News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by RankingMember on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:12AM (#12692447)
It never made sense to me why you'd want to have a built-in GPS these days when modular devices are available that are A. generally better-designed and B. replaceable. People buying used cars in the coming years will be stuck with these big-screened dinosaurs in their dash that are essentially wasted space.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by icefox on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:05AM (#12692909)
The navigation system that came with my 2004 Infiniti performs better than almost any systems I have used. It is well integrated with the car, it starts in seconds, there are physical buttons for the most common operations, it always plans a route in a few seconds at most. The screen space is used well so I can see what I need with just a glance. The company that built it clearly thought through what they were building and built a product that is solid and scores very high on usability.

Integrated navigation systems can provide more value than what a phone can. The obvious point is that the screen can be bigger, but more valuable is integrated with the car audio to turn down music when giving directions. When driving in tunnels and there is no GPS because it can talk to the car it knows the speed and can provide better estimations. And having permanent buttons right on your dash that you can hit without taking your eyes off the road is something that no phone will have. These are the type of features that a integrated navigation system should absolutely nail.

The navigation in my 13 year old car might be a dinosaurs, but in the world of car software what matters more than age is usability.

Now on the flip side I have used various navigation systems that are almost the exact opposite and are always a pain to use. If that is all you have ever experienced it is entirely understandable that you might think that this years system is a dinosaur. Having recently car shopped I was saddened at the state of many of the systems I tried. They probably have 10X as much computing power, but they were slower and more difficult to use. I could easily see how someone who bought one of these thinking how next years model would be better simply because it would be faster from the faster computer when it is clear that it was lazy coding and a failure to prioritize usability.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by runako on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:36AM (#12693212)
> integrated with the car audio to turn down music when giving directions

This is also the case using e.g. Waze via Bluetooth connection to the car.

If you live in a place where new roads are built with any frequency, car GPS's become quickly obsolete.

I also find that a car GPS often requires you to use your smartphone anyway, to look up the address of your destination.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by mikey_p on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @07:29PM (#12697219)
That's exactly how I felt about our old Volvo. We bought it used and didn't even know it had nav until I accidentally hit the the buttons on the back of the steering wheel during our test drive. It was a disc based system, but pretty fast. The discs were 10 years old and some points of interest were out of date, but it was surprisingly good for being that old. If there was a missing waypoint or destination, we would just enter the street address in and be good to go.

The interface was what I loved though. The screen popped up out of the dash* which meant that it was super easy to see without looking down at the center console, and it didn't replace our radio or other screens with the nav, the screen was nav only.

The controls were cursor based (not pointer, but just menu selection) so the buttons were on the back of the steering wheel, so you didn't even have to take your hands off the wheel to run it. All it needed was a 4-way pad and an enter and back button. There was an IR wireless remote that the passenger could use.

One of my favorite features was that it easily supported multiple waypoints, search along route, and it stored routes even when you turned the car off. Taking a multi-day road trip? No problem!

* How the motorized screen still worked on a 10 year old volvo is probably a small miracle considering what didn't work on that car.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by j45 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:14AM (#12692994)
I have had the same experience with my car. Car manufacturers are far better at the car/dash experience than phones, however the phones have been catching up. Apps like Waze are hard to ignore. What would be ideal is a high quality integration between the two worlds, or at least the ability to use the phone's touchscreen as an extended mirroring display of one's phone if you choose as a universal standard.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by CWuestefeld on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:02PM (#12694032)
You would think so...

In my '13 Hyundai, the navigation UX is pretty good, but I swear that the entertainment part of it was written by a summer intern.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by masklinn on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:26PM (#12695768)
Ditto, though I wouldn't call most of the nav systems I've used "pretty good".
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by j45 on Thursday October 13, 2016 @12:57PM (#12702184)
I also have an Infiniti, and have suffered through others. Relatively speaking it is pretty decent and still usabale. Have you tried it out?
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by izacus on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:13PM (#12696832)
Well, Android Auto is exactly that and Google announced Waze support in this years IO.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by j45 on Thursday October 13, 2016 @12:58PM (#12702192)
I'd like to see a car have both Apple car and Android Auto. My point was more around the universal ability to extend either to your screen and not have to have to pick a particular car and particular phone to work together.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by coldpie on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:01AM (#12692860)
Yeah, it's pretty sad. I was ready to buy a brand-new Subaru a couple years ago, but they mandated the shitty touch screen in the dash on all new models. Ended up with a used Mazda3. I was very interested in the new ND Miata, but they mandate the dumb LCD screen in the middle of the dash. Nope, not doing that. Seems early 2010s are the last of the good, pre-technology cars. Hopefully the self driving ones come soon before those models are worn out.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by joezydeco on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:30AM (#12693158)
The GPS navigation feature on the new Mazda Connect systems is a $400 SD card that plugs into the dash. That's it.

For $400 I'll stick with my phone. If only Mazda got CarPlay working on their dashboards as they've been promising for two years now.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by coldpie on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @11:55AM (#12693968)
Or you know, just use the physical HVAC and radio controls that have worked just fine for forty years.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by joezydeco on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:27PM (#12694260)
In its defense, the Mazda Connect system is pretty nice. It's solely focused on entertainment, navigation, and some secondary car management functions (maintenance intervals, explanation of trouble lights, long-term MPG charts).

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but the touchscreen/command knob is the way things are now. You can't do terrestrial radio, satellite radio, bluetooth, USB music playback, etc with a single knob and 20-character display. All of these features have worked their way into being standard now. Nobody ships an AM/FM radio.

And now that backup cameras are mandatory in the USA as of the 2018 model year, you're going to need that LCD display anyway. So it's easier to throw all the HMI/IVI on that board and be done with it.

The Mazda Connect is run off an NXP iMX6 SoC, which is very powerful yet affordable enough to put in Mazda's base models for no upgrade charge. It's also highly hackable. =)

Oh, and HVAC is still done with physical knobs in a convenient location.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by mikestew on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @02:21PM (#12695298)
You can't do terrestrial radio, satellite radio, bluetooth, USB music playback, etc with a single knob and 20-character display.

The 2nd easiest-to-use interface in our vehicles is the USD$85 Pioneer DIN 1 head unit we put in our '81 VW camper van. It does all of what you list, as well as Pandora and (some other music service). Lots of buttons, not just one knob, but I'll bet that display doesn't do a whole lot more than 20 characters.

The most easy-to-use interface we have is CarPlay on the aftermarket head unit in our '04 Scion xB. Any cars we buy in the future will have CarPlay or no sale. I'm done with crap ass automotive UIs done by some designer trying to make her mark on the world. And though I'm sure some makers have UIs that don't suck, I'm not going to the trouble to find out which. CarPlay or nothing.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by aeharding on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @01:55PM (#12695089)
Mazda Connect has worked very well for me.

So weird that it came with a CD player, though. I thought those would have been gone by 2016...

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by zeveb on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @04:31PM (#12696209)
A CD player's still convenient on a long road trip when one wants to listen to one's own music, not the radio or the satellite. A phone can only hold so much!
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by sliken on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @05:24PM (#12696534)
With 64GB MicroSD cards running for $20 or so are you really phone limited? How many CDs do you have? My note4 has 32GB (internal) and a 64GB microsd.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by zeveb on Thursday October 13, 2016 @11:11AM (#12701233)
Many phones don't support SD cards. I still have my old travel book of CDs — it's dozens & dozens of them.

(as an aside, why am I getting hit with 'you're submitting too fast' recently? I'm really not submitting that many comments!)

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by joezydeco on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:14PM (#12696839)
The Mazda Connect has two USB ports in the dashboard. You can charge a phone with one and plug a multi-terabyte portable drive full of MP3s into the other.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by zeveb on Thursday October 13, 2016 @10:47AM (#12701082)
> You can charge a phone with one and plug a multi-terabyte portable drive full of MP3s into the other.

Will it recognise an ext4-formatted drive, or does it require FAT, NTFS or something else?

Perhaps there are two people in the car charging their phones?

I really, really don't understand the hatred for CDs. Why, someone downvoted my original comment because I noted that they can be useful for a long road trip! Honestly, I'd expect that to be non-controversial: CDs require no data connexion; they are a physical audio format, which means that they can be converted to MP3, FLAC or whatever else one likes; they are owned by you, unlike a streaming music service's tracks.

I think that they still have their use cases.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by izacus on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:19PM (#12695721)
As an owner of the new Mazda3, I actually use the builtin nav more than I do the phone one. It's always there, it's always loaded, always initialized, has better organized UI (canceling routes, adding waypoints, etc. needs way less taps than Sygic/Apple Maps/GMaps do) and shows the upcoming navigation events on the projected HUD.

Unfortunately it also runs less smoothly and it's uglier and RDS traffic info is less reliable than phone one. At least for me the simpler UI and phone battery saving rally outweigh the downsides though.

(I got my nav included with the car, but compared to VAG group which charges 1000EUR+ for nav unit, 400EUR didn't seem to be all that much IMO.)

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by masklinn on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:27AM (#12692565)
The big screens and not-required data connections are convenient. There are also local oddities to GPS e.g. in Japan GPS are keyed on landlines and mapcodes (proprietary GPS-ish codes) not addresses.

OTOH the interfaces of built-in navs &al tend to be unmitigated disasters.

At the end of the day, phone integration (Android's Auto and Apple's CarPlay) are probably what you want.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by Tomdarkness on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:51AM (#12692776)
The reason I have it built-in is it integrates with the head-up display meaning I don't have to take my eye off the road to see directions.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by kctess5 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:19PM (#12695727)
This. My mom's BMW has a really useful navigation display on the HUD. It also shows your speed. These two things mean you basically never have to look down from the window. Definitely comes in handy, especially in stressful driving scenarios.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by jbob2000 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:33AM (#12692621)
My car has voice-control, so I press a button on the steering wheel, speak my destination, and I'm good to go. It works really well. I can't do this easily on a smartphone while I'm driving.

The "big-screen dinosaur" is incredibly helpful for showing routes and directions, much better than the dinky smartphone screen.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by ChrisRR on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:46AM (#12692738)
"Ok google, navigate to <place>"
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by izacus on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @03:20PM (#12695728)
Which makes Google happily google for "Navigate to place" instead of starting GMaps. At least on my Nexus 5X :/
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by Jemmeh on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:41AM (#12692691)
Bluetooth headset + phone gives you the same functionality. They even have bluetooth buttons you can attach to your steering wheel if reaching up to your ear isn't something you want to do.

Easily replaceable, cheaper, better design.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by arbitrage on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:48AM (#12692751)
Now you have to keep track of chargers, and kludge things onto your car. A button on your wheel, a holder on your window or clipped somehow onto your dash.

No thanks.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by Jemmeh on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @06:45PM (#12696980)
The bluetooth buttons just connect to your car. Install it, and then never mess with it again.

I assume most people take their phone around with them these days. I have a magnetic mount in my car, so as I'm sitting down I just lay it on the magnet on the dash and go.

Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by j45 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:15AM (#12693004)
It's possible to speak to the phone using the buttons of the car. Specifically pressing the dial or command button. If your car has bluetooth phone audio, or bluetooth "music" audio connection it becomes a lot more possible.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by lallysingh on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:35AM (#12692635)
This depends on your car model. Many (like mine) have horrible voice control systems.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by JBReefer on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:46AM (#12692732)
Ford has a good passthrough to Android (hold down Speak button). GM has a terrible system that requires you to wait to speak for a quiet beep, and chides you if you don't. It's very odd and never fails to infuriate me.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by 6DM on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @10:04AM (#12692890)
I found that for my Ford Edge, I basically have to shout at it before it understands me. My wife laughs at me every time.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by gol706 on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:13PM (#12694142)
I have the exact same car and problem. I think her laughing is making it even harder for the voice recognition but it's hard to prove.
Re:Most drivers who own cars with built-in GPS systems use p... by beachstartup on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @09:31AM (#12692597)
although i don't use it for directions, i use the digital map every time i drive. i drive a higher end car which has two maps, one in the center console and one in the instrument pod. i set the the instrument pod to show a top-down zoomed in dynamic heading version and the console map shows a bird's eye zoomed out fixed north version. very useful.

also satellite radio and weather/traffic is useful. if i want directions my phone will play them audibly over bluetooth while i look at my dash map (it's the same map!)

i think any car with bluetooth and a halfway decent regular map will be useful for years to come. my parents have a 10 year old car with a map that's still useful for basic nav.