News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by sotojuan on Friday October 07, 2016 @11:45PM (#12665573)
If you search for "open office" on HN there's a thread with a ton of comments in which one person described his ideal office setup as one that has an open/communal area in the middle and individual offices surrounding it in all sides. The commenter said they tried this in real life and it worked well.

I'm curious as to why this isn't as popular—it seems so obvious. I'm actually in a program with a similar layout (except there's only individual rooms on two sides) and it works great.

I'm skeptical of "serendipity" arguments... Bell Labs had private offices and they did fine.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by biot on Saturday October 08, 2016 @12:01AM (#12665605)
On Bell Labs and open offices, Richard Hamming (retired Bell Labs scientist) said:

"Another trait, it took me a while to notice. I noticed the following facts about people who work with the door open or the door closed. I notice that if you have the door to your office closed, you get more work done today and tomorrow, and you are more productive than most. But 10 years later somehow you don't know quite know what problems are worth working on; all the hard work you do is sort of tangential in importance. He who works with the door open gets all kinds of interruptions, but he also occasionally gets clues as to what the world is and what might be important. Now I cannot prove the cause and effect sequence because you might say, ``The closed door is symbolic of a closed mind.'' I don't know. But I can say there is a pretty good correlation between those who work with the doors open and those who ultimately do important things, although people who work with doors closed often work harder. Somehow they seem to work on slightly the wrong thing - not much, but enough that they miss fame."

From http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by reitanqild on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:28AM (#12665928)
This get brought up again and again, yet:

Those who had their doors open still had offices (and I guess a few of them sometimes closed the doors.)

For us who have had to live in open offices where people come in to chat about guns[0] and cutting legs of dogs and daydreaming loudly about things so pervert that anything you have yet heard from big T (yet, at least, I have seen the news) pales and can make even native Norwegians blush...

...for us it is less about where we are in 10 years and more about where we are today.

[0]: minor remark: I am as pro-gun as any of the locals it seems, just don't start chatting about them in the open floorplan where I sit to work.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by svjsdjfnskj on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:52AM (#12665970)
It's not a binary thing! you can shut the door when you need to concentrate and open it when you want to be sociable. That's how it was in my last job and it worked great. Currently I'm in an open-plan office that's hot and noisy, so I work from home in the mornings when I do work that requires concentration and then I go into the office in the afternoon for easier work and chatting.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by dredmorbius on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:10AM (#12666127)
John Seeley Brown, in The Social Life of Information, has a pair of anecdotes from Xerox's repair staff and either Xerox or Kodak (I think) customer service.

The support techs used to have a morning coffee session before heading out into the field on their calls. These turned out to be hugely useful tech transfer opportunities as repairmen would share both their unsolvable problems (machines which had broken and couldn't be fixed) and "This One Weird Trick" solutions.

The second anecdote involved customer service operators, who had previously, if I'm remembering this correctly, shared floor space with techs, but had been moved to their own space. Following the move, there were two specific operators who were able to help out customers by not following the specific scripts they'd been provided, but rather by supplying actual useful questions, diagnostics, and suggestions. When studied by management, it it turned out that one was a veteran of the former seating arrangement. The other, however, was a more recent hire. She did, however, sit next to the more senior rep, and had picked up tips listening and talking to the other employee.

The lesson I'm drawing is that you don't need people to be interrupted all the time. But you do need them to have some opportunities for a free-wheeling exchange. Finding the right balance point between heads-down work (the Xerox techs, for example, were mostly on the road and at customer sites, so they wouldn't have had input from other techs), and exhange opportunities.

In academia, there's the teaching vs. studying/research balance. A few days of lecture and sessions, with other time devoted to actual research, gives that balance of peturbing your own thinking and exposure to new ideas, and focusing on your own work. E.O. Wilson addresses that in his recent book, Letters to a Young Scientist (along with advice to avoid as much teaching and administrative responsibilities as possible).

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by taneq on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:46AM (#12666185)
A company I used to work for had expanded past its available office space, and so they had to rent another office nearby. They moved all the upper management, project managers, and engineers (basically the 'cool kids' / 'important people') over to the new office, leaving some admin staff behind at the main office with the workshop.

The resulting loss of communication between workshop and everyone else caused havoc and a bunch of things went wrong.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by dredmorbius on Saturday October 08, 2016 @05:50AM (#12666333)
There's a well known international company who "rationalises" (or did a decade or so back) its office space by putting all contractors, regardless of assignment, on a single floor.

I found myself wedged between a contingent working COBOL and a very chatty (and pleasant) graphic designer, with the sole other contractor in my unit located at the extreme opposite side of the building, and my direct reports a half dozen floors up.

I suppose it made sense at some level....

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by keithpeter on Saturday October 08, 2016 @06:34AM (#12666436)
Classic example of resource allocation by org chart.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by taneq on Saturday October 08, 2016 @07:36AM (#12666572)
That seems about as logical as putting desks in alphabetical order.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by dredmorbius on Saturday October 08, 2016 @09:38AM (#12666896)
I plan on organising my future business by weight. With daily weigh-ins.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by mamon on Saturday October 08, 2016 @07:25AM (#12666545)
Most offices already have dedicated space for discussions and exchange of ideas. It is called "kitchen", or "watelcooler area". Rest of the space should be private offices to do some quiet, focused work.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by douche on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:14AM (#12666992)
One of the things I miss about working in blue-collar jobs is the sanctity of the coffee break and the lunch hour. 9 o'clock, noon, 3 o'clock, tools down, everybody goes to the break room and has a cup of coffee, shoots the shit, catches up on what else is going on.

The plant I used to work in also did daily standups. They worked a hell of a lot better than any I have ever seen in software, since they started the minute after everybody was supposed to punch in, rather than some amorphous time mid-morning when somebody decided there might be a better-than-average chance of everybody finally dragging into the office or there not being some other regularly scheduled meeting.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by dredmorbius on Saturday October 08, 2016 @11:04AM (#12667156)
There's a huge difference between work which you can do tools-down without a lot of fuss, versus work which involves keeping a ton of state in your head. I've done both myself, and there's a distinct difference between working with your hands and working with your mind entirely.

Not that tools-based work can't involve thinking. The design or planning elemments of carpentry or construction or machining or cabinetry can be quite cerebral. But there's that hand-eye tangibility that's missing.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by clacke2 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @07:26AM (#12666547)
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by dwc on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:19AM (#12667006)
Several times over the years I've had an office with a door. Normally I kept the door open, but I would close it if I had work that required extreme (for me) concentration, or if the environment outside was excessively distracting that day, etc. IME, this is quite common for other people as well.

Since I have trouble concentrating when people are talking and get quite unhappy about it but managed to keep my door open the vast majority of the time, I have to wonder. Was Bell Labs an excessively noisy place, or were the closed door people there those kind of people?

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by michaelmrose on Saturday October 08, 2016 @01:52AM (#12665847)
I'm sure he did good work but this is the intellectual equivalent to snack food. Its entirely possible to be open to outside influence without giving random coworkers visible permission to interrupt whenever.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by marvy on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:05AM (#12665874)
> entirely possible

But that's his point, isn't it? It sounds like it should be possible, yet he never saw it happen.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by initram on Sunday October 09, 2016 @01:58PM (#12672367)
Well, his definition appears to be that the people with closed doors did it "enough that they miss fame". Who's to say whether those people made extremely good contributions, but since they were introverts didn't seek out fame, or actively ran from it? The whole quote is just anecdotal stuff.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by twelve40 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:22AM (#12666024)
This can clearly go the other way: people who make an impact are approached so much that it's hard to keep the door closed, doesn't mean it's their natural preference.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by lazyjones on Saturday October 08, 2016 @09:45AM (#12666910)
He may be right, but as an employer, your aim won't be to make all your programmers famous. The work better done behind closed doors is probably at least as important as that of the visionary with open doors: putting out fires, fixing bugs, meeting deadlines. As an employee, you'll surely want the "open door" work ...
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by cloudjacker on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:27AM (#12665925)
Because any of us here work anywhere for ten years right?

We get our cliffs and we get liquidity and none of this workplace nuance matters.

Your mere presence is elevated into importance because you got an exit. Being honest.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by oldprogrammer2 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @09:10AM (#12666841)
When we moved our dev team to a new area, I chose this style of layout. Each developer has their own small office, which forms an outer perimeter. Each office also has a 4x4 window next to the door to keep the atmosphere open. In the middle is an open kitchen and a standup area, separated by the bathrooms. We have a conference room in the corner. All of this is behind key-access doors, giving the team a sense of sanctuary.

Each office, as well as the standup area and the conference room, have a whiteboard wall.

I would say that the general idea is that developers come together at standups, and typically plan out the day. If two or more developers determine a discussion is needed, they normally schedule right after the standup. Then the developers depart to their offices, and generally put their heads down and work in quiet. Most leave their doors open throughout the day, and close their doors when they have phone calls or small meetings.

The arrangement works well. Adhoc conversations are not discouraged, and occur throughout the day as needed, but the separate offices keep the trivial conversations and disturbances to a minimum.

From a cost perspective, this layout requires considerably more space than an open layout. And separate offices require separate HVAC ducts, and walls and doors are (obviously) additional expenses, too. I'm grateful that our team's contributions were recognized by the company (a non-tech company), such that the expense was considered worth it. it's certainly a cornerstone of my sales pitch for recruiting developers.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by existencebox on Saturday October 08, 2016 @01:22PM (#12667742)
If it helps, let me put my vote of support for that sales pitch. Literally that fact alone had me going "I wonder where he works", and I'm in quite a good spot right now. I cannot express how much a motivator a sane office space has become for such a silly thing after the last few years of open-sardine-cans. I would love to see more companies recognize that certain acts of consideration to their eng (I don't mean the more transient stuff like "free dinners" "pool table") are a significant differentiator for my strata of less-extroverted devs.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by JohnBooty on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:17AM (#12666999)
I'm glad it's working out for you!

Our company (also a non-tech company!) is investing in such a space for us and I'm very very excited. Excited and grateful.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by ams6110 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @12:22AM (#12665664)
It isn't popular because it's more expensive. Cubicles are cheaper than offices, and desks in a row are cheaper than cubicles.

It's a beancounter mentality, possibly understandable in a startup with limited funds for offices, but a false economy in the long run.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by throwaway7645 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:06AM (#12666122)
I work in an open floor plan where I'm right on the aisle and hate it. Unless I'm focused 100%, it is human nature to check your back when someone is behind you. I can now identify the entire office floor's staff via their walk. It is a good way to keep abreast of issues and socialize, but waaaaay less productive than when we has cubes.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by Can_Not on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @12:46PM (#12694422)
Anecdotally speaking, this streamlines the process for your butterfly fairy manager to float in and unnecessarily disrupt everyone's work at once with random out of context comments during their daily bypass appropriate communication channels.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by abalone on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:02AM (#12665986)
This is often repeated on HN threads as a plausible explanation for open plans, always without evidence. But it makes very little sense as a theory. Companies do not have a financial inventive to consciously cripple their very highly paid, very difficult to hire developers' productivity. People are their number one expense and asset, vastly moreso than office space. Far from cutting corners, many open plan companies also spend lavishly on amenities to keep engineers happy.

A more plausible explanation is companies do open plan because they believe it will help foster collaboration, culture and team productivity. You may disagree but the "beancounter" theory makes no sense.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by adrianN on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:10AM (#12666000)
It's easy to measure the money saved when you go from individual offices to an open plan. It is a lot harder to measure the lost productivity of your programmers.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by dredmorbius on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:02AM (#12666112)
So, agreeing with that, are you aware of a specific terminology or theory of easy-to-measure vs. hard-to-measure costs and benefits?

It's a question which has been bugging me something fierce of late.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by abalone on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:23AM (#12666031)
That's not really true. You can look at developer velocity and bug fix rates, to name a couple of readily available metrics. It would not be some big mystery if open plan was killing productivity.

Also, it does not explain why a "beancounter" mindset about office space would be paired with lavish expenses on free lunches and other de rigueur amenities in said offices, as is typical of open plan startups. Conclusion: it's not a beancounter mentality that drives the decision.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by ZenoArrow on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:42AM (#12666073)
> "You can look at developer velocity and bug fix rates, to name a couple of readily available metrics."

How? If an office starts out open plan (which many of them do), are you going to move to new offices just to test the theory that it'll make your employees more productive? Plus, bug fix rates are a bad metric, bugs are not equal in complexity, and even if you try and guess at the complexity before working on a bug that's only an estimate, and one that doesn't take into account other important factors such as the level of churn in the codebase and the level of familiarity the developer has with the part of the codebase they are asked to fix.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by douche on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:32AM (#12667057)
Just because you have to do something that is suboptimal when you're starting out because of resource constraints, doesn't mean that you should enshrine that sub-optimal situation as ideal.

As an absurd example, Jobs and Woz made the first Apple computers in a garage. When they started making some actual money and could afford something better, they didn't insist on their engineers all working in garages.

Open offices are very reminiscent of the kind of environment that I remember from college, where the default studying option seemed to be going to the library, staking out a seat at a big table, building a fort of books, and "studying," with the emphasis on appearing studious and some sort of bizarre status hierarchy about how many hours you held station there.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by abalone on Saturday October 08, 2016 @11:24AM (#12667237)
The new Apple campus, designed by Jobs, will be open plan.

http://iphone.appleinsider.com/articles/16/10/06/apple-to-un...

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by Can_Not on Wednesday October 12, 2016 @11:42AM (#12693846)
What if there is an increase in bug fixes because the open office decreased the quality of work resulting in more bugs?
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by abalone on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:04AM (#12666118)
There are plenty of companies that have shifted formats, and a gross change in productivity would show up in those metrics.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by ZenoArrow on Saturday October 08, 2016 @08:21AM (#12666705)
Which metrics? There aren't any accurate ones I know of. Anecdotal evidence is possible, but I don't see how programmer productivity can be measured with scientific rigour.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by crdoconnor on Saturday October 08, 2016 @08:10AM (#12666675)
>You can look at developer velocity

Developer velocity compares what you thought the complexity of a problem was vs how much time it actually takes. It conflates the level of optimism with the speed of development and glosses over how complex the stories should be.

Smart developers get overly pessimistic when pointing stories if they're measured by developer velocity rather than actual business value delivered because it makes them seem faster.

>and bug fix rates

Last time that metric was taken seriously developers deliberately inserted bugs.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by ams6110 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @09:21AM (#12666866)
Pretty much any development metric that drives some kind of reward will be gamed (maybe even unconsciously) by the developers. It's just basic psychology.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by abalone on Saturday October 08, 2016 @11:25AM (#12667242)
Those are issues with tying compensation and performance evaluation to metrics, not with detecting changes in them due to office environments.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by enraged_camel on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:23AM (#12666030)
>>Companies do not have a financial inventive to consciously cripple their very highly paid, very difficult to hire developers' productivity.

I highly doubt that:

a) most companies have done studies to measure correlations between office plan types and developer productivity

b) they even know how to measure developer productivity accurately

On the other hand, they can easily measure headcount per square foot. It's a simple division that even the stupidest executive can perform. The other stuff is just hand-waved away.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by Frqy3 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:38AM (#12666066)
Also, the managers who sign off and make the final decision on which office plan to go with tend to spend most of their own work time meeting and talking to people, rather than needing to sit and concentrate on something for several hours. I expect this influences a cognitive bias when these managers consider the productivity level of an open plan office.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by twelve40 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @05:43AM (#12666311)
They don't consciously cripple, they just can't connect the dots. The facilities person tells the CFO, hey, I found you this great office for 1/3 the price. Then the VP of Eng, who never codes anyway, spends 100% of time in meetings replies, awesome - we'll have an open floor plan for better exchange of ideas. Win-win, right?
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 08, 2016 @05:14AM (#12666246)
You're implying that management bases its decisions on scientifically founded research. I've never noticed that to be true just about anywhere. Most corporations don't implement best practices in, well, anything. Why should office layout be any different?
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by vonmoltke on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:27AM (#12667034)
Or, with apologies to Andrew Lang, they use scientifically-founded research the way a drunk man uses a lamppost: for support rather than illumination.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 08, 2016 @11:01AM (#12667147)
Right. I mean, this is the industry that occasionally thinks it's a good idea to install rootkits as part of game or music drm. The idea that they're too smart to work contrary to their own long term interests is laughable.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by opo on Sunday October 09, 2016 @06:35PM (#12673946)
Well all the research basically shows that productivity goes down when distractions increase, so you won't even see anyone quoting research to justify their decision. The executives who make this kind of decision generally know they will always have a nice office so it won't hurt them (and maybe the unsaid reason is that deep down they know that only them having an office helps the little people to understand their place in the org).

It doesn't help when the cool kids like Facebook endorse this kind of idiocy - other companies feel it is safer to just follow what others are doing. We need to have a new major tech player endorse the idea that the goal of a company building is to make the workers as productive as possible - you get better work from them, they enjoy it more and it will become easier to retain or recruit people.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by walshemj on Saturday October 08, 2016 @07:48AM (#12666604)
Companies may not want to do that but the individual "tail" functions will optimise for there needs and ignore the wider needs of the company.

Look Boss I saved 10% on office costs - ignoring the fact that productivity has gone down by 20%

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by Perixoog on Saturday October 08, 2016 @07:39AM (#12666581)
It's not about what companies financial incentives are, but what type of behavior they reward their staff for.

"Noone ever got fired for buying IBM"

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by tempodox on Saturday October 08, 2016 @05:03AM (#12666219)
The thing is, the higher rents for more floor space and separate offices are very tangible metrics for beancounters, whereas suboptimal developer productivity isn't. And that doesn't change when a company stops being a startup (by whatever definition).

My own anecdotal experience is that I have never, ever, seen private offices for devs. The private offices I know are all given as a privilege (for some boss), not for productivity.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by ams6110 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @09:07AM (#12666827)
I have been a software professional for almost 30 years. I have worked in shared offices, open plans, cubes, but have never in that time had a private office of my own. Often my immediate managers/leads did not have offices either. The execs always have offices, yet in many cases are rarely in them.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by borplk on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:31AM (#12665936)
It's about money. It was always about money, the collaboration thing is just a veil.

Companies will always invent "happy vocabulary" to justify whatever it is that is in their interest to do.

If they could pack their employees into little cardboard human boxes all separate from each other they would say "Our environment encourages strong focus and solitude."

You can put a positive spin on anything.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by BjoernKW on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:19AM (#12666145)
It's also about (perceived) control. Otherwise remote work would be pretty much the norm today - at least for software development and similar kinds of knowledge work.

Development output isn't easily measurable. What's easily measurable though is people sitting in a chair and pretending to "work".

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by ap22213 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:31AM (#12666055)
Let's imagine a universe where research showed that factory workers gained significant productivity when they had private spaces to concentrate. Do you think that the factory owners would suddenly erect partitions? Of course not - at least not until they faced significant competition and were losing market share.

Too many people doing software over-inflate their importance to management. The reason why there are few offices at tech companies is simple. Management views software developers as factory workers, and they want to 'see' them working hard for the money that they're spending.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 08, 2016 @01:09AM (#12665779)
Money.

Open offices are cheaper. So if you can con your mostly 20-something and 30-something tech staff that it's the best way to go, then you're golden, you save a ton of money and your employees don't even realize they're being ripped off.

As for "serendipity" it's the classic post-hoc fallacy problem. People think "oh, there was that one time" where something good happened in an open office, and they think that means nothing good would happen without open offices. Serendipity happens plenty with offices, but it happens amidst a background of much greater productivity and less annoyance at noisy office mates.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:04AM (#12665993)
People are so in pursuit of the "water cooler serendipity" that they're turning their whole offices into water coolers!
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by jasonkester on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:28AM (#12666045)
your employees don't even realize they're being ripped off.

Careful with your terminology there. To be "ripped off" requires there to be no other choice. Your car has broken down in the desert and the single mechanic within 100 miles can charge you what he wants.

In that light, it is not possible for an engineer contemplating accepting a job offer from Facebook to be "ripped off". He's in intelligent businessperson negotiating a deal with a ton of other options available. They can't force him to do anything, and if he sees an open plan office as a downside, he can negotiate compensation in other forms.

Personally, I'm happy to work in any environment you put me in. Stick me in the swimming pool and feed me margaritas all day if you think it helps your corporate culture. I'll assume you've done the math and factored in the drop in productivity, so I won't feel bad to watch it happen.

That's the nice thing about business. You can assume the other side of the table is also behaving rationally, and let him shoot himself in the foot if he pleases.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by thaumasiotes on Saturday October 08, 2016 @06:38AM (#12666443)
> Careful with your terminology there. To be "ripped off" requires there to be no other choice. Your car has broken down in the desert and the single mechanic within 100 miles can charge you what he wants.

That doesn't reflect any usage of "ripped off" that I've ever heard. If I buy a doodad from one of three sidewalk stalls all next to each other, I pay $40, and any of them would have sold it to me for $5, it would be conventional to say I got ripped off.

Or, if I buy a dowsing rod advertised at a nonnegotiable price, it would still be conventional to say I got ripped off, because there's no such thing as a dowsing rod.

"Ripped off" means you paid more for something than it was worth. The lone mechanic in the desert isn't doing that; his services really are that valuable.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by xiaoma on Saturday October 08, 2016 @08:08AM (#12666665)
>>your employees don't even realize they're being ripped off.

>Careful with your terminology there. To be "ripped off" requires...

>It is not possible for an engineer contemplating accepting a job offer from Facebook to be "ripped off". He's in intelligent businessperson

For someone telling people to be careful with their terminology, the word "businessperson" sure is an odd way to describe a W2 employee taking on a full time job.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by throwanem on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:22AM (#12667014)
The regulatory framework around it doesn't change the fact that it's a negotiated sale of labor.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by xiaoma on Saturday October 08, 2016 @05:45PM (#12668872)
If you redefine the word "businessperson" to include everyone who has ever taken or pursued work as an employee, the meaning is both at odds with common English usage and so broad as to be nearly meaningless.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by nickthemagicman on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:31AM (#12665933)
Short term money. If it kills productivity, they lose money in the long run.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by theprotocol on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:44AM (#12665958)
Nearly every company these days falls for this. I suspect suits completely misunderstand the principle of time value of money, as they wrongly conflate "short term money" with "earlier money."

And in finance, when it comes to inflows of money, earlier always trumps later (as it's assumed that you can thus will invest that money for longer when you get it earlier).

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 08, 2016 @03:50AM (#12666091)
That's true of a lot of practices, but when the feedback loop isn't as tight, it's easy for companies to ignore it. There are countless examples of big companies hemorrhaging talent because of their corporate culture, policies, etc. I've witnessed it many times with my own eyes. But that sort of thing doesn't manifest as the company burning to the ground in the next year and then people going "why did that happen? oh, it's because we lost Jim". Instead it looks like a failure to execute as well on big projects. But because there are always so many things changing from project to project, it's always easy to blame something else. And the management at most big corporations are loathe to blame themselves or their policies, so they always find some other convenient excuse.

This is a big reason why companies change character of time and transition from being industry powerhouses to also-rans.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by badsock on Saturday October 08, 2016 @12:09AM (#12665622)
I've seen this called "cave and commons", and yeah, it seems like a very good setup. I first saw it mentioned in Stewart Brand's (highly recommended) book How Buildings Learn.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by Animats on Saturday October 08, 2016 @02:57AM (#12665978)
I've seen the reverse of that at one part of Google - individual desks in the middle, many small glass-walled conference rooms around the perimeter.
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by gbin on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:02AM (#12666951)
Google has private offices ? Which building ?
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by madmax108 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @10:17AM (#12666998)
This is EXACTLY how we have it at our office (Series D startup). On a daily basis, I pend about half my time in the open area with my team and everyone else dropping by, and the rest in a room where I can be plugged in at peace to get some concentrated coding done. The office rooms range from 1-2 person rooms to 6-10 person rooms, and all of them can be used at any time of day by anyone in office.

It's funny how I never have to stretch timelines or have communication issues with this setup.

+1, would recommend.

Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by thesimpsons1022 on Saturday October 08, 2016 @04:03AM (#12666116)
microsoft has that in some teams. one team specifically i knew was transitioned from offices to the open floor plan but their old offices remained empty. this allowed them to have both
Re:Just shut up and let your devs concentrate, advises Joel ... by blt on Saturday October 08, 2016 @12:09AM (#12665623)
Because then it takes even more space than one or the other.