News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by luka-birsa on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:03PM (#12875032)
Anybody else sees a problem with training the AI to move troops around a battlefield, with the purpose to exterminate the opponent?
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by stale2002 on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:12PM (#12875093)
No?

Starcraft isn't troops on the battlefield, in the same way that Risk, the boardgame isn't troops on the battlefield.

Just because the 1s and 0s or game pieces represent "troops" to humans, doesn't mean that the underlying game mechanics have anything at all to do with a real war.

For all we know, the problems solved by a monopoly AI, are more applicable to a real war than those solved by a Risk or starcraft AI.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by spacehacker on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:42PM (#12875404)
You must admit that there is an underlying aggressive theme in games like StarCraft. The visuals show clear resemblance of people being killed by projectiles and by other war technology. The AI will be rewarded for skillfully decimating the enemy, for protecting the units it has control over and for coming up with strategies like ambush, raids, patrolling etc. I am more convinced by the idea that an AI will be able generalize to the real world from playing StarCraft than from playing Monopoly. However, I think it will be quite a leap to the real world either way.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by ssalazar on Friday November 04, 2016 @04:18PM (#12875719)
> You must admit that there is an underlying aggressive theme in these games. The visuals show clear resemblance of people being killed by projectiles and by other war technology.

An AI doesn't know or care about any of this. Literally its applying statistics to optimize a cost function or assign labels to input states. These numbers could represent number of kills or number of dollars; the computer doesn't care.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by Spellman on Friday November 04, 2016 @05:41PM (#12876393)
And that's what makes it ~spooooooky~.

It's just absentmindedly optimizing a cold value function! No more humanity! More more external input! Just cold machine logic!

We've doomed ourselves!!!!

But seriously. No, there is nothing inherent about an AI maximizing wins in StarCraft than one maximizing profits on the stock exchange. Although I feel like there's a bunch of Sci-Fi where this obviously goes awry.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by chronic6l on Friday November 04, 2016 @04:44PM (#12875952)
The computer doesn't even know what a kill is.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by manux on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:12PM (#12875104)
I do research in "Deep RL" for a living. The same algorithms (and advances related to them) that can be used in such a scenario can be used to create machine learning solutions for social good.

Similarly, algorithms used to detect cancer in medical imaging can be used to do automatic targeting on killer drones. Should we stop doing research altogether?

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by harigov on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:07PM (#12875063)
It's going to happen anyway. I think we are better off doing such things in the open and having some visibility into it rather than be surprised when something happens.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by treehau5 on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:09PM (#12875078)
I'm so sick of this argument. How about we have a spine for once and say no?
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by dguaraglia on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:14PM (#12875123)
How is 'saying no' going to stop the military of this or any other country from doing it? How do you measure the disadvantage we'd be at by not allowing our military to do it, but letting other militaries (over which we have no control) do it?

Having a spine has nothing to do with it.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by pmyjavec on Friday November 04, 2016 @11:19PM (#12877967)
So, basically another arms race to the bottom, similar to nuclear warheads ? 1940s thinking with 2016 technology. I hear what you're saying but not all progress is good progress.

The limits of our ability to think a global scale are an issue, we still have a tribe mentality, this discussion demonstrates that. "The Chinese, The British etc"

We still think in terms of tribes, but we have technology change the world. Until we evolve some more we're probably not fit to wield more and more powerful weapons.

It would be good if we could stop worrying about weaponry all together and focus on real issues like deforestation, poverty, pollution of the sea, climate change etc.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by dguaraglia on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:53PM (#12882105)
I get it, and I wholeheartedly support your position on the issue. The reality, unfortunately, is that we are horrid little creatures always scheming and fighting for power. Stopping nation X from doing, will only encourage nations Y and Z to develop it faster as an advantage.

The only way I can see an agreement to limit the escalation of AI warfare is on the same context we saw the START treaty: once the weapons are developed by at least two key players as "deterrent" there's an incentive to reach an agreement to stop further development.

Call me cynical, but if this election has shown me anything is how tiny-minded people still command an inordinate amount of power in this country.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by mzw_mzw on Saturday November 05, 2016 @02:13PM (#12881031)
How do you plan to convince China and Russia to stop worrying about weaponry and thinking in terms of tribes?
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by Mtinie on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:14PM (#12875118)
Ok, for conversation sake we all come together and say, "No, AI cannot be used for offensive or defensive military actions".

How do you propose that ban be enforced?

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by webkike on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:13PM (#12875112)
All 7 billion of us? Good luck with that.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by Mtinie on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:21PM (#12875190)
I agree with you, it's a virtually impossible task.

The commenter I was responding to has strong ideas about it however, so I wanted to provide the opportunity for an explanation.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by formula1 on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:16PM (#12875140)
What are you willing to sacrifice to say no? How about your immediate comfort and free time. Thats the real cost. Its not "when it happens we'll stabd togethor", Its "youtube videos or protecting the world from a potential future threat that everyone will think Im crazy for worrying about"
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by s_q_b on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:53PM (#12875497)
Good luck convincing South Korea, Japan, India, the EU, Britain, Australia, Canada....
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by mwambua on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:17PM (#12875154)
I'd be curious to hear more of your argument. The world is a complex place. How do you protect the one's you love when others exist who wouldn't say no?
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by jjawssd on Friday November 04, 2016 @05:29PM (#12876296)
Eventually the only people left are those who wouldn't say no
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by hota_mazi on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:22PM (#12875199)
Scientific research and progress: just say no.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by throwawaymsft on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:33PM (#12875322)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_(game)

Legends trace the origin of the game to the mythical Chinese emperor Yao (2337–2258 BC), who was said to have had his counselor Shun design it for his unruly son, Danzhu, to favorably influence him.[64] Other theories suggest that the game was derived from Chinese tribal warlords and generals, who used pieces of stone to map out attacking positions.[65][66]

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by s_m_t on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:20PM (#12875176)
If you are going to do war you should do it well. An AI commander could be programmed to maneuver troops in a way to reduce civilian casualties, reduce damage on infrastructure, and even maximize the chances of the enemy surrendering rather than having them killed.

Of course, I doubt that an AI commander would replace a human making the actual decisions in the foreseeable future. It would just be another intelligence tool for military command. From this point of view you are essentially arguing for our military to be ignorant, I don't think that is a good bet.

Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by hueving on Friday November 04, 2016 @05:28PM (#12876287)
This worry and the implication (control use of AI) is similar to the development of cryptography. Try to stop people from doing evil with it is a completely fruitless task.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by astrobe_ on Saturday November 05, 2016 @04:57AM (#12878838)
You should be more scared of the AI that tracks, profiles, predicts and influences you.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by nerfhammer on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:23PM (#12875213)
For example, chess?
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by Nadya on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:13PM (#12875113)
There are better war simulators if that were the purpose. There also wouldn't be a need to publicize it. Finally, big data/A.I is already used by the military. It probably isn't "decision making" levels, but it doesn't need to be. "Decision helping" is a good enough advantage.
Re:DeepMind and Blizzard to release StarCraft II as an AI re... by make3 on Friday November 04, 2016 @06:19PM (#12876641)
the press is going to make a huge clickbait deal about this, even if the complexity of starcraft 2, even if huge, is extremely small compared to the complexity of the world