News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:20PM (#12865332)
I'm really weirded out that people can't see the value Slack added. Having your messages stored while you are offline is hugely valuable. If I have been out of signal range on a train, I want to be able to look at history on my phone once I'm back in range of a cell tower.

Beyond that, a well made UI for web, desktop and phone that is consistent is valuable. 'Adding a pretty UI' isn't a zero-effort or skill thing.

No, Slack isn't a world away from IRC or email - but it's enough better that people want to use it, that's good. I'm not sure where all the hate comes from.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by fizzbatter on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:28PM (#12865410)
Hate? Everyone i know loves slack. I love slack. I've used it for my last two companies for (~many) years now. That doesn't make it innovative though, imo.

I can't think of a single feature they've done that is innovative. Attaching a file to a message?. Searching history? These aren't new or special in any way shape or form.

What slack did far more than UI, was UX. Top to bottom, it's a very nice UX. It's why i love Slack.

There's no hate coming from me - i'm just a realist. Slack didn't do anything amazing. It just did things right. Which is unfortunate for all of us users, as it took so many years to do things right. Unfortunately for slack though, they showed what is a good UX.. how hard do you think it is to copy that UX? Not easy, sure, but the template is there. Spend some time copying Slack, and i think you can manage to make Slack.Clone.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:42PM (#12865560)
It sounds a lot like all the people that bash StackOverflow - "It's just posts and a voting system, I could write that in a week!", ignoring all the complexity and design behind it, operating at scale and cultivating the environment.

If people need something to be 'amazing' not to put it down, and 'amazing' doesn't include doing the right things to be highly successful...

If no one else did it, was it really so obvious?

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by SomeStupidPoint on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:54PM (#12865691)
Microsoft has a well regarded developer network and Q&A system regarding Microsoft technologies, at least in my (limited to primarily Azure) experience.

Similarly, Microsoft has already operated a widely used integrated chat, profile, and community system at scale. Given their recent pushes, it wouldn't be entirely surprising for them to bring back similar platforms for business users integrated with LinkedIn.

That would eat a lot of Slack's potential big clients, because MS has a history of enterprise grade support on products like that, and Slack has scale issues for large orgs.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by blakeyrat on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:41PM (#12866717)
Does Slack even allow on-premise installs yet? That instantly disqualified them from the last 3 jobs I've had. (All of which had data protection issues that prevented them from using off-premises IM systems, mostly HIPAA regulations.) Microsoft's got that market already sewn-up, right out of the gate.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Pyxl101 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:47PM (#12867317)
As far as I'm aware Slack does not offer on-premise installs. (On-premise in this case could mean running in my own account at a cloud service provider) It's unfortunate because I'd love to adopt them as well at my current company, but it will be very difficult to achieve if the only option is to become yet another tenant of some large multi-tenant infrastructure.

Microsoft will quickly take over this market if they offer an easy-to-manage on-prem solution that's integrated with the company directory, as it seems they've done. Plenty of firms already have Exchange and ActiveDirectory and Skype for Business.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Daviey on Thursday November 03, 2016 @06:25PM (#12868572)
I think this is one reason teams use hipchat, because it does provide this.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by 8_hours_ago on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:52PM (#12867351)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Microsoft Team doesn't currently have a self-hosted option. I hope it's in the pipeline because my company can't use an offsite IM service. It would be nice if Microsoft added support and then Slack followed. Competition is good!
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by it33 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @05:21PM (#12868078)
Mattermost is an open source, self-hosted Slack-alternative: https://www.mattermost.org/what-slack-might-learn-from-its-o...
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by oddvar on Friday November 04, 2016 @12:52PM (#12873993)
There is also Matrix (matrix.org), an open standard for decentralized communications. Our goal is to let all apps talk to each other - including Slack, Mattermost, and Microsoft Teams!

Check it out using any Matrix-enabled app: https://matrix.to/#/#matrix:matrix.org

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by cmdrfred on Friday November 04, 2016 @01:21AM (#12870558)
Skype can be self hosted.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by irodoramatic on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:09PM (#12865841)
For enterprise companies that already use a lot of MS services, and which have tight security policies on what software can be used/licensed/installed, an MS Slack clone could be a wonderful thing for employees.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by ganset on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:06PM (#12866387)
Having worked for a company with security concerns and tightly coupled to Microsoft, Lynx fucking sucks and a MS Slack alternative would have made my short time there much more bearable.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by geofft on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:05PM (#12866960)
I think you are interpreting the rhetoric as "Slack is not innovative, therefore it is not praiseworthy."

The claim is something else entirely: "Slack is not innovative, therefore it is not immune to competition."

There isn't any value judgment with the second claim. "didn't do anything amazing" is a statement of fact, not a put down. It's not somehow morally bad to do nothing amazing! If anything, it's morally good. There's no sense wasting time building amazing technological breakthroughs when the problem space doesn't need it, and just needs someone to execute well on boring problems. (Slack is particularly good at recognizing this and just getting the job done; see also their tech stack running on PHP.)

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by JamesBarney on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:46PM (#12867781)
Stack overflow benefits from tremendous network effects while Slack does not.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by mdonahoe on Friday November 04, 2016 @05:56PM (#12876490)
Slack has some limited network effects with guest access, but they should really make inter-company collaboration easier.

The lock-in due to loss of history is a bigger reason to stick with slack though once you have it.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by acedinlowball on Friday November 04, 2016 @07:12PM (#12877006)
Sorry, but you're wrong about this. This is my opinion on the matter and I understand that not everyone will agree with me.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by exstudent2 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:22PM (#12866530)
People bash StackOverflow for their draconian moderation, not because it would be technically trivial to implement (it wouldn't, nothing at scale is).
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by JamesBarney on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:49PM (#12867813)
Stack overflow was hugely popular before their draconian moderation. And I use it less because of it. The most valuable questions I have as a developer are things like "what are they trade offs between using system.js or webpack". "How should I use flux Or redux to get the most benefit?" Or "how does the js build ecosystem work". These are much more valuable in my opinion then "I got error 4602 how do I solve it?".
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:43PM (#12867756)
I've seen both. The "draconian moderation" is also the reason for their success.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by exstudent2 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:54PM (#12867861)
That's highly debatable. I use it despite the moderation. Half the questions I get answers for are "closed, off topic".
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Friday November 04, 2016 @10:48AM (#12872965)
If it wasn't for the moderation, it'd be a swamp of terrible just like the forums of old.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by exstudent2 on Friday November 04, 2016 @02:11PM (#12874633)
Many people feel otherwise. Anyway it's way off topic to the op.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by intoverflow2 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:47PM (#12865623)
>What slack did far more than UI, was UX. Top to bottom, it's a very nice UX. It's why i love Slack.

I don't think they even do that well, it's a complete nightmare finding anything on slack beyond the last 24 hours.

What Slack did well was branding and marketing.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:57PM (#12865722)
I haven't met a single person (unless they were ~really~ non technical) that enjoyed using slack.

It never works the way I expect it to work, and very simple things that you can do within IRC takes multiple steps in Slack.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by hosh on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:52PM (#12866827)
I enjoy using Slack. There were a lot of nuances that together adds up into substantial improvements over Hipchat or IRC.

I am also a remote software engineer who have been working on distributed teams for the past 8 years. I've tried a bunch of different things to collaborate remotely, including IRC. Your mileage may vary.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:10PM (#12867003)
What downsides did you find to using IRC?

Either way each choice is just a tool and if it works for you - thanks great!

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by hosh on Thursday November 03, 2016 @07:03PM (#12868870)
Wasn't a downside to IRC so much as there are UI/UX stuff in Slack that helps a lot. These are small things that seems obvious now, but they help with communication.

I've been working on applying the theory of Kanban starting from first principle: "Make work visible." Visibility helps develop trust. Slacks helps with signaling a lot, and there are obviously a lot of thought put into the design.

Some examples:

1. URL for every message. I can paste that URL into Github PRs or Jira to reference a conversation where people talk through something.

2. Cross-device notifications and fallbacks, and other controls such as Do Not Disturb, etc. This allows me to control heads-down coding vs. when people needs help.

3. Notification integration helps. I know there are IRC bots that can do that, but how well you can just click through things depends upon the IRC client you choose. Being able to see a log of say, Github and Jira (usually in a separate channel) helps stay in the loop. The same with when adding CI/CD notifications.

4. Starring messages helps me manage time. I don't read everything people send over the chat. I certainly do NOT try replacing person-to-person contact with Slack (or IRC or HipChat). Sometimes I'll star something I want to read later (which may or may not happen).

5. URLs posted often have previews, which also helps with managing whether I go read it or not.

I'm sure these things can be done with IRC, and Hipchat probably copied over some of these ideas. Mattermost has certainly cloned the important stuff. By no means am I saying any of this seem earth-shattering innovative, but it is clear to me that Slack was designed around remote working, and it works well.

To keep things in perspective too: before Gmail, I used to run my own web server and used terminal-based apps for that. I don't do that anymore because it was easier to just dump things in Gmail and then search for things I need. I'm still keeping my tmux+emacs setup though -- maybe I'm missing out with web-based development.

So yeah, Slack is a great tool, and it works well with what I do. If you don't use it with discipline, or you have not developed much of a philosophy on how this all works together, it's not going to work well. You won't have a philosophical framework in which to curate or vet what you want in your life or attention-space.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by thesimpsons1022 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:37PM (#12866680)
i enjoy the built in gifs and emojis but thats about it
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:09PM (#12866996)
When I used it at a previous job emojis/gifs were quite fun, but after awhile I stopped using them.

I feel like they get in the way more than anything - and other platforms can still implement those just as easily.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by beachstartup on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:01PM (#12865761)
i agree, the search and history are its achilles' heel right now. i still cut and paste important stuff out of slack into a big notes text file because i know it will be a shitty experience finding it later.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by geoka9 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:07PM (#12866977)
You know you can "star" stuff in slack, right?
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by beachstartup on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:18PM (#12867077)
so what? i want to search based on keyword, not know ahead-of-time what i'm going to find important in 6 months.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by domino on Friday November 04, 2016 @01:28AM (#12870585)
Shameless plug here, but you could give us a try: https://pogo.ai , we aim to solve that problem (and more :) )
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by vehementi on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:57PM (#12865719)
Marketing yeah. They weren't the first to do the obvious "make IRC in the cloud with persistent storage and notifications/app/etc." I had been waiting for, just the first I heard of.

Do you have any other issues, just curious or is their search algorithm enough to make the Slack platform a net bad UX?

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by drumdance on Friday November 04, 2016 @09:57AM (#12872576)
I personally prefer Flowdock's UI, but they're slipping behind.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by reitanqild on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:35PM (#12865483)
> I can't think of a single feature they've done that is innovative.

This reminds me a lot of HN dismissing Dropbox on the original show HN or something:

"We have git, rsync, FTP. We can hack something like this together in an afternoon."

Except that was before Dropbox went ahead to become a huge success.

This time we are saying this after Slack has already established itself. :-]

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by fizzbatter on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:44PM (#12865578)
So what? you don't have to innovate to be a success, that's where a lot of HNers get stuck imo.

Sure, i'm not calling Slack amazing - but i very clearly said i use slack, love it, pay for it and recommend it. I used Dropbox too.

I don't think anyone here is claiming Slack isn't a massive success. Nor that the product is any less great because it's not innovative. A comment like:

> This time we are saying this after Slack has already established itself. :-]

seems to suggest "we" are somehow wrong.. but i'm not sure where. Is my above statement somehow wrong? Or are you simply linking success and innovation where as i am not?

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by reitanqild on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:00PM (#12865745)
>> This time we are saying this after Slack has already established itself. :-]

> seems to suggest "we" are somehow wrong.. but i'm not sure where.

Thanks, it was just an attempt to not talk down to anyone even if I disagree.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by reitanqild on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:30PM (#12867172)
I agreed earlier today.

Rethinking it I think they might have been really innovative, but more in sales, marketing etc than in pure technical terms.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:46PM (#12865606)
The general response in the thread was hoping that Slack would get gutted and dismissing it as trivial. Not being 'innovative' isn't a sin. Thinking there is nothing to learn from slack sounds like a mistaking to me.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by SomeStupidPoint on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:04PM (#12865788)
But MS already operated a widely used webchat, profile, and community network, before social networks were a thing. As usual, MS did a meh implementation ahead of the market, got scooped by a bunch of slick implementations, and will come back a few years later with a relatively solid enterprise offering.

MS is going to bundle LinkedIn with a Slack-clone tied to their CMS and AI chat systems, and provide an easy-to-scale-in-private-cloud platform to enterprise. Part of their Azure smart services.

That's all people mean: Slack did a pretty good job, but it's very similar to stuff MS has done before, and there's not really a secret sauce trench. So MS will probably be able to win a lot of the enterprise market.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by GFischer on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:46PM (#12867307)
Well, isn't what you're describing the Teams software that prompted Slack's letter?

Only tied to Office365, not Azure and LinkedIn.

https://products.office.com/en-US/microsoft-teams/group-chat...

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by reitanqild on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:00PM (#12865754)
This was my feeling as well.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by mercer on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:54PM (#12865689)
I have the feeling doing Dropbox right is a lot more difficult than doing Slack right. I still use Dropbox because somehow Drive and iCloud still don't work quite as nicely as Dropbox does. But I might be wrong; I've never built chat or file-sync apps.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Ntrails on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:58PM (#12865735)
It's not about what can be done, it's about prior art.

I've used xmpp chats with a couple of clients since well before slack and I'd struggle to think of a feature in slack that I hadn't used before.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by scaryclam on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:43PM (#12866741)
We're actually investigating switching over to an XMPP server and completely ditching slack. No-one in the company uses it, no-one likes using it and XMPP just seems to work.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by croon on Friday November 04, 2016 @08:11AM (#12871946)
I wasn't a pro about it, but I set up and ran our XMPP at a previous company. What I saw as a real problem was a split between clients, servers, modules over the protocol, so it definitely wasn't painless in what functionality worked between one server, modules, a client and inevitably someone choosing a different client. You might do it better than me and it ends up working great for you, or it's gotten better in the last few years since I tried it, but if my experiences are any indication I wouldn't recommend that route. YMMV.

But if you don't like Slack, I'm guessing Mattermost is out of the question as well. I'm still using IRC in a lot of places which "just works", but obviously that is missing a lot of features and fluff of newer technologies, even if some can be retrofitted in.

Please et me know what you decide and your success since it's still relevant for me in a couple of places.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by jpalomaki on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:55PM (#12866853)
Both Slack and Dropbox are simple ideas, executed extremely well. I see that for both of them the challenge is there's quite many customers who don't demand the best execution, but can settle for not-so-good-but-a-bit-cheaper alternative.

Both companies can probably make well enough money to survive and achieve growth, but maybe not such an exponential growth the investors where expecting.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by yoz-y on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:25PM (#12866002)
After having read http://www.asymco.com/2014/04/16/innoveracy-misunderstanding... I think that people often misuse the term innovation. From my understanding Slack is innovative, precisely because it is useful. Its novelty is not in features but in the delivery. Yes IRC had all the features but it is hardly something one can recommend. Slack made the long process of setting up a server, shell/bouncer, dcc a matter of a few clicks. On top of that they provide a unique client for everybody which means that everybody sees the same thing. Throw in the integrations and you have a very compelling package. The features one by one are not new or revolutionary, but they were the first to push the whole deal out.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by swasheck on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:23PM (#12865980)
"Hate" no longer means "hate." It means "disagree with another at any level."
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:35PM (#12866079)
People were saying they hope Microsoft would put Slack out of business. That's not disagreeing, that's actively disliking them.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by swasheck on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:50PM (#12867335)
But even dislike != hate.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by mercer on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:39PM (#12865528)
Plus, Microsoft can throw engineering power at integrating their 'clone' with all their other tools. While I can't seem myself buying into their ecosystem anytime soon, that's a huge advantage that will be hard for Slack to compete with.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:44PM (#12865583)
I'd imaginethe developers of the products integrating their own things into Slack would give more and better thingts than Microsoft integrating other products into their things. We'll have to see if people start shifting where they integrate.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by mercer on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:26PM (#12866010)
Good point. I'm too far away from Moft's ecosystem to be able to tell how well they can execute such integrations...
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by mamcx on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:26PM (#12866566)
Is like to say cooking is just about mix ingredients.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dingaling on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:09PM (#12866412)
> Top to bottom, it's a very nice UX. It's why i love Slack.

I wouldn't even credit them with that. 20 minutes ago I yet again pressed up-arrow to scroll up one line to see a message off the top of the page and yet again it dropped me into an editing prompt for my last message. What?

And then there's the click-click-click of jumping between channels to see the latest messages, instead of having some form of summary.

In my experience people tolerate the UI of Slack, they don't praise it.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by leesalminen on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:47PM (#12866771)
I've long thought that an aggregated screen holding all unread message (with a button to expand +/- 5 lines) was sorely missing from Slack.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Fishkins on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:36PM (#12867707)
This is a newish feature that's at least close to what you want https://get.slack.help/hc/en-us/articles/226410907-View-all-...
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Eridrus on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:35PM (#12865489)
Slack is undoubtedly better than IRC, but so is Flowdock or HipChat and the other players that existed in this space before.

Slack's innovation was getting a huge funding round, blowing it on advertising to mainstream non-tech markets and trying to build a competitive moat with 3rd party integrations that other developers are incentivized to make on their own due to Slack's large user base.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by KevanM on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:41PM (#12865554)
I only heard of Slack through people showing off their ridiculous bots on Twitter.

I think the first was the bot that told you off for using gendered pronouns.

The evangelism it has fostered has been a great promoter, however now I think if our company (non-tech) adopted it - it would be a massive distraction.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:34PM (#12867211)
I prefer IRC because I can grep the logs. Slack's search is next to useless.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:26PM (#12865383)
Adding a backlog to IRC is something that has been around almost as long as IRC.

Bots to sit in channels to passively log; bots which act to send messages to people who are presently offline, at the time at which they come online again; and so on.

Adding a log to IRC isn't particularly innovative. Slack's value is almost entirely in its user engagement, not its technology.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by jerf on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:33PM (#12865464)
As far as I know, all the pieces to make Slack have been around for a while. But nobody ever put them together properly. So the fact that all the pieces existed doesn't count for very much in the end.

Nor was it obvious that if someone put it together properly it would achieve commercial success. I was theoretically in the right place at the right time to have put together something like Slack at my job, but there was no desire to invest enough to do that and eventually the entire product was EOL'ed a couple of years before Slack was released, not just because the product itself was not doing well but the entire market segment was not doing well. Commercial IM products have not done well historically, because it was difficult to do enough better than the free stuff to get people to pay.

What Slack may demonstrate is that, indeed, there was a market there all along, it's just the activation energy was higher than almost anyone was prepared to pay.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by stock_toaster on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:19PM (#12865932)
Slack was basically just a prettier hipchat clone when it first came out.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:20PM (#12867085)
And what Slack's numerous competitors are proving is that Slack's total absence of any new or challenging technology has made it easy pickings for duplication. Slack remains competitive in the face of copy cats only because of its current user engagement. Thus, the threat from Microsoft and other behemoths who can effectively purchase users is very real.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by elcct on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:49PM (#12866229)
That's the key - make something worth more than the sum of its parts
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by luka-birsa on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:39PM (#12866707)
The reason why we started using Slack is simple. Its simpler than IRC and accessible to non techies and it's free (compared to HipChat and others from that time).

Not marketing, or features or UX - price was key for us.

I still hope Slack wins, but MS is a very serious threat. In the end its best for us, users - prices will drop, new features will be added, support will be awesome all thanks to competition.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dimino on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:11PM (#12865855)
What people are saying is that not only have the pieces to make Slack been around for awhile, but IRC has implemented those pieces successfully for 20 years.

The only "innovation" Slack provided was the UI, and that's textbook "bad startup idea", because of how easy it is for someone else to step into the space.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by jerf on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:12PM (#12866438)
"but IRC has implemented those pieces successfully for 20 years."

It did indeed... implement them as pieces. The out-of-the-box experience for an IRC network does not look like Slack.

And the UI was a non-trivial component. Personally I'm in the segment who doesn't much care and for whom IRC is a fine amount of bandwidth... but a looooot of other people, including lots of people with money, want something more.

Slack is not "just IRC". The proof is that if it was, we wouldn't be talking about Slack, we'd be talking about IRC. We aren't.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dimino on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:20PM (#12867576)
The UI was a trivial enough component that it can be replicated by a dozen competitors, to suddenly become a hugely busy space such as it is now.

Those people with money can easily be stolen out from under Slack, precisely because they didn't innovate, they simplified.

Slack is "just IRC", and the proof is that if it were more, there wouldn't be nearly as much competition in the space, with more people joining every month, it seems.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:18PM (#12867071)
We are talking about IRC. Right now. In this thread. ;)
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:36PM (#12866100)
Except, that's not true. As I pointed out with History, IRC does not do that. Even if you count hacks like bots or additional services, it doesn't do it well, easily, or as a core part of the thing that is there the second you set it up without extra effort.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dimino on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:18PM (#12867560)
I don't understand why people keep saying it's not "easy" or IRC doesn't do history "well"? ZNC or another bouncer is plenty easy to set up and configure, and you get a full history of all messages in a chat.

Slack didn't innovate, it simplified. I called it a "UI" simplification, but you can call it whatever you like. They didn't innovate on technology, and that's a dangerous place to build your startup, because someone like Microsoft can eat your lunch and there's nothing you can do about it.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:33PM (#12865457)
Bots? It's awkward. In Slack, you scroll up. No bot is going to be as simple to use and obvious as that. If you do manage to integrate it that well, you will need to set up the bot, which is a separate service, get your clients to understand the bot, etc... It's like suggesting a tin can with strings to solve a communication problem. A rough, imperfect solution.

Who gives a damn about innovative? It may have been obvious and simple, but if no one else is doing it well, and they do, sneering at it seems dumb. They made a good call, and are profiting from it.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:59PM (#12865742)
I'm sure OP was using bots as an example - IRC bouncers exist ,and if that's too technical for you then there are multiple other solutions.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:37PM (#12866103)
Sure, and none of those solutions are as good as 'scroll up' after clicking five buttons to make a slack team. By quite a way.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by donum on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:21PM (#12866519)
When I used a Bouncer, all messages that I missed just were there after logging in. I could just scroll up. Easy!
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:56PM (#12866873)
Bouncers are really "Set it and forget it"...

Pings show up - if you desperately need phone notifications there are many apps/solutions to deal with that too. (but lets be real...nobody ~really~ wants notifications outside of work)

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by ue_ on Friday November 04, 2016 @10:25AM (#12872756)
With a bouncer you literally just scroll up.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by threatofrain on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:24PM (#12865981)
I didn't read Mc_Big_G's post as negating the value of Slack, but rather the technological innovativeness of Slack, and when I look at HipChat, Kato, or any of the various competitors in that space when Slack was born, I don't see why Slack's victory was so obvious. That's why I put a little more weight on the luck theory.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:40PM (#12866130)
They provided a ton of value by bringing things together, by making everything easy and work intuatively. I guess my point is I think too many people are indeed dismissing slack as being lucky, or just pushing with heavy marketing, when I think they actually did something of value we can learn from.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by threatofrain on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:45PM (#12866196)
But what would you say about HipChat or other competitors? Why didn't HipChat win? Was there a critical feature they missed or botched?

Providing value is not the whole story. That's why I begin looking for alternative factors -- like luck and circumstance.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by blakeyrat on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:50PM (#12866803)
HipChat hasn't botched anything, but they also haven't done anything really well. HipChat is merely... ok I guess?

The thing keeping HipChat going in the face of Slack is that Slack can't be used on-premises, which is HUGE for an extremely large percentage of business.

HipChat hasn't improved as fast as Slack because they haven't needed to-- since no HIPAA-compliant business (to give just one example) can use Slack at all, the two products don't really compete with each other currently.

That doesn't apply to this new Microsoft solution, which will probably kill-off HipChat long before it kills off Slack. Unless Atlassian really gets their butt moving and starts improving their product.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Fishkins on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:35PM (#12867697)
I don't know about the overall reason, but in my personal experience Slack just worked way better. My team used Hipchat for a while a few years ago. We found it to be very buggy. I would frequently send messages, but the recipient would never get any indication I'd sent it. The same thing happened for my incoming messages. Technically the message would be there if I looked though all my chats and checked for messages I hadn't seen yet, but there were no notifications or indications they were new.

Even when the worked, Hipchat notifications weren't configurable a the granularity I wanted.

Slack also is prettier and feels more cohesive to me, but that's a secondary concern.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by yarou on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:17PM (#12866473)
Ultimately, the deal breaker for me is that Slack is not on-prem. Microsoft's solution will be, and that will be the true end for Slack.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by BoorishBears on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:17PM (#12866475)
Marketing
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by quanticle on Friday November 04, 2016 @12:18AM (#12870347)
>No, Slack isn't a world away from IRC or email - but it's enough better that people want to use it, that's good.

Move Slack into IRC's position, and Microsoft Teams into Slack's position, and you can see what Microsoft is trying to do. The problem with Slack is that right now, they're caught in the middle. They're not a consumer-facing company (at least, their profit model isn't consumer-facing), but, at the same time, they haven't invested in the boring schlep work (auditing, compliance, etc.) to make their product truly competitive to large enterprises. So they're stuck in this small-to-medium business space, while Microsoft is trying to vault ahead of them to capture the large enterprises.

From what I've seen, this is pretty much Microsoft's cloud strategy in a nutshell: take other companies' products, do the boring schlep work to add auditing, compliance, Active Directory Integration, etc. and then sell it to enterprises as a cloud service. This appears to be Azure's strategy against AWS, Office 365's strategy against Google Docs, Visual Studio Team Services' strategy against Github, and now, Microsoft Teams' strategy against Slack. It's a brilliant strategy that plays to Microsoft's strengths - knowing the needs of enterprise customers - while relying on the broader market to fill in for its weaknesses in discovering new products and doing UI design.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by geofft on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:26PM (#12865376)
Email does the stored-history thing. So does every other mobile IM app I have (the built-in SMS app, Google Hangouts, BBM, etc.).

Furthermore, in the IRC world that's not uncommon either; Quasseldroid does this. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.iskrembile...

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:39PM (#12865525)
Email sucks for real-time communcation. Most of the other IM applications you list suck for multi-person communication. Quassel looks good, but clearly harder to set up than Slack.

People always point at everything and go 'this stuff existed!' - even if all Slack did was pull everything together into a single cohesive environment, that's useful to people, it provides value. I'm shocked people are shocked by that idea.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by blakeyrat on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:54PM (#12866850)
It's from the same set of people who don't understand why Microsoft's Active Directory is more popular than the cluster of hard-to-configured, barely-related Linux utilities needed to reproduce some of its functions on a Linux server.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by geofft on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:58PM (#12865732)
It absolutely provides value! But I don't think the commenter above is claiming that it doesn't provide value. They're claiming it's not innovative.

Some of the most important work in the tech industry is highly valuable and not one bit innovative. CRUD apps that bridge data from two different parts of an organization are amazingly valuable and amazingly important, but have no innovation. There's nothing wrong with that CRUD app—but there's nothing making that app better from another CRUD app that also bridges those two departments.

None of this thread is saying that Slack is bad. It's not criticizing Slack. It's not saying people are wrong to use it. It's just saying that people can jump ship very easily because there's nothing innovative.

Slack is great. I use it daily and love it. But the things I like about it aren't tied to Slack the company in any way, and it would be easy for me to love Microsoft Teams (or some hypothetical open-source, competent-at-UX, mobile-enabled version of IRC) every bit as much. Slack doesn't seem to realize that.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:45PM (#12866191)
Yeah, except people were saying they were hoping Microsoft would kill Slack, as though it's some cardinal sin to not be innovative. (And I contest that, Slack definitely bought things together that other people didn't. It's obvious in hindsight, but so was Dropbox, for example).
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by geofft on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:00PM (#12866331)
I don't see those people in this thread? Certainly I don't see 'Mc_Big_G or myself saying that (and 'Mc_Big_G says basically the opposite). Would it help if I also said I don't hope Microsoft will kill Slack?

More precisely, I hope that if Microsoft builds a vastly better product, that they kill Slack, and if Slack builds a vastly better product, that they kill Teams, and if someone else builds a vastly better product (maybe Ryver stops arguing on Twitter and focuses on product? maybe everyone realizes that Zulip has been awesome all along? maybe Mattermost builds great mobile apps?), they kill both Slack and Teams. And I hope Slack does not get complacent about the product they have built and how hard it is to build a vastly better one, because I am currently using Slack and invested in it. I hope this because competition is a good thing. Is that wrong?

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by wahern on Thursday November 03, 2016 @05:11PM (#12867987)
XMPP/Jabber has always supported offline message storage.

I don't hate Slack; heck, I've never even used it. But like _many_ people I'm disappointed that we still don't have a non-proprietary, federated IM system. That leaves most of us ambivalent, and some of us bitter.

IRC is still around, but IRC isn't a substitute for IM. IRC can't be truly federated because there's no global directory or routing the way there is for SMS or XMPP.

XMPP is still around. I can even chat with a few GTalk stragglers, and quite a few tech-savvy people still run their own XMPP servers. But it seems to be on the decline. For a brief period it was gaining corporate momentum, but that stopped years ago.

My company still uses XMPP for corporate IM. Fortunately, nobody can agree whether to move to IRC, HipChat, or Slack. So for now I can actually instant message with co-workers from my personal XMPP server/account. That was actually useful when I was on contract and didn't have (or want to deal with) juggling and logging onto corporate accounts.

Somebody else suggested Slack was like the iPhone, in that it offered features and usability previously unimagined. I don't think so. The iPhone wouldn't have gotten anywhere if it wasn't a _phone_. It would have just been a fancy minicomputer if it didn't have the built-in capability to interoperate with any other phone, and participate in the global federated telephone and SMS network.

For all of Slacks features, they pale in comparison to what _could_ be. They could still create a better IM client, with better searching, indexing, etc, etc. But if it supported global federation a la XMPP, the sky would be the limit. Instead of the Internet people are simply excited about an upgraded AOL experience.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Veratyr on Thursday November 03, 2016 @07:06PM (#12868890)
Just because you didn't mention it, Matrix https://matrix.org/ is another option. It supports federation, services (like IRC bridges), encryption, push notifications, offline storage and has some really nice clients for Android and iOS.

I found it really cool that I could spend ~half an hour setting it up on my own server then just pop in on chats on another server.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by empath75 on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:32PM (#12866058)
I work at the company that popularized internet messaging in the 90s. We used our own product exclusively for interoffice communication, until slack came out, and slack totally replaced it within the course of a couple of months, totally organically. Literally nobody at the company uses our own product any more.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by beamatronic on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:12PM (#12866439)
Yahoo Messenger, right?
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by jlgaddis on Thursday November 03, 2016 @07:46PM (#12869171)
Personally, my money would would be on AOL (by a large margin), followed closely by ICQ. MSN Messenger and Yahoo Messenger, although relatively popular, were latecomers.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by lokedhs on Thursday November 03, 2016 @09:37PM (#12869708)
It's not zero effort, but it's low effort. Implementing the important features of Slack (specifically the ones you mention) is not hard. I know that because me and one other person did that as a weekend project over a few months[1]. It's not because we're the most amazing developers in the world, but

(Sure, not as poslished but that would only take one more designer to fix.)

What I'm saying here is that GP is correct, and you are significantly overestimating the value of what Slack provides. They have the mindshare right now, but that's really all. They don't even the benefits a company like Facebook has, since a Slack competitor is still useful if a small number of people use it, as opposed to social media companies who are not useful at all unless they have a large userbase.

[1] https://github.com/cicakhq/potato

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by serge2k on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:17PM (#12866482)
> 'Adding a pretty UI' isn't a zero-effort or skill thing.

It's not a huge barrier to entry though.

I think the hate comes from the ridiculous letter.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by EpicEng on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:37PM (#12866672)
MS has already added enough value for us to switch over. I work in life sciences and the fact that they are HIPAA compliant makes this a no trainer for us.

I don't think people are hating on slack here, it's just that what they do isn't nearly as hard to u.plement as they seem to think it is, so a letter like this just comes off as pompous.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by forgetsusername on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:37PM (#12867226)
>Having your messages stored while you are offline is hugely valuable.

Sure. Nice feature. hardly game-changing or innovative.

Our company is just getting on the Slack train. I'm honestly underwhelmed with the experience. I suppose I expected a lot given the hype and valuation. My main gripe is the lack of UI customization.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by carterehsmith on Thursday November 03, 2016 @09:48PM (#12869754)
> Having your messages stored while you are offline is hugely valuable. If I have been out of signal range on a train, I want to be able to look at history on my phone once I'm back in range of a cell tower.

Perhaps you should also try using email. Or SMS. They can do that.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by flamedoge on Friday November 04, 2016 @03:08AM (#12870851)
Amazing!
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by NDizzle on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:32PM (#12865447)
I've had a persistent to IRC backlog since 1998. This is a simple task for anyone who reads a site that is called "hacker news".
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:34PM (#12865471)
Yes, but are those the only people using Slack? Most of us communicate with people for whom that's non-trivial. Even if it is, it's effort to set up, has to run somewhere, and it doesn't integrate well. It's a crappy solution to the problem, when Slack's is 'scroll up'.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by NDizzle on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:38PM (#12865520)
In my experiences using Slack, the people who aren't the normal IRC crowd (take that as you will, heh) fall out of common use after a short period of time. You're left with roughly the IRC crowd.

That may be dependent on team dynamics.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:41PM (#12866157)
Obviously, small sample size, but that's not my experience at all. I've used Slack in two or three different environments for 1y+, and people didn't seem to drop it.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by fdgdasfadsf on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:23PM (#12866537)
Depends upon age. Anyone in the UK under 30-35 grew up using MSN messenger so even the least technical of non-technical people are happy using something that as far as they can see is basically the same as MSN.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by praneshp on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:33PM (#12865462)
I had a persistent IRC backlog pre-Slack too. It's less difficult to get your colleagues that dont read "hacker news" to do it.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by wang_li on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:03PM (#12865781)
You've just described iMessage.