News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by praptak on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:34AM (#1304130)
The question contains a hidden assumption: "Everything that expands, must expand into something else." This assumption seems obvious because everything that we can directly observe has this property. But this does not make it automatically true for the universe.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by michael_dorfman on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:51AM (#1304154)
If it is true for matter, and the universe is the sum total of all existent matter, why wouldn't it be true for the universe?

Put another way: "Expands into something else" is what "expands" means.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by ThomPete on Thursday April 29, 2010 @08:03AM (#1304175)
Words don't dictate reality.

And words sure don't represent reality.

The expanding universe theory is an attempt to visualize what is going on, not to actually describe what is really going on.

Language is a simplification of reality. They create linear narratives (expanding from something smaller to something bigger)

But just as time probably isn't what we think it is, these narratives aren't anything but descriptors of experienced phenomena.

Just as when Dawkins talks about the selfish gene. He isn't saying that they are really selfish (they don't have agency) he say they behave as if they are selfish.

There is absolutely nothing that dictates that we need to be able to express in language what is going on, case in point quantum physics where we have non locality.

The expanding universe theory makes sense because the metaphors used to describe it take our perspective into consideration.

But in reality there isn't necessarily any expansion taking place. In physical reality yes, but that is not all of reality.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by samd on Thursday April 29, 2010 @08:38AM (#1304229)
"Everything is vague to a degree you do not realize till you have tried to make it precise." - Bertrand Russell
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:01AM (#1304269)
When the balloon expands, its two dimensional surface are increases because the balloon is expanding into the 3rd dimension. Why can't a universe of n dimensions simply expand into the n+1 dimension?

Or, put in a better way - the universe humans can perceive is expanding, without expanding into anything else we can perceive.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by goodside on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:56PM (#1305086)
Because positing the existence of an n+1 dimension complicates the theoretical model without adding to its predictive power. Curvature and expansion can be defined perfectly well using intrinsic measures within n dimensions, without positing another. Further, the n-dimensional manifold might curve in ways that cannot be embedded into n+1 dimensions. For example, a Klein bottle is a logically possible shape of a 2D universe that cannot be embedded into a 3D universe without colliding with itself. Now, if this happens you might say, "Aha! But a Klein bottle can indeed exist embedded in 4D. So perhaps our universe is not in n+1 dimensions, but n+2." But how far does this continue? Adding dimensions every time you find something new out about the curvature of space is like adding epicycles to the geocentric model. You don't need an infinite supply of dimensions to embed the universe in, since everything you know about it can be described without reference to any of these unobservable dimensions that you might suppose exist.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:09AM (#1304683)
You're reading too much into the analogy. It's merely to help understand how a 3D space can expand without having a center, and nothing else.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:08PM (#1304931)
I just explained the workings of the analogy. I think you're parroting those words without completely understanding my comment or the words themselves.

(Note, if all matter is n-dimensional, then expansion of the n-dimension space into dimension n+1 wouldn't be expansion of the Universe into anything. It would be the expansion of an n-dimension subset into an n+1 dimension universe.)

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by JoeAltmaier on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:31AM (#1304322)
Exactly
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by Herring on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:22AM (#1304304)
>If it is true for matter, and the universe is the sum total of all existent matter, why wouldn't it be true for the universe?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_of_composition

http://www.logicalfallacies.info/relevance/composition/

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by ErrantX on Thursday April 29, 2010 @05:59AM (#1303992)
Don't believe the metaphors. In every science special worth its salt, you'll see some image of a balloon being inflated.

I've always considered this metaphor really good; it's just it is badly explained. The go to guy for decent pop physics explanations is, in my mind, Dr Brian Cox [1] (he does some really excellent TV shows here in the UK). His explanation with the balloon notes that while the surface area increases (expansion of the universe) the volume of the balloon rubber does not. You have to ignore the air inside and outside of the balloon as having any importance.

Then it should become clear how the universe can "expand" without actually expanding into anything.

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Cox_(physicist)

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by michael_dorfman on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:07AM (#1304005)
You have to ignore the air inside and outside of the balloon as having any importance.

And that's the bit of mental acrobatics that makes the metaphor break down. Which is why the advice above ("Don't believe the metaphors") is relevant.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:09AM (#1304278)
If any given model of the universe involves n dimensions, why can't we simply have it expand into the n+1 dimension? When you inflate a balloon, it's 2d area is increasing by the balloon expanding into the 3rd dimension.

In any model of the universe as a brane of n dimension, its expansion can be modeled as expansion in the n+1 dimension. Perhaps "universe" is a paradoxical word that cannot have a meaning? It's hard to imagine a world of infinite dimension.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by sp332 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:17AM (#1304450)
It doesn't work. Time & space - all the dimensions that exist - exist inside the universe. There is no "space" out there to expand into.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:04PM (#1304908)
So you posit a universe of an infinite number of dimensions? That's nonsense. Just because there's nothing in dimension n+1 doesn't mean it's not part of the universe. It would also allow expansion of the n-dimension brane.

Do you know of cosmological models proposing an infinite number of spatial dimensions?

EDIT: Note that the "expansion of the universe" is really only "expansion we observe through telescopes." I've never heard anything about astronomical observations concerning dimensions S, 6, or others. 3D space can easily expand without the need for anything outside the universe, in a universe of more than 3 dimensions.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by sp332 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:56PM (#1305085)
I'm saying that there are a finite number of dimensions - maybe a dozen or less. They all exist inside the universe. "Outside" the universe, there are no dimensions. There is no space or time. There is actually no "place" for you to "go" outside the universe. It only makes sense to say that the universe is expanding by measuring the space and matter in it. There is no measuring stick outside to hold the universe up to.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:38PM (#1305268)
What happened to empiricism? Where's your evidence that dimensions other than the 3 we can see are expanding?

Waiting for the light bulb...

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by sp332 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @02:15PM (#1305410)
By "n" I thought you meant all the dimensions in the universe, not just 3+time. Like you were inventing new dimensions to expand into. So never mind that part.

But just because the dimensions we see are expanding, doesn't mean they are expanding into other dimensions we can't see. Here I ask you for some empiricism - what's your evidence? To modify the balloon example, just imagine a flat rubber sheet that is stretched to be a little bigger. No extra dimensions necessary.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @02:30PM (#1305455)
True, that, but we do have empirical evidence that spacetime is not flat.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by sp332 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @03:55PM (#1305781)
"Not flat" doesn't mean wrinkled into other dimensions. Again, it's just a metaphor/visualization, not a direct representation. It's like this image: http://sparrow.stanford.edu/~chumakov/images/grids-negative-... The 2D space has "negative curvature," but it doesn't bend into a third dimension. It's still flat.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by ErrantX on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:11AM (#1304015)
I don't know - as long as you say, during the explanation, that the air inside/outside is irrelevant then it's a good demonstration of expansion!
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by michael_dorfman on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:49AM (#1304152)
Umm, no.

When you blow up a balloon, the volume of rubber remains the same, but the area gets larger-- because it expands into open space.

When the universe expands, the volume of matter remains the same, but the area.....um, what? Expands into open space? That can't be right.

So, if the universe is getting larger, like a balloon, where is it going?

Oh, so it's not really like a balloon, then.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @08:57AM (#1304266)
So, if the universe is getting larger, like a balloon, where is it going?

In a way, it's like all of the light waves are shrinking locally, and only the ones traveling the distance between galaxies are staying the same. (Which is not what's really happening either.)

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by ErrantX on Thursday April 29, 2010 @08:03AM (#1304174)
> When you blow up a balloon, the volume of rubber remains the same, but the area gets larger-- because it expands into open space.

Well, actually you're considering the air there - so it doesn't work. Ignore the air and think about how the balloon skin moves through the medium.

In fact the balloon can be considered as not expanding into open air; simply more air is inside it than before - equally a little less air is outside it than there was before (ignoring pressure differences for the moment). Imagine if the skin was perfectly flat and was stretched. The air "moves" around it but is irrelevant to the expansion (and thinning) of the skin. The example only demonstrates how an object can have a larger area without changing volume.

Same principle - but in the balloon it is easier to demonstrate relative movement.

Im only basing this on my own experience but anyone I've ever given the proper explanation too has gone "oh yeh, I see" (or something the that effect).

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by AngryParsley on Thursday April 29, 2010 @05:38AM (#1303970)
While the IO9 post is better than most pop-physics articles, I feel a need to repeat myself...

Your question contains invalid assumptions. There is no analogy that gives both a satisfying and accurate answer. You want to know about physics? Understand the math. The closest you can get without differential equations is Feynman's QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by gaius on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:19AM (#1304299)
Did you see Agora yet? In it the mathematician Hypatia in 4th century Egypt (played by Rachel Weisz) makes the radical announcement that circles are not really shapes in their own right, they're just a type of ellipse, and everyone wigs out - everything they know about astronomy and physics will have to be rethought. Anyway, awesome film.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by AngryParsley on Friday April 30, 2010 @05:55AM (#1307680)
I watched Agora tonight. It was good. I didn't know a movie could cause me to dislike religion even more than I already did.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:16AM (#1304100)
The question doesn't really mean anything. Space (and time) and attributes/characteristics/features of our universe. So there is no "outside" (multiverse models aside). Likewise you cannot ask what was "before" the big bang, as time only came in to existence with the big bang.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by euroclydon on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:27AM (#1304119)
Likewise you cannot ask what was "before" the big bang, as time only came in to existence with the big bang.

If there were ever a reason not to like cosmology, it's statements like that.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:45AM (#1304582)
Definitely have to disagree. I think this sort of understanding is what makes physics and cosmology awesome. It's hard to imagine as we experience 3 spatial dimensions and 1 of time (and can only experience that time dimension in one direction). There could be universes with no time, or a dozen space dimensions, or 2 time dimensions. How would you define "before" for a universe with multiple time dimensions?

Edit: the human perception of time is an interesting subject. Physics (GR) holds that there is a 4D space-time. What we experience as separate constructs is really just too sides of the same coin. Although thermodynamics seems to define a "direction" to time, there's no real reason why you couldn't move in both time directions. For example, the production of an anti-particle in a particle accelerator (e.g a positron) is really just a particle (electron) travelling back in time to the production point. You can get around cause and effect issues if you assume the universe is in fact a 4D static environment, where time travel (forward or backward) has been predetermined by the static layout created during the big bang. This does of course have implications for free will... However, the multi-verse interpretation of QM gets you out of this.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by euroclydon on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:05PM (#1304914)
Whoa whoa, when you say: "the production of an anti-particle in a particle accelerator (e.g a positron) is really just a particle (electron) travelling back in time to the production point." Do you mean the particle actually traveled back in time, or that you are able to create a model with bi-directional time, and the model's calculations work with the observed results in the accelerator, or is this the type of question I'm not allowed to ask?
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by lmkg on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:18PM (#1305181)
According to some philosophies of physics, there isn't a difference between the two things you just said. Traveling backwards through time is a valid, experimentally consistent, and self-consistent interpretation of a physical phenomenon. If you're not satisfied that means that it's "really" happening, then I think you'll need to be more specific about what you think "truth" means. Spoiler: physics makes your brain hurt. For example, I hear that that are small enough time/distance scales where causality because mathematically ill-defined.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:28PM (#1305222)
sure you can ask it! and it's a good question, and similar to many which cause heated debate in QM (essentially - the model works beautifully, but what does it _mean_?). Basically I don't have the answer. All I can say is that when an anti-particle is created, that is IDENTICAL to - per our model - a particle travelling back in time and being destroyed at the production point. Now we know the model works extremely well. It describes the system to a very high degree of accuracy, and can be used to make predictions about how that system evolves. So - if the model is correct (let's assume it is), and anti-particle production -> moving forward in time == particle moving backwards -> destruction, which is it that we are observing?

Basically, I think most physicists would say these two scenarios are the same thing, just expressed (or observed) in two different ways.

Edit: actually this highlights an important distinction between the quantum and macro-worlds. Things can only happen in one direction in the macro-world thanks to entropy (everything -> disorder). Whereas in the quantum world there's no such restriction, and things can happen in either direction.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by tfh on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:40AM (#1304138)
> time only came in to existence with the big bang

My brains segfaults imagining that there was a time where time didn't exist...

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by bhousel on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:59AM (#1304648)
Think of it this way: We don't have any way of measuring time that doesn't also involve space. Whether it's pendulums, or atoms vibrating, or photons bouncing around, any way we measure time is linked to (and relative to) whatever space is around it. If space is being deformed by a large mass being there, time will be affected (slowed down). Some theories of time say that what we think of as 'time' is really just a byproduct of space.

So if space didn't exist (in any meaningful way that we would understand today) before the big bang, time couldn't exist either.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stan_rogers on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:26AM (#1304738)
For anyone who hasn't seen it, this lecture by Bill Phillips (Nobel Laureate, of NIST, given at the Perimeter Institute) on time, relativity, cooling and the Bose-Einstein condensate is probably the most entertaining real science lecture you're ever going to see:

http://feeds.tvo.org/~r/tvobigideasVideo/~5/QOpqIcl2UDk/BI_F...

It's long, but it won't merit a tl;dw unless you have no curiousity, imagination, sense of humour or innate geekiness.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @08:49AM (#1304253)
That's like trying to imagine what being dead "is like" for materialist atheists. If you don't believe in an afterlife, then your consciousness simply ceases. There is no experience of being dead.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by jbarciauskas on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:50AM (#1304364)
I imagine being dead as being what my life was like before I was born.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:05PM (#1304918)
What was that like?
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by jbarciauskas on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:12PM (#1305157)
Exactly
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by crazydiamond on Thursday April 29, 2010 @05:32AM (#1303965)
So the galaxies are sitting still, the space inside it is expanding ... at faster than the speed of light.

The way my puny layman mind can figure out ... if 2 objects move away from one another at slightly more than half the speed of light, then one would see the other as apparently moving away at greater than the speed of light.

Also, iirc, the expanding balloon metaphor was more to give an idea how all points are moving away from one another, and each sees itself as the center. It was not meant to talk of dimensions, or moving into ... (btw, thanks a lot for the link. great read)

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by lmkg on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:35PM (#1305256)
Warning: special relativity hurts your brain.

First, there's no such thing as objective space. There is no objective Frame of Reference. You can pick a frame of reference, and it should probably be an inertial (non-accelerating) frame of reference, but it's just as valid as any other frame of reference. Inertial frames of references move with respect to each other at constant, less-than-C velocity.

Ok, so you picked a frame of reference, and in that frame of reference you have two objects A and B moving away from each other, each with a velocity of 0.5c, for a total relative velocity of c. What does this look like to either of the objects? Well, to answer that question, we have to jump into their frames of reference, which are moving at 0.5c with respect to ours.

In this new frame of reference, one of the objects A is stationary. Object C that was stationary in the previous frame of reference is now moving at 0.5c. And the other object B, that in the previous frame of reference was moving away at c? In this frame of reference, it is moving away at less than c. Why? A combination of time dilation and space compression, which you probably know happens in special relativity.

In the original frame of reference, object A was moving at 0.5c because it took 1 year to travel from one point to another than are half a light year apart. In the new frame of reference, the object A is standing still and the two points are moving, and they're more than half a light-year apart, and it takes less than 1 year for the new one to get here. Similarly, time & distance separation between points that the other object B is passing have altered in the new frame of reference. There's some math which isn't that complicated but is a bit onerous, but the punchline is that it appears to be traveling less than the speed of light in the new frame of reference.

Why does space and time contort like this? So that a light particle traveling will appear to be moving at the speed of light in any inertial reference frame, regardless of the relative velocities of those reference frames.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by tydok on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:34AM (#1304042)
> 2 objects move away from one another at slightly more than half the speed of light, ...

IIRC, mass grows towards infinity as it approaches the speed of light. So that's not possible if the objects have mass.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by ErrantX on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:45AM (#1304056)
Which bit are you questioning - making it to half the speed of light (I believe that is entirely possible) or the relative speed being more than the speed of light?

If it is the latter; it's perfectly possible. Ultimately it is just mathematics - as pointed out on Wikipedia apparent "FTL" travel is allowed by most models.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faster-than-light

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by tydok on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:56AM (#1304070)
The first part, making it to half the speed of light.

With massless particles is of course possible. My physics is a bit rusty so I can't really argue on this matter :)

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by crazydiamond on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:39AM (#1304337)
So are you saying there is a maximum speed which is less than half the speed of light, for objects that have mass. What is that max speed ??

From what i know, a great deal of energy is required to accelerate it, as the speed increases, but its still a finite amount.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:03AM (#1304658)
maximum speed for any object with mass is the speed of light in vacuo. You can't accelerate beyond this as, as you impart more energy to the object, it increases in mass, making it harder to accelerate further. As you approach c the mass tends -> infinite, hence requiring infinite energy to get to c.

Objects with no mass on the other hand, all move at c.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by JoeAltmaier on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:34AM (#1304327)
Unless you change the "size" of the space between them - then they are getting further apart without moving, which is what is happening.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by baddox on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:12AM (#1304690)
"We're not actually sure whether the universe is infinitely large, or merely very, very big, but in even supposing it is, ... "

Forget the philosophical/physics questions, what do those words even mean?

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by crazydiamond on Thursday April 29, 2010 @05:38AM (#1303969)
> The expanding universe is due to gravity, which means that in regions of high density, the dominant gravitational effects are entirely local.

Is this the conventional view. I always thought the universe was expanding as a result of the big bang momentum. This expansion would keep going unless there was a critical mass to pull it back. (that was the way things were when i was a kid). Or am i misreading.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by a-priori on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:25AM (#1304116)
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy: "dark energy is a hypothetical form of energy that permeates all of space and tends to increase the rate of expansion of the universe"
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:06AM (#1304672)
not sure that quote is correct. Gravity is an attractive force, it should slow expansion. However recent observations indicate the expansion is accelerating. This has (I beleive - been out of modern physics for a little while) lead to the positing of "dark flow", missing or dark energy.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by Devilboy on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:56AM (#1304069)
The expansion is accelerating though
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by Shorel on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:44AM (#1304804)
I think it is a valid question, not because it is valid in a strict physical sense, but because a lot of people can have the same doubts.

Carl Sagan would have provided an interesting anecdote or analogy to explain the answer instead of ridiculing whoever ask this.

Sadly, my writing skills are way lesser than those of Sagan.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by ghjrtyh on Thursday April 29, 2010 @08:35AM (#1304224)
This guy is either crap at explaining, or hasn't got a clue what he's talking about.