Indian Bread".

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by eastern on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @10:34PM (#13128222)
English-speaking Indian living in India here, been eating rotis, naans, parathas, bhatirey, dosa, appams every day for half a century.

ALWAYS thought of all these as Indian breads. So does everyone else. For example, look at the menu of a famous Indian restaurant: https://www.zomato.com/ncr/bukhara-itc-maurya-chanakyapuri-n...

There are countless other menus on that site that do the same.

The article gets it absolutely correct.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sridca on Thursday December 08, 2016 @02:51AM (#13129015)
English-speaking South Indian (Tamil) living in Canada & India here.

NEVER thought of dosas, idlis, idiyappam, uthappam, etc. as a "bread".

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by jff on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:37PM (#13126473)
Bhatura are deep fried, roti are pan-fried.

Edit: basically, India doesn't have a particularly big tradition of oven baking, so by a definition of "bread must be baked" you're gonna have a lot of things that aren't bread.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:11PM (#13126734)
Correct. Bhatura is fried dough.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:52PM (#13126995)
So is bannock bread!
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by alphakappa on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:10PM (#13126729)
Nit: Dosas don't need to be fried. They are often just made on a non-stick pan without oil. Sometimes with a touch of ghee on top for flavor, but again, not for frying.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by moultano on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:15PM (#13126761)
So roti isn't bread? That's a strange definition.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by DanBC on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:37PM (#13126463)
Cornbread, traditionally cooked in a skillet, isn't a bread?

Most people I know would call English muffins a bread product.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:10PM (#13126726)
> Cornbread, traditionally cooked in a skillet, isn't a bread?

It's not. Americans have a strangely funny way of naming things. Only in America would you find "Orange Juice" that would say in the ingredients. "Contains no juice. Artifically flavored and coloured."

English muffins are baked goods, not breads.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by greglindahl on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:49PM (#13127291)
Source for the "orange juice" claim? You're thinking of products like "Sunny Delight Beverages Orange", which you should note does not call itself "orange juice". Even in the US, that's not allowed.

Skillet bread, on the other hand, is bread, as are english muffins.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by duaneb on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:20PM (#13127700)
Either people in India use the english word "bread" or they have different meaning.

I would be very, very weirded out if someone handed me bread and it does not contain ground grain.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by parennoob on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @09:32PM (#13127972)
> Either people in India use the english word "bread" or they have different meaning.

The only thing people use the English word "bread" in India for is the sliced white bread that you can find in any store in the US or Europe. All the other words are mentioned by the article. Also, as the article clearly states, the author, for the purposes of the article, counts the following things as breads:

> It would be virtually impossible to capture the full diversity of India’s breads ... or even to say what, in India, counts as bread. But here we’ve given it a go. I went about it like this: if it’s starchy and used as a utensil, it’s bread.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by SixSigma on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:35AM (#13129702)
Rice is a grain
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by duaneb on Thursday December 08, 2016 @02:39PM (#13133439)
True. But—to my understanding—the rice to which you're referring is soaked with lentils, not ground into a flour, and you aren't going to find ANY gluten in rice (which gives bread its characteristic texture with wheat, barley, oat, rye, etc etc).

At this point, it's more of a question of "foamy thing", unrelated to the rich history of cooking flour with water (and maybe some salt).

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by SixSigma on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:37PM (#13134049)
Well, I can add Besan Ki Roti the the list of things that seem to be bread which is made from chickpea flour.

And I make moong bean roti myself.

I feel this is all a bit "we call these things bread" is like "we call these things fruit and these things vegetables" and then someone says "but what about bananas and cucumbers and strawberries" so we have to introduce "culinary fruits vs botanical fruits vs berries"

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by duaneb on Thursday December 08, 2016 @04:50PM (#13134618)
Well, in the English world, bread has roughly the same definition; people mostly argue about whether it includes a leavening agent or not. (I'm of the opinion it shouldn't require a leavening agent). If you handed someone a generic food sponge when they asked for bread, they would become very angry at you because they explicitly asked for a certain type of food that you did not give them.

Which is not to say that whatever people speak doesn't have a word that's a superset of "bread", but it's certainly a much less useful, descriptive, and precise word.

In fact, the ONLY alternative definition of "bread" in english is actually "sweetbread" which, ironically, seems to be meat-based rather than derived from the word "bread".

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by vram22 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @03:14PM (#13125800)
>it's missing the most important Indian bread - the Naan

That description is at least somewhat subjective. I would say Indians in India tend to eat roti (tandoori roti) as much as naan, and plain roti and chapati even more (the latter two are considered home foods, so not seen much at restaurants). Naan tends to have a slightly higher-end image (IMO/IME) and I've seen foreigners in India tending to order naan more often than rotis (particularly garlic naan, which seems to be a favorite of many). My guess it that it has been marketed to them more than tandoori rotis in the glossy magazines. on planes, etc., plus it might be/look more close to some Western breads (e.g. garlic bread like garlic naan, also the shape of naan is a bit like a French bread, maybe), so a bit more familiar to them.

But in India plenty of people eat and relish tandoori rotis, plain rotis (which are roasted on a tava in the house, not an outdoor tandoor), and chapatis (thinner version of plain rotis, but also allowed to quickly puff up on the open flame after roasting on tava). IMO tandoori roti tastes better than naan, which is made of maida (refined wheat flour).

And all of the above taste pretty good in slightly differing ways (though all except naan are made of whole-wheat flour).

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by cdr on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:07PM (#13126222)
Naan is everywhere in the US. I'd expect tourists preferring naan is pure familiarity. I see naan at every grocery store, much like sushi. Or pita, thinking of breads.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by vram22 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:01PM (#13126179)
>And all of the above taste pretty good

particularly with an alu matar or matar paneer or a dal tadka :)

http://jugad2.blogspot.in/2011/05/got-tadka.html

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @02:48PM (#13125592)
What are the three major ingredients of a "bread"? Isn't a dough any hard-set culinary foam created by somehow cooking a relatively homogenous, ultimately water-based dough?

Were you thinking of "flour, water, and leavening"? Flour is any grain processed so as to make breadmaking easier. All these recipes include water. There are hundreds of different unleavened breads, and many of these breads are yeast-leavened.

Crepes and pancakes are (usually) quickbreads. A Chinese scallion pancake might not fit that bill (and might not be a quickbread), but Dosas clearly do.

The article carefully explains why naan isn't included: it's not an Indian bread. Naan is a staple throughout central Asia, which is where India imported it from.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:12PM (#13126259)
The TOP 4 Ingredients in a basic "Bread" are a basic bread Flour, Water, Yeast and Salt. Granted the ones I called out have 3 of the 4, but the main characteristics of something that's called Bread is the process i.e. Baking. If it's not baked in an oven, it's not Bread. I didn't make that up, that what has defined a Bread since the beginning of time :)
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by pcrh on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:05PM (#13126692)
Yeast isn't essential to define bread. As a Seán, you might know that Irish soda bread uses sodium bicarbonate as a leavening agent.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soda_bread

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:14PM (#13126752)
Bro, I am full-blooded American-Indian (dots not feathers), born to 1st generation Indian Immigrants :)

The Sean name was my Dad's idea and I thank him for it. He didn't want me to get ragged and bullied for having a long name like 'Apu Nahasapeemapetilon'.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:18PM (#13126308)
Not all breads are leavened at all, and not all leavened breads are leavened with yeast.

Lots of breads have no salt --- Tuscan, for instance --- but I think most Indian breads do.

All breads have some kind of "flour" (which again is just any plant substance processed to make it easy to make a dough out of) and some water-based liquid.

Not all breads are baked! Lots of them are griddled, including several Indian breads that nobody is contesting the bread-y-ness of, and lots of cultures have fried breads (bannock bread for instance). I think the only commonality of bread cooking techniques is that they're all dry-heat cooked... but then you get to Chinese bao and you have to wonder about that too.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by msrpotus on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @04:28PM (#13126375)
Pita isn't necessarily baked; is it in some other category?
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by sean_patel on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:52PM (#13126996)
Correct. Pita is not bread. it literally means 'cake or pie' in modern Greek.

Like I said, Americans like things 'dumbed down', so anything and everthing that is round and made with dough is called "____ Bread"

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:39PM (#13127230)
51% of Wikipedians believe that the word "Pita" is literally derived from West Asian words (in several languages) for (wait for it) "bread".

Pita is obviously bread. Even your definition, which requires "baking in an oven", covers pita. If pita isn't bread, neither is naan --- at which point we've reached a pretty silly place of defining one of the world's most popular breads as "not bread".

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:58PM (#13127850)
etymonline (not infallible, but generally where I go for etymology questions) doesn't attempt to trace "pita" back beyond modern Greek or Hebrew. It doesn't give the impression that the origin of the word is well understood.

I'm mostly with you as to bread (and certainly as to "pita is bread"), but I feel like noodles are generally not considered bread, despite being made from dough.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by tptacek on Thursday December 08, 2016 @09:14PM (#13136156)
Noodles are a great question. Why aren't noodles bread?

* They're often made from dough that is identical to bread dough (perhaps minus the leavening)

* They're cooked wet (which is why they don't leaven themselves) --- but then so are bagels and pretzels!

I'm guessing the reason will go back to the original purpose of bread, which was to create a portable, palatable, readily accessible foodstuff from grain. Without bread, the only straightforward way to eat grains is porridge. So bread can (and I think maybe always is?) eaten out of hand, and is cooked often well in advance of consumption.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by thaumasiotes on Thursday December 08, 2016 @10:15PM (#13136402)
> Why aren't noodles bread?

I tend to think that they're not considered "bread" for two reasons:

- Their form factor is not appropriate for the concept "bread".

- They don't contain perceptible air bubbles.

Really, it's mainly the first one.

Two categories can be, um, vocabularily distinguished for pretty arbitrary reasons. Noodles are just a case of the same thing from a nutritional perspective leaving the prototype for the "bread" concept far enough behind that they're perceived differently.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @08:55PM (#13127836)
> Pita is not bread. it literally means 'cake or pie' in modern Greek.

You're going to have a tough time explaining tyropita.

Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by bbgm on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @01:56PM (#13125120)
Naan is not the most important bread. About the only time I've eaten naan (growing up mostly in India) is at restaurants. At home it's always roti, parathas, or poori.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by redditmigrant on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @01:39PM (#13124964)
Naan is definitely the most famous Indian bread, but the one that most Indians, especially in the north consume regularly is the roti,chapatti etc.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by vertex-four on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @02:39PM (#13125504)
It's not consumed often in the south either - in at least Tamil Nadu and Kerala, most common is chapatti or the "Malabar" parotta (but more common than that is just to skip the bread and eat rice). Naan is cooked in a tandoor, so it's only served at places which serve tandoori chicken, which is not many places.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by vram22 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @03:20PM (#13125850)
Actually tandoors (for making both tandoori roti and naan and tandoori chicken, chicken tikka, etc.) became quite common in restaurants in medium to large Indian cities some years ago. In fact I used to regret that you could not get the regular plain chapatis and rotis in restaurants (except for cheaper messes or dining halls); it became so that tandoori roti or naan was the only option even in any average or hole-in-the-wall restaurant.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by vertex-four on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @03:39PM (#13126006)
Huh, interesting - I left India some years ago, so I must've missed out on that.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by alphakappa on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @05:16PM (#13126769)
Naan while being common in restaurants, is not common in households. It requires a specialized oven and isn't easy to make at home. Roti/Chappati/Parathas are the common ones. There are regional differences too - Naans are uncommon in South Indian restaurants. The staple one in this category in Kerala is a Barotta which is a flaky bread similar to the Thai rotis.
Re:A Guide to the Breads of India by perseusprime11 on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @09:22PM (#13127941)
If Pizza is an Italian bread then we can call Dosa as Indian bread. Otherwise I agree this is a stretch