News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:26PM (#12865383)
Adding a backlog to IRC is something that has been around almost as long as IRC.

Bots to sit in channels to passively log; bots which act to send messages to people who are presently offline, at the time at which they come online again; and so on.

Adding a log to IRC isn't particularly innovative. Slack's value is almost entirely in its user engagement, not its technology.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by jerf on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:33PM (#12865464)
As far as I know, all the pieces to make Slack have been around for a while. But nobody ever put them together properly. So the fact that all the pieces existed doesn't count for very much in the end.

Nor was it obvious that if someone put it together properly it would achieve commercial success. I was theoretically in the right place at the right time to have put together something like Slack at my job, but there was no desire to invest enough to do that and eventually the entire product was EOL'ed a couple of years before Slack was released, not just because the product itself was not doing well but the entire market segment was not doing well. Commercial IM products have not done well historically, because it was difficult to do enough better than the free stuff to get people to pay.

What Slack may demonstrate is that, indeed, there was a market there all along, it's just the activation energy was higher than almost anyone was prepared to pay.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by stock_toaster on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:19PM (#12865932)
Slack was basically just a prettier hipchat clone when it first came out.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:20PM (#12867085)
And what Slack's numerous competitors are proving is that Slack's total absence of any new or challenging technology has made it easy pickings for duplication. Slack remains competitive in the face of copy cats only because of its current user engagement. Thus, the threat from Microsoft and other behemoths who can effectively purchase users is very real.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by elcct on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:49PM (#12866229)
That's the key - make something worth more than the sum of its parts
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by luka-birsa on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:39PM (#12866707)
The reason why we started using Slack is simple. Its simpler than IRC and accessible to non techies and it's free (compared to HipChat and others from that time).

Not marketing, or features or UX - price was key for us.

I still hope Slack wins, but MS is a very serious threat. In the end its best for us, users - prices will drop, new features will be added, support will be awesome all thanks to competition.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dimino on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:11PM (#12865855)
What people are saying is that not only have the pieces to make Slack been around for awhile, but IRC has implemented those pieces successfully for 20 years.

The only "innovation" Slack provided was the UI, and that's textbook "bad startup idea", because of how easy it is for someone else to step into the space.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by jerf on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:12PM (#12866438)
"but IRC has implemented those pieces successfully for 20 years."

It did indeed... implement them as pieces. The out-of-the-box experience for an IRC network does not look like Slack.

And the UI was a non-trivial component. Personally I'm in the segment who doesn't much care and for whom IRC is a fine amount of bandwidth... but a looooot of other people, including lots of people with money, want something more.

Slack is not "just IRC". The proof is that if it was, we wouldn't be talking about Slack, we'd be talking about IRC. We aren't.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dimino on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:20PM (#12867576)
The UI was a trivial enough component that it can be replicated by a dozen competitors, to suddenly become a hugely busy space such as it is now.

Those people with money can easily be stolen out from under Slack, precisely because they didn't innovate, they simplified.

Slack is "just IRC", and the proof is that if it were more, there wouldn't be nearly as much competition in the space, with more people joining every month, it seems.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dleslie on Thursday November 03, 2016 @03:18PM (#12867071)
We are talking about IRC. Right now. In this thread. ;)
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:36PM (#12866100)
Except, that's not true. As I pointed out with History, IRC does not do that. Even if you count hacks like bots or additional services, it doesn't do it well, easily, or as a core part of the thing that is there the second you set it up without extra effort.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by dimino on Thursday November 03, 2016 @04:18PM (#12867560)
I don't understand why people keep saying it's not "easy" or IRC doesn't do history "well"? ZNC or another bouncer is plenty easy to set up and configure, and you get a full history of all messages in a chat.

Slack didn't innovate, it simplified. I called it a "UI" simplification, but you can call it whatever you like. They didn't innovate on technology, and that's a dangerous place to build your startup, because someone like Microsoft can eat your lunch and there's nothing you can do about it.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:33PM (#12865457)
Bots? It's awkward. In Slack, you scroll up. No bot is going to be as simple to use and obvious as that. If you do manage to integrate it that well, you will need to set up the bot, which is a separate service, get your clients to understand the bot, etc... It's like suggesting a tin can with strings to solve a communication problem. A rough, imperfect solution.

Who gives a damn about innovative? It may have been obvious and simple, but if no one else is doing it well, and they do, sneering at it seems dumb. They made a good call, and are profiting from it.

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:59PM (#12865742)
I'm sure OP was using bots as an example - IRC bouncers exist ,and if that's too technical for you then there are multiple other solutions.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by Latty on Thursday November 03, 2016 @01:37PM (#12866103)
Sure, and none of those solutions are as good as 'scroll up' after clicking five buttons to make a slack team. By quite a way.
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by donum on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:21PM (#12866519)
When I used a Bouncer, all messages that I missed just were there after logging in. I could just scroll up. Easy!
Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by kzisme on Thursday November 03, 2016 @02:56PM (#12866873)
Bouncers are really "Set it and forget it"...

Pings show up - if you desperately need phone notifications there are many apps/solutions to deal with that too. (but lets be real...nobody ~really~ wants notifications outside of work)

Re:Slack may regret its letter to Microsoft by ue_ on Friday November 04, 2016 @10:25AM (#12872756)
With a bouncer you literally just scroll up.