Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by epicureanideal on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:31PM
(#13028109)
I think if there's reason to believe that votes were miscounted or there was fraud, there should be a recount.
But I can't help but notice that the media seemed to hammer Trump about the possibility of not accepting the results of the election. I strongly suspect if he were the one demanding a recount it would be treated very differently. It's disappointing that our society so obviously switches its standards based on someone's in-group or out-group status.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by xapata on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:46PM
(#13028186)
Recount is different from rejection of results. It was unclear whether he was anticipating a legal fight or simply planning on ignoring the counts. My guess is that he wanted to lose so that he could focus on making noise and have no responsibility.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by epicureanideal on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:54PM
(#13028224)
Why would anyone put so much time and money into an activity they hope to lose?
I think the whole issue was created to make him look bad. "Hey, if you lose, will you accept the results?" After Gore/Bush, I don't know if anybody would immediately say "Yes" without thinking about the possibility of questionable things happening. Would you accept the results of an election with fraud? Until the election happens, you can't have 100% confidence that you won't think there was some fraud.
A lot of us here have questions about voting machines, people voting who shouldn't, etc. These are natural concerns that should be Hillary's concerns (as they are now) and not just Trump's.
The question was not "Assuming there is iron clad proof of no voter fraud, will you accept the results if you lose?" The answer would almost certainly have been "Yes" in that case. I think all of us on this site are smart enough to assign non-zero probability to the chance that this question was asked WITHOUT the "no voter fraud" disclaimer specifically to elicit the reaction that it got.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by Avshalom on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:44AM
(#13028445)
"I think the whole issue was created to make him look bad."
...He created the issue.
He spent weeks/months claiming the system was rigged, the election would be rigged, that the only way he could possibly lose was if he was cheated because he was going to win by such a landslide. He kept calling for people to loiter around polling sites with guns to prevent funny business...
That wasn't post-2000 reticence about the preliminary call.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by xapata on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:05AM
(#13028961)
> money
He loaned $45 million and gave less than $10 million, but mostly as in-kind gifts not cash. He said back in 2000 he could run for president and make money from the campaign. I think he succeeded, depending on the interest rate of that loan. He spent a bunch of campaign funds by buying from his own businesses.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by ant6n on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:52AM
(#13030899)
> A lot of us here have questions about voting machines, people voting who shouldn't, etc.
I thought only Republicans keep continuing the fairy tale of non-citizens voting, which they then use to justify voter suppression of poor people and minorities; which is the actual question this election.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by paulddraper on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:54PM
(#13028225)
> Recount is different from rejection
Recount is also different then acceptance.
This recount is purely academic. You would have to alter tens of thousands of votes across several states to change this election's outcome. No harm in being academic I suppose. Hope the millions are worth it.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by derrickdirge on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:53AM
(#13028923)
If you know the method, it seems like you should be able to alter an arbitrary number of votes. I wouldn't think they'd have to alter them one at a time or anything.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by postcarnival on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:41AM
(#13028433)
Let's not pretend this is some altruistic "academic" endeavor to satiate some curiosity. This is a thought-out play borne out of the rejection of the election result by the left.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by rbanffy on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:37AM
(#13029078)
Don't you think a significant difference between districts where everything is similar except for the voting mechanism, with a trend to favor a specific candidate on one hard-to-audit mechanism is suspicious?
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by postcarnival on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:07AM
(#13035864)
It might be so, but I also find reports of 3+ million illegals, 4+ million dead people, and other alleged acts of fraud to be suspicious... If we're going to go down that path it won't be pretty and it will likely involve more than just those 3 states. That said from what I read MI has already declared they've certified (recounted) their results so at this point Stein is just hustling money. I do wish technology could advance our voting systems on the whole though.. possibly block-chain based? but might require voter id! oye
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by Melchira on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:52AM
(#13037067)
Citation needed for those claims. As far as I can tell they come from a guy on twitter who refuses to share the data or explain his methodology. Parroting unverified and most likely false claims like this only serves to legitimize the fake "news sites" that publish this stuff without fact checking.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by postcarnival on Saturday November 26, 2016 @03:29PM
(#13045680)
When did I "parrot" anything as truth? I said I find it highly suspicious. If you want to go down the path of "fake news" sites how about we talk about almost every major network that had Clinton winning in a landslide?
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by FreeKill on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:19PM
(#13028038)
To bring this more in line with HackerNews usual content, what do you guys think the chances are that the voting machines will actually show a significant discrepancy from the paper receipts? Will this recount actually involve an audit of the voting machine software at all?
I have my doubts the outcome will be significantly changed, but I'd love it if the process involved an auditing of the voting machines, just from a curiosity standpoint...
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by rbanffy on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:26PM
(#13028077)
I would suggest it be checked, but not expect to find anything depending on the model. It'd look for zeroed out blocks, blocks containing data from other blocks or blocks containing random data where there should be none because this is how I'd erase traces of malware myself. Also look for directories with suspicious deleted entries (because I almost forgot I'd need to rewrite those too to erase any fingerprints).
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:21AM
(#13028344)
Basically, this is pretty much academic at this point. Hilary would have to gain enough votes to flip all 3 states. Trump will win the recount.
However, this will absolutely enrage his base as they see it as an attempt by the elite to steal the election. Trump seems to be moderating on some of his previous stances, but will likely reverse and be even more extreme after he wins a recount. Also, look for pressure on the Senate to completely suspend the filibuster and push through a very right wing Justice.
Based on how President Obama and Hilary Clinton are handling this so far, I expect them to intervene to squash any recount and try to make the transition as smooth as possible.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by narrowrail on Thursday November 24, 2016 @11:08AM
(#13030975)
>look for pressure on the Senate to completely suspend the filibuster and push through a very right wing Justice
Currently, Republicans hold the Senate (52,R vs 48,D). And, according to Wikipedia:
"On November 21, 2013, the Senate voted, in a 52 to 48 vote, to require only a majority vote to end a filibuster of all executive and judicial nominees, excluding Supreme Court nominees, rather than the 3/5 of votes previously required. A 3/5 supermajority is still required to end filibusters on legislation and Supreme Court nominees."
So, that is some context for anyone else not up to speed on the specifics.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by pvdebbe on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:03AM
(#13030345)
I noticed the same, Obama and Hillary both started to act very sportsmanlike right after the results. As is appropriate. It's the media and other factors that seem to hold on to a distant dream they once had.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by vinay427 on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:13AM
(#13030689)
What's unsportsmanlike about a recount, especially by a third party candidate that received so few votes? It's not like she's not accepting the results of the election, just challenging the accuracy of the reported results.
"
A candidate can’t actually file for a vote recount under Pennsylvania law. Instead, they would have to challenge a county board regarding its vote computations, and a state appeals judge would have to rule that a statewide recount is necessary. That means the Clinton campaign would either have to request a recount by petition in every voting district or present a prima facie case showing voter fraud. (Prima facie is a lower threshold than beyond a reasonable doubt. A judge would just have to rule that fraud probably occurred in order to call for a recount.)
"
While a state judge just possibly might rule for Clinton for a recount, I seriously doubt a judge would do that Jill Stein as she has no realistic chance of winning the state.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by cmurf on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:35PM
(#13032275)
If there's any modern case to be made for the electoral college, it's in these states. If they aren't all effectively faithless voters, then the founding purpose of the college is not true and should be done away with. Instead, it sounds like the faithless voters, should there be any, and if they defect, would vote for some other Republican. So it's not like Hillary would win just because Donald doesn't get enough votes.
If the election is questionable, the state legislatures can pick its Electors, and they should. That's what authenticates the process. Of course there needs to be more facts than just speculation there's been tampering or fraud; but the way these systems are designed, they may not have sufficient auditing to determine it, itself a big problem.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by rmason on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:16AM
(#13028786)
They'd be wasting their money in Michigan. The director of the Michigan Bureau of Elections said nothing is connected to the Internet. That's because Michigan is entirely a paper and optical scan state.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by rubyfan on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:20PM
(#13028047)
What is this data referenced in the article?
FTA: With your help, are raising money to demand recounts in Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania-- three states where the data suggests significant discrepancies in vote totals," the page reads.
Re:Jill Stein to file for recount in three states
by dangrossman on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:26PM
(#13028078)
> The scientists, among them J. Alex Halderman, the director of the University of Michigan Center for Computer Security and Society, told the Clinton campaign they believe there is a questionable trend of Clinton performing worse in counties that relied on electronic voting machines compared to paper ballots and optical scanners
Source: Computer scientists urge Clinton campaign to challenge election results
But Alex Halderman (the professor mentioned) posted a clarification, saying: "Were this year’s deviations from pre-election polls the results of a cyberattack? Probably not. I believe the most likely explanation is that the polls were systematically wrong, rather than that the election was hacked. But I don’t believe that either one of these seemingly unlikely explanations is overwhelmingly more likely than the other. "
https://medium.com/@jhalderm/want-to-know-if-the-election-wa...
But I can't help but notice that the media seemed to hammer Trump about the possibility of not accepting the results of the election. I strongly suspect if he were the one demanding a recount it would be treated very differently. It's disappointing that our society so obviously switches its standards based on someone's in-group or out-group status.
I think the whole issue was created to make him look bad. "Hey, if you lose, will you accept the results?" After Gore/Bush, I don't know if anybody would immediately say "Yes" without thinking about the possibility of questionable things happening. Would you accept the results of an election with fraud? Until the election happens, you can't have 100% confidence that you won't think there was some fraud.
A lot of us here have questions about voting machines, people voting who shouldn't, etc. These are natural concerns that should be Hillary's concerns (as they are now) and not just Trump's.
The question was not "Assuming there is iron clad proof of no voter fraud, will you accept the results if you lose?" The answer would almost certainly have been "Yes" in that case. I think all of us on this site are smart enough to assign non-zero probability to the chance that this question was asked WITHOUT the "no voter fraud" disclaimer specifically to elicit the reaction that it got.
...He created the issue.
He spent weeks/months claiming the system was rigged, the election would be rigged, that the only way he could possibly lose was if he was cheated because he was going to win by such a landslide. He kept calling for people to loiter around polling sites with guns to prevent funny business...
That wasn't post-2000 reticence about the preliminary call.
He loaned $45 million and gave less than $10 million, but mostly as in-kind gifts not cash. He said back in 2000 he could run for president and make money from the campaign. I think he succeeded, depending on the interest rate of that loan. He spent a bunch of campaign funds by buying from his own businesses.
> time and money
Maybe he just wanted to be on TV.
Is that illegal?
I thought only Republicans keep continuing the fairy tale of non-citizens voting, which they then use to justify voter suppression of poor people and minorities; which is the actual question this election.
Recount is also different then acceptance.
This recount is purely academic. You would have to alter tens of thousands of votes across several states to change this election's outcome. No harm in being academic I suppose. Hope the millions are worth it.
I have my doubts the outcome will be significantly changed, but I'd love it if the process involved an auditing of the voting machines, just from a curiosity standpoint...
However, this will absolutely enrage his base as they see it as an attempt by the elite to steal the election. Trump seems to be moderating on some of his previous stances, but will likely reverse and be even more extreme after he wins a recount. Also, look for pressure on the Senate to completely suspend the filibuster and push through a very right wing Justice.
Based on how President Obama and Hilary Clinton are handling this so far, I expect them to intervene to squash any recount and try to make the transition as smooth as possible.
Currently, Republicans hold the Senate (52,R vs 48,D). And, according to Wikipedia:
"On November 21, 2013, the Senate voted, in a 52 to 48 vote, to require only a majority vote to end a filibuster of all executive and judicial nominees, excluding Supreme Court nominees, rather than the 3/5 of votes previously required. A 3/5 supermajority is still required to end filibusters on legislation and Supreme Court nominees."
So, that is some context for anyone else not up to speed on the specifics.
https://jillstein.nationbuilder.com/recount
https://twitter.com/morgan_murphy/status/801589703078187008
" A candidate can’t actually file for a vote recount under Pennsylvania law. Instead, they would have to challenge a county board regarding its vote computations, and a state appeals judge would have to rule that a statewide recount is necessary. That means the Clinton campaign would either have to request a recount by petition in every voting district or present a prima facie case showing voter fraud. (Prima facie is a lower threshold than beyond a reasonable doubt. A judge would just have to rule that fraud probably occurred in order to call for a recount.) "
While a state judge just possibly might rule for Clinton for a recount, I seriously doubt a judge would do that Jill Stein as she has no realistic chance of winning the state.
If the election is questionable, the state legislatures can pick its Electors, and they should. That's what authenticates the process. Of course there needs to be more facts than just speculation there's been tampering or fraud; but the way these systems are designed, they may not have sufficient auditing to determine it, itself a big problem.
http://www.freep.com/story/news/politics/2016/11/23/michigan...
FTA: With your help, are raising money to demand recounts in Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania-- three states where the data suggests significant discrepancies in vote totals," the page reads.
Source: Computer scientists urge Clinton campaign to challenge election results
http://www.cnn.com/2016/11/22/politics/hillary-clinton-chall...
But Alex Halderman (the professor mentioned) posted a clarification, saying: "Were this year’s deviations from pre-election polls the results of a cyberattack? Probably not. I believe the most likely explanation is that the polls were systematically wrong, rather than that the election was hacked. But I don’t believe that either one of these seemingly unlikely explanations is overwhelmingly more likely than the other. " https://medium.com/@jhalderm/want-to-know-if-the-election-wa...
https://medium.com/@jhalderm/want-to-know-if-the-election-wa...