News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:01AM (#1304269)
When the balloon expands, its two dimensional surface are increases because the balloon is expanding into the 3rd dimension. Why can't a universe of n dimensions simply expand into the n+1 dimension?

Or, put in a better way - the universe humans can perceive is expanding, without expanding into anything else we can perceive.

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by goodside on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:56PM (#1305086)
Because positing the existence of an n+1 dimension complicates the theoretical model without adding to its predictive power. Curvature and expansion can be defined perfectly well using intrinsic measures within n dimensions, without positing another. Further, the n-dimensional manifold might curve in ways that cannot be embedded into n+1 dimensions. For example, a Klein bottle is a logically possible shape of a 2D universe that cannot be embedded into a 3D universe without colliding with itself. Now, if this happens you might say, "Aha! But a Klein bottle can indeed exist embedded in 4D. So perhaps our universe is not in n+1 dimensions, but n+2." But how far does this continue? Adding dimensions every time you find something new out about the curvature of space is like adding epicycles to the geocentric model. You don't need an infinite supply of dimensions to embed the universe in, since everything you know about it can be described without reference to any of these unobservable dimensions that you might suppose exist.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by retube on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:09AM (#1304683)
You're reading too much into the analogy. It's merely to help understand how a 3D space can expand without having a center, and nothing else.
Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by stcredzero on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:08PM (#1304931)
I just explained the workings of the analogy. I think you're parroting those words without completely understanding my comment or the words themselves.

(Note, if all matter is n-dimensional, then expansion of the n-dimension space into dimension n+1 wouldn't be expansion of the Universe into anything. It would be the expansion of an n-dimension subset into an n+1 dimension universe.)

Re:If The Universe Is Expanding, What's It Expanding Into? by JoeAltmaier on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:31AM (#1304322)
Exactly