News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by DenisM on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:00PM (#13038056)
As of this moment nearly every top level comment claims that sensationalized news is just as bad as manufactured news.

Come on guys, there is a huge difference. Lumping together everything you don't like about X is not a productive way to address individual problem. It really only helps to give yourself an excuse to throw your hands up in frustration.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tomp on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:18PM (#13038222)
This right here is the problem:

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-11-25/washington-post-nam...

When the idea of "fake news" is used to discredit sites like ZeroHedge and WikiLeaks as "Russian propaganda", you know it's not about fakeness/truth, but only about control - in other words, propaganda.

(I'm not saying that ZeroHedge is a quality site, far from it - but they've always been anti-establishment, pro-conspiracy theory, and they haven't changed their stance during this election campaign at all.)

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by ry4n413 on Friday December 02, 2016 @01:03AM (#13086420)
"Which is not to say readers should accept everything, or anything, at face value. Quite the contrary: as we have warned since the very start, our main intention, while informing readers, has been to make them think critically - to present a different side to things, even if it is ultimately dead wrong. For pete's sake, this a blog after all, not some established pillar of the fourth estate with editors, sub-editors, reporters, journalists, crossword puzzle makers, back office, and so forth. " http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-11-24/personal-note
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:34PM (#13038339)
No, it's not. It's a problem you have. It's not the same problem as fakenews, which is a form of webspam and has nothing to do with the case for Wikileaks being an instrument of Russia.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tomp on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:47PM (#13038470)
Clearly, "fakenews" is a problem only some people have - otherwise, it would be considered a "problem" even before the election!

It's very similar to "election fraud" - before the results, when Democrats were confident they'd win, Trump warning about election fraud was branded a lunatic, a threat to democracy, now we have the same situation on the other side but suddenly it's "the right thing to do" (smart and trustworthy people, e.g. Nate Silver, have dismissed the claims).

The bias is obvious for all neutral people. If a problem is only a problem when you have it, it's not a real problem, merely propaganda.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:50PM (#13038494)
No. The story is about fakenews. It's not about whatever other problems you might have. Talking about a specific problem doesn't mean we're disposing of other problems. On the other hand, requiring us to talk about other problems before we discuss a specific problem is a form of censorship (or trolling, which often has censorship as its ultimate aim).
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by 551199 on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:37PM (#13038371)
Yep, thats the strategy for msm to discredit independent and other news sources. Too bad they destroyed their brand during election.

It's clever branding I give them that, but I doubt it flies after election cycle meltdown.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by DanBC on Sunday November 27, 2016 @03:52AM (#13048361)
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by exabrial on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:31AM (#13037820)
Sadly, CNN, fox, CBS, Huffington Post, et all spread sensationalized fake news for the last 8 years (while ignoring Obama's abuses with the NSA, TPP, executive orders, ect) and this only has become an issue since Trump was elected. The train left the station a long time ago, but was willfully ignored. There simply is no integrity in reporting these days, though I would grateful to be proven wrong.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:36AM (#13037864)
There is a huge difference between fakenews, like the "Denver Guardian" fake newspaper site that ran stories about HRC being involved in the death of FBI agents in order to rack up tens of thousands of dollars from impressions, and sensationalized news.

Every time this topic comes up, we have to tediously explain the difference, not because the difference is hard to understand, but because people seize on the name "fake news" as an excuse to attack the media. There's nothing wrong with media criticism, but you shouldn't write it in a way that obscures to readers what these stories are actually about --- webspam farms running entirely fabricated stories.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by denzil_correa on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:53AM (#13037986)
> There is a huge difference between fakenews, like the "Denver Guardian" fake newspaper site that ran stories about HRC being involved in the death of FBI agents in order to rack up tens of thousands of dollars from impressions, and sensationalized news.

I'm really surprised this even has to be spelled out, TBH. IT goes to a point where I feel people are intentionally obfuscating the issue.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by keymone on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:04PM (#13038095)
obfuscation and false-equivalence is the best defense against propaganda accusations. did wonders for russia these last couple years.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pabloski on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:28PM (#13038298)
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by keymone on Friday November 25, 2016 @03:55PM (#13039762)
and you couldn't have shared a better link to express that opinion!
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by mc32 on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:48AM (#13037947)
Fake news ala straight-faced version of the Onion is a problem. It delivers content to many sides and spreads fabrications. One concern is that established media will use this punching bag of sorts to delegitimize smaller news organizations and make themselves into the canonical news organizations. In other words they seem to be seeing this as an opportunity for a power play.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by Broken_Hippo on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:04PM (#13038094)
There is comedic fake news, fakier news, and then there is serious fake news.

While occasionally people are duped by The Onion, the site itself doesn't pretend to be posting real stories. Believing this is akin to believing the fakier news, which is basically the tabloids of old. Lizard people, celebrity "news" and gossip and the like. A certain subset of folks have always gone for that stuff, but I like to think that more of them read it for the giggles. The main reason any of this gets into mainstream is lack of fact checking by the real news folks.

But the other breed, the serious fake news, is the real problem. Even otherwise intelligent folks can't really sort out if they are real or not because it is just so freaking plausible. Their goal is to be believed, and reaffirm some suspicions and beliefs people have. Even worse, some of these sites will mix in factual stuff with their fakes. These are the ones that, "seem to be seeing this as an opportunity for a power play". In a sense, any news organisation that caters to any political party - fox news to an extent, and the more insidious players (occupydemocrats, for example) - are guilty of just this. Twist, lie, and misrepresent are part of the game.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:50AM (#13037965)
Do you have evidence for this other than the fact that major news outlets are reporting on fakenews?
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by cmac2992 on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:56AM (#13038016)
It becomes a finer line when you have the Washington Post reporting (more accurately reporting an "expert" claim) that hillary Clinton may have been poisoned on 9/11 by Putin.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:37PM (#13038377)
No, it doesn't. This is again a false equivalence.

Stories in the mainstream press can be slanted, or even false --- stories are retracted all the time! That doesn't make them "fakenews". Fakenews sites are spam, fabricated out of whole cloth.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by daxorid on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:38PM (#13038381)
It is not "fine" at all. CNN last week intentionally reported the absurd claim that Richard Spencer questioned whether Jews are people. They knew it was incorrect, and reported it anyway.

Only later did they issue a quiet retraction. This is par for the course for US media organizations.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:44PM (#13038433)
Reconstituting the same false equivalences over and over again isn't going to make the argument any more compelling. Really, you're just making the case for us. Two responses:

1. CNN misapprehended Spencer's comment, which wasn't about whether Jewish people are human, but instead whether members of the mainstream media are. The story wasn't fabricated --- it was misreported. Again: the media does not have to be perfect for us to reasonably talk about "fakenews", which is webspam consisting of entirely fabricated stories.

2. Here's something you will not see happening on fakenews sites:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3961672/CNN-Jake-Tap...

Look! A retraction!

PS:

It's worth adding that part of the uproar over this CNN chyron is because Spencer is in fact a white supremacist and does in fact have strong anti-Semitic views, and CNN was in part being accused of amplifying those views.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by meira on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:18PM (#13039147)
You are just saying that MSM way of handling fake news is more professional than alt right fake news. I think it only makes the matter worse.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pcwalton on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:28PM (#13039217)
If by "more professional" you mean "with infinitely more regard for the real truth", then sure.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by meira on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:40PM (#13039288)
All these Russians accusation thing is fake news. Very professional.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:45PM (#13039323)
No, they are not. For the n-th time: there's a distinction between stories that don't pan out (this isn't even one of those!) and fakenews, which is a form of webspam.

The continued insistence that any discussion of fakenews include litigation of all the flaws of all other news media is a form of trolling, meant to prevent us from discussing the phenomenon of fakenews.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @02:28PM (#13039219)
No, that is in fact not what I'm saying.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pas on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:59AM (#13038042)
Umm, could you link to that maybe?
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by cmac2992 on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:13PM (#13038177)
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2016/09/12...

Even though they aren't claiming these claims are true, its at the very least, incredibly misleading. They spend most of the article talking about how Putin has poisoned people in the past, and talking up the Drs credentials. There should be a disclosure that the claims are unsubstantiated. Or it should never have been posted.

That said the Washington post did some of the best reporting this election season.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by smt88 on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:19PM (#13038232)
There was no "claim" to disclaim by saying it's unsubstantiated. The original tweet was just that Clinton should be tested for poisons, not that she was definitely (or even likely) poisoned.

It's true that headlines like these cause people to become certain about what is an unsubstantiated idea. But it's also within the realm of possibility that Putin did try to poison Clinton. It would be far from the most egregious thing he's ever tried to do, and (as the story describes) he's done it before.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by smt88 on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:12PM (#13038170)
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2016/09/12...

They didn't report it as fact. They reported it as, "This respected guy is saying this thing."

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by 551199 on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:30PM (#13038307)
Please MSM colluding with Clinton campaign giving fake news daily. Most shocking being 'Trump raping 13 year kid' which was fabricated as nearly all other negative Trump stories.

Read the Podesta wikileaks if you haven't already.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tzs on Friday November 25, 2016 @01:39PM (#13038891)
> Sadly, CNN, fox, CBS, Huffington Post, et all spread sensationalized fake news for the last 8 years (while ignoring Obama's abuses with the NSA, TPP, executive orders, ect)

The things on your parenthetical list have all been extensively covered in mainstream media. The key is to include newspapers among your sources, instead of just mostly TV news sites which tend to be less broad and less deep.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by 3pt14159 on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:40AM (#13037896)
I've come around to thinking that not only is propaganda unavoidable, it's sometimes a good thing. Sometimes it's useful to avoid war, or to avoid public backlash against something that is actually good, but misunderstood like (potentially, anyway) TPP.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by iamnothere on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:53AM (#13037987)
If you look at history, propaganda is more often used to justify war than to prevent it.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pas on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:05PM (#13038101)
Eh. Propaganda is always sold as education. It's an explanation, to carefully frame issues, direct public discourse and so on.

Rational analysis should not care of the source of information, but about its veracity.

Alas people are not that great at this, hence propaganda works.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by mcphage on Saturday November 26, 2016 @02:09AM (#13042234)
> Rational analysis should not care of the source of information, but about its veracity.

You can mislead without lying. Veracity is not sufficient.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tormeh on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:15PM (#13038192)
And how do you verify news? By going out and verifying everything personally? If not, you have to trust someone. I'd rather trust the NYT than Breitbart, because I care about veracity, not because of an allegiance to the NYT. And also because the NYT cares more about the things I care about, but that's an independent factor.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pas on Sunday November 27, 2016 @05:01PM (#13051826)
I just addressed this in an other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13038215

tl;dr - I agree with you. NYT has some street cred, Breitbart has negative of that, that's why people should require more evidence for Breitbart's claims than for NYT's, and yes, we should take bias into account, but that's different, sort of orthogonal effect.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by exabrial on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:57AM (#13038027)
Yes, I'm well aware of the difference between web farms and news for profit. However, the former paved the way for the latter, and in my mind is guilty for the 'problem' they created.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by cinquemb on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:22PM (#13038257)
What's the end game here? What are we supposed to get riled up about now? Didn't some experts at the very prestigious Princeton University release a study already confirming the state of affairs we're left in the US (and arguably the rest of the world)?

I'm in complete and utter disgust, thanks Washington Post for waking me up. Which Soros' funded NGO's can I apply to for my daily rations of cookies and riot gear?

"What difference, at this point, does it make?" - Hillary Clinton

PS: Maybe Bezos should authorize linking this post in the black Friday emails I've been getting lately, and for every person that clicks through, they can get a further discount! Im sure more others are bound to become "woke" (thats the phrase people are using this days, no?).

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by sprucely on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:43AM (#13037912)
There is only one thing I can think of that would be worse than the spread of fake news, and that is legislation to address the spread of fake news. Unfortunately, that's where this is leading; if not in the Trump administration, then in the following.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by smt88 on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:15PM (#13038193)
It's already illegal in the US for a corporation to lie about its products. It's not unreasonable to expect that some organizations (i.e. corporations created explicitly for the purpose of campaigning) can be sued for lying about their "product" -- a candidate, for example.

But considering the Supreme Court's historically zealous defense of the First Amendment (see: Citizens United), we're unlikely to see much change in that regard.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by Practicality on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:22PM (#13038251)
I am surprised that anyone is surprised by this, honestly. Russian culture does not place even as much of a value on truthfulness as American culture does, and even that is not that high.

It should be seen as a given that there is significant Russian propaganda working all the time on every issue they care about. Of course they would be trying to influence the American election.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by fjdjcjcnf on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:22PM (#13038250)
It is highly unethical to flagkill every comment that disagrees with you. I suggest you stop doing it
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by dang on Friday November 25, 2016 @01:58PM (#13039022)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13037839 and marked it off-topic.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:30PM (#13038308)
Thank you for reminding me to flag that post.
[dead]
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:33AM (#13037839)
This is extremely disingenuous.

1. Fakenews sites are webspam sites that run entirely fabricated stories as if they're news. For instance: the often-repeated claim that HRC was involved in the death of an FBI agent was fabricated by a person who admits to doing it and made tens of thousands of dollars posting that and stories like that to Wordpress sites they set up with official sounding names like "The Denver Guardian", counting on the fact that people in other media markets wouldn't know there was no such publication. Nothing the Clinton campaign did is anything like that.

2. The Clinton campaign and PACs supporting that campaign are not "the US government" --- nor is the Washington Post, which is an independent media outlet that routinely runs stories critical of the US Government (as you are about to see even more clearly during the next four years).

The equivalences you are posing here are so false as to approach trolling.

The story posted here might be wrong, or it might be inappropriate for HN. You can write a comment in good faith challenging the story. You can flag the story. What you can't reasonably do is express your displeasure by trolling the thread. Please stop doing that. You do it a lot.

[dead]
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pas on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:17PM (#13038215)
No one is arguing about freedom of the press.

Also, there are journalistic ethical rules, fake news blogspam is not the press.

For example, a journalist has certain protections, but in exchange for that he/she (or her/his editor/publisher) has to be publicly known, by name, to be accountable for what they write/publish.

And any piece of data, any representation of information is suspect of forgery. The whole problem of solipsism is still pretty valid.

And ultimately we can only resort to the good old Bayesian rule of inference: wild claims require very hard evidence.

And when an established publishing house places its reputation on the line, that counts a bit. When a shit tier conspiracy blogger claims something about Benghazi, that requires a bit more than "our sources say Bush lied about WMDs".

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by cryoshon on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:39AM (#13037890)
this whole "fake news" narrative arc needs to be fucking murdered, and here's why:

stories which detail items of unpopular fact surrounded by biased opinions which threaten the status quo are being lumped in with stories which fabricate facts and are transparently clickbait.

the first type of story headline: "hillary took money from the saudis and will sell us out"

the second type of story headline: "hillary murdered young children in 1990"

see the difference? one of the two has a fact regarding campaign finance (presented in a very slanted yet still correct way) that is tied to a speculation/opinion (easily identifiable bias) that will validate a broad range of opinions and potentially begin to form opinions in the uninformed. the other is a bogus fact that will draw attention and validate the most extreme already-existing opinions.

the mainstream media is viciously desperate to make the issue of hillary losing the election into a matter of "too many people fell victim to the fake news stories which claimed hillary murdered children in 1990. those stupid republican idiots are just so darn impressionable." this couldn't be farther from the truth. masses of people falling for headline 2 generates rioting in the streets, not voting for an "outsider".

people saw the first type of story, and believed it. facts often don't have to be twisted in order for the reader to arrive at a certain conclusion, and hillary was laden with a billion of these facts.

the whining regarding russian interference in our election is very much overblown, as well as cynically ignorant/ intellectually dishonest. the USA meddles in countless other elections, consistently, via propaganda and other means. this doesn't make it right when anyone does the same to us, but a discussion of foreign influence in our elections should be within the proper context: geopolitical powers meddle in each other's affairs as much as they think they can get away with.

furthermore, russians did not start propagandizing yesterday. many of the urban russians are a technologically inclined and cosmopolitan people who are prolific on the internet, and it is certain that these people are the ones filling the ranks of putin's propaganda forces. they simply aren't stupid enough to try making completely counterfactual claims fly-- it's a waste of their time. the russian angle of propaganda has been (even since the times of the early soviet union) a kernel of undeniable and ugly truth, which can be opined upon within a range of speculation. you could say that in this election, their angle was "hillary clinton is corrupt". this angle of propaganda only works if people immediately recognize the kernel beneath the headline, and identify with the sentiment.

for many people in this country, "russian propaganda" fit cleanly with their own domestic "not-propaganda" media sources. so what if it was the russians feeding information to wikileaks? for many people, the relevant facts of the matter pre-emailgate were exactly the same as after. calling the real development of narration around the kernal of hillary clinton being corrupt "fake news" is a massive disservice to the public, as well as abject denial of the situation. voters didn't like hillary because they thought she was corrupt. there were many media which supported and fostered that dislike, using facts. there were many other media which fostered that dislike using fictions. don't throw the fact out with the fiction, regardless of the source of each.

btw: i voted green party, not in a swing state. if that makes any difference to you.

---

this is the part of my comment where i make a lofty call for improved critical thinking training for our citizenry. the way to kill the problem of propaganda is not via suppression of inconvenient storys, as zuckerberg wants to do with "fake news", but rather an increase in general ability to identify and deconstruct malicious thoughtware. there are a few easy rules of thumb that could help people a lot. maybe i'll write them into an ebook. the problem is that a lot of people don't give a shit about critical thinking, and find any kind of intellectualizing to be faggy.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:49AM (#13037954)
"Hillary Clinton is involved in the death of an FBI agent", or "The Dalai Lama joined Putin in blaming Obama and Clinton for ISIS", or "The Pope endorsed Donald Trump" aren't "unpopular facts surrounded by biased opinions". They're fake news.

That is the difference between "fakenews" and "biased" or "sensationalized" news. There is no number of paragraphs you can write that will make the difference between those two concepts any less stark.

Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by pabloski on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:32PM (#13038326)
Does "the russians bombed the 100th pediatric hospital in Aleppo" qualify as fake news? You know, because it is practically impossibile that Aleppo is full of pediatric hospitals. They need groceries, discos, supermarkets too!
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:35PM (#13038348)
I have no idea, because a Google search for that headline turns up nothing.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by zappo2938 on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:30AM (#13037817)
So what? "Eighty-three percent of Americans identify themselves as Christians." I don't see how this is different from all the people knocking on my door telling me about the good news, er, um, the fake news, from 31 AD.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by Kenji on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:45AM (#13037931)
Let's be honest here: The information war was fought on both sides. You had to dig through the mud to find any reliable news. I consumed a healthy mix of pro-clinton western media, RT, candidate videos straight from rallies and leaks like wikileaks or the video where Hillary stumbled. That's how you get a good overview.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:50AM (#13037957)
You cannot in fact improve the overview you get of current events by consuming outright fabrications, which is what we're discussing in this story.
Re:Russian propaganda effort helped spread ‘fake news’ durin... by Kenji on Friday November 25, 2016 @11:55AM (#13038003)
I disagree. By seeing the propaganda from both sides, you get an insight into who has which goals. The only things you miss out on are the things they all want to hide and the only things you get wrong are the things they all lie on in the same way. It's like cross-examination in a courtroom.