News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by krylon on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:37PM (#12761886)
Black Mirror is really, really, really good. The writing, the cast, it is just incredible.

But it is also incredibly depressing. Maybe depressing is the wrong word. Emotionally exhausting, you might say. Well worth watching once, but I recently could not bring myself to re-watch it because it so dark. And not even dark humor, which I like, just dark. Maybe in the spring, I'll come around...

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by jacquesm on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:44PM (#12761967)
What makes it so good is the fact that it is so believable. I wished I could come up with a 'white mirror' alternative where all our tech is used for good but it wouldn't be nearly as believable. Human nature being what it is you'd hope the future isn't even darker than what black mirror shows, it easily could be.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by drewrv on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:07PM (#12762277)
Star Trek TNG is as close to 'white mirror' as we'll ever get. A universe where human nature advances alongside technology. It's obviously way more far fetched and the show hasn't aged well though.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by jbpetersen on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:16PM (#12763060)
That's assuming we're headed towards being The Federation and not The Borg.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by trhway on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:18PM (#12764289)
>towards being The Federation and not The Borg.

what is wrong with the Borg? I mean emotionally we all dislike it, yes. Yet speaking objectively, the Borg is the naturally highest state of developed life we can conceive off. Atoms makes molecules like proteins, lipids, etc., the molecules make cells, cells make organisms, organisms make society... The same cycles of assembly/integration and specialization, basically the same 2nd law driving life at different scales. Looking at the level of integration and specialization our society has so far reached i'd say it is just the level of primitive multi-cell organisms. The Borg is the natural state of society when the level of integration and specialization increases, and increasing of that level is just the 2nd law gradient in application to the live systems. Resisting it is just like insisting on staying "free" single cells instead of combining into organisms. The organisms would see the stars, the cells - no.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by Namrog84 on Friday October 21, 2016 @06:56PM (#12765625)
What's interesting is that throughout the different startreks. They touch on disconnected borg greatly depressed and missing the collective. There is less fear and more collaboration in the borg. And while individuality is reduced. There are still subtle differences between individuals and smaller groups. Though some accept and desire more individuality. And yet here we are today with so much interconnectedness and how lonely and disjoint so many people are. I definitely have things I'm embarrassed about but if there was an optional to join/leave collective I think it'd be neat/great.

We all only get to experience our single life. But to have opportunity to have memories and experience many more just sounds enticing to me. Borg isn't mindless. It is a collective where ones arguments don't need to be debated because you can reach better consensus because you can fully experience and understand the counterpoint and why views differ. We are all blind to our own anecdotal experiences.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by trhway on Friday October 21, 2016 @07:29PM (#12765813)
> And while individuality is reduced. There are still subtle differences between individuals and smaller groups.

Exactly. General symmetry breakup process guarantees that uniformity in highly interconnected environment wouldn't be a stable state, ie. it means the necessary emergence of non-uniformity, basically individuality, at different scales - personal, group/team, cube, ... It is just that such individuality would look different as it will be driven by emerging non-uniformity instead of just physical barriers of our skulls.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by M_Grey on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:03PM (#12764791)
We're heading toward the same thing every species before us has; death and extinction. We're just accelerating the process, and have the unique ability to anticipate it. Nothing has shown an ability to avert the inevitable however.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by oldmanjay on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:12PM (#12763620)
Given that humanity's track seems to be toward ever greater diversity, it's hard to imagine we'd become a one-dimensional archetype species.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by 794CD01 on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:36PM (#12763875)
In what was is human diversity increasing? Broadcast television has been causing the decline of regional accents and increasing cultural homogenization for decades. Many obscure languages are dying out in favor of consolidation at the regional or national level.

In the past, humans were naturally diverse simply because there were so many distinct communities that hardly ever interacted with each other. Nowadays you might be exposed to many times more diversity than the average medieval peasant ever was but there's nothing contradictory about that happening as the total amount of diversity in the world continues to decrease.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by oldmanjay on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:32PM (#12764451)
You'll have a hard time convincing me that a world with several orders of magnitude more humans is somehow less diverse than the times with fewer humans unless you somehow remove the ability to process arithmetic from my brain.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by bbctol on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:44PM (#12764563)
Wait, how does more humans = more diversity? I would think any abstract measure of diversity would be based on average differences, or standard deviations away from the mean. Obviously, the absolute extremes are greater with more people, but it seems entirely logical to say diversity has decreased as the number of people increase.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by 794CD01 on Monday October 24, 2016 @09:38AM (#12778620)
Easy. The more populated world is the one that has a global telecommunications network, whose homogenizing influence far outweighs higher-order effects like population.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by bbctol on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:07PM (#12764167)
Hardly. Increasing connection is shifting us closer to a single world-culture every day, which has advantages and disadvantages. All the world's most powerful people wear Western-style suits and speak English.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by raz32dust on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:23PM (#12764355)
This was my initial thought as well. But on further thought, it doesn't seem to be true. I think, with technology and inter-connectivity, we are getting exposed to diverse points of view more than ever before. It might eventually lead to one culture, but then that would be because we all learned from all the options and settled on the best combination.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by atondwal on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:54PM (#12765222)
> It might eventually lead to one culture, but then that would be because we all learned from all the options and settled on the best combination.

Isn't that the whole point of the Borg?

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by bbctol on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:49PM (#12764626)
Oh, each human being is definitely exposed to more diversity, but that doesn't mean the world is getting more diverse. Now, I can be English and interact with people who are French, German, American, Chinese and so on; previously, I could have spent my whole life only interacting with Anglo-Saxons, but not know about the Bretons, Picts, Gaels, Geats, Swedes, Goths, Navajo, Hopi, Anasazi and so on nearby and around the world.

Perhaps we'll settle on one culture as we choose the best one. I more imagine we'll end up with one culture in an endless echo chamber, forever unable to sense our own biases.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by jacquesm on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:09PM (#12762307)
I don't find Star Trek believable at all, starting with the 'Warp Drive'. As soon as you add a device like that to a plot it becomes impossible to see it as a possible future.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by paublyrne on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:34PM (#12762596)
I don't think it was supposed to be believable. It's a utopian society, reflecting the time in which it was conceived. The idea that society would be become more liberal, more socialistic, more tolerant by having greater access to information and not wanting for material goods is the more interesting one. We will be able to see if that's true over the next hundred years.

The Warp Drive is just a plot device, so that the humans can interact species from other, distant worlds.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by throwanem on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:14PM (#12763644)
> I don't think it was supposed to be believable.

Roddenberry surely intended it to be. It was the show he'd wanted to make all along, or a great deal closer to it than the original, in any case; since his death and especially since the show wrapped, many early screenwriters have described, in various fora, the extent to which he'd try to enforce the logical consequences of his political philosophy, such as the disappearance of workplace interpersonal conflict, a libertine attitude toward sexual activity, and such enduring peace both internal and external as to render unnecessary the maintenance of a military organization. After Roddenberry's ill health made it impossible for him to exert creative control, and especially after his death in 1991, TNG-era Trek evolved toward a more plausible portayal of its characters and societies.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by monocasa on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:27PM (#12762507)
I mean... NASA has a team that works on how to warp spacetime in order to provide apparent propulsion.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by TheGrimDerp1 on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:15PM (#12763049)
http://www.universetoday.com/130649/nasas-em-drive-passes-pe...

Not terribly far fetched, just need more pylons.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by tedunangst on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:19PM (#12763100)
You can reimagine most episodes without it. They're not visiting different planets in a spaceship, just different cities connected by a monorail. Er, hyperloop.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by jagermo on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:47PM (#12763386)
Or use wormhole technology to connect planets via a hyperloop like in "Pandoras Star". Interesting read how humanity would conquer other systems if space travel was irrelevant.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by LeoPanthera on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:11PM (#12764862)
This is basically the plot of Stargate SG-1.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by jagermo on Saturday October 22, 2016 @02:42AM (#12767550)
Less ancient aliens, more political backstabbing.

And SG1 had that horrible starship spinoff

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by mjevans on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:33PM (#12763240)
More accurately, making flying air-carrier visits to different parts of Earth.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by rimantas on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:05PM (#12762259)
And the tech is also very believable. Not overdone, nothing gimmicky, feels very real.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by haberman on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:49PM (#12763999)
I love the show, but I find it unbelievable in the same way I find 1984 unbelievable. Both serve as brilliant reminders of what humanity could become if we succumbed to our darkest nature. But just by existing, they serve as warning signs of what we must not let happen.

I don't want to give away any spoilers since the twist is so brilliant, but I find "White Bear" particularly unbelievable. That episode rocked me to my core, but I also don't think it would actually happen.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by erikpukinskis on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:26PM (#12765009)
> I wished I could come up with a 'white mirror' alternative where all our tech is used for good but it wouldn't be nearly as believable.

Why? Imagine:

Everyone on Earth, if they have a problem, can be connected to a handful of people who already had that problem and offer friendly advice free of charge. Where that advice is tied to purchases or revenues, the network of people facilitating this experience will take a cut.

If you want to do something, say, plant some tomatoes, you can ask an AI how to do it in a way that has a high probability of success. If you are willing to follow a set of specified terms (specific production standards, etc), the AI will offer you financing and a guaranteed buyer for the product. Extend this to every form of production. Pre-financed contractors are available to take over processes you'd rather not do, or to mentor you in processes you want to learn.

Imagine every neighborhood, every culture, every regional cuisine, every micro-ecology, every species and family all has a hive of autonomous micro-corporations surrounding it, helping keep those cultures alive, keeping participants solvent and supporting its economy. Imagine people who are sick of the vanilla-ifying and globalization of culture have an alternative supported by a federation of tiny businesses powered by decentralized software... businesses that never could have existed in the "Minimum 10 Head Count Million Dollar Market Cap" business development physics of today, but are trivially financed by autonomous HR AIs with micropayment accounts.

Right now the systems we have to do these two things are imperfect, but I believe this is the future the internet/open source/open culture/non-profit/DIY/decentralization/blockchain crowd is driving toward. I welcome anyone who thinks these three goals are impossible. But imagine that we can get there. What would we do with such technologies? I think the ramifications are fascinating.

What if there are 400 million forest rangers roving the planet relocating endangered species to nearby biomes where they can survive for a few more decades?

What if the stories of the poor and the out-of-touch-with-production-culture can be told and shared, instead of being locked out of the media financing landscape?

What if the people whose home cooking you love to eat could just cook all day and live off the money?

What if you could get paid to take care of any sick person you wanted, because they're worth more to the economy healthy?

To me, there are so many beautiful uses of technology that I am certain we will get to. Black Mirror is spot-on in its worries. But I'm chock full of equivalent hopes.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by TeMPOraL on Friday October 21, 2016 @06:23PM (#12765434)
It's so, so easy to destroy the dream though. Consider the "what if AI" questions you raised, and read this very short story:

http://squid314.livejournal.com/332946.html

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by erikpukinskis on Friday October 21, 2016 @08:24PM (#12766160)
I described a couple of AIs that do a couple of very specific things well. They probably won't even be able to understand each other. An AI that "is never wrong" is complete science fiction.

General AI is a fascinating thing to imagine, and great fodder for fiction, but it has no basis in science.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by bartwe on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:28PM (#12764402)
The movie 'Her' comes to mind.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by eli_gottlieb on Friday October 21, 2016 @08:16PM (#12766121)
I think that just means you should get out more. Human nature and horror literature have little resemblance to each-other.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by CPLX on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:45PM (#12761982)
The word that seems most appropriate to me is cynical. The worldview of the show is essentially the exact counter to the tech/entrepreneurship community's unique strain of optimism.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by untog on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:07PM (#12762967)
> The worldview of the show is essentially the exact counter to the tech/entrepreneurship community's unique strain of optimism

I think it's the inevitable outcome of tech/entrepreneurship's naivety. Facebook and Google both came from this "unique strain of optimism" and they've come to represent much of what Black Mirror discusses.

Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by wldcordeiro on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:43PM (#12761954)
I was talking to my SO about this, it's an incredible show but unlike so many other shows that you can binge watch, it just isn't one of those. You need to take time off from it to process it because it's so heavy and dark.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by mikeleeorg on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:49PM (#12763406)
I really appreciate shows that don't encourage binge watching. Now, I enjoy binge watching as much as the next binge watcher, but since Black Mirror has a definitive ending after each episode, it's that much easier for me to turn off my laptop and go do something else - which usually is talking about the episode I just watched...
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by dexterdog on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:24PM (#12762476)
You also can't binge watch a quality show like this because it really wrecks the experience.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by wldcordeiro on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:47PM (#12763379)
Totally agree, aside from the sheer depressive feeling you get from watching an episode they're so high quality that I feel like you're not going to get as good of an experience binge watching it. But I'm far from a binge watcher, my brother is one and my SO to some extent but I can't watch a 45min-1hr long episode and then want to immediately start another.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by throwanem on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:16PM (#12763676)
I'd be curious to know how you found Stranger Things, if you've seen it. As a rule I don't binge-watch either, but after watching the first episode of that show, I found myself quite strongly compelled to keep watching until it was done. Having previously had such experiences only with novels, and quite few even of those, I found it very odd that a TV show could manage to produce the same effect.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by wldcordeiro on Friday October 21, 2016 @05:17PM (#12764911)
Found the first episode really awesome, still haven't watched the second and it's been more than a month. I'm admittedly behind on the times but I've been watching The Sopranos (maybe 1-2 episodes a week) and have made my way to the 4th season now. Stranger Things is on my list of shows to watch though because there's a number of things I really liked about that first episode!
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by dexterdog on Saturday October 22, 2016 @11:52AM (#12769158)
That's a bingeable show because it hooks you with cliffhangers. I don't consider it a great show by any stretch like I do Black Mirror so binging is fine. I watched 3 or 4 episodes and put it down. I'll finish it at some point.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by throwanem on Sunday October 23, 2016 @10:40AM (#12773750)
True. I've also been a huge fan of pre-van Stephen King, and the show is so completely pitch-perfect in that regard as to make it uniquely bingeable for me.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by cm3 on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:11PM (#12762322)
I wasn't too affected by the previous seasons and haven't watched Season 3 yet (except episode 00 pre-netflix with Mr Mad Men), but if you're up for it and really want to feel emotionally exhausted after a motion picture, I can recommend Denis Villeneuve's Incendies (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1255953/). If Lost in Translation leaves you disillusioned, then Incendies will be a punch to the stomach you feel for another day. It's one of those rare movies you appreciate and regret watching at the same time. A longer running movie with similar themes (I mean mini series) is the UK production The Honourable Woman, but it doesn't leave you as emotionally affected, so I wouldn't recommend it as a must watch.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by krylon on Friday October 21, 2016 @04:53PM (#12764661)
Thanks for the suggestion! I have put Incendies on my to-watch list, with a caveat. I'll probably watch it in the spring or summer, when I bounce back from hard emotional experiences more easily.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by walterbell on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:56PM (#12762143)
It postulates threats without hints of solutions, e.g. few happy endings, valiant resistance movements, defections by oppressors, deus ex machina resolutions. TV Tropes probably has a name for this genre of storytelling.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by Jordrok on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:44PM (#12763356)
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by walterbell on Friday October 21, 2016 @03:09PM (#12763607)
Thank you!
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by Jtsummers on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:25PM (#12762482)
It's very similar to Outer Limits, perhaps a bit more the 90s incarnation than the original.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by pmiller2 on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:49PM (#12762785)
I've described it as "Clockwork Orange meets the Twilight Zone, with a technological spin."
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by zwily on Friday October 21, 2016 @02:47PM (#12763377)
S3E1 has the happiest ending so far... And it's not all that happy. :)
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by ghaff on Friday October 21, 2016 @12:49PM (#12762029)
Yes! It's definitely one of those shows that I don't just casually flip on. I really have to be in the right mood to sit down and watch an episode.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by gdubs on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:46PM (#12762731)
Agreed -- so troubling. I actually felt sick to my stomach just from watching the new trailer. It's a really well done show, but so, so dark.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by draw_down on Saturday October 22, 2016 @01:26AM (#12767348)
I'm a depressive type and can't bring myself to watch it, for basically the same reason I don't look when I drive past a car crash. Sometimes people give me guff for it too-- "but it's so good!!" I think I'll live if I don't see one tv show. Even a good one. I'm negative enough about the state of the world and its future as is.
Re:'Black Mirror' Is Back, Reflecting Our Technological Fears by gordon_freeman on Friday October 21, 2016 @10:29PM (#12766741)
I had exactly same experience watching 'Mr. Robot'. Can't even say it's dark humor.. It's just dark. Too dark for me.