Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into?
by euroclydon on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:05PM
(#1304914)
Whoa whoa, when you say: "the production of an anti-particle in a particle accelerator (e.g a positron) is really just a particle (electron) travelling back in time to the production point." Do you mean the particle actually traveled back in time, or that you are able to create a model with bi-directional time, and the model's calculations work with the observed results in the accelerator, or is this the type of question I'm not allowed to ask?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into?
by lmkg on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:18PM
(#1305181)
According to some philosophies of physics, there isn't a difference between the two things you just said. Traveling backwards through time is a valid, experimentally consistent, and self-consistent interpretation of a physical phenomenon. If you're not satisfied that means that it's "really" happening, then I think you'll need to be more specific about what you think "truth" means. Spoiler: physics makes your brain hurt. For example, I hear that that are small enough time/distance scales where causality because mathematically ill-defined.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into?
by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:28PM
(#1305222)
sure you can ask it! and it's a good question, and similar to many which cause heated debate in QM (essentially - the model works beautifully, but what does it _mean_?). Basically I don't have the answer. All I can say is that when an anti-particle is created, that is IDENTICAL to - per our model - a particle travelling back in time and being destroyed at the production point. Now we know the model works extremely well. It describes the system to a very high degree of accuracy, and can be used to make predictions about how that system evolves. So - if the model is correct (let's assume it is), and anti-particle production -> moving forward in time == particle moving backwards -> destruction, which is it that we are observing?
Basically, I think most physicists would say these two scenarios are the same thing, just expressed (or observed) in two different ways.
Edit: actually this highlights an important distinction between the quantum and macro-worlds. Things can only happen in one direction in the macro-world thanks to entropy (everything -> disorder). Whereas in the quantum world there's no such restriction, and things can happen in either direction.